Hi Dana,
Sounds like your AtoM installation all on one server then, is that correct?
It is possible the old IP or hostname could be referenced in say /etc/elasticsearch/elasticsearch.yml, but most likely not (usually commented out).
If you cd to your atom home directory, have a look at the file apps/qubit/config/search.yml (or perhaps it is in just config/search.yml), see if any host references there are to something other than localhost or 127.0.0.1 - if you see your old information there, change it and let me know.
Then also while you're there, run the command
sudo -u www-data php symfony cc
(assumes www-data owns the files in that directory, if 'ls -alF' shows a file user of nginx use that instead for instance).
Thanks,
Dave Hume, Artefactual Systems Administrator