Ansible Galaxy account issues

[Hristo Stoyanov]

I think the idea to link up Galaxy account to Github as the only auth service is wrong. This is why neither Github not Docker hub do it. 

Here is why:

I created an account in Github, used that account to log into Galaxy and add my roles. Then deleted my account in GitHub (but still use the repositories there and organization under different github account). Now i can no longer log into my old Galaxy account and the roles I added are unmanageable and basically junk. Another problem is that I am forced to use the same username as my Github username, if I choose to open a new Galaxy account.

Any ideas how can I recover my Galaxy account?

[Greg DeKoenigsberg]

On Thu, Aug 27, 2015 at 2:26 PM, Hristo Stoyanov <hr.st...@gmail.com> wrote:
> I think the idea to link up Galaxy account to Github as the only auth
> service is wrong. This is why neither Github not Docker hub do it.

Certainly willing to discuss it. :)

> Here is why:
> I created an account in Github, used that account to log into Galaxy and add
> my roles. Then deleted my account in GitHub (but still use the repositories
> there and organization under different github account).

OK, I'm confused. From Github:

"Deleting your user account removes all repositories, forks of private
repositories, wikis, issues, pull requests, and pages."

So if you delete your account, how are you still using your
repositories? I'm guessing that you forked them elsewhere, and are
now working with forks of a since-deleted project. Which is how it
should work in Galaxy as well, right?

> Now i can no longer log into my old Galaxy account and the roles I added are unmanageable and basically junk.

If you really delete the Github account, the roles you added from that
account would have been broken anyway because Galaxy pulls them from
the originally associated Github repo, which would no longer be there.
This is precisely the kind of scenario we're trying to detect and
mitigate.

> Another problem is that I am forced to use the same username
> as my Github username, if I choose to open a new Galaxy account.

Is there a reason you object to that?

> Any ideas how can I recover my Galaxy account?

You should still be able to login to your old Galaxy account and use
it until the switchover happens. We're waiting until January to (a)
make sure it's the right thing (I think it still is) and (b) give
plenty of time to identify and work out corner cases.

--g

> --
> You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups
> "Ansible Project" group.
> To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an
> email to ansible-proje...@googlegroups.com.
> To post to this group, send email to ansible...@googlegroups.com.
> To view this discussion on the web visit
> https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/ansible-project/09c5249c-bb75-4342-b096-4062fb0b3738%40googlegroups.com.
> For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout.



--
Greg DeKoenigsberg
Ansible Community Guy

Find out why SD Times named Ansible
their #1 Company to Watch in 2015:
http://sdtimes.com/companies-watch-2015/

[James Cammarata]

And if for some reason you can't login since it was removed (and you had no other associated accounts), just send the details to sup...@ansible.com and we can get things sorted out.

James Cammarata

Director, Ansible Core Engineering

github: jimi-c

To view this discussion on the web visit https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/ansible-project/CAM1FbhH9L6PyEWfdm0S72XPu1NDGkzmJbBHHR3bNSWF5t85aGQ%40mail.gmail.com.

[Hristo Stoyanov]

Greg,

Here is the runaway account in Galaxy:

https://galaxy.ansible.com/list#/users/16353

"peruncs" is no longer a valid account in Github, but as you can see the repositories with the roles are live and well on github. The reason is that Github will only garbage-collect organizations and repositories when all associated admins have been deleted. However, I have another account "hrstoyanov" which manages them and keeps them alive.

The problem is that Galaxy was linked to the "peruncs" GitHub account .... 

So, I had to recreate the roles here: 

https://galaxy.ansible.com/list#/users/16352

with a name i do not like (i still prefer my roles to be under PERUNCS namespace/organization, e.g. ansible-galaxy install peruncs.docker), which is now impossible.

I think issues like that could be avoided if you allowed Galaxy specific accounts

Anyway, I still think linking accounts to github can be an issue