Respected Biologists and Managers,
My understanding is that you are considering the use of toxic rodenticide drops over the Farallones.
I would like to draw your attention to a 2-year risk assessment study examining the toxic effects of rodenticides on non-target animals including raptors. Our study used ecological risk assessment calculations based on previously established toxicity data, and included a wide variety of commonly used rodenticides including diphacinone, imidacloprid and zinc phosphide. Please note that brodifacoum, which has been used in the past, is a rodenticide in the same anticoagulant family as diphacinone. Imidacloprid is sometimes blended into the anticoagulant rodenticides and is also extremely toxic to non-target receptors including native birds (Mineau and Palmer 2013).
As the name indicates, anticoagulant rodenticides cause animals to bleed internally. Causes of mortality are internal hemorrhaging and related
toxicity effects (McMillin 2017); non-target wildlife is definitely impacted (Lima and Salmon 2010; Hosea 2000; US
EPA 1998a). Significant toxic impacts have been observed on screech owls, great-horned owls and golden eagles. These previously obtained toxicity studies indicate negative impacts are anticipated for burrowing owls and other native birds.
Our study concluded that rodenticide drops would have heavy impacts on non-target wildlife including protected and sensitive species. Furthermore, many rodenticides can persist, which can result in exposure over longer terms.
Please consider my note as a strong recommendation against pesticide drops on the Farallone Islands. We cannot afford to lose more wildlife. Please consider using non-toxic rodent removal options, if at all, or benign neglect.
Multiple other references and our exposure dose calculations are available if desired.
Best regards,
Maya Khosla
Wildlife Biologist and Toxicologist
Selected References
Hosea,
R. 2000. Exposure of Non-Target Wildlife to Anticoagulant Target Wildlife to
Anticoagulant Rodenticides in California. Proceedings of the 19th Vertebrate
Pest Conference.
Lima
L. and T. Salmon. 2010. Assessing some potential environmental impacts from
agricultural anticoagulant uses. Proceedings of the 24th Vertebrate Pest
Conference. Proceedings of Vertebrate Pest Conference. University of California
Davis. 199-203.
McMillin,
S. 2017. Conference Paper: Impacts to non-target wildlife from rodenticide use
in urban areas. Urban Wildlife Conference. June 7.
Mineau,
P. and C. Palmer. 2013. The Impact of the Nation’s Most Widely Used
Insecticides on Birds. American Bird Conservancy Report.
US
EPA.1991. Reregistration Eligibility Decision (RED): Rodenticide Cluster.
EPA 738-F-98-004.