Twelve Days of Thanks and Giving | Day 6
Susanne Jul
On the sixth day of Thanks and Giving, we give to you … six steps of the U.S. federal disaster assistance process.
In our last two posts, we talked about where and how to find help after a disaster. Today, we offer a glimpse into why disaster assistance is a complex matter. We look under the hood of the official U.S. federal response to disaster, led by FEMA. We hope this will shed clarity on what needs to happen for federal assistance to be distributed to disaster survivors.
We
describe the official U.S. federal response process in six steps,
drawing heavily on Unit 3 of A Citizen’s Guide to Disaster
Assistance (Emergency
Management Institute. Independent Study IS-7, 2003).
The philosophy underlying federal assistance is that community and local government drive the relief effort:
The responsibility of preparing for
disaster recovery begins with the individual and builds to the larger
responsibility of the community and local government. The local
government has the primary role of planning and managing all aspects of
the community’s recovery. Community planning efforts are supported by
voluntary, faith-based and community organizations; private sector; and
State, Local, Tribal, Territorial and Federal Governments.
— National Disaster Recovery Framework
Brochure
The federal government can bring far greater resources to an incident than a local government. But it cannot bear the brunt of all disasters, especially as the impact of disasters continues to grow. Neither can the federal government know the necessary details of every stricken neighborhood to determine who needs what, when. Therefore, the federal government requires local governments to share the cost of a disaster, and consults with local agencies to resolve last mile issues,
State, local, tribal and
territorial government officials are primarily responsible for managing disaster
recovery in their communities.
— Recovery Resources | FEMA.gov (our emphasis)
Federal assistance is available to supplement the
resources of State, local, and voluntary agencies in major disasters.
— A Citizen’s Guide to Disaster
Assistance, p. 3-1 (our emphasis)
Once approved, FEMA uses a series of official frameworks to direct their actions, including,
The National Response Framework
(NRF) is a guide to
how the nation responds to all types of disasters and emergencies. It
is built on scalable, flexible, and adaptable concepts ... to align key
roles and responsibilities.
— National
Response Framework
The National Disaster Recovery
Framework (NDRF) enables
effective recovery support to disaster-impacted states, tribes,
territorial and local jurisdictions.
— National Disaster Recovery Framework
This post walks through how these frameworks are activated.
Preparation and time are critical when responding to a disaster. State and federal officials may begin their response even before the disaster occurs:
In predictable disasters, such as
hurricanes, [Advanced Emergency Response Teams (ERT-A)] may be sent into
the area before the storm strikes to set up emergency communications
equipment and help coordinate early response efforts. An important role
of the ERT-A is to obtain information on the impact of the event and
identify the types of short and long-term assistance that may be needed.
— A Citizen’s Guide to Disaster
Assistance
When the risk is high enough, the President may declare a State of Emergency in advance, as President Biden did for Florida four days in advance of Hurricane Ian’s landfall.
From the beginning, FEMA will work with state, local, nonprofit and private sector partners to provide relief. For instance,
Nearly a week before its first U.S. landfall ... the American Red Cross mobilized more than 100 trucks loaded with tens of thousands of relief supplies, dozens of emergency response vehicles and hundreds of disaster responders to be ready to support families in the path of Hurricane Ian.
As the storm approached the coast,
some 2.5 million Floridians were asked to evacuate and the Red Cross
worked closely with our partners to support more than 200 evacuation
centers.
— Hurricane Ian Relief Information |
Red Cross
Unfortunately,
tsunamis, earthquakes, and other less predictable disasters do not
offer much warning, leading to delays before help can arrive.
Local authorities request state help when local resources aren’t enough. State authorities request federal help when state resources aren’t enough. For example,
… local officials declared a State
of Emergency, acting in accordance with the local emergency operations
plan. As the flood waters rose and spread and essential buildings
suffered major damage, local officials determined that they did not have
adequate resources to respond effectively … and asked the State for
assistance. To support their request, local officials described the
extent and types of damage caused by the flood. They asked for specific
kinds of assistance, including help in evacuating persons from affected
areas and in keeping people from entering unsafe highways or other
restricted areas.
— A Citizen’s Guide to Disaster
Assistance, p. 3-5
If
the state agrees to the local request for assistance, the state
governor will declare a State of Emergency, thereby releasing state
resources.
If the State concludes that effective response needs may exceed both the State’s resources and those of the community, then the State can request that FEMA regional officials join them in conducting preliminary damage assessments (PDAs). Based on the PDA, the governor decides whether to request federal aid.
The request must include specific
information required by law, including the nature and amount of local
and State resources that have been or will be committed to
disaster-related work. The request must also guarantee that the
cost-sharing provisions of the Stafford Act will be met.
— A Citizen’s Guide to Disaster
Assistance, p. 3-9
The above request process may seem lengthy. However,
In general, the larger and more
severe the disaster, the less information is needed initially to support
the request. A smaller or less obvious situation requires a greater
amount of information to verify that Federal assistance is needed. An
aerial survey conducted by FEMA and State officials might be enough to
demonstrate the need for Federal help, although damage assessments would
continue after the declaration to help manage response and recovery
measures.
— A Citizen’s Guide to Disaster
Assistance, p. 3-9.
Moreover, state and federal authorities do not just sit around and await a phone call:
Typically, when a disaster as
serious as that in the [flood] scenario occurs, it is apparent from an
early stage that not only State but also Federal assistance may be
needed. State and FEMA officials would continually monitor the progress
of the incident.
— A Citizen’s Guide to Disaster
Assistance, p. 3-5
Thus, FEMA’s regional teams will be communicating with state and local authorities to assure a fast response as soon as it is determined that federal assistance is needed. As we saw above, for big enough disasters, FEMA may have the necessary Declaration of a State of Emergency that authorizes action before the event even happens.
Representatives
of other response organizations such as nonprofits, local community
organizations, and local businesses are typically included in these
discussions. Most notably is the American Red Cross, which has a unique
congressionally-chartered mandate “to carry out responsibilities
delegated to us by the federal government.”
Step 4. U.S. Presidential Declaration of State of Emergency
Formally, the FEMA Regional Director evaluates the governor’s request for federal assistance and makes a recommendation to the FEMA Director, who then reviews the recommendation, and passes it on to the President.
While this review may take time, it may be foreshortened for larger events, as we saw above. Indeed, in response to Hurricane Ian (2022), President Biden signed an Emergency Declaration for the State of Florida within hours of receiving the request from the Florida governor.
Step 5. Federal Response
FEMA leads the federal effort, but is by no means the only agency involved. Seventeen federal agencies, plus the Red Cross, are listed as primary or support agencies for the fifteen emergency support functions (ESF) of the National Response Framework. These federal agencies along with state agencies and non-governmental organizations have a seat at the table when determining and delivering federal relief:
The Federal, State, private, and
voluntary agency response team relationship is established and fostered
at an initial meeting held as soon as possible after the President’s
declaration. All Federal, State, and voluntary agencies that can provide
some form of disaster assistance are invited to be represented at this
meeting. Initial relief coordination procedures are established,
especially the details of setting up and staffing sites where disaster
victims can apply for assistance. The [Federal Coordinating Officer
(FCO)] and [State Coordinating Officer (SCO)] conduct subsequent
coordination meetings as often as needed to establish priorities and
objectives, identify problems, and document achievements.
— A Citizen’s Guide to Disaster
Assistance, p. 3-13
FEMA's involvement in the response effort is determined by an agreement to which both FEMA and state authorities commit. Much of the agreement is based on the governor's request for assistance,
This agreement describes the period
of the incident (or disaster), the types of assistance to be provided,
the areas eligible for assistance, the agreed-upon cost-share
provisions, and other terms and conditions.
— A Citizen’s Guide to Disaster
Assistance, p. 3-11
- Assistance for individuals and businesses
- Assistance
for repairing or replacing essential public systems and facilities
- Assistance
for hazard mitigation to prevent or reduce future risk of the disaster
Step 6. Long-term Recovery
Many disaster assistance organizations, such as the Red Cross, only provide disaster response assistance. These are actions carried out immediately, to save lives, reduce economic losses, and alleviate suffering. However, people are in crisis long after the flood waters recede or the wildfire burns out. Homes may need to be repaired and communities rebuilt.
FEMA is in it for the long haul, helping individuals and communities for the full disaster recovery period:
The National Disaster Recovery Framework (NDRF) enables effective recovery support to disaster-impacted states, tribes, territorial and local jurisdictions. ... The NDRF focuses on how best to restore, redevelop and revitalize the health, social, economic, natural and environmental fabric of the community and build a more resilient nation.
— National Disaster Recovery Framework | FEMA.gov
The federal disaster response process may not be perfect, but consider all that has to happen for a well-considered response to happen. The description above is a tremendously simplified story – much, much more is going on than we have time here to describe. However, we hope this glimpse under the hood of the official U.S. federal response to disaster sheds some clarity on the process of getting federal aid to where it is needed.
So, once the earthquake has subsided, the wildfire is contained, or the tsunami has receded, know that a vast and complex response engine with many moving parts is working to help you. However, it might take time. So, be prepared to be proactive, work with your community, and do what you can to help yourself and those around you.support our work.
We thank you for all that you give.