Commentaries on Tarkasangraha

[Nityananda Misra]

Dear list members

There are at least 90 known commentaries on the Tarkasangraha as per the appendix in the excellent English translation of the work by Mm V N Jha (ISBN 978-93-80864-03-7, CIFSS, 2010). Have all these been published? By any chance would anybody have a list of all published commentaries or commentaries available on archive on the work?

Thanks, Nityananda

--

Nityānanda Miśra

[ajit.gargeshwari]

Here is a Partial List

• Tarkasangraha as a Compromise Between Nyaya & Vaisesika Schools of Philosophy Priya K. (Thesis).pdf
• A Critical Study of the Tarkapada of the Brahmasutra Sankarabhashya - Biba Rani Kalita  (Thesis).pdf
• Bauddha Tarkabhasha Ka Samikshatmak Adhyayan - Arpana Guleria  (Thesis)
  
• Tarka Sangraha (Tika Traya) Dipika, Nyaya Bodhini of Govardhana Ganga of Sivadatta Mishra Gauda Sivadatta Mishra .pdf
• Tarka Sangraha- Complete Version(1).pdf
• Tarka Sangraha Dipika & Nilakanthi Nilakantha Bhatta Pandit Sivadatta Venkateswara Steam Press.pdf
• Tarka Sangraha Dipika Acharya Anand Jha.pdf
• Tarka Sangraha Dipika and Praksa Lakshmana Sarma 1864 (Pothi or Oblong).pdf
• Tarka Sangraha Dipika Dipiak Prakasa of Shankar Sharma Dalal Mehendale K.C., Dalvi D.J..pdf
• Tarka Sangraha Dipika English Translation and Notes Suktankar S.S..pdf
• Tarka Sangraha Dipika English Translation Bahulikar B.N..pdf
• Tarka Sangraha Dipika Kasinath Pandurang Parab Nirnaya Sagar Press (English Translation).pdf
• Tarka Sangraha Dipika Kasinath Pandurang Parab Pious Book Corporation.pdf
• Tarka Sangraha Dipika Nyaya Bodhini of Govardhan Mahadev Rajaram Bodas BSS 1918.pdf
• Tarka Sangraha Dipika Nyaya Bodhini of Govardhan Mahadev Rajaram Bodas BSS 1930.pdf
• Tarka Sangraha Dipika Nyaya Bodhini of Govardhan Mahadev Rajaram Bodas Pusalker A.D. BSS 1963.pdf
• Tarka Sangraha Dipika Nyaya Bodhini of Govardhan Mahadev Rajaram Bodos BSS 1918 (Appendix Missing).pdf
• Tarka Sangraha Dipika Phakkika of Kshma Kalya Gani Jitendra Jaitli, Jiana Vijaya Muni.pdf
• Tarka Sangraha Dipika Translation Nirnaya Sagar Press 1876.pdf
• Tarka Sangraha Ganga Shiva Dutta Mishra Guand.pdf
• Tarka Sangraha Hindi commentary Dayanand Bhargava MLBD.pdf
• Tarka Sangraha Hultzsch E. (German).pdf
• Tarka Sangraha James Ballantyne R. (Hindi Parphrase & English Version) 1851.pdf
• Tarka Sangraha James Ballantyne R. (Lectures on the Nyaya Philosophy of the Tarkasangraha) 1849.pdf
• Tarka Sangraha Kamala Vyakhya Govind Vaijapurkar S. Indumati Hindi Ramachandra Jha Chowkambha.pdf
• Tarka Sangraha Laksana Tippani Raja Narayana Shukla Chowkambha.pdf
• Tarka Sangraha Nyaya Bodhini and Hindi Tika Kedarnath Tripathi MLBD.pdf
• Tarka Sangraha Nyaya Bodhini Govardhan & Padakritya Chandrasinhva Ed. Dhundhiraja Sastri P. Shastri Chowkambha (Incomplete).pdf
• Tarka Sangraha Nyaya Bodhini Govardhan & Padakritya Chandrasinhva Pandit Sivadatta Venkateswara Steam Press 1892.pdf
• Tarka Sangraha Nyaya Bodhini Govardhan & Padakritya Chandrasinhva Pandit Sivadatta Venkateswara Steam Press 1949.pdf
• Tarka Sangraha Nyaya Bodhini Padakrutya Chandraja Simha Bala Manorama Guruprasad Shastri Parikshika Sita Rama Shastri.pdf
• Tarka Sangraha Nyaya Bodhini Sita Sanskrit & Padma Hindi Vyakhya Anand Jha Nyayacharya.pdf
• Tarka Sangraha Nyaya Shekhara Kunigal Yagna Narayana Shastri Sringeri.pdf
• Tarka Sangraha of Ananda Gyana Tripathi T.M. University of Baroda 3 (MS).pdf
• Tarka Sangraha Padakrutya Chandraja Simha Nyaya Bodhini Govardhana Ambikaprasad Sharma.pdf
• Tarka Sangraha Padakrutya Chandraja Simha Nyaya Bodhini Govardhana Vishma Sthala Mahadev Gangadhar Bakre Panis Nirnaya 1919.pdf
• Tarka Sangraha Padakrutya Chandraja Simha Nyaya Bodhini Govardhana Vishma Sthala Mahadev Gangadhar Bakre Panis Nirnaya 1925.pdf
• Tarka Sangraha Printed At Akhya Shila Yantra, Mumbai (Pothi or Oblong Book).pdf
• Tarka Sangraha Sukha Praveshini Vira Raghavacharya T..pdf
• Tarka Sangraha with 9 commentaries Chandrashekahara Sastri Bala Manorama Press.pdf
• Tarka Sangraha With Four Commentaries Dhundhiraja Sastri P. Shastri Chowkambha.pdf
• Tarka Sangraha, Bhaskarodaya on Tarka Sangraha Dipika Prakasa of Nilakantha of Laksmi Narasimha Mukund Jha Chowkambha.pdf
• Tarka Sangraha, Bhaskarodaya on Tarka Sangraha Dipika Prakasa of Nilakantha of Laksmi Narasimha Mukund Jha Nirnaya Sagar press.pdf
• Tarka Sangraha, Dipika Sarvasva Kuruganti Sri Rama Shastri Kuganti Sri Rama Shastri.pdf
• Tarka Sangraha, Elements Of Indian Logic And Epistemology Chandrodaya Bhattacharya.pdf
• Tarka Sangraha, Elements of indian logic Atreya B.L. (LQ).pdf
• Tarka Sangraha, Paribhashika Padartha Sangraha Kurugunti Srinivas Shastri .pdf
• Tarka Sangraha, Tarka Sangraha Sarvasva Paribhashita Padartha Sangraha Rama Bramha Shastri.pdf
• Tarka Sangraha, Translation Jivanands Vidyasagar 1872.pdf
• Tarka Sangraha Rahasya (Tarka Sangraha Prasnottari) Kirtyananda Jha Chowkamabha
• Tarka Sangraha Padakrutya Hindi Bhashya Sesha Raja Sharma Regmi Chowkambha
• Tarka Sangraha Nyaya Bodhini Padakrutya & Megha Hindi Bhashya Sasvatanada Jha Chowkambha
• Tarka Sangraha Nyaya Bodhini Padakrutya Dipika Kiranvalli of Krishna Vallbhacharya
• Tarka Sangraha Dipika Indumati Sanskrita Hindi Vyakhya Ramachandra Jha Chowkambha 1972

Regards

Ajit Gargeshwari

[Ajit Gargeshwari]

Another Partial List

Tarka Sangraha Bala Bodhini Narasimha Deva Shastri Tippani Madhava Shastri Bhandari
Tarka Sangraha Dipika Indumati Sanskrita Hindi Vyakhya Ramachandra Jha Chowkambha 1976
Dipaka Prakarna Subrahmanya Sastri Sakti Sanjivini Rama Sarma P.S. Ed. Sankaranaryan S. (Tarka Sangraha)
Nila Kantha Prakasika Vyakhya on Tarka Sangraha Dipika by Nilakantha Bhatta
Tarka Sangraha ( Sabda Bodha Dala krutya) Artha Vivarna  Vadavi Madhvacharya
Tarka Sangraha Bala Prabodhini Upanayasa, Ullasa Shiva Narayan Shastri
Tarka Sangraha Dalakrutya Sabdha Bodha
Tarka Sangraha Guru Krupa Vyakhya Narasimha Murthy M.L. Venkateswara University
Tarka Sangraha Hindi Commentary Daynand Bhargav MLBD
Tarka Sangraha Nyayabodhini Govardhana Nyaya Bodhini Visaya Mala Kamakshi Ed. Madhvacharya Pandurangi PPSM
Tarka Sangraha Padartha Sagar Krishnava Dhuta Pandita Ed. Manur Bhima Bhatta
Tarka Sangraha Sabda Bodha Raja Giriyacharya S. ( Sujayendra Tirtha)
Tarka Sangraha Sarvasava Kurugunti Rama Sastri Ed. Maha Nanda Jha
Tarka Sangraha Dipika & Kiranavallli Ed. Unknown
Tarka Sangraha Dipika Translation Kasihinath Pandurang Parab with En Tr. Nirnaya Sagar Press
Tarka Sangraha Laghu Bodhini Sankara Desika Venkateswara Steam Press
Tarka Sangraha Indumati Ramachandra Jha Tika Rajanaryan Shastri Chowkambha
Nyaya Sekhari by Navin Hollal a commentary on Tarka Sangraha Sharda Pitha Sringeri
Sangrahartha Sangraha by Padumannur Narayanachar Prahaldacharya D. (Tarka Sangraha)
Tarka Sangraha Aloka Vyakhya by Navya Mangal Abhijana Varadhacharya
Tarka Sangraha Dipika Nyaya Bodhini Padakrutya Kiranavalli Vyakhya Krishna Vallabhacharya Chowkambha
Tarka Sangraha Dipika Prakasika with Balapriya and Prasarna Ramanuja Tatacharya N.S. (revised)
Tarka Sangraha Dipika Prakasika with Balapriya and Prasarna Ramanuja Tatacharya N.S.
Tarka Sangraha Dipika Swami Virupakshananda R.K. Mutt
Tarka Sangraha Padakrutya Chandraji Sharma Tarka Mimamsa Gajanan Shastri Musalgaonkar Chowkambha
Tarka Sangraha Sabda Bodha Nyaya Bodhni of Govardhanaand Padakrutya of Chandraji Sharma
Tarka Sangraha Sakti Sanjivini Rama Sarma P.S. Ed. with Tippani Sankaranarayanan S.
Tarka Sangraha Several Commentaries Ed. Satkari Sharma Vangiya Chowkhamba
Tarka Sangraha, Vidyadhari by Goda Subramanya Shastri By Devadatta Sharma

Regards
Ajit Gargeshwari
न जायते म्रियते वा कदाचिन्नायं भूत्वा भविता वा न भूयः।
अजो नित्यः शाश्वतोऽयं पुराणो न हन्यते हन्यमाने शरीरे।।2.20।।

--
You received this message because you are subscribed to a topic in the Google Groups "भारतीयविद्वत्परिषत्" group.
To unsubscribe from this topic, visit https://groups.google.com/d/topic/bvparishat/Md2i5-gNNyQ/unsubscribe.
To unsubscribe from this group and all its topics, send an email to bvparishat+...@googlegroups.com.
To view this discussion on the web visit https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/bvparishat/17ef6a5c-a08b-4e3a-8692-a8aec43e8e9d%40googlegroups.com.

[Madhav Deshpande]

Thank you so much, Ajit Ji, for this marvelous list of commentaries on the Tarkasaṃgraha.  The other work that has a very large number of commentaries is Mammaṭa's Kāvyaprakāśa.  The number of commentaries is a kind of measure of the popularity of a given work.  For some reason, introductory works on Mīmāṃsā like the Mīmāṃsā-Paribhāṣā and Mīmāṃsā-Nyāya-Prakāśa don't have such a large number of commentaries.  Even the Vedānta-Paribhāṣā does not have such a large number of commentaries.  Did more students study the Tarkasaṃgraha as compared to students studying these other works from allied branches?  What has been the experience in the Pāṭhaśālās?

Madhav M. Deshpande

Professor Emeritus, Sanskrit and Linguistics

University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan, USA

Senior Fellow, Oxford Center for Hindu Studies

[Residence: Campbell, California, USA]

--
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "भारतीयविद्वत्परिषत्" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to bvparishat+...@googlegroups.com.

[V Subrahmanian]

On Fri, Oct 18, 2019 at 10:54 PM Madhav Deshpande <mmd...@umich.edu> wrote:

Thank you so much, Ajit Ji, for this marvelous list of commentaries on the Tarkasaṃgraha.  The other work that has a very large number of commentaries is Mammaṭa's Kāvyaprakāśa.  The number of commentaries is a kind of measure of the popularity of a given work.  For some reason, introductory works on Mīmāṃsā like the Mīmāṃsā-Paribhāṣā and Mīmāṃsā-Nyāya-Prakāśa don't have such a large number of commentaries.  Even the Vedānta-Paribhāṣā does not have such a large number of commentaries.  Did more students study the Tarkasaṃgraha as compared to students studying these other works from allied branches?  What has been the experience in the Pāṭhaśālās?

One reason could be the fact of काणादं पाणिनीयं च ....So, all those who go for mimamsa, uttara and purva, will have studied the tarka sangraha and of course, the more advanced works there. 

As an aside, it is said the Srimadbhagavatam has several hundred commentaries. 

warm regards

subrahmanian.v 

[Madhav Deshpande]

Thinking about texts with high number of commentaries, two works that come to my mind are Nāgeśabhaṭṭa's Paribhāṣenduśekhara and Śabdenduśekhara.  It looks like while Śabdenduśekhara was widely studied, the larger work Br̥hat-Śabdenduśekhara was not studied so widely.  Similarly, while the Parama-Laghu-Mañjūṣā and the Laghumañjūṣā were studied more widely, the larger Br̥hat-Mañjūṣā was not studied so widely. These larger texts have only recently been published, while the shorter texts have undergone numerous editions, commentaries and reprints. For some reason, there are half dozen commentaries on Kaiyaṭa's Pradīpa [now published from Pondichery], but not so many on Nāgeśa's Uddyota [except Vaidyanāṭha's Chāyā, extracts included in the Nirnaya Sagara edition of the Mahābhāṣya].  I am wondering what all these differences point to.  It would be nice to have some sort of a historical account of the curriculums of traditional Pāṭhaśālās for the last few centuries from various parts of India.  That might throw some light on which texts were more widely studied and where.  Do we have sources for such a historical account?

Madhav M. Deshpande

Professor Emeritus, Sanskrit and Linguistics

University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan, USA

Senior Fellow, Oxford Center for Hindu Studies

[Residence: Campbell, California, USA]

--
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "भारतीयविद्वत्परिषत्" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to bvparishat+...@googlegroups.com.

To view this discussion on the web visit https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/bvparishat/CAKk0Te1NiDpXnZ1YK9d_nAesuwjTwNgXXV%2B6%2B52krKZ68XiJVA%40mail.gmail.com.

[Ajit Gargeshwari]

A bibliography has to be created consulting NCC and books which have accurate an verifiable bibliography information. Once that is done in a comprehensive manner then further analytical studies including 'historical account of the curriculums of traditional Pāṭhaśālās for the last few centuries from various parts of India' Newer editions and more secondary studies is possible Request subject matter experts like you to contribute towards a comprehensive bibliography .

PS It is just not enough to say a given text has a thousand commentaries. Those commentaries have to be listed. Published information should be documented and manuscripts where they exists information should be given accurately

Regards
Ajit Gargeshwari
न जायते म्रियते वा कदाचिन्नायं भूत्वा भविता वा न भूयः।
अजो नित्यः शाश्वतोऽयं पुराणो न हन्यते हन्यमाने शरीरे।।2.20।।

[Ajit Gargeshwari]

Can scholars please point out books or reports which have information on  curriculum being followed by different pathashals across India. Have the  curriculum and emphasis changed over the centuries. What are the texts and which editions of the texts are prescribed for various branches of learning.

Regards
Ajit Gargeshwari
न जायते म्रियते वा कदाचिन्नायं भूत्वा भविता वा न भूयः।
अजो नित्यः शाश्वतोऽयं पुराणो न हन्यते हन्यमाने शरीरे।।2.20।।

[K S Kannan]

This pursuit also involves the question of how many pathashala teachers are members of BVP. After "Sanskrit in India" survey of 1974(?), do we have an updated list of pathashala-s?

At least if we have pathashala-heads on our list, there may be some hope for some decent quantum of information.

--

You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "भारतीयविद्वत्परिषत्" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to bvparishat+...@googlegroups.com.

To view this discussion on the web visit https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/bvparishat/CALaEieiGSBhc7bEzAi0ANCAb%3D4OXNYdRacc%2BfUMTfKta3vNHsw%40mail.gmail.com.

[Ajit Gargeshwari]

Directory of Indological Research Institutes & Veda Pathashala Ed. Bhgyalata Pataskar Vaidika Samsodhana Mandala,2010

The book covers  curriculum for patshals in which Vedas are thought upto 2010

Are more such books and reports available

Regards
Ajit Gargeshwari
न जायते म्रियते वा कदाचिन्नायं भूत्वा भविता वा न भूयः।
अजो नित्यः शाश्वतोऽयं पुराणो न हन्यते हन्यमाने शरीरे।।2.20।।

You received this message because you are subscribed to a topic in the Google Groups "भारतीयविद्वत्परिषत्" group.
To unsubscribe from this topic, visit https://groups.google.com/d/topic/bvparishat/Md2i5-gNNyQ/unsubscribe.
To unsubscribe from this group and all its topics, send an email to bvparishat+...@googlegroups.com.
To view this discussion on the web visit https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/bvparishat/CAN47gm4UHsPvBKv0K5bnE3OCTei_uDa8NnJCoV4bgx%2Byf5q4Vw%40mail.gmail.com.

[Siddharth Wakankar]

Dear Friends,

There are many local libraries or centres of learning where rare manuscripts are preserved.

Some 25/30 years back,I saw one such com.on the Tarkasangraha in the Sarvajanik Vachanalay,Nashik. It is written by some scholar named Gadgil Shastri. This library, like the H.P.T.College,Nashik,contains many rare and unknown Sanskrit MSS.

Moreover,in the Libraries of the different Maharajas also,there is a treasure of old and rare MSS not much known outside that State. It is just possible that we may get some com.on the Tarkasangraha in those libraries.

Some young scholars should take up such a project to unearth such rare and almost unknown MSS.,by focusing on certain specific texts.

Prof. Siddharth Y Wakankar.

Vadodara.9427339942.

To view this discussion on the web visit https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/bvparishat/CALaEiej33rTPwMX2OMsduXXgUD2sEkJTk-OPp74q6ZnJ4zX-2w%40mail.gmail.com.

[Roland Steiner]

> Some young scholars should take up such a project to unearth such rare and
> almost unknown MSS.,by focusing on certain specific texts.

Just released:

The second volume of Bhāskarakaṇṭha's Mokṣopāya-Nirvāṇa-Ṭīkā edited by
Bruno Lo Turco (Roma).

"This volume completes the critical edition of the large extant
fragment of the Nirvāṇaprakaraṇa — the sixth section of the Mokṣopāya
— with the commentary Nirvāṇaṭīkā of Bhāskarakaṇṭha, one of the last
great non-dualist Śaivite masters. The Mokṣopāya, a huge
philosophico-soteriological work probably composed by a Kashmiri
author in the tenth century of our era, was the original version of
what would become the Yogavāsiṣṭha, which enjoyed enormous popularity
in India, in certain regions second only to the two great epic poems."

https://uvhw.de/studia-indologica/product/190910_08-203-5.html

For volume 1 and the remaining volumes in this series, see:
https://uvhw.de/studia-indologica.html

Best,
RS

[Roland Steiner]

Dear members of the list,

the second volume of Bhāskarakaṇṭha's Mokṣopāya-Nirvāṇa-Ṭīkā has
appeared, edited by Bruno Lo Turco (Roma).

[Siddharth Wakankar]

Hearty congratulations on achieving this gigantic and ambitious project.

May you continue to enrich our libraries and scholarly world.

Best of luck in your sincere and dedicated efforts.

Prof. Siddharth Y Wakankar.

Vadodara 9427339942.

--
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "भारतीयविद्वत्परिषत्" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to bvparishat+...@googlegroups.com.

To view this discussion on the web visit https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/bvparishat/20191019142457.Horde.gyD1v_jnI3QqTzyn_LprG4A%40home.staff.uni-marburg.de.