Session 5 | MLAG Seminars Series 2025-2026 (23 February, 13h00, Online)

0 views

Skip to first unread message

FLUP | Instituto de Filosofia

unread,

Feb 17, 2026, 3:12:25 PM (13 days ago) Feb 17

to Lekton

MLAG Seminars Series 2025-2026

Session 5

Carving Nature without Joints: The Role of Values in the Identification of Kinds

| Francesco Guala & Davide Serpico (University of Milan)

23 February 2026 | 13h00 | Online

The Mind, Language and Action Group (MLAG), a research group of the Institute of Philosophy at the University of Porto, invites you to the fifth talk of the new MLAG Seminar Series featuring presentations by international researchers on topics of interest to the group.

The talk, given by Francesco Guala and Davide Serpico (University of Milan) and entitled "Carving Nature without Joints: The Role of Values in the Identification of Kinds", will take place on February 23, 13:00-14:30 Western European Time (WET).

ONLINE | LINK MICROSOFT TEAMS

Meeting ID: 311 808 653 439 13

Passcode: ec6WP7q5

Abstract: What roles do values play in the identification of kinds? In this paper, we explore this question within the framework of the property cluster view, showing that topological tools provide fruitful ways to address them. In the first part, we argue that a key epistemic value (inductive success) imposes non-trivial constraints on the shape of kinds. In the second part, we distinguish between two roles that non-epistemic values may play in the individuation of kinds. On the one hand, values may shield our inferential practices from costly mistakes and mitigate the negative effects of performative kinds. On the other, it may be desirable to let values play a weaker role to facilitate communication and comparability across contexts. We conclude with some reflections on the pros and cons of letting values play a stronger or a weaker role in kind-making. These options do not reflect a sharp dichotomy between ‘value-laden’ and ‘value-free’ science, but rather a spectrum of contexts in which the epistemic and non-epistemic pressures on kind construction vary.

MLAG Seminars Series 2025-2026: https://ifilosofia.up.pt/activities/mlag-seminars-series-2025-2026

Information about MLAG can be found here: https://ifilosofia.up.pt/research-groups/mlag

To contact the organisers, please send an email to mlag....@gmail.com

Organisation:
Sofia Miguens (MLAG-IF)
Dan Zeman (MLAG-IF)
James Grayot (MLAG-IF)
Rafael Antunes Padilha (MLAG-IF|IFCH-UNICAMP)
Samuel Lima (FLUP)
João Carlos Rocha Lima (FLUP)

RG Mind, Language and Action Group (MLAG)
Instituto de Filosofia da Universidade do Porto – UID/00502/2025
Fundação para a Ciência e a Tecnologia (FCT)

____________________________________________

Instituto de Filosofia (UI&D 502)
Faculdade de Letras da Universidade do Porto
Via Panorâmica s/n
4150-564 Porto
Tel. 22 607 71 80
E-mail: ifilo...@letras.up.pt
http://ifilosofia.up.pt/