RESULT: sci.archaeology.moderated moderated passes 481:44
Warren Lavallee
moderated group sci.archaeology.moderated passes 481:44
There were 481 YES votes and 44 NO votes, for a total of 525 valid votes.
There were 3 abstains and 5 invalid ballots.
For group passage, YES votes must be at least 2/3 of all valid (YES and NO)
votes. There also must be at least 100 more YES votes than NO votes.
There is a five day discussion period after these results are posted. If no
serious allegations of voting irregularities are raised, the moderator of
news.announce.newgroups will create the group shortly thereafter.
Newsgroups line:
sci.archaeology.moderated All aspects of archaeology. (Moderated)
This vote was conducted by a neutral third party. Questions about
this proposal should be directed to the proponent.
Proponent: Doug Weller <dwe...@ramtops.demon.co.uk>
Mentor: Todd M. McComb <mcc...@best.com>
Votetaker: Warren Lavallee <war...@Syra.NET>
RATIONALE: sci.archaeology.moderated
This newsgroup would *not* replace any of the existing groups
(sci.archaeology, sci.archaeology.mesoamerican, and alt.archaeology).
It would meet a long-standing demand for a moderated newsgroup for
the discussion of archaeology without flames and without the postings
either based on speculation or of a non-scientific nature that have
put many people off in the past. It would still leave any and all
posters the forums that currently exist, so there can be no question
of denying anyone an outlet for their ideas.
CHARTER: sci.archaeology.moderated
Sci.archaeology.moderated is to be a moderated newsgroup dedicated to
the discussion of archaeology, the study of the past through its
material culture. All viewpoints and levels of knowledge are welcome,
subject to the moderation policy described below. Because archaeology
is such a broad subject and because lively debate on archaeological
issues is encouraged, this group is moderated by a panel of several
people and prospective articles are assigned randomly to any moderator
for approval. Moderators will represent both professional and amateur
archaeologists. This method will hopefully lead to the fastest
turn-around time and least intrusion possible. It is hoped that
almost every poster's article will be approved as soon as is humanly
possible. The text itself will either be accepted as is, or rejected
-- however if only a minor aspect of an article is inappropriate,
the moderator will usually suggest changes.
Moderation Policy:
Articles may be requests for information, announcements of relevance,
etc. Lengthy quoting (more than 30 lines) of source material must be
accompanied by commentary or by other text which ties it to on-going
discussions. Articles which quote substantially the same source
material repetitively will not be approved. Articles consisting of
materials which are available on-line at ftp or WWW sites will not be
approved, rather pointers to sites may be given. Moderators may waive
this rule at their discretion.
Articles which contain personal attacks of any sort, racist comments,
ad hominem arguments, etc. will not be approved for posting.
Disagreements are welcome (so long as they contain no flames), but if
a thread looks as though it's never going to be resolved, the
moderators reserve the right to terminate it/suspend it until new
evidence is produced.
Blank messages, test messages, MAKE.MONEY.FAST, binaries, uuencoded
messages, and so forth, will not be approved for posting. Archaeology
related advertisements for courses, jobs, new book notices, etc. will
be accepted, but not advertisements for metal detectors or the sale of
antiquities.
While the principle purpose of a moderated archaeology group is
clearly the exchange of useful archaeological information and postings
generally should be scholarly and include verifiable citations of the
hard evidence which supports them, discussions of alternative
perspectives which meet these criteria are not prohibited.
Although posts which reference works in which a consistent pattern of
false and/or out of context claims have been demonstrated will not be
considered
appropriate for discussion in a moderated science group, alternatives
to presently accepted views, when well researched and presented in a
verifiable format, will not be denied a fair hearing.
Racist and Ethnocentric remarks will not be tolerated in postings to
the moderated group. Regardless of label the quideline shall simply be
whether ethnocentrism and racism are involved. For example: In the
case of assumptions like those once promulgated by
"Hyperdiffusionists", that cultural evolution cannot explain observed
phenomena because people X "obviously" could not have produced
artifact Y without help, ethnocentrism and racism are clearly present
and the post should be rejected.
Moderators may, at their discretion, change the Subject: lines for
threads which have strayed from the initial subject.
Cross-posting is discouraged and where they occur will obviously have
to be clearly archaeologically relevant. Due to the nature of Usenet,
rejected posts do not get crossposted.
Rejected articles which would be acceptable after editing will be
returned to the poster with an explanation and suggestions for change.
Articles rejected for other reasons may be shared with the other
moderators for group consideration if the poster wishes to appeal.
Any article that contains more than fifty percent quoted material (and
the author's signature shall not count as original material for
purposes of determining the proportion) may be trimmed or rejected at
the discretion of the moderator. In exercising this discretion, the
moderator shall take readability considerations into account, such as
the amount of quoted material at the beginning of the message, and the
size of the blocks of quoted material. If the entire length of the
article (excluding header and signature) is less than 24 lines of 80
characters, then the requirement of 50% original material _may_ be
waived at the moderator's discretion.
In keeping with Usenet netiquette conventions, signatures should be
restricted to 4 or 5 lines. Moderators may, at their discretion, trim
.sigs to four lines before posting articles.
All articles should have an easily identified name and email address
for the poster. Because of the variety of newsreaders, all submittals
should be signed with the sender's name and email address. If this is
missing, moderators may add one at their discretion.
Moderators:
Anyone may volunteer to join the moderation panel with the consent of
a two-thirds supermajority of the current moderators. If the number of
moderators fall below 8, volunteers will be solicited by a posting to
the newsgroup.
An automatic script will be used to share postings among the
moderators. Moderators may at their discretion consult other
moderators about posts or send a post to another moderator with that
moderator's agreement.
It is important to have a clear policy to cover the possibility that
there is conflict in the affairs of the moderation panel itself. It
is generally believed that moderators will come and go throughout the
course of the group, and in all cases the goal will be a consensus
amongst the panel regarding the addition of new moderators. A
standard group decision process will be followed: a motion will be
made to add a new moderator, and if there are no objections it will go
ahead. Friendly relations are certainly expected.
If there is an objection to a motion, and a group decision is not
reached by discussion, a vote can be carried out in accordance with
the statements below. In any of the following cases, a secret ballot
may be requested -- and if a suitable (meaning: agreeably neutral)
volunteer on the panel to collect the ballots cannot be found, will be
carried out via point #5 below -- but voting will generally be public
(within the confines of the moderation panel itself).
1. If it comes to a vote, new moderators must be approved by a two-
thirds supermajority amongst the moderation panel. Abstentions will
not affect the outcome of this vote, meaning that a supermajority
among voting moderators must be obtained. In the case of only two
voting moderators who disagree, the prospective moderator will not be
added.
2. Moderators who will be on vacation for more than a day or two are
expected to have their names removed from the active file for that
period. This implies no permanent change in status, and they will be
simply returned to active duty afterward.
3. Moderators can be removed by a supermajority (as above) vote
amongst the moderation panel (including the moderator in question).
Abstentions will count as votes against removal.
4. If there is controversy amongst the moderators concerning the
application of these guidelines, the moderation panel agrees to submit
to binding arbitration by moderators-advice at UUNET. This situation
covers true interpretive controversy, as well as such technical
scenarios as: only two moderators, one wanting to remove the other; so
many moderators on extended leave or genuinely unresponsive that the
active panel cannot remove them to get on with business, etc.
5. Any votes or motions may be called into question by moderators
returning from leaves of absence.
6. All prospective moderators must agree to abide by these guidelines
in their entirety before consideration for moderator status. By
acting as a moderator, this point is implied, regardless of written
confirmation. Moderators will not be allowed to moderate their own
postings.
END CHARTER.
MODERATOR INFO: sci.archaeology.moderated
Moderator: Doug Weller <dwe...@ramtops.demon.co.uk>
Amateur, interest in Roman Britain
Moderator: Hope Anthony <ho...@utxvms.cc.utexas.edu>
Amateur with a degree in Archaeoastronomy and
interest in Mesopotamia
Moderator: Julian Barker <jul...@rodent.demon.co.uk>
Amateur, Egyptology, European Neolithic and Bronze Age and
Ancient Middle Eastern Languages
Moderator: Kathy Bartsch <ost...@ucsub.colorado.edu>
Student, Arch-Student List Owner
Moderator: Philip Blair <bla...@iol.ie>
Amateur, interest in standing stones
Moderator: Ariane Burke <ABU...@bldgarts.lan1.umanitoba.ca>
Asst Prof. of anthropology subfield arch) with U. of Manitoba
Moderator: John Carr <JOHN...@delphi.com>
Professional, Americanist, a sysop on the Delphi Archaeology
and History forum
Moderator: John A. Giacobbe <Cata...@aol.com>
Western Archaeological Services, Inc.
Moderator: Gerard Alan Latham <Ger...@galatham.demon.co.uk>
Amateur, committee member with the
Wallingford Historical and Archaeological Society
Moderator: Vince Russett <10065...@CompuServe.COM>
County Archaeologist for Avon, England
Moderator: Doug Rutherford <ycru...@yknet.yk.ca>
Professional, area of specialization: Subarctic North America
Moderator: Nigel Strudwick <nc...@cam.ac.uk>
Professional, Egyptology
Moderator: Adrian Tribe <tcr...@ucl.ac.uk>
Professional Archaeological Conservator, English Heritage
Moderator: Steve Whittet <whi...@shore.net>
Amateur, interest in CAD site details, Middle East
Article submission address: <sci-archaeol...@mccomb.vip.best.com>
Administrative contact address: <dwe...@ramtops.demon.co.uk>
END MODERATOR INFO.
DISTRIBUTION:
This Call for Votes is being posted to the following newsgroups:
sci.anthropology, sci.archaeology,
sci.archaeology.mesoamerican,
alt.archaeology, soc.history,
soc.history.moderated, soc.history.medieval
This Call for Votes is also being sent to the following mailing lists:
ARC...@tamvm1.tamu.edu
brit...@mailbase.ac.uk
mail...@mailbase.ac.uk
sci.archaeology.moderated Final Vote Ack
Voted Yes
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
00mk...@bsuvc.bsu.edu
10027...@compuserve.com Doug Moncur
10040...@compuserve.com Chris Kelaart
10072...@compuserve.com Hugh Waterhouse
10133...@compuserve.com Alexander Clark
10136...@compuserve.com Jacqueline Chase
10200...@compuserve.com Susan Musser
2067...@MSU.EDU John.Stone
71020...@compuserve.com Marc
71540...@compuserve.com Jim Singleton
7511...@CompuServe.COM C. D. Ritchie
75457...@compuserve.com Jim Westerman
95...@mne.net C.L.
A.C....@soton.ac.uk Anja Wolle
A.R.M...@durham.ac.uk Andrew Millard
ABU...@bldgarts.lan1.umanitoba.ca Burke, Ariane
a...@crsa.bu.edu Al Wesolowsky
ac...@freenet.carleton.ca Keith H. Ennis
ada...@post.tau.ac.il Ada Smolin
ae...@freenet.carleton.ca Nigel Allen
aed...@LUCS-03.NOVELL.LEEDS.AC.UK Pete Freeman
ago...@mailer.fsu.edu Anne Gometz
a...@ix.netcom.com A J Mims
ajedi...@netgate.net A.J. Edington-Molyneux
al...@caxton.york.ac.uk Dr Alan Vince
alem...@mainelink.net
alg...@tid.es Fco. Javier Garcia Algarra
alhu...@magi.com Anthony Huxley
alle...@spectra.net allen lutins
alma...@cris.com Al Magary
alu...@ccwf.cc.utexas.edu andrea ludden
am...@extro.ucc.su.oz.au Angus Mann
AM...@warthog.ru.ac.za DR LE WEBLEY
an...@yfn.ysu.edu Mark A. McConaughy
ander...@pi.se
an...@sarah.ct.se Andy Pettersson
an...@harlequin.com Andy Latto
an...@sentex.net Andy Schoenhofer
ann....@sstar.com
ant...@abdn.ac.uk Neil Curtis
an_...@selway.umt.edu Randy Skelton
apb...@unicorn.it.wsu.edu Abigail Pierce Beck
ape...@orednet.org Arlene E. Penner
aphi...@ieee.org Adam D. Philippidis
ara...@algonet.se Martin Rundkvist
arc...@ns.iconn.net Frances Kemmish
arch...@mcmi.com Hamilton.Chapter.OAS
ari...@taronga.com Stephanie da Silva
ar...@fluo.univ-lemans.fr Armel Le Bail
arwi...@serf.uccs.edu Ingeborg
atk...@alleg.edu Joshua Atkins
ava...@infobahnos.com Daniel Gendron
barr...@agate.net Mark W. Barrows
base...@burgoyne.com
bazz...@mbox.vol.it Bruno Bazzani
bead...@norwich.net eadling
BEAT...@aol.com
benjamin...@yale.edu Benjamin H. Diebold
ber...@xs4all.nl Edu J.M. van Berkel
b...@drmail.dr.att.com
b...@VNET.IBM.COM Brian G. Harper
bho...@globalnet.co.uk Barry Horne
Bill-...@uiowa.edu William Green
birc...@email.njin.net Shag
bke...@netcom.com B. Keith Ryder
bla...@iol.ie Philip Blair
bog...@mail.uwlax.edu Lloyd Bogart
bon...@ix.netcom.com Bonnie L. Wisthoff
boui...@cs.uni-sb.de Peter G. Bouillon
br...@crl.com Brame
bre...@tiac.net Brian Bresnahan
bru...@acsu.Buffalo.EDU Thomas Brunton
bur...@ubaclu.unibas.ch Thomas =?iso-8859-1?Q?B=FCrglin?=
bu...@Phys.UAlberta.CA Michael Burianyk
c-we...@students.uiuc.edu Cameron Wesson
caps...@wizard.firn.edu William Capshaw
caroline....@antsaoir.demon.co.uk Caroline Mac Intyre
Cata...@aol.com
cat...@netcom.com Mark Kupferman
cbs...@phoenix.Princeton.EDU Christopher B. Stone
cco...@gpu.srv.ualberta.ca Patrick Conway
cdo...@mtn.org Clark A. Dobbs
cha...@mailer.fsu.edu Christine M. Hamlin
cha...@jmb2.jmb.com Charlie Jernigan
cha...@simsc.si.edu Tom Chase
cjh...@argonet.co.uk Chris Hicks
c...@connix.com Christopher Jonke
ck...@neh.fed.us
cla...@Starbase.NeoSoft.COM Cameron Laird
cla...@Starbase.NeoSoft.COM Claire
cl...@eng-h.gov.uk C.Jewess
clas...@magnus.acs.ohio-state.edu Carroll A Lassettre
cl...@columbia.edu Christopher Lodge Stamper
cny...@telepost.no Chris Nyborg
co...@colina.demon.co.uk Colin Paul Adams
cps...@onramp.net Dave
CRi...@bdm.com Charles Rigano
crom...@bnr.ca david (d.c.) cromwell
csar...@coffey.com christopher arthur
D.B.Du...@sheffield.ac.uk David Dungworth
dae...@mail.usask.ca David Ebert
DAG...@prodigy.com M LANA CROSS
da...@direct.ca Dahl
dal...@hol.gr Costis J Dallas
dan...@iaccess.za Danie van Zyl
dan_...@MENTORG.COM Dan Masi
David.A...@Dartmouth.EDU David A. Chapin
da...@lolita.colorado.edu David Knapp
dav...@ashmnt7.demon.co.uk David Craig
DB...@aol.com
dea...@mcs.net Mark Nielsen
Deborah.Mo...@tc.umn.edu Deborah Morse-Kahn
de...@esfm.ipn.mx Antonio de Ita
DE...@UConnVM.UConn.Edu Bob Dewar
dfo...@kos.compulink.co.uk Dave Forth
dh...@swcp.com David Hill
dim...@ccsua.CTSTATEU.EDU Charles Wm. Dimmick
dipl...@idirect.com diplomat
d...@webxs.com Dick Johnson
djm...@rs6000.cmp.ilstu.edu David J. MacDonald
dla...@epas.utoronto.ca David Lasby
DNa...@aol.com
doca...@mcs.com Angst-sensei
DonS...@aol.com
dou...@netdoor.com Douglas Stewart
ds...@packrat.aml.arizona.edu David Sewell
dswi...@tcp.co.uk Dave Swindell
d...@Brooktrout.COM David T. Wolff
dunl...@pixie.udw.ac.za John Dunlevey
dunn...@msn.com Ferguson Meek
dwe...@ramtops.demon.co.uk Doug Weller
dwe...@freenet.mb.ca Doug Evans
EBi...@aol.com
ed...@dial.pipex.com Hugh Swan
eda...@sas.upenn.edu Elin Danien
e...@thegroup.net Ed Taylor
efe...@holli.com ECFenner
eh...@dial.pipex.com John Oxley
ELE...@delphi.com
ell...@tenet.edu Elliot Richmond
emr...@freenet.mb.ca Marlin Penner
EPe...@aol.com
er...@portal.ca Eric Pettifor
eric...@mindspring.com Eric Geer
Er...@qb.island.net.Scoffield Erik Scoffield
Espe...@hd.uib.no Espen S. Ore
ess...@MindSpring.COM Hussein Essawy
et...@grendel.as.utexas.edu Ethan Vishniac
etx...@tn.ericsson.se Lisbeth Andersson
far...@datasync.com Paul Farrar
fbmo...@actrix.gen.nz Knox
fe...@jove.acs.unt.edu Huddleston Lee Eldridge
fi...@bowdoin.edu Steve Fisk
FM-L...@wpg.uwe.ac.uk
ga...@SCHOLAR.CHEM.NYU.EDU Paul J. Gans
gar...@feruce.demon.co.uk Gareth Jones
gar...@airmail.net Garreth Campbell
gate...@ERE.UMontreal.CA Gates-St-Pierre Christian
gbl...@midland.co.nz George Black
ge...@math.ucla.edu Geoffrey Mess
Ger...@galatham.demon.co.uk Gerard Alan Latham
ge...@Theorie.Physik.UNI-Goettingen.DE Franz Gerl
ger...@ix.netcom.com gerry.g
GGP9...@sheffield.ac.uk Adrian F. Lane
gj.ba...@ukonline.co.uk G J Barclay
gj...@enterprise.net Graham Judd
GLAS...@ctrvax.Vanderbilt.Edu
glenn...@ukonline.co.uk Glenn Foard
g...@world.std.com Gerald N Shapiro
go...@ecf.toronto.edu GOPAL Ganapathiraju Sree Ramana
gqv...@udcf.gla.ac.uk Wilson Angerson
Graham...@isltd.insignia.com Graham Povey
gre...@duke.usask.ca D'Arcy Green
gr...@ohs.uwo.ca Greg Chapman
GRIC...@hoasy5.isd4.tafensw.edu.au
gri...@usa.pipeline.com Katherine Griffis
gron...@telepost.no Vidar Grønvold
g...@ram.compulink.co.uk Gus Ramage
hal...@brictric.demon.co.uk Hal Bethell
hal...@VNET.IBM.COM Steven Halter
ham...@argonet.co.uk P Hamilton Leggett
ham...@jade.mv.net Darryl Hamson
har...@ibm.net Marc Hardy
har...@hsonline.net Rich Green
Harle...@aol.com
HAR...@utarlg.uta.edu
har...@omnifest.uwm.edu Paul Hartman
har...@iupui.edu James Harvey
has...@netcom.com Haskia Hasson
hcay...@gibbs.oit.unc.edu Hugh Cayless
hcfl...@dewey.csun.edu John P. Adams
hein...@intersurf.com Heinrich
he...@netcom.com Henry Polard
hiero...@cix.compulink.co.uk Dennis Larder
hilb...@magellan.cloudnet.com WB or CM Hilbrich
hil...@smartlink.net Mimi & JB Hiller
hml...@blue.weeg.uiowa.edu H. Lack
hoo...@falcon.cc.ukans.edu JOHN HOOPES
how...@achilles.net Howard Mansfield
hwr...@laurel.ocs.mq.edu.au Haddon Wright
I.Li...@mailbox.uq.oz.au ian lilley
i00...@disch3.disc.dla.mil martin j coghlan iii
Ianb...@aol.com
ivan....@yale.edu Ivan A Ghezzi
iz...@vcn.bc.ca Peggy A. Stonnell
j-b...@students.uiuc.edu Johann Beda
J.D.W...@soc.staffs.ac.uk John Wilcock
j....@trl.OZ.AU Jacques Guy
jab...@husc.HARVARD.EDU John Abbott
jac...@GAS.UUG.Arizona.EDU George M Jacobs
jae...@access.digex.net Judy Gerjuoy
ja...@lonestar.jpl.utsa.edu John W. Arnn
jb...@cix.compulink.co.uk Julian Back
jba...@GAS.UUG.Arizona.EDU Jeffrey L Baker
jba...@vauxia.com James B. Bandow
jcip...@magnus.acs.ohio-state.edu Judith Cipriano
jco...@univ-st-etienne.fr
jcp...@cris.com JC
j...@pacifier.com Jim Wile
Jeff...@aol.com
Jenny....@Bristol.ac.uk Jenny Wragge
je...@scala.scala.com Randell Jesup
jfein...@umassd.edu Jonathan E. Feinstein
jfj...@ix.netcom.com Jesse James
jfm...@umich.edu John F. Mansfield
jf...@runet.edu John M Ford
JH...@MAIL.NYSED.GOV John Hart
jh...@silver.sdsmt.edu Jim Haug
jhc...@instanet.com
Jim.Ha...@nau.edu Jim Hasbargen
JIM...@ids.net
jk...@acs.ucalgary.ca Jennifer Kahn
jkni...@pobox.leidenuniv.nl J.W.A. Knikman
JL...@aol.com
jmb...@yaix.yaix.es Jose Maria Bello Dieguez
joachim...@student.uni-tuebingen.de Joachim Rehmet
joel...@iakn.uio.no Joel Boaz
Joel.E...@salata.com Joel Ehrlich
jo...@hodg.demon.co.uk John Hodgkins
jo...@kurz-ai.com John Armstrong
JOHN...@delphi.com
John...@aol.com
jo...@ranplc.co.uk
jo...@gorge.net John Taylor
J...@johnbell.demon.co.uk Jon Bell
Jpc1...@aol.com
j...@hammer.msfc.nasa.gov J. Porter Clark
jrap...@ic.sunysb.edu Jill H Rappaport
jsc...@mail.coin.missouri.edu James A. Schell
jtr...@azstarnet.com Jim Treat
jul...@rodent.demon.co.uk Julian Barker
jvon...@mv.us.adobe.com Janine Von Furst
jwa...@scholar.cc.emory.edu John Wagner
K.B.Ti...@bradford.ac.uk KB TIDSWELL
kapp...@klphs.unizh.ch Thomas Kappeler
Karlene...@nps.gov Karlene Leeper
ka...@Kodak.COM
kba...@haverford.edu Kyle Barger
kcle...@swarthmore.edu Kate Cleland
ke...@azstarnet.com Richard Wilkinson
Ken_Sch...@nps.gov Ken Schoenberg
ke...@cybercash.com Kerry Ogata
ket...@hermes.cam.ac.uk K.E. Taylor
Kevin....@newcastle.ac.uk K.T. Greene
kill...@usit.net Stephen Killeffer
k...@shell.portal.com Kim DeVaughn
kir...@enh.nist.gov Russell A. Kirsch
kl...@hap.arnold.af.mil Greg Klein
kloe...@grove.ufl.EDU
ko...@ix.netcom.com Kevin B. O'Brien
kv...@cam.ac.uk Katie Boyle
L.J.H...@ukc.ac.uk ljh1
lac...@melbpc.org.au Lachlan Cranswick
Lag...@aol.com
lar...@teleport.com Larry Caldwell
Lars-Olof...@abc.se Lars-Olof Eriksson
la...@mail.utexas.edu
la...@lake.scar.utoronto.ca Marti Latta
lbr...@Starbase.NeoSoft.COM lbrains
le...@xmission.com Lee Choquette
leic...@CRUSHER.EVMS.EDU Lawrence G. Leichtman
leon...@cs.tu-berlin.de Roland Jehring
l...@cais.cais.com Laura Fargas
lha...@unm.edu
liv8...@lustudat.student.lu.se Bjorn Holmer
lon...@maxey.dri.edu Lonnie Pippin
lor...@postbox.acs.ohio-state.edu Tammy Barette
Lowell...@nps.gov Lowell Blikre
Luc.T...@ping.be Luc Tutenel
lu...@servidor.dgsca.unam.mx Genevieve Lucet
luk...@neca.com
m.hey...@dial.pipex.com Mike Heyworth
m.l...@ix.netcom.com M.Levi
mall...@io.com MA Lloyd
mang...@bard.edu Frank Mangione
ma...@bosagate.demon.co.uk Marc Line
Mar...@aol.com
mark.c...@rp.fr Prenom NOM
Mark.R....@nd.edu Mark Schurr
MarkS...@aol.com
MAR...@smtp.ntrust.org.uk Rob Woodside
Mart...@aol.com
martin.sk...@mailbox.swipnet.se Martin Skjöldebrand
ma...@hermetica.com Martin McCarthy
MATTH...@YMV5.YMP.GOV
ma...@igs.net Matthew Roberts
matu...@marlin.navsea.navy.mil Alex Matulich 03T1 602-6691
mb...@bournemouth.ac.uk Mark Bell
MBO...@delphi.com Sherry
mbuc...@cris.com Michael Bucklin
mca...@cloud9.net Marc Carter
m...@physics.ucf.edu Michael Johnson
mdo...@i1.net M. J. Dolan
md...@hns.com Mike Dunn
mer...@sphinx.pharaoh2.org J. Scott Dorr
mfa...@mbox.vol.it Mario Fabbri
mfi...@gsf.de Markus Figel
mh...@raven.phs.com Mike Hatz
mhe...@cus.cam.ac.uk Dr M.H. Evans
mhh...@watarts.uwaterloo.ca Matthew Hill
mh...@du.edu J. Maureen Hoof
migu...@chisme.tid.es Miguel Angel Ruz Fernandez
mi...@myates.demon.co.uk Mike Yates
Min...@act.org
mjac...@u.washington.edu Martha Jackson
mj...@dorevale.demon.co.uk Mike Brown
mjw...@mv.us.adobe.com Michael J. Ward
mken...@esri.com Melita Kennedy [ESRI-Redlands]
MKen...@t-online.de Mary Kennedy
MLO...@medic.up.ac.za Marius Loots
mont...@sas.upenn.edu Antonia Montague
MOR...@hartwick.edu JENN MORAN
ms4...@rrz.uni-hamburg.de
m...@cix.compulink.co.uk MW and N Southwood
na...@mips.pfalz.de Christian Weisgerber
na...@croydon.dartmouth.edu Nathan Keir Edel
n...@agate.net Dave
nc...@cam.ac.uk Nigel Strudwick
ndun...@inference.co.uk
new...@esc.cam.ac.uk Robert Newman
ni...@inferno.fc.hp.com Nick Ingegneri
nic...@cix.compulink.co.uk Nick Dunlavey
nkpo...@earthlink.net Nancy K. Porter
nmcn...@acs.bu.edu N.A.F. McNelly
nno...@uga.cc.uga.edu
Ollivie...@hsc.fr.net Ollivier Robert
ore...@earthlink.net Dennis Clark
ost...@ucsub.Colorado.EDU Kathy Bartsch
P.Met...@student.canterbury.ac.nz Peter Metcalfe
P.Pe...@open.ac.uk P.Perkins -Phil Perkins
P.S....@bradford.ac.uk PS RUSH
pack...@limestone.kosone.com Frank Packer
par...@spdc.ti.com Walter Parrish
patr...@email.unc.edu Patrick Livingood
pa...@walnuts.demon.co.uk Paul N Brown
pa...@interlog.com Paxil Psycho
pde...@bcm.tmc.edu Philip Deitiker
pe...@kiera.ericsson.se Per Olofsson
pet...@cmd.uu.se Petter Ericson
pet...@visigoth.demon.co.uk James Petts
phu...@innet.be Patrick Hublou
pio...@umich.edu Piotr Michalowski
pit...@panther.middlebury.edu Tracy L. Pitman
p...@btc.uwe.ac.uk
PLA...@delphi.com
pmic...@csn.net pmichals
pmi...@pmiles.demon.co.uk Paul Miles
Pr...@aol.com
ptah...@zeta.org.au Peter May
pta...@maestro.geo.utexas.edu Paul Takac
ptb...@owl.WPI.EDU Pete Bastien
QCJ...@prodigy.com LYNDA GRANGER
R049%NEMOMUS...@ACADEMIC.NEMOSTATE.EDU Tia Bivens
ra...@snsc.dri.edu Hal Rager
ra...@acs.bu.edu
ra...@ark.franken.de Ralf W. Stephan
rand...@inet.uni-c.dk Elin Rand Nielsen
rap...@research.canon.com.au Andrew Raphael
rdm...@utarlg.uta.edu
redm...@acf2.NYU.EDU Sean Redmond
red...@az.com redrick
rel...@brynmawr.edu Richard S. Ellis
rev...@uow.edu.au Phil Herring
rfle...@mail.bcpl.lib.md.us Richard G. Fleddermann
rhug...@pipeline.com Roy V. Hughson
ri...@bcm.tmc.edu Richard H. Miller
rin...@iinet.net.au Dave Rindos
rl...@TIGGER.STCLOUD.MSUS.EDU Richard B. Lane
rlg...@rsb000.ks.boeing.com Richard L. Grubb
rm...@isdmnl.wr.usgs.gov Robert Mark
robe...@laser09.aspire.cs.uah.edu Valerie Roberts
ro...@UDel.Edu Thomas R Rocek
ron...@duke.usask.ca Ron Doucette
ron...@ES.COM Ron Williams
ROSS...@CNSVAX.UWEC.EDU Brent Rossow
rpa...@spot.Colorado.EDU Robert Parson
rp...@stilling.ftech.co.uk Roy Stilling
rsp...@primenet.com Richard Spear
rstr...@cix.compulink.co.uk Richard Strathie
RU...@logica.com Rule Nick
rune...@icacomp.com Jennifer Smith
rus...@cougarnet.byu.edu Jeff Rust
rwa...@netspace.net.au Robert R. Wagner
rwb...@elnet.com Roger W. Brown
ryc...@ionet.net Philip Rychel
S.NE...@ix.netcom.com Stella Nemeth
sal...@vax.ox.ac.uk
sb...@indiana.edu Stephen Joseph Ball
sbha...@styx.ios.com Shankar Bhattacharyya
scr...@cats.ucsc.edu
sde...@ecst.csuchico.edu Sean D. Dexter
sdon...@trmx3.dot.ca.gov Steve Dondero
SDun...@aol.com
se...@spectra.net Ed Engelman/Sue Atkinson
sel...@cix.compulink.co.uk Andrew Selkirk
sgl...@world.std.com steve glines
shar...@ix.netcom.com Prince
SHIC...@VM.TEMPLE.EDU
shof...@epix.net Shawn D. Hoffman
sho...@imtn.tpd.dsccc.com Sheilah Horman
shun...@chat.carleton.ca Scott Huntley
sim...@cix.compulink.co.uk Simon Watts
sjp...@mailer.york.ac.uk Simon Trafford
ske...@sedona.intel.com Sean V. Kelley~
smac...@polar.Bowdoin.EDU Scott MacEachern
sor...@ll.mit.edu John M. Sorvari
srs...@HK.Super.NET Stephen Selby
st...@mcs.com Joe Bernstein
stev...@cyberport.com Steven Dye
Steve_...@ccgate.ssp.nmfs.gov Steve Lesnik
stewart....@antsaoir.demon.co.uk Stewart Mac Intyre
stra...@borg.com Stratton
s...@valinor.mythical.com Stu Labovitz
sutt...@rmplc.co.uk Richard Rothwell
s...@kozmix.ow.nl Sander van Malssen
swe...@ideanet.doe.state.in.us Susan Weller
ta...@ridgecrest.ca.us Tasos Serghides
tat...@pop.iquest.net Rudolph J. Tatay
tb...@sybase.com Tony Basoglu
tcf...@ucl.ac.uk Clive Robert Orton
tch...@utep.edu Tim Church
tcr...@ucl.ac.uk Adrian Tribe
t...@isgtec.com Ted Richards
tegt...@panix.com John R. Tegtmeier
tgr...@ix.netcom.com Tom Griffin
thas...@mortis.demon.co.uk John Edmund Rupik
the...@the-end.demon.co.uk Simon Parsons
Theo.P...@ping.be Theo Peeters
tho...@blue.misnet.com Tom Head
tin...@panix.com Bruce Tindall
tle...@neosoft.com Terrance Lewis
tmcn...@magnus.acs.ohio-state.edu Timothy J McNiven
t...@saoralba.demon.co.uk Tom Bell
to...@bets.montgomery.pa.us Tony Villareal
to...@minerals.csiro.au Tony Sanderson
toto...@guild.bc.ca Rodger Whitlock
tre...@caerlas.demon.co.uk Trevor Reynolds
tro...@olympus.bzn.vlt.eds.com Todd Trotter
Tro...@aol.com
tsim...@luna.cas.usf.edu Terrance Simpson (ANT)
twi...@HUB.ofthe.net
u920...@muss.CIS.McMaster.CA Steve Chrisomalis
ucy...@ucl.ac.uk Eileen Jamieson
V056...@ubvms.cc.buffalo.edu
V187...@ubvms.cc.buffalo.edu
v...@msen.com Vince Vielhaber
v...@uni.net Rau
wa...@cse.ogi.edu Karen Ward
WA...@aol.com
wdol...@unm.edu
web...@piazza.com Bill Moore
Whe...@virginia.edu David E. Wheeler
whi...@shore.net Rowland S. Whittet
win...@uni-muenster.de Stephan Winkler
W...@xray.caltech.edu
wyld...@netcom.com Myrddin
xant...@qualcomm.com Kent Paul Dolan
Yax...@aol.com
ycru...@YKnet.YK.CA Doug Rutherford
yu...@io.com Mike Kuninobu
zaf...@super.zippo.com Patricia A. Swan
Voted No
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
afa...@us.itd.umich.edu Andrew Philip Fabbro
afar...@spdmail.spd.dsccc.com Al Fargnoli
al...@moonrake.demon.co.uk Alan M. Dunsmuir
alde...@netcom.com Richard M. Alderson III
alt...@CS.cmu.edu Erik Altmann
apa...@digital.net L P. Mangas
ber...@Okway.okstate.edu John Berry
bo...@datasync.com Martin H. Booda
bru...@Think.COM Eric Brunner
cq...@freenet.carleton.ca Hank Walker
dau...@smtp-gw.spawar.navy.mil Anthony Dauer
demoni...@cix.compulink.co.uk Dominic Green
din...@netcom.com Phares Woods
DSchw...@gnn.com Douglas Schwartz
egw...@netcom.com Eric
har...@iastate.edu Brandi N Foster
hen...@uvic.ca
h...@tiac.net Howard I. Cohen
IBJI...@aol.com
India...@aol.com
ir...@gnu.ai.mit.edu Iraj Mughal
kh...@cs.nyu.edu Hasnain Khan
KidE...@aol.com
kna...@vkpmzd.kph.Uni-Mainz.DE J%org Knappen
lfo...@iastate.edu Lance Foster
LMI...@vms.cis.pitt.edu LISA A. MITTEN
lpio...@magnus.acs.ohio-state.edu Len Piotrowski
mbwi...@ix.netcom.com Mary Beth Williams
md...@cornell.edu Michael Oltz
ml...@andrew.cmu.edu Michael Loomis
mug...@alumni.caltech.edu Asim Mughal
ol...@viking.mv.com Olav Nieuwejaar
OneSa...@aol.com
os...@hep.uchicago.edu Scott Oser
pa...@catfish.lcs.mit.edu Patrick J. LoPresti
pcr...@u.washington.edu P. Creasy
q...@netcom.com Dave Harman
ry...@gwis2.circ.gwu.edu Glen Patrick Ryan
stai...@bga.com Dwight Brown
thor.k...@pcb.mpoli.fi Thor Kottelin
TJAS...@us.oracle.com TJASKIEW.US.ORACLE.COM
tla...@email.univpubs.american.edu Todd C. Lawson
t...@spacetec.no Tor Arntsen
wide...@cc.helsinki.fi Risto Widenius
Abstained
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
des...@ccs.carleton.ca Derek Smith
h...@wwa.com Henrietta Thomas
m...@RedBrick.COM Maxime Taksar KC6ZPS
Votes in error
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ccc...@vip.cybercity.dk
! No vote statement in message
duk...@gunnison.com Casey Dukeman
! No vote statement in message
lud...@arch.urgu.e-burg.su L.Koryakova
! No vote statement in message
pp00...@interramp.com Laurie E. W. Brandt
! No vote statement in message
re...@tamu.edu Jeni Voncannon
! No vote statement in message