Garth Spellman, the curator of ornithology at Denver Museum of Science and Nature, gave this reply when I inquired about his thoughts on this Hairy:
Looks like this individual has a problem with its melanin pathways. Black plumage is normally straight melanin and browns or tans are phaeomelanin. Oftentimes birds have problems or develop problems in these pathways that can lead to aberrant plumage. This can often happen in older birds, but not always. The brownish color actually looks like the same color found in Hairy Woodpeckers down in Panama (yes they get all the way down there). The subspecies in Panama is small and brown."
Linda Hodges
Colorado Springs