Livelihoods vs. Lions: How can wildlife be made to pay?

1 view
Skip to first unread message

Elisabeth Janaina

unread,
Jan 2, 2016, 12:40:31 PM1/2/16
to southsudankob
Livelihoods vs. Lions: How can wildlife be made to pay?
Posted on December 24, 2015 by Keith Somerville
For impoverished local herders who see only costs and corruption from
conservation, breaking the law can seem necessary for survival.
A young Maasai herder tending to his cattle. Credit: Andreas Lederer.

A young Maasai herder tending to his cattle. Credit: Andreas Lederer.

In early December 2015, it was reported that eight lions from the
Marsh Pride in Kenya’s Maasai Mara National Game Reserve had been
poisoned by Maasai herders illegally grazing their cattle there. The
Mara reserve is a protected area from which herders are banned.

The deaths were widely reported by Kenyan and international media. Not
only was the poisoning a blow to the country’s already vulnerable lion
population, but the lions had appeared on the BBC’s popular Big Cat
Diary TV series and in the 1982 book The Marsh Lions: The Story of and
African Pride by Brian Jackman and Jonathan Scott. Scott, a leading
wildlife artist, writer and photographer, has followed generations of
the pride since 1978, and was one of the presenters of Big Cat Diary.

The poisonings were a huge blow to the Mara’s lions and were
indicative of the huge and unresolved problems of aligning wildlife
conservation and habitat protection with rural livelihoods and the
urgent need to raise the incomes of communities across lion range
states.

Had it not coincided with major global stories, the killings of the
lions had all the ingredients for a re-run of the media-fest that
followed the shooting of the lion known as Cecil in Zimbabwe in the
summer. Scott attempted to publicise the killings, not as a
sensationalist story like Cecil’s, but to raise serious issues. He
wrote on his blog: “Now we have to honour the lives of those
extraordinary big cats by putting things right. The only way to do
that is by ensuring that we speak our truth. We must ask those
difficult questions and confront the very complex issues that make up
the political environment surrounding the Masai Mara. We must do that
on behalf of all Kenyans. This is a national issue as well as a local
one.”

It is. And it is an issue that affects all communities that live
around national parks and game reserves across Africa, the wildlife in
and around those protected areas, the conservationists and researchers
working to preserve species and habitats, and governments which have
to make the decisions that affect the balance between human needs and
those of conservation. Too often, it is one or the other, rather than
a serious attempt to empower local people, benefit them and so provide
real incentives for struggling, impoverished rural communities to see
wildlife as a benefit rather than an obstacle.

Making a living in the Maasai Mara

To understand the complexity, one needs to look at the case of the
Maasai Mara and the Maasai pastoralists and then broaden the picture
out to consider the future of conservation and community development
across the continent, where the same problems are often replicated.

The Maasai living around the reserve are traditionally cattle herders.
Under colonialism and successive governments since independence, they
have been moved off land set aside for reserves, which has restricted
access to grazing. Changing land ownership and utilisation practices
have affected their freedom of movement. Moves by successive
governments to establish individual rather than community ownership
and to sub-divide land previously owned communally has led to the
fencing of rangeland, restriction of cattle and wildlife movement to
follow seasonal grazing, increasing conflict between rich and poor,
and greater human-wildlife conflict.

This process has also involved corruption and land-grabbing by senior
politicians and public officials in league with local clients in the
Maasai community. Maasai pastoralists, hemmed in by fenced-off land
owned or claimed by political grandees and the local recipients of
their patronage, have been forced to look for grazing elsewhere.

The herders accused of killing the Marsh Pride lions − Simindei
Naurori and Kulangash Toposat − have been charged with the poisoning
and could be handed life sentences or fined Sh20 million ($200,000)
each – a sum the herders would be incapable of raising. If they are
found guilty, justice of a sort will have been seen to have been done.
But they are victims as much as the lions that died from eating the
poisoned remains of the three cows. If the herders poisoned carcasses
of cattle killed by lions they will have broken the law, but not to
poach for substantial gain but to survive in an increasingly harsh
habitat and economic environment in which their options are forever
narrowing.

Paula Kahumbu, CEO of Kenya’s Wild Direct NGO, is a fervent supporter
of wildlife conservation but she sums up the situation well when she
says that local communities must be provided with a role and incentive
to coexist with wildlife and become part of conservation, but that
“Currently there are only costs for living with lions. No rewards”.

Indeed, for many, cattle are the only realistic source of income. But
sub-division of land, land grabs, and loss of land for building houses
and arable farming reduce the opportunities to survive, let alone
improve incomes and living standards. In such as situation, local
communities will break the law if they feel they have no other option
and will break it regularly if they can do so with impunity because of
a lack of serious attention to the wider issue by government as well
as corruption, mismanagement and under-funding of the Kenya Wildlife
Service, which means regulations aren’t enforced.

The Mara reserve is not a national park run by central government. It
is owned and run by Narok County and its governor and council. Park
fees and other earnings from the massive tourist industry are routed
through the Narok authorities and very little goes to local people,
who bear the burden of living next to a reserve rich in predators and
other wildlife that can damage their livelihoods. Of the reserve fees
charged to tourists, 55% goes to Narok County Council and 36% to the
Mara Conservancy (a private conservation area bordering the reserve).
Of the Council’s share, 19% goes to the group ranches bordering the
Mara reserve; 9% of earnings go to the KAPS company that administers
tourist fees. Little trickles down to rural communities. The situation
is made worse by corruption, with repeated accusations by
conservationists and communities over the years that Narok Council is
illegally taking money from tourist fees and other income.

In fact, in January this year, local communities – supported by some
local and national politicians – protested that the Narok Governor and
Council were misappropriating the reserve income. Thousands of Maasai
marched on the governor’s office in Narok to protest and were met with
the use of live ammunition and tear gas by the police. One person was
killed and several injured when Kenyan police clashed with Maasai
protesting against a local governor they accuse of misappropriating
tourism funds from the game reserve. Governor Samuel Tunai and his
administration were said to be misusing the $80 a day collected from
each tourist entering the Mara and income from lodges. A Senator,
Stephen ole Ntutu, said Tunai “cannot account for billions of
shillings from all financial sources including the Mara. He should be
held to account”.

The Kenyan Auditor-General and the Anti-Corruption Commission are
investigating use of the funds, but no details of their findings have
yet been released.

From no-win to win-win

What the events show is that local people are angry that they get no
benefit and only costs from wildlife conservation and related tourism.
They feel they are in a no-win situation and so break the law to the
detriment of conservation efforts and income from tourism – and the
Mara produces income of around $19m a year. But to them that is a
price that must be paid to survive because the distant and egregiously
corrupt system of government is neither responsive to their needs nor
prepared to look at ways of empowering them.

This situation is replicated in many conservation or protected area
across East and Southern Africa, where local communities suffer loss
of land and depredations of lions, leopards, elephants, buffalo or
hippos and have little recourse other than to break the law or turn
the resources to their advantage by poaching or helping poaching
syndicates. Some, like the Maasai in this case, just kill in order, as
they see it, to protect their herds.

I witnessed the problem in Botswana in July 2015 around the Chobe
National Park. The banning of commercial or subsistence hunting by
local people has resulted not in preservation of species but in
greater assistance by locals to outside poaching syndicates. A
poorly-thought out conservation measure has had the opposite effect to
that intended.

Kenya must address the real issues of protecting the Mara and its
lions and not opt for quick, cosmetic solutions that do not dig down
and get to the roots of the problem. Jonathan Scott, not surprisingly,
wants measures to stop all grazing in the Mara’s protected areas. But,
he says, “There are no easy solutions to please everyone.” The
government and wildlife authorities must recognise that this “is a
failure on the part of the administration at both local and national
level. Kenya needs tourism – it pays the bill for protecting our
wilderness and provides employment…and generates millions of dollars
each year for Narok County”. Scott goes on to call for the recent
killings to be a catalyst for change in “addressing the complex issues
that need to be resolved if wildlife and local communities are to
prosper side by side”.

He is right, but the problem is finding formulas (and they will differ
from country to country, from locality to locality) that will empower
people, provide income, and incentivise them to actively aid
conservation.

Keith Somerville is a Senior Research Fellow at the Institute of
Commonwealth Studies, University of London; he teaches at the Centre
for Journalism at the University of Kent; his book Africa’s Long Road
Sine Independence. The Many Histories of a Continent is published on
14 January 2016 by Hurst and Co, and he has just completed the
manuscript of a work on the history and political economy of the ivory
trade in Africa.
If you enjoyed this post, please consider leaving a comment or
subscribing to the RSS feed to have future articles delivered to your
feed reader.
Reply all
Reply to author
Forward
0 new messages