_________________________
Björn Brändewall
Webdesigner/Programmerare
Net-On!
Tel: 0480-49 16 94
Fax: 0480-49 16 72
www.net-on.com
Rätt banner på rätt site.
(Quoted the whole message, to show my point)
I wish Opera would force a legal signature delimeter ('-- \n'), and warn
agains wrongly formatted (80*4 characters) signatures, at least when
posting to nntp. (And when we're at it, I wish Opera had a perfect score
on GNKSA)
--
Frode Gill
>[....] (And when we're at it, I wish Opera had a perfect score
>on GNKSA)
I don't. It's ok if Opera gives a warning when I do something stupid
like posting without a subject line, but it shouldn't make it
impossible to do such stupid things. IMO! GNKSA isn't a standard.
So I don't want a perfect score. But I'd really like Opera to comply
with *most* of the requirements.
References for interested readers:
http://www.xs4all.nl/~js/gnksa/
and
http://www.xs4all.nl/~js/gnksa/Evaluations/opera-3.0b6.txt
--
Rijk van Geijtenbeek - mailto:ri...@iname.com - http://rijk.op.het.net
"But IE3 is almost completely extinct, whereas Netscape 4's undead corpse
still shambles about the earth wreaking a horrific vengeance upon the
living." (Matt McIrvin)
<Cookie 11 of 11>
>On 19 Dec 2000 12:23:30 GMT, frode...@agresso.no (Frode Gill) wrote:
>
>>[....] (And when we're at it, I wish Opera had a perfect score
>>on GNKSA)
>
>I don't. It's ok if Opera gives a warning when I do something stupid
>like posting without a subject line, but it shouldn't make it
>impossible to do such stupid things.
Outlook Express has almost destroyed quite a few norwegian usenet-groups,
and is causeing harm on a general basis, because of all the standard-
violations and all the stupid things it let the users do and post. Can
you give me one good reason for posting without a subject line?
>IMO! GNKSA isn't a standard.
No, it is not a standard. If it was, I would have *demanded* Opera to
follow it ;-)
But GNKSA is a well-defined set of rules, and if all newsreaders followed
them there would be a lot less problems with postings on usenet.
--
Frode Gill
>Rijk van Geijtenbeek <ri...@iname.com> wrote:
>
>>On 19 Dec 2000 12:23:30 GMT, frode...@agresso.no (Frode Gill) wrote:
>>
>>>[....] (And when we're at it, I wish Opera had a perfect score
>>>on GNKSA)
>>
>>I don't. It's ok if Opera gives a warning when I do something stupid
>>like posting without a subject line, but it shouldn't make it
>>impossible to do such stupid things.
>
>Outlook Express has almost destroyed quite a few norwegian usenet-groups,
>and is causeing harm on a general basis, because of all the standard-
>violations and all the stupid things it let the users do and post.
I don't advocate Opera to destroy standards, like OE does with
localized versions. Translating 'Re' for example...
>Can
>you give me one good reason for posting without a subject line?
I think Opera should be configurable to disable most warnings, just
like the 'send insecure form' warning in the browser. The specific
example might not be the best one ;-)
>>... GNKSA isn't a standard.
>
>No, it is not a standard. If it was, I would have *demanded* Opera to
>follow it ;-)
LOL. Time for opera.demandlist ?
>But GNKSA is a well-defined set of rules, and if all newsreaders followed
>them there would be a lot less problems with postings on usenet.
I notice Agent doesn't get a perfect score either. That's not to say
GNKSA-compliance wouldn't help make Opera a better newsreader, just
that apparently a decent newsreader can be made without complying.
>On 20 Dec 2000 09:13:13 GMT, frode...@agresso.no (Frode Gill) wrote:
>
>>But GNKSA is a well-defined set of rules, and if all newsreaders followed
>>them there would be a lot less problems with postings on usenet.
>
>I notice Agent doesn't get a perfect score either. That's not to say
>GNKSA-compliance wouldn't help make Opera a better newsreader, just
>that apparently a decent newsreader can be made without complying.
In fact, in nl.newsreaders (which I left BTW) GNKSA is called I list
of features of the favourite newsreader of the composer of GNKSA. I
looked at their demands and wishes once and I /did/ found them to be
unusual and high-demanding and some even stupid! I don't like that
list of demands, I think every newsreader should have some
configurability and some things it shouldn't do (because of abuse of
newsservers, like excessive cross-posting). But GNKSA isn't the right
list for that. I have yet to see a complete and "correct" list, but
GNKSA certainly is not.
Luc
--
FINAGLE'S FIFTH RULE:
Program results should always be reproducible.
They should all fail in the same way.
I don't think you should count on seing that in the nearest future,
the Opera wishlist is enough as it is:)
--
Ina
Common sense is the most evenly distributed quantity in the world.
Everyone thinks he has enough.
-- Descartes, 1637