Here's an academic debate which has spilled over to the columns of the local newspapers (Herald/O Heraldo):
Milagris and Lairai: fostering the bond of divine unity
Sushila Sawant Mendes
QUOTE: Goencho Sahib unites us all. We have many such unifying factors. Every
generation of the people of Assolna, Velim and Cuncolim have grown up
with the belief that the Goddess Shantadurga of Fatorpa is the sister of
Saude Saibin of the Church of Our Lady of Health in Cuncolim. The
festival of the Sontrios in Cuncolim and the devotional visits of the
Catholics to this temple is a graphic representation of this undying
belief. Tomorrow is both the feast of Milagres Saibin at Mapusa and the
Shree Devi Lairai Zatra at Shirigao, both to be celebrated on the same
day after thirteen years, on April 24 this year. UNQUOTE
Mary to Mira: Just a sound away?
Oscar de Noronha
QUOTE The article titled ‘Milagris and Lairai: fostering the bond of divine unity’, by historian Dr Sushila Sawant Mendes (O Heraldo, April 23, 2023) has added to the myth rather than clarified it. One would expect to be enlightened on the origin of the statue of Our Lady of Miracles (Milagr Saibinn, in Konkani), or the story of the Seven Sisters, or even be favoured with a sociological or anthropological explanation; but that was not to be. At any rate, as a lay reader, I wish to raise a few issues about its interface with Catholic practices in Goan society. UNQUOTE