At first glance, this does not seem like intended behavior. If you believe this to be an issue with the platform not behaving as documented or as intended, I'd recommend filing a new issue on the
Issue Tracker. Should you choose to do so, I recommend linking to this thread for context and posting a link to the public issue here so that others in the community can follow along. Be sure to include the following:
- The exact command being run to confirm that the failover replica is down and where it was run. This could also include logs or screenshots with timestamps
- The timestamp for when you run SHOW SLAVE STATUS on the replica which is giving you a potentially false positive. This too could include logs or screenshots
Keep in mind that this Groups forum is best suited for general discussions and best practices.