Jira (HI-630) Issues knocking out hiera values

[Helmut Ritter (Jira)]

Helmut Ritter created an issue

Hiera / HI-630 Issues knocking out hiera values Issue Type: Bug Assignee: Unassigned Created: 2022/03/25 3:07 AM Environment: helmut@puppet:~$ lsb_release -d Description:    Ubuntu 20.04.4 LTS helmut@puppet:~$ puppet -V 7.14.0 helmut@puppet:~$ hiera -V 3.8.0 helmut@puppet:~$ Priority: Normal Reporter: Helmut Ritter Given the following hera.yaml:   — version: 5 defaults:   datadir:   /etc/puppetlabs/code/environments/%{::environment}/hieradata   data_hash: yaml_data hierarchy:   - name:  "Nodes"     path:  "nodes/%{::fqdn}.yaml"   - name:  "Domains"     globs:       - "domains/%{::domain}/*.yaml"   - name:  "Operating Systems"     paths:       - "%{::operatingsystem}-%{::virtual}.yaml"       - "%{::operatingsystem}-%{::operatingsystemrelease}.yaml"       - "%{::operatingsystem}.yaml"       - "%{::kernel}.yaml"   - name:  "Roles"     path:  "roles.yaml"   - name:  "Profiles"     path:  "profiles.yaml"   - name:  "Applications"     globs:       - "apps/*.yaml"   - name:  "Common settings"     path:  "common.yaml"   common.yaml: lookup_options:   classes:     merge:       strategy:          'deep'       knockout_prefix:   '–' [...] classes: [...]  - openntpd   The value "openntpd" can be knocked out via "- -openntpd" both from "%{::kernel}.yaml" and "%{::operatingsystem}.yaml" but not from "%{::operatingsystem}%{::operatingsystemrelease}.yaml" or later anymore. If I change order in hiera.yaml to:     - name:  "Operating Systems"     paths:       - "%{::operatingsystem}-%{::virtual}.yaml"       - "%{::operatingsystem}.yaml"       - "%{::kernel}.yaml"       - "%{::operatingsystem}-%{::operatingsystemrelease}.yaml"   "openntpd" get's knocked out from "%{::operatingsystem}-%{::operatingsystemrelease}.yaml" and "%{::kernel}.yaml" but not from "%{::operatingsystem}.yaml" and later. Add Comment

This message was sent by Atlassian Jira (v8.20.2#820002-sha1:829506d)

[Helmut Ritter (Jira)]

Helmut Ritter commented on HI-630

Re: Issues knocking out hiera values To reproduce:   hiera.yaml: — version: 5

defaults:   datadir:   /etc/puppetlabs/code/environments/%{::environment}/hieradata   data_hash: yaml_data

hierarchy:   - name:  "Nodes"     path:  "nodes/%{::fqdn}.yaml"   - name:  "Domains"     globs:       - "domains/%{::domain}/*.yaml"

- name:  "Operating System Release"     path:  "%{::operatingsystem}-%{::operatingsystemrelease}.yaml"   - name:  "Operating System"     path:  "%{::operatingsystem}.yaml"   - name:  "Kernel"     path:  "%{::kernel}.yaml"   - name:  "Operating System Platform"     path:  "%{::operatingsystem}-%{::virtual}.yaml"

- name:  "Roles"     path:  "roles.yaml"

- name:  "Applications"     globs:       - "apps/*.yaml"   - name:  "Common settings"     path:  "common.yaml"

common.yaml: — lookup_options:   knockout:     merge:       strategy:          'deep'       knockout_prefix:   '–' knockout:   - common   - roles   - kernel   - operatingsystem-virtual   - operatingsystem-operatingsystemrelease   - node roles.yaml: — knockout:   - --roles   kernel.yaml: — knockout:   - --kernel   operatingsystem-virtual.yaml: — knockout:   - --operatingsystem-virtual   Result ("roles" got knocked out): [helmut@BSDHelmut ~]$ sudo puppet agent -t -v Info: Using environment 'production' Info: Retrieving pluginfacts Info: Retrieving plugin Info: Loading facts Info: Caching catalog for bsdhelmut.charlieroot.de Info: Applying configuration version '1648205634' Notice: [common, kernel, operatingsystem-virtual, operatingsystem-operatingsystemrelease, node] Notice: /Stage[main]/Config/Notify[Knockout:]/message: defined 'message' as '[common, kernel, operatingsystem-virtual, operatingsystem-operatingsystemrelease, node]' Notice: Applied catalog in 19.34 seconds [helmut@BSDHelmut ~]$   Now change order in hiera.yaml and put "kernel.yaml" somewhere lower:

— version: 5 defaults:   datadir:   /etc/puppetlabs/code/environments/%{::environment}/hieradata   data_hash: yaml_data

hierarchy:   - name:  "Nodes"     path:  "nodes/%{::fqdn}.yaml"   - name:  "Domains"     globs:       - "domains/%{::domain}/*.yaml"

- name:  "Operating System Release"     path:  "%{::operatingsystem}-%{::operatingsystemrelease}.yaml"   - name:  "Operating System"     path:  "%{::operatingsystem}.yaml"  - name:  "Kernel"    path:  "%{::kernel}.yaml"   - name:  "Operating System Platform"     path:  "%{::operatingsystem}-%{::virtual}.yaml"

- name:  "Roles"     path:  "roles.yaml"

- name:  "Kernel"     path:  "%{::kernel}.yaml"

- name:  "Applications"     globs:       - "apps/*.yaml"   - name:  "Common settings"     path:  "common.yaml"

Result ("kernel" got knocked out but "roles" didn't): Notice: [common, roles, operatingsystem-virtual, operatingsystem-operatingsystemrelease, node] Notice: /Stage[main]/Config/Notify[Knockout:]/message: defined 'message' as '[common, roles, operatingsystem-virtual, operatingsystem-operatingsystemrelease, node]'

Add Comment