Different behaviour between native and browser versions

[Александр Гурьянов]

Hi there. I have very strange behaviour with emscripten version of dosbox-x. 

I use exactly same codebase for PC and browser. But they are behave differently. 

For example I have this simple DOS program:

#include <conio.h>

void main (int argc, char *argv[]) {
  printf("%.2f\n", (double) 1000);

}

I compile it for dos, and run it with dosbox-x in browser and PC. 

The PC output is 1000.00, but the browser output is 0.00. 

The weirdest thing is that this only happens with printf and %.2f, I tried David M. Gay's 'dtoa()' function to print the doubles 

manually and it works exactly the same under dosbox-x in browser and PC.

Asan, UBsan and valgrind does not see any errors in the code when I run it on PC.

I build dosbox-x with stacksize  = 1Mb, and I found that if I restore default value it start failing randomly. 

But error is always "unrechable executed" and not related to stacksize.

I tried Asan, UBsan for borwser build, and they are totaly ueseless they always end with same "unreachable executed" in same funcitons as a build without it. 

-s SAFE_HEAP=1/2 -sASSERTIONS=1 also end with "unreachable executed" in same functions.

I also tried -O1,O2 builds, nothing changed. I can't run -O0 because of the browser's local limits.

The typical error stack is:

ncaught RuntimeError: unreachable
    at DOS_Device::Write(unsigned char const*, unsigned short*) (0505c02e:0xb04ce3)
    at DOS_WriteFile(unsigned short, unsigned char const*, unsigned short*, bool) (0505c02e:0x1bc6a)
    at Program::WriteOut(char const*, ...) (0505c02e:0x9850)
    at showWelcome(Program*) (0505c02e:0x3a8372)
    at DOS_Shell::Prepare() (0505c02e:0xad20b5)
    at SHELL_Run() (0505c02e:0x95461e)
    at BIOS::cb_bios_boot__func() (0505c02e:0xc2be24)
    at Normal_Loop() (0505c02e:0x9b4470)
    at DOSBOX_RunMachine() (0505c02e:0xd3a9c)
    at jsdos_main(Config*) (0505c02e:0x7a3261)
$DOS_Device::Write(unsigned char const*, unsigned short*) @ 0505c02e:0xb04ce3
$DOS_WriteFile(unsigned short, unsigned char const*, unsigned short*, bool) @ 0505c02e:0x1bc6a
$Program::WriteOut(char const*, ...) @ 0505c02e:0x9850
$showWelcome(Program*) @ 0505c02e:0x3a8372
$DOS_Shell::Prepare() @ 0505c02e:0xad20b5
$SHELL_Run() @ 0505c02e:0x95461e
$BIOS::cb_bios_boot__func() @ 0505c02e:0xc2be24
$Normal_Loop() @ 0505c02e:0x9b4470
$DOSBOX_RunMachine() @ 0505c02e:0xd3a9c
$jsdos_main(Config*) @ 0505c02e:0x7a3261
$server_run() @ 0505c02e:0x75a157
$runRuntime @ 0505c02e:0x75edbf
ret.<computed> @ 7218a4e8-6c38-4c3c-9e76-65c481c94470:8
doRewind @ 7218a4e8-6c38-4c3c-9e76-65c481c94470:8
(anonymous) @ 7218a4e8-6c38-4c3c-9e76-65c481c94470:8
Module.receive @ 7218a4e8-6c38-4c3c-9e76-65c481c94470:8

[Александр Гурьянов]

https://github.com/emscripten-core/emscripten/issues/20947

чт, 7 дек. 2023 г. в 23:26, Александр Гурьянов <caii...@gmail.com>: