Jira (FACT-2642) fact value for aggregates is printed twice on facter 3 and once on facter 4

[Andrei Filipovici (Jira)]

Andrei Filipovici created an issue

Facter / FACT-2642 fact value for aggregates is printed twice on facter 3 and once on facter 4 Issue Type: Bug Assignee: Unassigned Created: 2020/05/28 4:11 AM Priority: Normal Reporter: Andrei Filipovici For a fact with chunks: chunk(:chunk1) do     'value 1' end chunk(:chunk2) do     'value 2' end fact.value on facter 3 yields: value 1 value 2 [   "value 1",   "value 2" ]   facter 4 gives: value 1 value 2   if we have the aggregate method with just an int, when calling fact.value, facter 3 prints the value twice and facter 4 prints it twice. Add Comment

This message was sent by Atlassian Jira (v8.5.2#805002-sha1:a66f935)

[Andrei Filipovici (Jira)]

Andrei Filipovici updated an issue

Facter / FACT-2642 fact value for aggregates is printed twice on facter 3 and once on facter 4

Change By: Andrei Filipovici Sprint: ready for triage

Add Comment

[Mihai Buzgau (Jira)]

Mihai Buzgau updated an issue

Facter / FACT-2642 fact value for aggregates is printed twice on facter 3 and once on facter 4

Change By: Mihai Buzgau Story Points: 3

Add Comment

[Bogdan Irimie (Jira)]

Bogdan Irimie updated an issue

Facter / FACT-2642 fact value for aggregates is printed twice on facter 3 and once on facter 4

Change By: Bogdan Irimie Sprint: ready for triage

Add Comment

[Mihai Buzgau (Jira)]

Mihai Buzgau updated an issue

Facter / FACT-2642 fact value for aggregates is printed twice on facter 3 and once on facter 4

Change By: Mihai Buzgau Sprint: ready for triage

Add Comment

[Bogdan Irimie (Jira)]

Bogdan Irimie updated an issue

Facter / FACT-2642 fact value for aggregates is printed twice on facter 3 and once on facter 4

Change By: Bogdan Irimie Sprint: ready for triage ghost-26.08

Add Comment

[Andrei Filipovici (Jira)]

Andrei Filipovici assigned an issue to Andrei Filipovici

Facter / FACT-2642 fact value for aggregates is printed twice on facter 3 and once on facter 4

Change By: Andrei Filipovici Assignee: Andrei Filipovici

Add Comment

[Andrei Filipovici (Jira)]

Andrei Filipovici updated an issue

Facter / FACT-2642 fact value for aggregates is printed twice on facter 3 and once on facter 4 Change By: Andrei Filipovici

For a fact with chunks: chunk(:chunk1) do     [ 'value 1' ] end chunk(:chunk2) do     [ 'value 2' ] end fact.value on facter 3 yields: value 1 value 2 [   "value 1",   "value 2" ]   facter 4 gives: value 1 value 2   if we have the aggregate method with just an int, when calling fact.value, facter 3 prints the value twice and facter 4 prints it twice.

Add Comment

[Andrei Filipovici (Jira)]

Andrei Filipovici updated an issue

Facter / FACT-2642 fact value for aggregates is printed twice on facter 3 and once on facter 4 Change By: Andrei Filipovici

For a fact with chunks: chunk(:chunk1) do     ['value 1'] end chunk(:chunk2) do     ['value 2'] end

and no aggregate function is used.

fact.value on facter 3 yields: value 1 value 2 [   "value 1",   "value 2" ]

facter 4 and 2.5.7 gives: value 1 value 2   Also if we have add the aggregate method with just an int, when calling fact.value, facter 3 prints --json or --yaml option the value twice output on facter 2.5.7 and make a fact that aggregates two values: { "fact": null } On facter 4 prints it twice is: 1097 . 8 { "fact": null } On facter 3 is: 1071.6171875 { "agre": 1071.6171875 }

Add Comment

[Andrei Filipovici (Jira)]

Andrei Filipovici updated an issue

Facter / FACT-2642 fact value for aggregates is printed twice on facter 3 and once on facter 4 Change By: Andrei Filipovici

For a fact with chunks: chunk(:chunk1) do     ['value 1'] end chunk(:chunk2) do     ['value 2'] end and no aggregate function is used. fact.value on facter 3 yields: value 1 value 2 [   "value 1",   "value 2" ]   facter 4 and 2.5.7 gives: value 1 value 2

Also if we add the --json or --yaml option the output on facter 2.5.7 and make a fact that aggregates two values: { "fact": null } On facter 4 is: 1097.8 { { "fact": null

} On facter 3 is: 1071.6171875 {

{ " agre fact ": 1071.6171875 }

Add Comment

[Andrei Filipovici (Jira)]

{ "fact": 1071.6171875 } The same thing happens if we aggregate two hashes.

Add Comment

[Andrei Filipovici (Jira)]

The same thing happens if we aggregate two When the chunks are hashes and we use the --yaml option: facter 2 . 5: --- fact: facter 4: fact: "" facter 3: fact: ""

Add Comment

[Andrei Filipovici (Jira)]

Andrei Filipovici updated an issue

Facter / FACT-2642 fact value for aggregates is printed twice on facter 3 and once on facter 4 Change By: Andrei Filipovici

For When using the last example with the memory addition from here: [https://puppet.com/docs/facter/3.11/fact_overview.html#writing-facts-with-aggregate-resolutions] and print the fact without any option and with --yaml and --json the only difference between facter 3 and 4 is how float numbers are printed with the yaml option: On facter 3: fact: 1135.015625 Facter 4: fact: "1102.89" The rest is the same. Facter 2 can't even solve the fact.   When printing hash values, everything works the same and no aggregate function is used.   When printing arrays there's a spacing difference when using the --yaml option: Facter 3: fact :     - value 1     - value 2 Facter 4: fact: - value 1 - value 2   Facter 2.5.7 and facter 4 are unable to solve aggregate custom facts, if they are written with chunks : {code:java} chunk /fact = Facter::Util::Fact.new ( 'fact') fact.define_resolution('hgy', type : chunk1 :aggregate ) do       chunk(:physical_memory) do ['value 1'] end chunk(: chunk2 virtual_memory ) do     ['value 2']   end end and no aggregate function is used fact . value/ code placeholder {code}

fact.value on facter 3 yields:

value 1 value 2 [   "value 1",   "value 2" ]

facter 4 and 2.5.7 gives: give nil. value 1 value 2   Also if we add the when a fact can't be resolved and -- json or -- yaml option is used the output on facter 2.5.7 and make a fact that aggregates two values outputs are : { "fact": null } On facter Facter 3 and 4 is : 1097.8 { " fact " : null } "" On facter 3 is Facter 2.5.7 : 1071.6171875 --- { " fact " : 1071.6171875 } When the chunks are hashes and we use the -- yaml option json is used : facter Facter 4 and 2.5 .7 : --- { " fact " : null } facter 4: fact: "" facter Facter 3: { " fact " : "" }

Add Comment

[Bogdan Irimie (Jira)]

Bogdan Irimie updated an issue

Facter / FACT-2642 fact value for aggregates is printed twice on facter 3 and once on facter 4

Change By: Bogdan Irimie Sprint: ghost-26.08 , ready for triage 2

Add Comment