There's a really big difference between these two potential scenarios:
(a) every single rails app I've ever written that uses find_by_*(params[*]) is immediately and completely compromised by anyone in the world with a simple well crafted url
-and-
(b) every single rails app I've ever written might be completely compromised if I've done my code in certain ways that are not common, like somehow converting user supplied string keys to symbols (authlogic being only an example).
In either case, yes, I should "immediately" upgrade my rails to avoid the risk, since "complete compromise" is a pretty severe thing to risk (no matter how remote the chance). Let no man mistake that, or dull that message.... Let's upgrade! Don't put it off.
But the difference between (a) and (b) is in how much ridiculous sums of money should be spent on how many sleepless man-nights. The difference also can be in some manager deciding to ban rails from his company (or not), or some large customer of some rails-centric company deciding to not hire that company any longer (or keep hiring them).
I can understand pushing for upgrades, reducing liability, being on the safe side, etc, but please don't overstate the issue. If it's (a), please don't be nebulous about it, just plainly state that it's (a) and provide proof if people disagree. But if it's (b), please don't imply that it's (a).
Dave