Saturday, September 4, 2010 - Page 2
Report: U.S. to 'tolerate' Afghan corruption
U.S. military commanders in Afghanistan are
developing a strategy that would tolerate limited corruption but target
large-scale abuses, The Washington Post reported late yesterday.
Citing unnamed senior defense officials, the
newspaper said Pentagon officials had concluded that the Taliban insurgency was
the most pressing threat to stability in Afghanistan rather than corruption.
They also believe that a sweeping effort to stamp out corruption would create
chaos and a governance vacuum that the Taliban could exploit, the report
said.
"There are areas where you need strong leadership,
and some of those leaders are not entirely pure," the paper quotes a senior
defense official as saying. "But they can help us be more effective in going
after the primary threat, which is the Taliban."
Graft is a major issue in Afghanistan, which is
rated by international monitor Transparency International as second only to
lawless Somalia on its scale of the world's most corrupt countries.
Afghan President Hamid Karzai has ordered a review
of the two anti-corruption bodies, the Major Crimes Task Force and the Sensitive
Investigative Unit, which have been operating for 18 months with the help of
foreign advisers and with mostly U.S. funding.
U.S. State Department spokesman Philip Crowley said
the United States was "in touch with the Afghan government" about the departure
of the deputy attorney general, adding he had been doing "vitally important"
work in fighting corruption.
Sen. John Kerry, after meeting Karzai earlier this
month, said the Afghan government must show progress on eradicating corruption
or risk losing U.S. support. Approval of nearly $4 billion in U.S. aid to
Afghanistan is being blocked amid fears that U.S. money is being siphoned off by
Afghan officials.
The United States has almost 93,000 troops in the
country, who along with 48,000 NATO soldiers are battling a Taliban-led
insurgency.
Chitwood out as Civil Air Patrol's national vice commander; Gen.
Courter is winning the 'culture war'
A corrupt core that has had its tentacles wrapped
around the Civil Air Patrol (CAP) for at least a dozen years has seen its grip
significantly loosened as the CAP's annual conference National Board (NB)
meeting rolled out this weekend in San Diego, Calif.
The Civil Air Patrol’s national
vice commander, Brig. Gen. Reggie Chitwood, yesterday lost his bid for
re-election to a fourth term in office. CAP national commander Maj. Gen.
Amy S. Courter finally has a second-in-command who is in her camp.
Col. Chuck Carr, the
CAP's Great Lakes Region commander, replaces Chitwood. Carr was one of
two candidates who had Courter’s endorsement. The other was Bill Charles,
who has held numerous senior positions in the CAP.
There was a big field of
candidates and worry that split votes might give Chitwood another
win. Through the ballots Chitwood held a consistent 27 votes while the rest
of the votes consolidated, finally with enough of a majority to elect
Carr.
The election not only removes
Chitwood from the national vice commander's slot, but removes him from any
voting boards, including the Board of Governors (BoG). Chitwood is the prime
suspect for vicious and distorted leaks from the BoG to Ray Hayden, owner of
CAP Insights, a web page that has been supporting
Chitwood.
Hayden has himself reported
recently receiving a cease and desist order from an attorney for Gen. Courter.
Hayden is a former member of the CAP who had his
membership terminated for cheating on U.S. Air Force Air University Command
and Staff College exams for ousterd former CAP national commander Tony Pineda
and two of his cronies. In an unprecedented move that received national media
attention, Pineda was removed from office, and stripped of his rank and his
membership in late 2007.
Hayden has not been a member of
the CAP for a few years, and has no first-hand experience of the CAP whatsoever,
except with members of the Chitwood camp, who source him.
Chitwood was a Pineda appointee,
though he did win two subsequent squeaker elections in his own
right. NOTF likes to think our coverage of Chitwood over the past
year has played a role in his ouster. We understand that when the candidates
were presenting, Chitwood was asked pointed questions, one or two that may have
been informed by NOTF's coverage - questions Chitwood did not
answer.
Often - but not necessarily -
the person who is in the vice commander’s slot in the last year of a national
commander’s tenure succeeds to the commandership. Chitwood's loss at least
weakens his bid for the national commander's slot next year. If Chitwood
should take the national commandership, that would probably mean the undoing of
all Gen. Courter and her team have worked to establish. This is a sign
Courter’s positive legacy may be sustainable.
NOTF regards this
election as another big win for Gen. Courter in a nasty culture war that
has raged since she took office three years ago. Gen. Courter has been
working to establish a culture of accountability and professionalism in the
CAP. She has worked smartly, valiantly and persistently against entrenched
corruption on all sides, which is now falling back. She has worked
while under constant personal attack.
In March of this year, according
to one of those leaks from the BoG, she persuaded Sen. Carl Levin, chairperson
of the Senate Armed Services Committee, to order an investigation of the
CAP. That investigation is still underway. We have no news of it
yet.
The fact that Chitwood was
allowed to run tells NOTF two additional things. First,
NOTF had hoped for changes to the CAP's governance model that would
allow the national commander to name his or her own
second-in-command. Chitwood is not the only vice commander who has
sabotaged a national commander in the CAP, and America learned separate
elections don't work in 1796. Second, this means that apparently Chitwood
is not under investigation and therefore has not and cannot be disciplined for
his constant efforts to undermine the national commander, his role in leaks from
the BoG, etc. This was a bit of a surprise to us - but stay
tuned.
The Chitwood loss is,
nevertheless, a Courter win. It indicates that all the efforts of the
corrupt core to muzzle Gen. Courter and to engage in every possible political
maneuver to compromise her and take her down have failed.
In other news from
the National Board:
NOTF has been told that
closed-door meetings have been running since Tuesday. The CAP is not
video-streaming the proceedings of this NB as it has most others, for reasons we
do not know. We suspect - but don't know - that quite a few battles may
have been won behind those closed doors and before the full NB formally
convened.
We understand that the
Membership Action Review Board (MARB) heard the appeal of Rhode Island Wing
Commander Gagliardi against his recent removal. We hear Gagliardi won the
appeal. This is disappointing, but no surprise. Most members of the MARB are appointees of Gen. Rick Bowling, a
former CAP national commander and chair of the CAP's BoG. As
NOTF has reported, Bowling has been at the very center of CAP
corruption going back at least a dozen years and he is a big player in the same
corrupt core that brought you Pineda, Kauffman and Chitwood. MARB members
hold their positions for life - or until they resign.
The MARB is the last stronghold
of the "Corrupt Ones." Over the past year, we have seen more and more actions
appealed to the MARB, where the decisions of the Courter team have been
reversed. Our informants at the National Board meeting tell us there
is ongoing discussion about replacing members of the MARB. We do not yet know
what it would take to make that happen, probably a change to the Constitution
and By-Laws of the CAP.
The MARB also recently reversed
the removal of John Tilton from the BoG, as NOTF has
reported. CAP Insights blamed Courter for this allegedly
improper removal, however, it was not Gen. Courter who personally
removed Tilton - that was done by a vote of the NEC.
It is not clear that the MARB's
action was proper. NOTF understands a closed-door meeting of the NEC
may begin to deal with this issue. The MARB is appointed by the CAP's
BoG. We believe the NEC can request action of the BoG.
Tilton was appointed to the BoG
by Pineda and has been supported by two successive chairs of the BoG,
Bowling and Hopper. The reversal of Tilton's removal by the BoG probably
means that Ned Lee was pushed back off the BoG. Ned Lee is a long-term CAP
member, a Spaatz cadet who met his wife in CAP. Lee is a superior court
judge from California. There is a hope that Lee would succeed Hopper as
the chair of the BoG, bringing professional judicial experience and an
appreciation of governance issues to the CAP. Lee, by the way, was
appointed by Gen. Courter and is representative of the high caliber of
leadership Courter is trying to bring to CAP affairs.
Over recent months, there have
been substantial changes to the BoG membership, with the result that the body is
no longer controlled by the "Corrupt Ones."
NOTF’s respect and
admiration go out to Gen. Courter and her team for what they are accomplishing
under very difficult conditions. CAP members are metaphorically dancing in the
streets, if the blogs are to be believed.
Please grant NOTF
permission to exercise gloating rights for its role in throwing a spotlight up
on corruption in the CAP. NOTF was the first to publish the
cheating issue that brought Pineda down after our story went out on the wires
and was published worldwide.
We understand our exposure of
the genealogy of corruption in the CAP has been useful. (See our
online archives: Message #7011, Sept. 21, 2009). And we are more than a
little proud to crow that our reading of the tea leaves around last year’s NB is
proving accurate and influential.
The Civil Air Patrol is a private,
congressionally-chartered corporation that acts as an Auxiliary of the U.S. Air
Force when requested by the Secretary of the Air Force. Head-quartered at
Maxwell AFB, Ala., its Web site is at
www.gocivilairpatrol.com .
National Guard soldiers return from Afghanistan
There were tears and hugs yesterday at a welcome
home celebration for 60 members of the Alabama Army National Guard.
A Busch Stadium send-off for Navy recruits
By Jim Corvey, NOTF-St. Louis
Yesterday, about 100
U.S. Navy recruits were sent off to basic training in a traditional
St. Louis send-off.
In the 52nd annual "Cardinal
Company" ceremony, the recruits were sworn in wearing red shirts. They
had a picnic with their families at the Soldiers Memorial yester
afternoon, then marched to Busch Stadium.
An enlistment ceremony was held
on the field before the game (last night against division rival
Cincinnati), the group watched the game, and then headed off to basic
training to applause from the appreciative crowd.
The St. Louis Cardinals and
the local Navy recruiting office have been holding "Cardinal Company" since
1958.
Japan set to dispose of chemical arms in
China
Japan is finally moving to dispose of
chemical weapons left in China by the Imperial Japanese Army at the end of World
War II.
Munitions are to be blown up and chemicals rendered
harmless in a mobile disposal facility set up in the capital city of Jiangsu
Province, officials said. A ceremony to mark the start was held last
Wednesday.
Japan to date has unearthed about 48,000 chemical
munitions across China, a fraction of the estimated 400,000 that the Japanese
military dumped as its forces fled the country.
This is the first time for the disposal work to be
carried out. Japan plans to destroy some 36,000 munitions kept in Nanjing,
formerly Nanking, within the next 12 months. It also plans to widen the scale of
operations to encompass other Chinese cities.
Michigan Guard unit being deployed
Friends and family will bid farewell to
approximately 70 Michigan Army National Guard soldiers from the Charlotte-based
Headquarters Battery, 1st Battalion, 119th Field Artillery, on Tuesday, Sept.
14, as they depart for Fort McCoy, Wis., and then Iraq for a 12-month tour of
duty.
The departure ceremony will be held at 9 a.m., at
the Eaton County Fairgrounds' grandstands in Charlotte, with a parade
through downtown at 10 a.m.
Air show comes to Martinsburg
About 40,000 people a day are expected to attend an
air show this weekend at West Virginia's Martinsburg Air National Guard
Base.
USS Hawaii arrives in Yokosuka By Lt.
Lara Bollinger, USN, Commander Submarine Group 7 Public
Affairs
The Virginia-class fast attack submarine USS
Hawaii (SSN 776) arrived at Yokosuka Naval Station, Japan, yesterday,
marking the very first time in the U.S. 7th Fleet's history that a
Virginia-class submarine visited the region.
With a crew of approximately 130, Hawaii
is on its first Western Pacific deployment. The boat's scheduled deployment will
give Hawaii's crew the opportunity to conduct a multitude of missions
and showcase the latest capabilities of the submarine fleet.
"My crew has worked very hard to train in
preparation for this important deployment," said Cmdr. Steve Mack,
Hawaii's commanding officer. "I'm proud that my submarine is the first
of its class to ever deploy to the Western Pacific region, and I'm looking
forward to completing all assigned tasking over the next few months."
For Culinary Specialist 3rd Class Andrew Myers,
this is his first deployment. "This is my first time to ever set foot in Japan,
and I'm very excited to experience the culture and sights of this beautiful
country," said Myers.
Measuring 377 feet long and weighing 7,800 tons
when submerged, Hawaii is one of the U.S. Navy's newest and most
technologically sophisticated submarines. The state-of-the-art submarine is
capable of supporting a multitude of missions, including anti-submarine warfare,
anti-surface ship warfare, strike, naval special warfare involving special
operations forces, intelligence, surveillance and reconnaissance, irregular
warfare and mine warfare.
General seeks to build professional, sustainable Afghan
forces
By John D. Banusiewicz, American Forces Press Service
Building Afghan security forces that are capable,
professional and sustainable is going to take a long time, but also is key to
long-term success, the general who leads the NATO training mission in
Afghanistan said in Kabul yesterday.
U.S. Army Lt. Gen. William B. Caldwell, IV,
explained the effort to reporters traveling with Navy Adm. Mike Mullen, chairman
of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, while Mullen was in a series of private meetings
at the U.S. Embassy and the International Security Assistance Force
(ISAF)'s headquarters.
When he stood up the NATO training mission there in
November, Caldwell said, the enormity of the challenge was quite evident. No
Afghan army or police training commands existed. The only standard for
graduation from basic training was starting the course and still being there on
the last day of training. Most police received no real training. The ethos that
guides professional military forces was absent in the Afghan security forces.
Recruiting was low, and attrition was high. In fact, Caldwell said, the Afghan
army had "negative growth," recruiting only 800 new soldiers in September 2009
while losing more than 2,000 through attrition.
With a target today of growing the Afghan security
forces by 55,000 members to 306,000 by December 2011, Caldwell said, the current
attrition rates indicate that 141,000 new members must be recruited and trained.
If attrition improves, he added, the recruiting requirement would ease
accordingly.
The focus of the NATO training mission for its
first 10 months has been to turn those trends around and lay a foundation for
the professionalization of Afghanistan's security forces, the general said. The
Afghan army now has had a training command for six months.
"It's going like gangbusters," Caldwell said.
"We've got the right advisors and they're working with them. They've appointed a
good Afghan commander, and they are taking control of the training for their
Afghan army." A training command for Afghan police was activated in May, and a
commander has just been appointed, Caldwell said, and the Afghan police now have
a good code of conduct.
Afghan police have a reputation for being corrupt,
Caldwell said, citing reports of police officers shaking people down for money,
using tactics such as setting up illegal checkpoints and charging people to pass
through them. When he found out that police officers were being paid far less
than a living wage, he said, he understood how that could happen. "We had set
the conditions so that a policeman was not even able to make a basic minimum
wage by serving his country," Caldwell said. Now that police make a decent wage
on a par with their army counterparts, he added, the incentive for corruption
diminishes and police have a sense they are part of a professional force that is
a viable career option.
Soldiers and police now can receive additional
incentive pay for serving in dangerous areas, as well as longevity pay raises
that reward them for continuing to serve.
And trainees now must meet standards. The weapon
qualification rate for Afghan soldiers and police at the end of basic training
is now 97 percent. "That's just as good as the U.S. Army," Caldwell noted. The 3
percent who don't qualify at that point receive more training and then
qualify.
Leader development is a limiting factor in building
professional forces, Caldwell said, and the training mission has taken on that
issue as a top priority, greatly increasing capacity to train soldiers and
police officers to become effective leaders.
Another limiting factor is literacy, the general
said, noting that 80 percent of the recruits can't read or write. "It's real
hard, especially for us, to comprehend that they couldn't even write their names
and they didn't know any numbers," he said. Weapons accountability is
impossible, he noted as an example, when the soldiers or police can't read the
serial number and know whether they have the right weapon. If a recruit can't
read the list of equipment he was supposed to be issued, the general added, he
won't know if the person issuing the equipment is holding equipment back to sell
on the black market, so the crime goes undetected.
When the NATO training mission stood up in
November, some Afghan recruits were enrolled in optional literacy programs, but
no mandatory programs existed, Caldwell said. Now, 23,000 members of
Afghanistan's security forces are in mandatory literacy training designed to
give them a third-grade reading level. That number will be 50,000 in December,
he added, and is expected to be 100,000 on any given day by June.
In the effort to move Afghan forces toward
self-sufficiency, Caldwell noted, a basic level of literacy becomes especially
important as training goes beyond infantry skills and starts to include more
specialized areas such as transportation, maintenance and medical disciplines.
Another challenge is finding qualified Afghan
instructors, the general said. Hiring only Afghan instructors, he explained, is
critical to building the enduring capability that is key to long-term
success.
And training doesn't end when Afghan units finish
their formal training, Caldwell said. The vast majority of operations now
involve Afghan units working alongside ISAF partners, so their training
continues as they learn on the job from professional forces.
Though the progress has been considerable in 10
months, Caldwell said, it will be a long time before the Afghan security forces
have matured to the point at which they can see to all of their training,
recruiting and retention needs without help and field professional and
sustainable forces on their own.
"Our mission is not one that is done by next
summer, or even next December," Caldwell said. The need to continue growing and
professionalizing the Afghan forces will remain for some time, he added.
Trainers build new Afghan health system
By Judith Snyderman, Defense Media Activity
For hands-on medical professionals it is very
difficult to stand back and watch others deliver care. Yet, that is precisely
the job of some 250 members of a nine-month-old medical training advisory group
serving in Afghanistan.
"That is our pathway to transition here, to help
the Afghans perform and to increase their capability, not by doing it for them,
but rather by advising them and stepping back," U.S. Air Force Col. (Dr.)
Schuyler K. Geller said during a Sept. 2 "DoD Live" Bloggers Roundtable
discussion.
Geller is the command surgeon and commander of the
medical training advisory group at Camp Eggers, NATO Training
Mission-Afghanistan/Combined Security Transition Command-Afghanistan.
Geller said one of first things incoming advisors
get is a medical mentor's manual that describes their role, "not as a clinician,
not as a nurse, not as a technician, but as a trainer."
He said mentors are often embedded in Afghan army
and police hospitals, and at regional hospitals. The largest facility and the
premier training institution for Afghan nurses, doctors and combat medics,
Geller said, is the 400-bed National Military Hospital in Kabul.
The time and effort required to become proficient
in medical fields is intensive, Geller said. For instance, he said, "the
physicians' training program in Afghanistan takes a 12th-grader and puts them
through a seven-year training program."
Geller said officials are working to recruit more Afghan
doctors, nurses and other medical specialists to bolster the country's medical
force. He pointed out that the goal is not just to train Afghan health care
workers, but to train them as instructors who will be able to carry on and
sustain the effort independently. Geller cited impressive progress on that
front.
"We will be able to transition in October the
combat medic training, the medical officer's basic training, the medical
sergeants or NCO training program and the logistics training program, entirely
over to the Afghans," he said.
Geller said he anticipates completing the
transition of the remainder of nursing, physician assistants, biomedical
maintenance, preventative medicine, lab, X-ray and other training programs by
2013.
Marine follows family heritage
By Cpl. Ned Johnson, USMC, Regimental Combat Team 2
U.S. Marine Corps Sgt. Dominick Valerio, a squad leader with
Company K, 3rd Battalion, 7th Marine Regiment, teaches a casualty evacuation
class in Sangin, Afghanistan, Aug. 27. Valerio views every moment with his squad
as an opportunity to teach them something new, preparing them for the challenges
that await them. (U.S. Marine Corps photo by Cpl. Ned Johnson)
U.S. Marine Corps Sgt. Dominick Valerio said he
joined the military because the men in his family have always defended America's
freedom.
"My grandfather served in
World War II, and both my uncles are Vietnam vets," said Valerio, a squad leader
here with Company K, 3rd Battalion, 7th Marine Regiment. "My brothers also serve
in the Army."
Having served in the Marine Corps Security Forces,
Valerio said he likes teaching young Marines. Though he always knew he would end
up in the military, Valerio said the Marine Corps' "dragon slayer" commercial
convinced him to become a Marine.
Valerio said he wanted to emulate a member of his
family who serves as a Marine infantryman, known in military vernacular as a
"grunt."
"My brother-in-law is with the 1st Battalion,
6th Marines, and is a 'grunt,'" said Valerio, a 22-year-old native of Phelps,
New York. "I knew I wanted to be an infantryman and I told the recruiter I would
do nothing else."
After completing basic infantryman training,
Valerio was given the opportunity to receive advanced training when he elected
to work in security forces rather than a regular infantry line company. "As a
'Security Forces' Marine," Valerio said, "I went to the Urban Assault Leader's
Course, Joint Fires Observer Course, Infantry Squad Leader's Course, and a ton
of other schools."
Lance Cpl. Ryan Kinne, a team leader with Company
K, said he appreciates Valerio's mentorship. "He will teach you anything you
want to know, if you ask," said Kinne, a 21-year-old native of San Antonio,
Texas. "He's given us classes on calling for fire, medical evacuation procedures
and lots of other things."
Valerio said his teaching style is anything but
conventional. "I like to use physical training to teach Marines," he said. "We
might go on a run and I can tell when everyone needs a break, so I'll stop and
teach them something important."
Valerio said he also incorporates other types of
physical training into his instruction, like carrying a litter and other tasks
Marines may have to perform under fire.
In Afghanistan, Kinne said, Valerio's training
sessions have had a positive impact on the battlefield. "We have taken
casualties and we have had to transport them to a landing zone and call in a
casualty report," he said. "That's where the training paid off."
Kinne said Valerio's "people" skills help him to
connect with his Marines. "He is very well-spoken,' Kinne said of Valerio. "He
can explain something no matter who you are."
Other Marines who know Valerio, like Lance Cpl.
Joshua Matthews, a team leader with Company K, say his physical courage,
military skills and teaching ability have gained him the respect of his
subordinates and superiors.
But Valerio also has earned his Marines' trust
because of his moral courage, Matthews said. "My favorite thing about him as a
squad leader is that he sticks up for his Marines," Matthews said of Valerio.
"Even at the risk of getting himself in trouble, he has stood beside Marines
that he thought were in the right."
Just how the hell did this happen?
Page 2