Are Tags from the dark side ???

[akazi...@gmail.com]

Hello 

I have been reading squilions of articles but I am still unsure if the usage of tags is a good practice. It seems to me that adding tags to tasks quickly leads to a cumbersome situation. How ever a tag on a role might be ok?

I think of having a main yaml like sites.yml which includes  all needed playbooks e.g. webservers.yml and dbservers.yml

The playbooks e.g. webservers.yml  define the hosts to act on and the roles to run. 

The roles should self standing and independent, I think of tagging the role with its own name. eg. javajdk gets tag: javajdk

so I can run 

       ansible-playbook -i inventory/staging webservers     

to do a complet setup or

       so I can run ansible-playbook -i inventory/staging webservers -t javajdk 

to only setup javajdk on the webservers

 

.

├── inventories

│   ├── production

│   └── staging

├── roles

│   ├── tomcat

│   └── javajdk

├── site.yml

├── dbservers.yml

└── webservers.yml

What do you think? Did I got it correct? Is there a better approach ?

Thanks a lot :-)

Michael

[akazi...@gmail.com]

Here is a littel edit:

I struggle to find the correct place where I would add the tag for the role. I do not want to tag the role in webservers.yml since this would not be a global definition. But I failed to find the correct place in roles/javajdk - is there any?

Other option: assuming i have many roles included in werbservers.yml - is there an other option to run only one of the roles ? 

[Kai Stian Olstad]

On Tuesday, 21 November 2017 10.32.27 CET akazi...@gmail.com wrote:
> Here is a littel edit:
> I struggle to find the correct place where I would add the tag for the
> role. I do not want to tag the role in webservers.yml since this would not
> be a global definition. But I failed to find the correct place in
> roles/javajdk - is there any?

You would need to tag every task in the role.

> Other option: assuming i have many roles included in werbservers.yml - is
> there an other option to run only one of the roles ?

Options as on ansible-playbook command line, then the answer is no.
You could use extra vars on the command line and have when on roles the roles.


--
Kai Stian Olstad

[Josh Smift]

As a new feature, you could imagine being able to put something like

tags:
- javajdk

into .../roles/javajdk/meta/defaults.yml, but I don't think there's
currently a way to tell a role "add this tag to all your tasks", inside
the role itself, other than adding the tag explicitly to all the tasks.

-Josh (j...@care.com)

(apologies for the automatic corporate disclaimer that follows)

This email is intended for the person(s) to whom it is addressed and may contain information that is PRIVILEGED or CONFIDENTIAL. Any unauthorized use, distribution, copying, or disclosure by any person other than the addressee(s) is strictly prohibited. If you have received this email in error, please notify the sender immediately by return email and delete the message and any attachments from your system.

[Brian Coca]

tasks/main.yml:

- tags: x, y z
block:
- rest of tasks
...





--
----------
Brian Coca