Re: Request for Review: GSOC Proposal on Debug WebUI For Tabstrip states (Medium Size)

[Darryl James]

Hello! 

Shibalik and I took a quick look over your proposal and things are looking very good!

We left some small comments to improve the design a tiny bit but overall this is a solid proposal!

Let us know if you have any questions.

Thank you!

On Thu, Mar 27, 2025 at 11:25 AM Koushik <koushi...@gmail.com> wrote:

Respected Mentors,

I hope you're doing well. I have been working on my GSOC proposal for Debug WebUI For Tabstrip states, and I would love to get your feedback before the submission deadline. I have structured my proposal carefully, ensuring that it aligns with the project’s objectives and follows Chromium’s best practices.
Could you kindly review it and share your thoughts? I want to make sure that my approach, deliverables, and timeline are well-structured and realistic. Any suggestions for improvement would be greatly appreciated.

Here is the link to my proposal: Proposal Link
Feel free to comment/suggest.
Looking forward to your feedback. Thank you for your time and guidance !

Regards,
Koushik

[Koushik]

[Koushik]

Thank You So Much for your Feedback. It indeed helped me a lot.
I have made all the required changes you suggested and also added some more things.

Also, please guide me if I need to add anything overall in the proposal to qualify GSOC requirements.

Please do have a look.
Proposal Link.

Thanks and Regards

Koushik Kumar Bug

[Darryl James]

Hello! Overall looks good, I left one more comment regarding the session state representation. Let me know if you have any questions!

Thanks!

[Koushik]

Thank you mentors for your time and support.

I have made all the changes as required, and also added some more points.

It would be very kind on both of your part, if you take a look and guide. 

Also, I would like to know, is the deliverable section good enough to meet GSOC requirements ?

Here's the proposal link.

Thanks & Regards

Koushik

[Darryl James]

Hello!

We are getting around to responding to your proposal now. Overall all looks good.

The deliverable section is perfect! We won't focus too much on that since we know timelines can change quite a bit so a rough outline is all we ask.

[Koushik]

Thank You all for your extensive guidance and support. 

I have submitted my final proposal in the portal.

Thanks Again.

Regards,

Koushik

[Koushik]

Respected Mentors, 

Pardon me. I am extremely sorry for disturbing you at the last minute. Actually, an idea to include a comprehensive test for the debug ui stumbled

upon me lately, especially after reflecting on our earlier discussion regarding the need for browser tests for the WebUI TabStrip theme change fix.

I have added the new changes under "Alternatives Considered" Section.

Request you to please have a look.

Thank you for your time and consideration.

Proposal Link

Regards,

Koushik

[Darryl James]

Thanks for the heads up! I think it's always good to list some alternatives you may have come up with.

Overall this proposal looks really good, I wouldn't change it too much before submitting the final version.

Thanks!

[Koushik]

Hi Darryl and Shibalik,

I hope you're doing well.

I applied for GSoC 2025 for webUI Tabstrip proposal, and while I wasn’t selected, I really appreciated the opportunity to contribute to Chromium and engage with the community, as this was my first open source contribution.

I’d be very grateful if you could share any feedback on my proposal or areas where I could have improved. Understanding this would really help me grow and better prepare for future open-source programs.

I also want to thank both of you for your guidance during the application period. I’m still interested in contributing to Chromium and would love to stay involved in the project, GSoC or not.

Warm regards,
Koushik Kumar Bug
+91-7047274427
[Linked In]
[Proposal Link]

[Sreeja Kamishetty]

Hi Koushik,

Darryl, and Shibalik will say more. 

I looked through your proposal and I thought it was such a detailed written one. I see your effort, your ideas for code design. I would highly encourage you to keep up the good work, opportunities will follow.

It is just that the program is very competitive and being selected or not is not your fault.

Best of luck,

Sreeja

--
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "chromium-gsoc-project10" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to chromium-gsoc-pro...@chromium.org.
To view this discussion visit https://groups.google.com/a/chromium.org/d/msgid/chromium-gsoc-project10/CAK15Jvqwp6dAiPWVLsXvZgjKrQ-M-qkdn6DawWupyeT2fEuoOQ%40mail.gmail.com.

[Darryl James]

Hi Koushik!

I see you have created another email thread with more details, I will respond there instead.

Thanks!