Joanna - thanks; I don't see any references to that variable in /etc/ansible, and the only places I see it in my playbook directory are references to the amazon key name, no files.
I think the problem may be orthogonal to what I was thinking of yesterday, though. I tried running my existing Ansible script with the debug output, as suggested earlier - this also failed with an SSH key problem. On further investigation, I realized that Ansible Tower provides a credentials repository, so, It might 'just work' through the Tower interface. I was hoping to debug my script through the terminal, but since everything else we do runs through Tower, I'll try testing through there.
Thanks for the help!
Nate