For many years we have followed the same process where we file a bug for each failure where the summary is the exact error message (a few exceptions).
This results in a many:one relationship between bugs and testcases as testcases can fail for different reasons.
This current process makes it harder to:
1) understand how often the test case is really failing (which indicates noise or need for attention)
2) automatically annotate known failures (sheriffs/try pushes/etc.)
The change we will be implementing is to have a single meta bug for each test case (file in mozilla-central). An example is:
If there is an investigation to fix the testcase or disable it on a given platform, then we can create a blocking bug on our meta bug for tracking purposes.
We will start off small, here are the restrictions we will use:
1) only test failures, not crashes || timeouts || leaks || infra
2) only for xpcshell
The plan is to roll this out (in the next 2 weeks) and monitor it for a few weeks before expanding to other test suites.
Feel free to ask questions in Matrix: #test (firefox-testing).