I have the Fish Grip Fish holder. It is great, it looks similar to a large vise grip but is plastic. It is about $14.00 I think and they float! I have used them on stripers, bass, pickerel and carp and it has held up well and allowed me to control the fish. I have used them when wading and kayaking and no issues. One thing I really like about it, is that the part gripping the fish has a large surface area so it doesn't poke through the fish's skin. Also it is really light so I can clip it to my bag or what ever I am wearing when fishing and not feel it. It doesn't have a scale however.