Jira (BOLT-1478) Scripts without explicit interpreters don't work

[Dylan Ratcliffe (JIRA)]

Dylan Ratcliffe created an issue

Puppet Task Runner / BOLT-1478 Scripts without explicit interpreters don't work Issue Type: Bug Affects Versions: BOLT 1.26.0 Assignee: Unassigned Created: 2019/07/23 12:50 AM Environment: Here is the full debug output of the commands that I ran: Running the task over winrm:  bolt task run python --nodes winstudents -i inventory.yaml --debug --modulepath . Ignoring byebug-10.0.2 because its extensions are not built. Try: gem pristine byebug --version 10.0.2 Loaded inventory from /Users/dylan/pxp-test/inventory.yaml Ignoring byebug-10.0.2 because its extensions are not built. Try: gem pristine byebug --version 10.0.2 Submitting analytics: { "v": 1, "cid": "cd6ff8b7-57ce-46f8-9394-07e32b28c7f5", "tid": "UA-120367942-1", "an": "bolt", "av": "1.26.0", "aip": true, "ul": "en-AU", "cd1": "Darwin 18", "t": "screenview", "cd": "task_run", "cd5": "human", "cd4": 1, "cd2": 8, "cd3": 7 } Loading modules from /opt/puppetlabs/bolt/lib/ruby/gems/2.5.0/gems/bolt-1.26.0/bolt-modules:/Users/dylan/pxp-test:/opt/puppetlabs/bolt/lib/ruby/gems/2.5.0/gems/bolt-1.26.0/modules Started with 100 max thread(s) Completed analytics submission Starting: task python on 3.8.187.183 Submitting analytics: { "v": 1, "cid": "cd6ff8b7-57ce-46f8-9394-07e32b28c7f5", "tid": "UA-120367942-1", "an": "bolt", "av": "1.26.0", "aip": true, "ul": "en-AU", "cd1": "Darwin 18", "t": "event", "ec": "Transport", "ea": "initialize", "el": "winrm", "ev": 1 } Running task python with '{"_task"=>"python"}' on ["3.8.187.183"] Running task run '#<struct Bolt::Task name="python", file=nil, files=[{"name"=>"init.py", "path"=>"/Users/dylan/pxp-test/python/tasks/init.py"}], metadata={"description"=>"does a python thing"}>' on 3.8.187.183 Started on 3.8.187.183... Completed analytics submission Opened session Executing command: $parent = [System.IO.Path]::GetTempPath() $name = [System.IO.Path]::GetRandomFileName() $path = Join-Path $parent $name New-Item -ItemType Directory -Path $path | Out-Null $pathstdout: C:\Users\Administrator\AppData\Local\Temp\jiigl2jc.uw3stderr: Command returned successfully Executing command: Remove-Item -Force -Recurse -Path "C:\Users\Administrator\AppData\Local\Temp\jiigl2jc.uw3"Command returned successfully Closed session {"node":"3.8.187.183","target":"3.8.187.183","action":null,"object":null,"status":"failure","result":{"_error":{"kind":"puppetlabs.tasks/task_file_error","msg":"File extension .py is not enabled, to run it please add to 'winrm: extensions'","details":{},"issue_code":"FILETYPE_ERROR"}}} Failed on 3.8.187.183: File extension .py is not enabled, to run it please add to 'winrm: extensions' Finished: task python with 1 failure in 1.12 sec Failed on 1 node: 3.8.187.183 Ran on 1 node in 1.21 seconds Running the command:  bolt command run "cmd.exe /c C:\ProgramData\PuppetLabs\pxp-agent\tasks-cache\e377cfba7d31e263cca6a946714b0e0904219892b95b72ebe60bd14e297e376b\init.py" --nodes winstudents -i inventory.yaml --debug Ignoring byebug-10.0.2 because its extensions are not built. Try: gem pristine byebug --version 10.0.2 Loaded inventory from /Users/dylan/pxp-test/inventory.yaml Submitting analytics: { "v": 1, "cid": "cd6ff8b7-57ce-46f8-9394-07e32b28c7f5", "tid": "UA-120367942-1", "an": "bolt", "av": "1.26.0", "aip": true, "ul": "en-AU", "cd1": "Darwin 18", "t": "screenview", "cd": "command_run", "cd5": "human", "cd4": 1, "cd2": 8, "cd3": 7 } Started with 100 max thread(s) Starting: command 'cmd.exe /c C:\ProgramData\PuppetLabs\pxp-agent\tasks-cache\e377cfba7d31e263cca6a946714b0e0904219892b95b72ebe60bd14e297e376b\init.py' on 3.8.187.183 Completed analytics submission Submitting analytics: { "v": 1, "cid": "cd6ff8b7-57ce-46f8-9394-07e32b28c7f5", "tid": "UA-120367942-1", "an": "bolt", "av": "1.26.0", "aip": true, "ul": "en-AU", "cd1": "Darwin 18", "t": "event", "ec": "Transport", "ea": "initialize", "el": "winrm", "ev": 1 } Running command 'cmd.exe /c C:\ProgramData\PuppetLabs\pxp-agent\tasks-cache\e377cfba7d31e263cca6a946714b0e0904219892b95b72ebe60bd14e297e376b\init.py' on ["3.8.187.183"] Running command 'cmd.exe /c C:\ProgramData\PuppetLabs\pxp-agent\tasks-cache\e377cfba7d31e263cca6a946714b0e0904219892b95b72ebe60bd14e297e376b\init.py' on 3.8.187.183 Started on 3.8.187.183... Completed analytics submission Opened session Executing command: cmd.exe /c C:\ProgramData\PuppetLabs\pxp-agent\tasks-cache\e377cfba7d31e263cca6a946714b0e0904219892b95b72ebe60bd14e297e376b\init.py stdout: Goodbye, World!stderr: Command returned successfully Closed session {"node":"3.8.187.183","target":"3.8.187.183","action":"command","object":"cmd.exe /c C:\\ProgramData\\PuppetLabs\\pxp-agent\\tasks-cache\\e377cfba7d31e263cca6a946714b0e0904219892b95b72ebe60bd14e297e376b\\init.py","status":"success","result":{"stdout":"Goodbye, World!\r\n","stderr":"","exit_code":0}} Finished on 3.8.187.183: STDOUT: Goodbye, World! Finished: command 'cmd.exe /c C:\ProgramData\PuppetLabs\pxp-agent\tasks-cache\e377cfba7d31e263cca6a946714b0e0904219892b95b72ebe60bd14e297e376b\init.py' with 0 failures in 1.11 sec Successful on 1 node: 3.8.187.183 Ran on 1 node in 1.11 seconds Running the script:  bolt script run python/tasks/init.py --nodes winstudents -i inventory.yaml --debug --modulepath . Ignoring byebug-10.0.2 because its extensions are not built. Try: gem pristine byebug --version 10.0.2 Loaded inventory from /Users/dylan/pxp-test/inventory.yaml Submitting analytics: { "v": 1, "cid": "cd6ff8b7-57ce-46f8-9394-07e32b28c7f5", "tid": "UA-120367942-1", "an": "bolt", "av": "1.26.0", "aip": true, "ul": "en-AU", "cd1": "Darwin 18", "t": "screenview", "cd": "script_run", "cd5": "human", "cd4": 1, "cd2": 8, "cd3": 7 } Started with 100 max thread(s) Starting: script python/tasks/init.py on 3.8.187.183 Completed analytics submission Submitting analytics: { "v": 1, "cid": "cd6ff8b7-57ce-46f8-9394-07e32b28c7f5", "tid": "UA-120367942-1", "an": "bolt", "av": "1.26.0", "aip": true, "ul": "en-AU", "cd1": "Darwin 18", "t": "event", "ec": "Transport", "ea": "initialize", "el": "winrm", "ev": 1 } Running script python/tasks/init.py with '[]' on ["3.8.187.183"] Running script 'python/tasks/init.py' on 3.8.187.183 Started on 3.8.187.183... Completed analytics submission Opened session Executing command: $parent = [System.IO.Path]::GetTempPath() $name = [System.IO.Path]::GetRandomFileName() $path = Join-Path $parent $name New-Item -ItemType Directory -Path $path | Out-Null $pathstdout: C:\Users\Administrator\AppData\Local\Temp\m53mfj2y.kjestderr: Command returned successfully Executing command: Remove-Item -Force -Recurse -Path "C:\Users\Administrator\AppData\Local\Temp\m53mfj2y.kje"Command returned successfully Closed session Failed on 3.8.187.183: {"node":"3.8.187.183","target":"3.8.187.183","action":null,"object":null,"status":"failure","result":{"_error":{"kind":"puppetlabs.tasks/task_file_error","msg":"File extension .py is not enabled, to run it please add to 'winrm: extensions'","details":{},"issue_code":"FILETYPE_ERROR"}}} File extension .py is not enabled, to run it please add to 'winrm: extensions' Finished: script python/tasks/init.py with 1 failure in 2.08 sec Failed on 1 node: 3.8.187.183 Ran on 1 node in 2.08 seconds Priority: Normal Reporter: Dylan Ratcliffe When running a task written in say; python, I would expect it to work if I have the python interpreter installed as normal on my system without specifying the interpreter as per the config docs: https://puppet.com/docs/bolt/latest/bolt_configuration_options.html#sample-bolt-configuration-file I have the following very basic task written in python: print("Goodbye, World!") With the following metadata: { "description": "does a python thing" } When I run the task over PXP I get a 127 error as per PCP-879, but when I use bolt I get the following error: File extension .py is not enabled, to run it please add to 'winrm: extensions' However the interpreters are set up correctly on the system as copying the file to the system and running the following command works: bolt command run "cmd.exe /c C:\ProgramData\PuppetLabs\pxp-agent\tasks-cache\e377cfba7d31e263cca6a946714b0e0904219892b95b72ebe60bd14e297e376b\init.py" --nodes winstudents -i inventory.yaml --debug   It appears that if the file doesn't have a known interpreter Bolt doesn't even try to execute it which surely is undesired behaviour. Add Comment

This message was sent by Atlassian JIRA (v7.7.1#77002-sha1:e75ca93)

[Dylan Ratcliffe (JIRA)]

Dylan Ratcliffe updated an issue

Puppet Task Runner / BOLT-1478 Scripts without explicit interpreters don't work

Change By: Dylan Ratcliffe

When running a task written in say; python, I would expect it to work if I have the python interpreter installed as normal on my system without specifying the interpreter as per the config docs: [https://puppet.com/docs/bolt/latest/bolt_configuration_options.html#sample-bolt-configuration-file] I have the following very basic task written in python:

{code:java} print("Goodbye, World!") {code} With the following metadata: {code:java}

{   "description": "does a python thing"

} {code}

When I run the task over PXP I get a 127 error as per PCP-879, but when I use bolt I get the following error:

{code:java} File extension .py is not enabled, to run it please add to 'winrm: extensions' {code}

However the interpreters are set up correctly on the system as copying the file to the system and running the following command works:

{code:java} bolt command run "cmd.exe /c C:\ProgramData\PuppetLabs\pxp-agent\tasks-cache\e377cfba7d31e263cca6a946714b0e0904219892b95b72ebe60bd14e297e376b\init.py" --nodes winstudents -i inventory.yaml --debug {code}

It appears that if the file doesn't have a known interpreter Bolt doesn't even try to execute it which surely is undesired behaviour.

Full debug output can be found in the "Environment" section

Add Comment

[Alex Dreyer (JIRA)]

Alex Dreyer commented on BOLT-1478

Re: Scripts without explicit interpreters don't work Not executing files by default on windows is intentional based on feedback from the windows team it was decided that known handlers are often set up for GUI interactions and should not be just run.

Add Comment