cikr...@gmail.com
unread,May 10, 2019, 5:41:08 AM5/10/19Sign in to reply to author
Sign in to forward
You do not have permission to delete messages in this group
Either email addresses are anonymous for this group or you need the view member email addresses permission to view the original message
to OSM Android bikerouting
Hi
First of all, thank you very much for your work - brouter and Poutnik's profiles are just great.
Our situation might be a bit special since we have a bike trailer used for one (soon: two) children which is powered by a wheel hub motor, combined with "conventional" bikes. This drive likes running at around 25 km/h. We just returned from holidays in Südtirol where routes have been proposed which have been too steep for this system.
So my question is: can your profile be tweaked such that it doesn't route with slope > ~ 10-12% ?
The profile we used is based on the Tandem dry trekking profile which itself is based on v2.6 of Poutnik's Trekking profile, including some modifications:
- cycleroutes_pref 0.5 instead of 0.2
- MTB_factor 0.5 instead of 0.0
- smallpaved_factor 0.5 instead of 0.0
- hascycleway only for tracks (for better safety)
- additional path penalty of 0.5 * haulpenalty if highway=path and not isbike
- slight adjustments for not_isbike_penalty (for better safety)
With these modifications we got excellent routing in the foothills of the Alps (hilly) where we live as well as e.g. in France (Burgundy).
But in Südtirol we got routes proposed with 9.5 km, 286 m elevation gain and a max slope of ~15% for ~300 m, preferred over 12.2 km, 298 m elevation gain and max slope of ~10% (I understand why the shorter route has lower overall costs).
Is there a "workaround" in order to exclude such slopes (> 10-12%) which are unrideable with the trailer (similar to steps)? I've found that with uphillcostvalue 75, uphillcutoffvalue 3.2 the rideable route would be preferred in this very case - but is this the way to go? 50/5.0 would also work, and it would be along "with electric power, smaller slopes (<5%) don't matter" - but if we ride together, my wife takes trailer and motor while I've to pedal myself, without the 'e'... What do you recommend?
Thanks for your help (might also be helpful for others).
C. Kristol