An awesome , quick response from Kevin Ash (finder of the Common Black-Hawk) and Cinnamon Bergeron has resulted in photos from Cinnamon showing the bird with a crayfish on the dam, and reference to photos in the eBird checklists of Alan Ketcham and Diane Roberts
showing the hawk with crayfish. These are all great verification that this somewhat lost young bird is acting as normally as a Common Black-Hawk in Colorado can by finding a good source of "mud bugs" (as crayfish are called in the South). In Ohio we called
them crawdads. Alan's photo shows the bird on the dam with two big claws lying next to it on the concrete. Obviously, this big hawk does what many others birds, most notably gulls, do when preparing to consume crayfish - they remove the claws. Many waterbirds
like Pied-billed Grebes and Hooded Mergansers skin the cat a little differently, probably because of the difficulty inherent with being in water and possessing feet adapted for pushing water, not delicately manipulating food: they just orient the morsel tailfirst
and then swallow it, claws and all.
Thanks to the folks above for their finding, photographing and sharing efforts.
Dave Leatherman
Fort Collins