SOAFEE TSC : Mixed Critical Workload Orchestration Tiger Team

171 views
Skip to first unread message

Girish Shirasat

unread,
Jul 21, 2022, 6:52:05 PM7/21/22
to Matteo Andreozzi, Hilario, Paolo, Mitra, Neel, 정두경, 이철희, Alex Agizim, konrad....@continental-corporation.com, Mathias....@etas.com, Fleischmann, Thomas (T1-27), Andreas Faerber (afaerber@suse.com), Joachim Werner, acar...@redhat.com, holger....@elektrobit.com, Bernhard Leiner, Rajive Joshi, Estela Rey Ramos, t...@soafee.io, Matt Spencer, Stamm, Martin02, Harvey, Luke, Al Stone, m...@soafee.io

CC: TSC/MSC & WG Chairs

BCC : GB

 

Hi All,

 

Unfortunately we were not able to bring the below topic into last week’s TSC due to Project Moonshot conversations hence wanted to continue via email  !

 

There have been some great conversations on this topics which we think need to be brought into a dedicated tiger team for discussion and disposition as soon as we can to avoid further fragmentation

 

Below is my suggestion for initial set of companies that I think have stakes in this conversation and should be part of this tiger team .Can I request folks that I have named below to please volunteer someone from their company ( which could also include themselves 😊 ) so that we can get this going. Note that the recommendations of this tiger team will form part of Moonshot as the ref implementation which will be seeded across the ecosystem.

 

@Mitra, Neel : Hi Neel – As this tiger team will be parented to cloud-native dev wg, would be great if you could please take the lead and connect with the folks below relying on @Estela Rey Ramos for any operations / community support to bootstrap this tiger team . Once the TT is in place, you can help assign a chair who can lead the team and report back into to the  Cloud-Native Dev WG.

 

Proposed Tiger  Team :

 

Regards,

Girish

 

 

 

From: Girish Shirasat <Girish....@arm.com>
Date: Monday, July 11, 2022 at 6:45 AM
To: Matt Spencer <Matt.S...@arm.com>, Matteo Andreozzi <Matteo.A...@arm.com>, Carey Smith <Carey...@arm.com>, Stefano Marzani <marz...@amazon.com>, Hilario, Paolo <pao...@amazon.com>, Mitra, Neel <indr...@amazon.com>, Harvey, Luke <lrha...@amazon.com>, 정두경 <dk....@lge.com>, 이철희 <chulhe...@lge.com>, Alex Agizim <alex_...@epam.com>, Stamm, Martin02 <martin....@continental-corporation.com>, konrad....@continental-corporation.com <konrad....@continental-corporation.com>, Mathias....@etas.com <Mathias....@etas.com>, Fleischmann, Thomas (T1-27) <thomas.fl...@cariad.technology>, Andreas Faerber (afae...@suse.com) <afae...@suse.com>, Joachim Werner <j...@suse.com>, Al Stone <ah...@redhat.com>, acar...@redhat.com <acar...@redhat.com>, Krippner Daniel (CS/EAR) <daniel....@de.bosch.com>, holger....@elektrobit.com <holger....@elektrobit.com>, Bernhard Leiner <bernhar...@tttech-auto.com>, Rajive Joshi <raj...@rti.com>, Thomas Brown <thomas...@nxp.com>
Cc: Robert Day <Rober...@arm.com>, Estela Rey Ramos <Estela....@ARM.com>, Foy, Bill <bil...@amazon.com>, Schleicher, Martin03 (uid22302) <martin.s...@continental-corporation.com>, joerg....@etas.com <joerg....@etas.com>, hans.geo...@cariad.technology <hans.geo...@cariad.technology>, michae...@cariad.technology <michae...@cariad.technology>, Michael Harverson <michael....@suse.com>, Alan Clark <ACL...@suse.com>, Francis Chow <fc...@redhat.com>, Ahsan Shamim <ash...@redhat.com>, Evers Steffen (IOC/PAP) <Steffe...@bosch.io>, Thomas Kuehbeck (TRI) <thomas....@woven-planet.global>, Bart Renka <Bart....@arm.com>, Diekhoff, Dirk <dirk.d...@elektrobit.com>, Bernhard Rill <Bernha...@arm.com>
Subject: SOAFEE TSC : Mixed Critical Workload Orchestration Tiger Team Proposal

Hi All,

 

Hope you all are doing well. I wanted to trigger this email before the SOAFEE TSC this Thursday on a proposal we want to bring into the TSC to start a tiger team under the direction of Cloud Native Dev Workgroup around the topic of mixed critical workload orchestration ( aka MCO )

 

As I am sure all of you would agree, MCO is one of the most important system level topic that SOAFEE is looking at addressing and one of the earliest that we started looking into. During our conversation with various SOAFEE SIG members, it has become evident that there are multiple threads in execution to address this problem . We think it will be a worthwhile effort to trigger a discussion to see if it makes sense to converge these threads knowing that each of these are  looking at addressing same problem while creating an open and scalable solution as latter is the only way to enable an ecosystem around it.

 

With this context, below is the first draft of proposal:

 

Tiger Team : Mixed Critical Workload Orchestration Task Force

Parent WG : Cloud Native Dev Workgroup

Objective : To enable an open standards based  mixed critical workload orchestration solution

Initial Proposed WG members @ Tiger Team: Arm, AWS, LGE, CARIAD , EPAM, SUSE, Red Hat, TTTech, RTI , Continental , Bosch, ETAS, EB, NXP

PS: This is our proposal inviting partners that we know are working on certain aspects of MCO while other partners in the SIG can join based on their interest .

 

We will discuss further around this in the TSC.

 

Regards,

Girish Shirasat 

Senior Director

Automotive Software/Systems , A&I LoB, Arm

SOAFEE TSC Chair

https://soafee.io/

 

IMPORTANT NOTICE: The contents of this email and any attachments are confidential and may also be privileged. If you are not the intended recipient, please notify the sender immediately and do not disclose the contents to any other person, use it for any purpose, or store or copy the information in any medium. Thank you.

Mitra, Neel

unread,
Jul 25, 2022, 7:31:59 PM7/25/22
to Girish Shirasat, Matteo Andreozzi, Hilario, Paolo, 정두경, 이철희, Alex Agizim, konrad....@continental-corporation.com, Mathias....@etas.com, Fleischmann, Thomas (T1-27), Andreas Faerber (afaerber@suse.com), Joachim Werner, acar...@redhat.com, holger....@elektrobit.com, Bernhard Leiner, Rajive Joshi, Estela Rey Ramos, estela....@soafee.io, Mitra, Neel, t...@soafee.io, Matt Spencer, Stamm, Martin02, Harvey, Luke, Al Stone, m...@soafee.io

Thanks @Girish for looping me in.  Appreciate the opportunity.

 

Hi All,

 

Happy Monday. Very excited that we are launching a focused team on Mixed Critical Workloads. This is a hot topic in the industry today, and feels like a huge opportunity for this community to dive deep, consolidate efforts and standardize. So as a next step, @estela & I will setup a kick off meeting for this group (in a week or so) and select a chair (s). The updated list for the tiger team is as below, but please feel free to reach out, if anyone else is interested to join.

 

Proposed Tiger  Team :

     

     

    Please reply back to @Mitra, Neel and @estela.reyramos if any questions / comments / suggestions.

     

    Thanks.

     

    Regards.

     

    Neel Mitra

    Principal Product Solutions Architect

    AWS Industry Products

    m : 201-676-0582

    Let’s Connect @ Linkedin

     

     

     

    Thoughts on our interaction? Provide Feedback here.

     

    signature_2121005187

     

     

    From: Girish Shirasat <Girish....@arm.com>
    Date: Thursday, July 21, 2022 at 6:52 PM
    To: Matteo Andreozzi <Matteo.A...@arm.com>, "Hilario, Paolo" <pao...@amazon.com>, "Mitra, Neel" <indr...@amazon.com>,     정두경 <dk....@lge.com>, 이철희 <chulhe...@lge.com>, Alex Agizim <alex_...@epam.com>, "konrad....@continental-corporation.com" <konrad....@continental-corporation.com>, "Mathias....@etas.com" <Mathias....@etas.com>, "Fleischmann, Thomas (T1-27)" <thomas.fl...@cariad.technology>, "Andreas Faerber (afae...@suse.com)" <afae...@suse.com>, Joachim Werner <j...@suse.com>, "acar...@redhat.com" <acar...@redhat.com>, "holger....@elektrobit.com" <holger....@elektrobit.com>, Bernhard Leiner <bernhar...@tttech-auto.com>, Rajive Joshi <raj...@rti.com>, Estela Rey Ramos <Estela....@ARM.com>
    Cc: "t...@soafee.io" <t...@soafee.io>, Matt Spencer <Matt.S...@arm.com>, "Stamm, Martin02" <martin....@continental-corporation.com>, "Harvey, Luke" <lrha...@amazon.com>, Al Stone <ah...@redhat.com>, "m...@soafee.io" <m...@soafee.io>
    Subject: [EXTERNAL] SOAFEE TSC : Mixed Critical Workload Orchestration Tiger Team

     

    CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you can confirm the sender and know the content is safe.

     

    CC: TSC/MSC & WG Chairs

    BCC : GB

     

    Hi All,

     

    Unfortunately we were not able to bring the below topic into last week’s TSC due to Project Moonshot conversations hence wanted to continue via email  !

     

    There have been some great conversations on this topics which we think need to be brought into a dedicated tiger team for discussion and disposition as soon as we can to avoid further fragmentation

     

    Below is my suggestion for initial set of companies that I think have stakes in this conversation and should be part of this tiger team .Can I request folks that I have named below to please volunteer someone from their company ( which could also include themselves 😊 ) so that we can get this going. Note that the recommendations of this tiger team will form part of Moonshot as the ref implementation which will be seeded across the ecosystem.

     

    @Mitra, Neel : Hi Neel – As this tiger team will be parented to cloud-native dev wg, would be great if you could please take the lead and connect with the folks below relying on @Estela Rey Ramos for any operations / community support to bootstrap this tiger team . Once the TT is in place, you can help assign a chair who can lead the team and report back into to the  Cloud-Native Dev WG.

     

    Proposed Tiger  Team :

    -          Cariad : @Fleischmann, Thomas (T1-27)

    -          Continental : @konrad....@continental-corporation.com

    -          Bosch/ETAS : @Mathias....@etas.com

    -          LGE : @정두경 ( DK )

    -          Aws : @Hilario, Paolo

    -          TTTech : @Bernhard Leiner

    -          SUSE : @Andreas Faerber (afae...@suse.com)

    -          Red Hat : @acar...@redhat.com

    -          Arm : @Matteo Andreozzi

    -          RTI: @Rajive Joshi

    -          EPAM : @Alex Agizim

    ff

    unread,
    Jul 26, 2022, 5:12:57 AM7/26/22
    to Mitra, Neel, Estela Rey Ramos, estela....@soafee.io, t...@soafee.io, Matt Spencer, Stamm, Martin02, Harvey, Luke, Al Stone, m...@soafee.io
    Hi

    The original mail was stating MC “Orchestration” while you refer to MC “Workload”. 
    I am interested in working on:
    • technologies to enforce determinism at the hypervisor and processor level. 
    • Evolving standards such as OCI to cover their execution qualities requirements 
    Should the group work on related subjects, I’d willing to contribute.

    Cheers

    FF


    De : 'Mitra, Neel' via SOAFEE TSC <t...@soafee.io>
    Envoyé : mardi, juillet 26, 2022 01:32
    À : Girish Shirasat <Girish....@arm.com>; Matteo Andreozzi <Matteo.A...@arm.com>; Hilario, Paolo <pao...@amazon.com>; 정두경 <dk....@lge.com>; 이철희 <chulhe...@lge.com>; Alex Agizim <alex_...@epam.com>; konrad....@continental-corporation.com <konrad....@continental-corporation.com>; Mathias....@etas.com <Mathias....@etas.com>; Fleischmann, Thomas (T1-27) <thomas.fl...@cariad.technology>; Andreas Faerber (afae...@suse.com) <afae...@suse.com>; Joachim Werner <j...@suse.com>; acar...@redhat.com <acar...@redhat.com>; holger....@elektrobit.com <holger....@elektrobit.com>; Bernhard Leiner <bernhar...@tttech-auto.com>; Rajive Joshi <raj...@rti.com>; Estela Rey Ramos <Estela....@ARM.com>; estela....@soafee.io <estela....@soafee.io>; Mitra, Neel <indr...@amazon.com>
    Cc : t...@soafee.io <t...@soafee.io>; Matt Spencer <Matt.S...@arm.com>; Stamm, Martin02 <martin....@continental-corporation.com>; Harvey, Luke <lrha...@amazon.com>; Al Stone <ah...@redhat.com>; m...@soafee.io <m...@soafee.io>
    Objet : SOAFEE TSC: Re: SOAFEE TSC : Mixed Critical Workload Orchestration Tiger Team
     
    --
    You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "SOAFEE TSC" group.
    To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to tsc+uns...@soafee.io.
    To view this discussion on the web, visit https://groups.google.com/a/soafee.io/d/msgid/tsc/CC5F0B46-AD5A-4DAD-A119-A534FB30BDF1%40amazon.com.

    Mitra, Neel

    unread,
    Jul 26, 2022, 4:20:48 PM7/26/22
    to ff, Estela Rey Ramos, estela....@soafee.io, t...@soafee.io, Matt Spencer, Stamm, Martin02, Harvey, Luke, Al Stone, m...@soafee.io

    Appreciate the note @ff . At this stage, we are keeping the topic broader to discuss around the workloads and its orchestration. We will rely on the tiger team to share their thoughts / opinions if it makes sense to segregate those in the future.

     

    Apologies for dropping the “orchestration” in my note, will correct it for the kick off invite and add you as well. Hope that helps.  

     

    Regards,

    Girish

     

    Reply all
    Reply to author
    Forward
    0 new messages