Comparable results in MARK

76 views
Skip to first unread message

jcl...@utk.edu

unread,
Oct 13, 2022, 9:18:27 AM10/13/22
to secr
I have 13 years of robust design spatially explicit CMR data and I am estimating lambda in OpenCR.  I want to check my estimates with non-spatial estimates in MARK.  I first ran a non-spatial Pradel model in OpenCR (fit2.2.UARB<-openCR.fit(UARBCHF, model=list(phi~1, p~1, lambda~1), method="Nelder-Mead", type='JSSAlCL') #Pradel-lambda model) but the results are different from my results in MARK using this model ({Phi(sex), lambda (sex), p( sex), f0(sex)}) as a robust design Pradel lambda full likelihood p an c model in MARK (the OpenCR model is for females only so I have to run a sex model in MARK because that data set is for both sexes).  

My results are significantly different even when I modeled f0 in MARK as fully time independent.  Any idea why my results are different?  I tried to run a simple CJS model in MARK but that is difficult because all the robust design applications require the estimation of the gamma' and gamma" parameters, and while I formatted it as a random movement model, the results also are different.  I checked the capture summaries for both platforms and they are identical.  Thanks!

Murray Efford

unread,
Oct 13, 2022, 3:47:33 PM10/13/22
to secr
Differences often hinge on what is held constant in each model. I get lost in the MARK models, so can't help directly. JSSAlCL (=PLBl) is obviously a conditional likelihood model that does not include f0, not a full likelihood model. Sorry I can't be more helpful.

jcl...@utk.edu

unread,
Oct 13, 2022, 3:56:05 PM10/13/22
to secr
Thanks Murray.  Are there any equivalent non-spatial models in both Mark and OpenCR that deal with robust design data that I can check by estimates against?   JSSAl models?

jcl...@utk.edu

unread,
Oct 18, 2022, 1:07:48 PM10/18/22
to secr
I cannot seem to get the MARK example models to run as in the openCR example vignette on my computer.  It seems to read the data okay but cannot complete the run, stopping at "STOP NORMAL EXIT".  Anyone have any ideas on why?  

Murray Efford

unread,
Oct 18, 2022, 4:03:56 PM10/18/22
to jcl...@utk.edu, secr
Hi
Can you be more specific? I think STOP NORMAL EXIT is expected at the end of a normal run. In the section 'CJS by sex' I get the output below. Perhaps you didn't set the Mark path?
Murray

fm <- secr::RMarkInput(microtusFMCH)
markFM <- RMark::mark(fm, model.parameters =
    list(Phi = list(formula = ~time+sex), p = list(formula = ~time*sex)),
    groups = 'sex', invisible = TRUE, output = FALSE, adjust = FALSE)
round(markFM$results$real[,1:4],4)
  The file is mark001.inp on unit 4.
  INPUT --- proc title ;

   CPU Time for the last procedure was 0.01 seconds.    
  INPUT --- proc chmatrix occasions= 6 groups= 2 etype= Live Nodes= 101
  INPUT --- ICMeans NoHist hist= 64 ;
  INPUT ---    time interval 1 1 1 1 1 ;
  INPUT ---    glabel(1)=sexF;
  INPUT ---    glabel(2)=sexM;

   * *  WARNING  * *   At least a pair of the encounter histories are duplicates.
   Number of unique encounter histories read was 33.
   Number of individual covariates read was 0.
   Time interval lengths are all equal to 1.

   CPU Time for the last procedure was 0.01 seconds.    
  INPUT --- proc estimate link=Logit NOLOOP varest=2ndPart    ;
   Model is { Phi(~time + sex)p(~time * sex) }
  INPUT --- model={ Phi(~time + sex)p(~time * sex) };
  INPUT ---    group=1 Phi    rows=5 cols=5 Triang ;
  INPUT ---        1 2 3 4 5 ;
  INPUT ---        2 3 4 5 ;
  INPUT ---        3 4 5 ;
  INPUT ---        4 5 ;
  INPUT ---        5 ;
  INPUT ---    group=2 Phi    rows=5 cols=5 Triang ;
  INPUT ---        6 7 8 9 10 ;
  INPUT ---        7 8 9 10 ;
  INPUT ---        8 9 10 ;
  INPUT ---        9 10 ;
  INPUT ---        10 ;
  INPUT ---    group=1 p    rows=5 cols=5 Triang ;
  INPUT ---        11 12 13 14 15 ;
  INPUT ---        12 13 14 15 ;
  INPUT ---        13 14 15 ;
  INPUT ---        14 15 ;
  INPUT ---        15 ;
  INPUT ---    group=2 p    rows=5 cols=5 Triang ;
  INPUT ---        16 17 18 19 20 ;
  INPUT ---        17 18 19 20 ;
  INPUT ---        18 19 20 ;
  INPUT ---        19 20 ;
  INPUT ---        20 ;
  INPUT ---    design matrix constraints=20 covariates=16;
  INPUT ---        1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0;
  INPUT ---        1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0;
  INPUT ---        1 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0;
  INPUT ---        1 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0;
  INPUT ---        1 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0;
  INPUT ---        1 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0;
  INPUT ---        1 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0;
  INPUT ---        1 0 1 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0;
  INPUT ---        1 0 0 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0;
  INPUT ---        1 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0;
  INPUT ---        0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0;
  INPUT ---        0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0;
  INPUT ---        0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0;
  INPUT ---        0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0;
  INPUT ---        0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0;
  INPUT ---        0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0;
  INPUT ---        0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 0;
  INPUT ---        0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 1 0 0 1 0 1 0 0;
  INPUT ---        0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 1 0 1 0 0 1 0;
  INPUT ---        0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 1;
  INPUT ---       blabel(1)=Phi:(Intercept);
  INPUT ---       blabel(2)=Phi:time2;
  INPUT ---       blabel(3)=Phi:time3;
  INPUT ---       blabel(4)=Phi:time4;
  INPUT ---       blabel(5)=Phi:time5;
  INPUT ---       blabel(6)=Phi:sexM;
  INPUT ---       blabel(7)=p:(Intercept);
  INPUT ---       blabel(8)=p:time3;
  INPUT ---       blabel(9)=p:time4;
  INPUT ---       blabel(10)=p:time5;
  INPUT ---       blabel(11)=p:time6;
  INPUT ---       blabel(12)=p:sexM;
  INPUT ---       blabel(13)=p:time3:sexM;
  INPUT ---       blabel(14)=p:time4:sexM;
  INPUT ---       blabel(15)=p:time5:sexM;
  INPUT ---       blabel(16)=p:time6:sexM;
  INPUT ---       rlabel(1)=Phi gF c1 a0 t1;
  INPUT ---       rlabel(2)=Phi gF c1 a1 t2;
  INPUT ---       rlabel(3)=Phi gF c1 a2 t3;
  INPUT ---       rlabel(4)=Phi gF c1 a3 t4;
  INPUT ---       rlabel(5)=Phi gF c1 a4 t5;
  INPUT ---       rlabel(6)=Phi gM c1 a0 t1;
  INPUT ---       rlabel(7)=Phi gM c1 a1 t2;
  INPUT ---       rlabel(8)=Phi gM c1 a2 t3;
  INPUT ---       rlabel(9)=Phi gM c1 a3 t4;
  INPUT ---       rlabel(10)=Phi gM c1 a4 t5;
  INPUT ---       rlabel(11)=p gF c1 a1 t2;
  INPUT ---       rlabel(12)=p gF c1 a2 t3;
  INPUT ---       rlabel(13)=p gF c1 a3 t4;
  INPUT ---       rlabel(14)=p gF c1 a4 t5;
  INPUT ---       rlabel(15)=p gF c1 a5 t6;
  INPUT ---       rlabel(16)=p gM c1 a1 t2;
  INPUT ---       rlabel(17)=p gM c1 a2 t3;
  INPUT ---       rlabel(18)=p gM c1 a3 t4;
  INPUT ---       rlabel(19)=p gM c1 a4 t5;
  INPUT ---       rlabel(20)=p gM c1 a5 t6;
   Model is { Phi(~time + sex)p(~time * sex) }
   Link Function Used is LOGIT        
   Varia{ Phi(~time + sex)p(~time * sex) } Iteration 60                                                            
   CPU Time for numerical optimization was 0.17 seconds.    
   -2logL { Phi(~time + sex)p(~time * sex) } = 724.05646    
   Penalty { Phi(~time + sex)p(~time * sex) } = 0.0000000    
   Gradient { Phi(~time + sex)p(~time * sex) }:
  0.2384817E-05   0.000000      0.6958124E-05  0.3141150E-05   0.000000    
  0.5478281{ Phi(~time + sex)p(~time * sex) } VC Matrix: 100% done.  CPU Time to compute VC matrix was 0.11 seconds.                                                  
 CPU Time to invert VC matrix was 0.01 seconds.    
 Gap Method for Num. of Estimated Parameters { Phi(~time + sex)p(~time * sex) } = 14          
 Numerical Threshold Method for Num. of Estimated Parameters { Phi(~time + sex)p(~time * sex) } = 14          
 Number of Estimated Parameters { Phi(~time + sex)p(~time * sex) } = 14          
   DEVIANCE { Phi(~time + sex)p(~time * sex) } = 61.676003                    
 DEVIANCE Degrees of Freedom { Phi(~time + sex)p(~time * sex) } = 28            
   c-hat { Phi(~time + sex)p(~time * sex) } = 2.2027144    
   AIC { Phi(~time + sex)p(~time * sex) } = 752.05646    
   AICc { Phi(~time + sex)p(~time * sex) } = 752.88486    
   BIC { Phi(~time + sex)p(~time * sex) } = 811.66381    
   Pearson Chisquare { Phi(~time + sex)p(~time * sex) } = 141.58475    
   Possible Encounter Histories { Phi(~time + sex)p(~time * sex) } = 124            
   Pearson Chisquare df { Phi(~time + sex)p(~time * sex) } = 100        
   Pearson chat { Phi(~time + sex)p(~time * sex) } = 1.4158475    
   Sum(Observed/Expected) { Phi(~time + sex)p(~time * sex) } = 152.45273    
   s-bar { Phi(~time + sex)p(~time * sex) } = 0.2495854    
   Fletcher chat { Phi(~time + sex)p(~time * sex) } = 1.1330538    
 Beta number 5 is a singular value.

   CPU Time for the last procedure was 0.28 seconds.    
  INPUT --- proc stop;

     CPU Time in minutes for this job was 0.00

     Time Start = 08:56:17.942   Time End = 08:56:18.490

     Wall Clock Time in minutes for this job was 0.01
STOP NORMAL EXIT
There were 50 or more warnings (use warnings() to see the first 50)
> round(markFM$results$real[,1:4],4)
                estimate     se    lcl    ucl
Phi gF c1 a0 t1   0.9002 0.0334 0.8131 0.9492
Phi gF c1 a1 t2   0.7224 0.0516 0.6111 0.8117
Phi gF c1 a2 t3   0.7323 0.0509 0.6218 0.8198
Phi gF c1 a3 t4   0.6836 0.0533 0.5713 0.7779
Phi gF c1 a4 t5   0.9345 0.0000 0.9345 0.9345
Phi gM c1 a0 t1   0.8589 0.0434 0.7510 0.9248
Phi gM c1 a1 t2   0.6373 0.0562 0.5217 0.7390
Phi gM c1 a2 t3   0.6487 0.0572 0.5304 0.7513
Phi gM c1 a3 t4   0.5933 0.0561 0.4805 0.6970
Phi gM c1 a4 t5   0.9060 0.0000 0.9060 0.9060
p gF c1 a1 t2     0.8741 0.0562 0.7184 0.9497
p gF c1 a2 t3     0.9078 0.0501 0.7529 0.9695
p gF c1 a3 t4     0.9578 0.0408 0.7579 0.9940
p gF c1 a4 t5     1.0000 0.0000 1.0000 1.0000
p gF c1 a5 t6     0.8917 0.0000 0.8917 0.8917
p gM c1 a1 t2     0.9634 0.0354 0.7862 0.9947
p gM c1 a2 t3     0.7954 0.0778 0.6037 0.9085
p gM c1 a3 t4     0.9210 0.0526 0.7385 0.9796
p gM c1 a4 t5     0.8302 0.0688 0.6527 0.9271
p gM c1 a5 t6     0.9318 0.0000 0.9318 0.9318


--
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "secr" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to secrgroup+...@googlegroups.com.
To view this discussion on the web, visit https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/secrgroup/bb15b5f2-cfea-4ccb-908e-5c66c2518cadn%40googlegroups.com.

jcl...@utk.edu

unread,
Oct 18, 2022, 4:40:51 PM10/18/22
to secr
Well, it works now for some reason.  Sorry about that.  

However, I am trying to convert my openCR robust design capture histories into Mark capture histories but when I enter the commands below do not seem to work. 
I used the example in the RMarkInput help document...

UARBRD <- RMarkInput (join(UARBCHF))
UARBRD.data <- process.data(UARBRD, model = "Robust",
                            time.interval = attr(UARBRD, "intervals"))

< Error in setup.model(model, nocc, mixtures) :
  Invalid type of model = ROBUST Valid types are
NULL
CJS
JS
more...

It does not seem to work for the Ovenbird data either.  Thanks!

Murray Efford

unread,
Oct 18, 2022, 4:50:07 PM10/18/22
to jcl...@utk.edu, secr
Hmm...

Ovenbird example works for me. Note need to first join() to make a "single-session"  capthist with correct intervals:

> ovenRD <- RMarkInput (join(ovenCH))
> library(RMark)
> MarkPath <- 'c:/MARK'    ## adjust for your installation
> ovenRD.data <- process.data(ovenRD, model = "Robust",
+     time.interval = attr(ovenRD, "intervals"))
> ovenRD.model <- mark(data = ovenRD.data, model = "Robust",
+     model.parameters = list(p = list(formula = ~1, share = TRUE),
+         GammaDoublePrime = list(formula = ~1),
+         GammaPrime = list(formula = ~1),
+         f0 = list(formula = ~1)))  

  The file is mark001.inp on unit 4.
  INPUT --- proc title ;

   CPU Time for the last procedure was 0.02 seconds.     
  INPUT --- proc chmatrix occasions= 49 groups= 1 etype= Robust Nodes=
  INPUT --- 101 ICMeans NoHist hist=  66 ;
  INPUT ---    time interval 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0
  INPUT ---    0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0  0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ;
  INPUT ---    glabel(1)=Group 1;
   Number of unique encounter histories read was 66.

   Number of individual covariates read was 0.
   Time interval lengths vary and/or not equal to 1.


   CPU Time for the last procedure was 0.01 seconds.    
  INPUT --- proc estimate link=Parm-Specific NOLOOP varest=2ndPart    ;
   Model is { S(~1)Gamma''(~1)Gamma'(~1)p(~1)c()f0(~1) }
  INPUT --- model={ S(~1)Gamma''(~1)Gamma'(~1)p(~1)c()f0(~1) };
  INPUT ---    group=1 S    rows=4 cols=4 Triang ;
  INPUT ---        1 1 1 1 ;
  INPUT ---        1 1 1 ;
  INPUT ---        1 1 ;
  INPUT ---        1 ;
  INPUT ---    group=1 Gamma''    rows=4 cols=4 Triang ;
  INPUT ---        2 2 2 2 ;
  INPUT ---        2 2 2 ;
  INPUT ---        2 2 ;
  INPUT ---        2 ;
  INPUT ---    group=1 Gamma'    rows=3 cols=3 Triang ;
  INPUT ---        3 3 3 ;
  INPUT ---        3 3 ;
  INPUT ---        3 ;
  INPUT ---    group=1 p  Session 1  rows=1 cols=9 Square ;
  INPUT ---        4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 ;
  INPUT ---    group=1 p  Session 2  rows=1 cols=10 Square ;
  INPUT ---        4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 ;
  INPUT ---    group=1 p  Session 3  rows=1 cols=10 Square ;
  INPUT ---        4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 ;
  INPUT ---    group=1 p  Session 4  rows=1 cols=10 Square ;
  INPUT ---        4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 ;
  INPUT ---    group=1 p  Session 5  rows=1 cols=10 Square ;
  INPUT ---        4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 ;
  INPUT ---    group=1 c  Session 1  rows=1 cols=8 Square ;
  INPUT ---        4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 ;
  INPUT ---    group=1 c  Session 2  rows=1 cols=9 Square ;
  INPUT ---        4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 ;
  INPUT ---    group=1 c  Session 3  rows=1 cols=9 Square ;
  INPUT ---        4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 ;
  INPUT ---    group=1 c  Session 4  rows=1 cols=9 Square ;
  INPUT ---        4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 ;
  INPUT ---    group=1 c  Session 5  rows=1 cols=9 Square ;
  INPUT ---        4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 ;
  INPUT ---    group=1 f0  Session 1  rows=1 cols=1 Square ;
  INPUT ---        5 ;
  INPUT ---    group=1 f0  Session 2  rows=1 cols=1 Square ;
  INPUT ---        5 ;
  INPUT ---    group=1 f0  Session 3  rows=1 cols=1 Square ;
  INPUT ---        5 ;
  INPUT ---    group=1 f0  Session 4  rows=1 cols=1 Square ;
  INPUT ---        5 ;
  INPUT ---    group=1 f0  Session 5  rows=1 cols=1 Square ;
  INPUT ---        5 ;
  INPUT ---    design matrix constraints=5 covariates=5 identity;
  INPUT ---    links=5;
  INPUT ---    Logit;
  INPUT ---    Logit;
  INPUT ---    Logit;
  INPUT ---    Logit;
  INPUT ---    Log;
  INPUT ---       blabel(1)=S:(Intercept);
  INPUT ---       blabel(2)=GammaDoublePrime:(Intercept);
  INPUT ---       blabel(3)=GammaPrime:(Intercept);
  INPUT ---       blabel(4)=p:(Intercept);
  INPUT ---       blabel(5)=f0:(Intercept);
  INPUT ---       rlabel(1)=S g1 c1 a0 t1;
  INPUT ---       rlabel(2)=Gamma'' g1 c1 a0 t1;
  INPUT ---       rlabel(3)=Gamma' g1 c1 a1 t2;
  INPUT ---       rlabel(4)=p g1 s1 t1;
  INPUT ---       rlabel(5)=f0 g1 a0 s1 t0;
   Model is { S(~1)Gamma''(~1)Gamma'(~1)p(~1)c()f0(~1) }
   Link Function Used is PARM-SPECIFIC
   Variance Estimation Procedure Used is 2ndPart

   M(t+1):
 Group=Group 1                                                                        
        20     22     26    { S(~1)Gamma''(~1)Gamma'(~1)p(~1)c()f0(~1) } Iteration 21                      
   CPU Time for numerical optimization was 0.02 seconds.    
   -2logL { S(~1)Gamma''(~1)Gamma'(~1)p(~1)c()f0(~1) } = 665.03291    
   Penalty { S(~1)Gamma''(~1)Gamma'(~1)p(~1)c()f0(~1) } = 0.0000000    
   Gradient { S(~1)Gamma''(~1)Gamma'(~1)p(~1)c()f0(~1) }:{ S(~1)Gamma''(~1)Gamma'(~1)p(~1)c()f0(~1) } VC Matrix: 100% done.  CPU Time to compute VC matrix was 0.01 seconds.    

 CPU Time to invert VC matrix was 0.01 seconds.    
 Gap Method for Num. of Estimated Parameters { S(~1)Gamma''(~1)Gamma'(~1)p(~1)c()f0(~1) } = 5          
 Numerical Threshold Method for Num. of Estimated Parameters { S(~1)Gamma''(~1)Gamma'(~1)p(~1)c()f0(~1) } = 5          
 Number of Estimated Parameters { S(~1)Gamma''(~1)Gamma'(~1)p(~1)c()f0(~1) } = 5          
   DEVIANCE { S(~1)Gamma''(~1)Gamma'(~1)p(~1)c()f0(~1) } = 535.97705                    
 DEVIANCE Degrees of Freedom { S(~1)Gamma''(~1)Gamma'(~1)p(~1)c()f0(~1) } = 61            
   c-hat { S(~1)Gamma''(~1)Gamma'(~1)p(~1)c()f0(~1) } = 8.7865090    
   AIC { S(~1)Gamma''(~1)Gamma'(~1)p(~1)c()f0(~1) } = 675.03291    
   AICc { S(~1)Gamma''(~1)Gamma'(~1)p(~1)c()f0(~1) } = 675.35723    
   BIC { S(~1)Gamma''(~1)Gamma'(~1)p(~1)c()f0(~1) } = 691.29427    
   Pearson Chisquare { S(~1)Gamma''(~1)Gamma'(~1)p(~1)c()f0(~1) } = 0.4326168E+10

   CPU Time for the last procedure was 0.02 seconds.    

  INPUT --- proc stop;

     CPU Time in minutes for this job was 0.00

     Time Start = 09:45:18.056   Time End = 09:45:18.195

     Wall Clock Time in minutes for this job was 0.00
STOP NORMAL EXIT

Output summary for Robust model
Name : S(~1)Gamma''(~1)Gamma'(~1)p(~1)c()f0(~1)

Npar :  5
-2lnL:  665.0329
AICc :  675.3572

Beta
                               estimate        se        lcl        ucl
S:(Intercept)                 0.3424579 0.5806818 -0.7956785  1.4805943
GammaDoublePrime:(Intercept) -0.5859911 0.7739881 -2.1030079  0.9310256
GammaPrime:(Intercept)       -0.2377173 2.4365461 -5.0133479  4.5379132
p:(Intercept)                -1.6562390 0.1034881 -1.8590757 -1.4534024
f0:(Intercept)                1.3812636 0.3463652  0.7023878  2.0601393


Real Parameter S
 
          1         2         3         4
1 0.5847875 0.5847875 0.5847875 0.5847875
2           0.5847875 0.5847875 0.5847875
3                     0.5847875 0.5847875
4                               0.5847875


Real Parameter GammaDoublePrime
 
          1         2         3         4
1 0.3575552 0.3575552 0.3575552 0.3575552
2           0.3575552 0.3575552 0.3575552
3                     0.3575552 0.3575552
4                               0.3575552


Real Parameter GammaPrime
 
         2        3        4
1 0.440849 0.440849 0.440849
2          0.440849 0.440849
3                   0.440849


Real Parameter p
 Session:1
         1         2         3         4         5         6         7         8         9
 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675

 Session:2
         1         2         3         4         5         6         7         8         9
 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675
        10
 0.1602675

 Session:3
         1         2         3         4         5         6         7         8         9
 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675
        10
 0.1602675

 Session:4
         1         2         3         4         5         6         7         8         9
 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675
        10
 0.1602675

 Session:5
         1         2         3         4         5         6         7         8         9
 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675
        10
 0.1602675


Real Parameter c
 Session:1
         2         3         4         5         6         7         8         9
 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675

 Session:2
         2         3         4         5         6         7         8         9        10
 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675

 Session:3
         2         3         4         5         6         7         8         9        10
 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675

 Session:4
         2         3         4         5         6         7         8         9        10
 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675

 Session:5
         2         3         4         5         6         7         8         9        10
 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675 0.1602675


Real Parameter f0
 Session:1
        0
 3.979927

 Session:2
        0
 3.979927

 Session:3
        0
 3.979927

 Session:4
        0
 3.979927

 Session:5
        0
 3.979927
There were 40 warnings (use warnings() to see them)
> cleanup(ask = FALSE)

jcl...@utk.edu

unread,
Oct 18, 2022, 5:02:39 PM10/18/22
to secr
What version of RMark are you running?  Mine still does not work even with the "join".

Murray Efford

unread,
Oct 18, 2022, 5:07:53 PM10/18/22
to jcl...@utk.edu, secr
packageVersion("RMark")
[1] ‘2.2.7’

Murray Efford

unread,
Oct 18, 2022, 5:12:05 PM10/18/22
to jcl...@utk.edu, secr
Something may have changed in RMark 3.0.0 (August 2022). I haven't time to check just now. Would be good if you can track this down.
Murray

jcl...@utk.edu

unread,
Oct 20, 2022, 11:39:21 AM10/20/22
to secr
I have both "marked" and "RMark" loaded.  I should have specified RMark for the process.data command
RMark::process.data

Murray Efford

unread,
Oct 20, 2022, 1:34:17 PM10/20/22
to jcl...@utk.edu, secr
It sounds like you found a simple explanation and solution. Thanks for reporting.
Murray

Reply all
Reply to author
Forward
0 new messages