Assignment 11-- Q.60 ( Doubt Clarification )

[Chhavi Singhal]

Sir,

I am regarding this Question to Assignment 11-- Q.60

here which 'ihr' are you referring?

Kindly clarify

Danke 🙏   

[NOC24 HS29]

Hello,

Here, "ihr" is used as the dative form of "sie" meaning "her". 

Die Stiefel gefallen ihr nicht. - She did not like the shoes.

Hope this helps.

[Chhavi Singhal]

So Sir,

why the sentence according to he given answers is -- The Shoes pleases her

Sir am I correct?

But Sir, why can't we say like this -- She does not pleased by the shoes ( Die Stiefel gefallen Sie nicht )

Kindly Clarify 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

Vielen Danke

Deine Deutsch A1 Kurz Student

[NOC24 HS29]

The sentence is "Die Stiefel gefallen ihr nicht." which means "She does not like the shoes." and not "The shoe pleases her."

We cannot use sie (as she) because the verb "gefallen" always requires Dativ form. And the Dativ form of "sie" (she) is "ihr".

Hope this helps.

[Chhavi Singhal]

can you plz provide the table of dative, akkusativ and naminativ for

ich,

du,

er/sie/es,

wir,

ihr,

sie, Sie

Vielen danke🙏🙏

[NOC24 HS29]

Here:

You can refer to https://easy-deutsch.com/german-pronouns/personalpronomen/ for this table.