Wow. Great CG world.
This makes me think of the current Mad Max movie, which uses almost exclusively practical effects, and as a contrast the the ape scenes in Dawn of the Planet of the Apes, which use CG.
I don't think practical fx are inherently superior to CG. It comes down to execution. In the Star Wars prequels, they were soulless because the execution was poor and if you are comparing that to the practical fx in the original trilogy, then of course it won't compare. Frank Oz is/was the greatest puppeteer of his time. The fx in the Transformers movies is soulless because Michael Bay has no soul. Life of Pi is another movie that made good use of CG.
This being the Ipse Dixit list, I will cite my sources: