Dvaita need not be revealed by the Shruti
31 views
Skip to first unread message
Jaishankar Narayanan
Nov 3, 2025, 8:10:55 AM (4 days ago) Nov 3
to Advaitin, adva...@lists.advaita-vedanta.org
Namaste,
I was reading the Brhadaranyaka Upanishad Bhashya for Poornam adah Poornam idam shAntipAtha at the beginning of the fifth chapter. There Bhashyakara says the below which reminded me of Murari, the Barber's story, which my Guru Pujya Swami Dayananda ji used to narrate so hilariously.
The story goes like this - There was an advaita guru in a village and a student came to study vedanta with him. He could not accept advaita siddhanta and left this Guru to study Vedanta with others. He studied Dvaita Vedanta for 12 years and then came back one day to debate with the Advaita Guru. The Advaita Guru asked him to wait as he was about to get a shaving from Murari, the barber. Murari was the local barber from the same village and he did a good job of shaving the Guru. After the shaving was done the Advaita Guru fell at the feet of Murari the barber exclaiming 'You are not merely Murari the barber but you are really Murari, the Lord Narayana himself, as you have made me tejsavi with your shaving'. Murari was mortified by what the Advaita Guru did and said that he is merely a barber and he can never be the Lord Narayana. The Advaita Guru then turned toward his former disciple and said 'what Murari knows without studying any shastra, you have known after studying the shastra for 12 years - how great!' :-)
Now let us see what bhashyakAra says
न च उपदेशार्हं द्वैतम् , जातमात्रप्राणिबुद्धिगम्यत्वात् ; न च द्वैतस्य अनृतत्वबुद्धिः प्रथममेव कस्यचित् स्यात् , येन द्वैतस्य सत्यत्वमुपदिश्य पश्चात् आत्मनः प्रामाण्यं प्रतिपादयेत् शास्त्रम् ।
na ca upadeśārhaṃ dvaitam , jātamātraprāṇibuddhigamyatvāt ; na ca dvaitasya anṛtatvabuddhiḥ prathamameva kasyacit syāt , yena dvaitasya satyatvamupadiśya paścāt ātmanaḥ prāmāṇyaṃ pratipādayet śāstram ।
Swami Madhavananda's Translation
Nor does duality require to be taught; it is understood by everyone as Soon as he is born; and nobody thinks from the very outset that duality is false, in which case the scriptures would first have to teach the reality of the dual world and then establish their own validity.
with love and prayers,
Jaishankar
I was reading the Brhadaranyaka Upanishad Bhashya for Poornam adah Poornam idam shAntipAtha at the beginning of the fifth chapter. There Bhashyakara says the below which reminded me of Murari, the Barber's story, which my Guru Pujya Swami Dayananda ji used to narrate so hilariously.
The story goes like this - There was an advaita guru in a village and a student came to study vedanta with him. He could not accept advaita siddhanta and left this Guru to study Vedanta with others. He studied Dvaita Vedanta for 12 years and then came back one day to debate with the Advaita Guru. The Advaita Guru asked him to wait as he was about to get a shaving from Murari, the barber. Murari was the local barber from the same village and he did a good job of shaving the Guru. After the shaving was done the Advaita Guru fell at the feet of Murari the barber exclaiming 'You are not merely Murari the barber but you are really Murari, the Lord Narayana himself, as you have made me tejsavi with your shaving'. Murari was mortified by what the Advaita Guru did and said that he is merely a barber and he can never be the Lord Narayana. The Advaita Guru then turned toward his former disciple and said 'what Murari knows without studying any shastra, you have known after studying the shastra for 12 years - how great!' :-)
Now let us see what bhashyakAra says
न च उपदेशार्हं द्वैतम् , जातमात्रप्राणिबुद्धिगम्यत्वात् ; न च द्वैतस्य अनृतत्वबुद्धिः प्रथममेव कस्यचित् स्यात् , येन द्वैतस्य सत्यत्वमुपदिश्य पश्चात् आत्मनः प्रामाण्यं प्रतिपादयेत् शास्त्रम् ।
na ca upadeśārhaṃ dvaitam , jātamātraprāṇibuddhigamyatvāt ; na ca dvaitasya anṛtatvabuddhiḥ prathamameva kasyacit syāt , yena dvaitasya satyatvamupadiśya paścāt ātmanaḥ prāmāṇyaṃ pratipādayet śāstram ।
Swami Madhavananda's Translation
Nor does duality require to be taught; it is understood by everyone as Soon as he is born; and nobody thinks from the very outset that duality is false, in which case the scriptures would first have to teach the reality of the dual world and then establish their own validity.
with love and prayers,
Jaishankar
Balagopal Ramakrishnan
Nov 4, 2025, 1:32:51 AM (3 days ago) Nov 4
to adva...@googlegroups.com, A discussion group for Advaita Vedanta
👌
--
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "advaitin" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to advaitin+u...@googlegroups.com.
To view this discussion visit https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/advaitin/CAOkLS-G1ghWMZqcNgEKiS-kQ6yxU8_C_GENvcXs1i48u7Xv9nQ%40mail.gmail.com.
Reply all
Reply to author
Forward
0 new messages