jkr, I am down in Shiawassee county (between Flint and Lansing). I have a tower about miles away (to the SE). I suspect you have a weak signal so SDRTrunk is not finding a control channel to lock on to.
First off do you have all four Benzie CC channels loaded in your channels entry for Benzie? SDRTRUNK will rotate between the CC channels and lock on which ever is handling commands and traffic. Depending on your location you mau or may not be able to receive from both sites. You can always remove the CC's for the site that you are not "hearing" I have C4FM as the modulation.
The Frequencies in the "tuners" tab will shift around as they tend to tune to the center of the bandwidth of the voice channels. The display on the control entry of the "now playing" screen will however show the actual frequencies of the CC and Voice channels.
Once you do start receiving some traffic look at each tuner and you can adjust the PPM (up or down) to get the measured error as low as possible. I've had good luck getting the error in the 100hz plus or minus. Make sur eyou have "Enable decoder(s) to auto-adjust PPM" clicked. Also, what are you using for controls for each tuner? I started off with AUTO and then played with the various values while checkinh back an forth to MESSAGES and Channel tabs.
On my channel display (while clicked on CONTROL I show a signal strength of -24.5 with peaks around -19.8. I have found anything lower than -43 db I do not get good receiving results.
How far away are the two Benzie towers from your house? Do you have an LNA to help boost signal? Type of antenna? How High?
Good luck, John.