RESULT: comp.lang.java.corba passes 650:38
Rebecca McQuitty
RESULT
unmoderated group comp.lang.java.corba passes 650:38
There were 650 YES votes and 38 NO votes, for a total of 688 valid
votes. There were 2 abstains and 12 invalid ballots.
For group passage, YES votes must be at least 2/3 of all valid (YES
and NO) votes. There also must be at least 100 more YES votes than NO
votes.
There is a five day discussion period after these results are posted.
If no serious allegations of voting irregularities are raised, the
moderator of news.announce.newgroups will create the group shortly
thereafter.
Newsgroups line:
comp.lang.java.corba Topics relating to Java and CORBA.
The voting period closed at 23:59:59 UTC, 7 Oct 1997.
This vote was conducted by a neutral third party. Questions about the
proposed group should be directed to the proponents.
Proponent: Jeff Nelson <co...@acm.org>
Proponent: Blake Scholl <bsc...@dialogosweb.com>
Votetaker: Rebecca McQuitty <m...@wco.com>
RATIONALE: comp.lang.java.corba
Since the CORBA (Common Object Request Broker Architecture) standard
was established by the OMG (Object Management Group), it has attracted
much attention in the computer industry at large. More recently, Java
implementations of CORBA technology have become prominent. Sun has
integrated CORBA support into its Java Developer's Kit, and Netscape
has included Java-specific support for CORBA into its web browser.
There are now over 10 different Java-based ORBs, including both
commercial and freeware products, and CORBA support is being
integrated into Java development toolkits. Sun, Netscape, IBM, and
Oracle recently announced plans to integrate Java more closely with
CORBA through the JavaBeans architecture. Sun also announced that RMI
would be implemented with support for IIOP to make RMI interoperable
with CORBA-based distributed object tools.
All these public attention has sparked increased discussion of Java
and CORBA. General CORBA mailing lists such as CORBA-dev,
dist-object, IDL-users, and ILU frequently carry discussions of Java
issues. The OMG also maintains mailing lists about Java and CORBA,
but they are available only to OMG members. The Java Developer's
Journal has a monthly column called "CORBAcorner," and recently
several best-selling books have been published on this topic, such as
Orfali's "Client/Server Programming with Java and CORBA."
In addition, there are many posts in comp.object.corba and in the
comp.lang.java hierarchy regarding Java-CORBA issues. Since there is
no CORBA specific Java newsgroup, many users are unsure about the best
place to post their messages about Java and CORBA; this frequently
results in problems with cross-posting. Comp.lang.java.corba would
create a clear forum for the discussion of topics related both to Java
and to CORBA.
CHARTER: comp.lang.java.corba
This unmoderated group is for aspects of Java technology that are
related to CORBA software development, products, and standards.
Possible discussion topics include:
* Questions about Java and CORBA
* Announcements of new products and services
* General Programming issues in Java and CORBA
* Design patterns related to Java/CORBA
* Discussion of OMG standards related to Java
* Recommendations and reviews of products, services, books and
tutorials
* Comparisons to other technologies
END CHARTER.
comp.lang.java.corba Final Vote Ack
Voted Yes
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
@plasma.novell.com:bi...@novell.com
a.br...@trendsoft.nl Arjen Brienen
acl...@ford.com Alan L. Clark
adha...@collins.rockwell.com Anita Hansen
Adrian_Piets/Legacy_T...@legacytech.com Adrian Piets
AFis...@heyde.de Fischer Andreas
ah...@remus.cs.uml.edu Andrew Hall
ahar...@opentext.com Andrew Harbick
ahar...@insweb.com Alan Harriman
ah...@austin.asc.slb.com Shamim Ahmed
ahy...@ny.ubs.com Aldon Hynes
ajeann...@hotmail.com Alex Jeannopoulos
al...@blackwhite.com Alexander Kotopoulis
a...@linus.mitre.org Alice Schafer
amdraht!m...@DasBuro.Com Markus Freericks
ami...@earthling.net Azhar Mirza
a...@sequent.com Ann Willingham
an...@visigenic.com Anant Khanolkar
ana...@best.com Anantha Kasetty
Andrew....@cs.cf.ac.uk Andrew Jones
Andrew...@barclays.co.uk Andrew Price
and...@omg.org Andrew Watson
and...@sybase.com Andrew Eisenberg
andy.l...@msx.qatraining.com Andy Longshaw
an...@dra.com Andy Marchewka
an...@iris.sei.irk.ru Andrei R. Yershov
an...@hplb.hpl.hp.com Andy Norman
ang...@cris.com Cleo Kiernan
a...@indcomp.com Andre' Hazelwood
arne...@oslo.geco-prakla.slb.com Truls Arnegaard
a...@island.de Andre Schmidt
asch...@informatik.th-darmstadt.de Gerd Aschemann
askul...@hotmail.com Atul S Kulkarni
av...@best.com AvantSoft, Inc.
a...@parcplace.com Anh Thu A. N. Vo
avo...@visigenic.com Andreas Vogel
awa...@meta.dublin.iona.ie Andreas Walsh
ba...@ERASETHISinterlog.com Brad Aisa
ban...@objs.com Tom Bannon
bari...@to.sligos.it Maurizio Barioglio
Barry.C...@durham.ac.uk Barry Cornelius
ba...@NifcoSynergy.COM Barry Donovan
bart...@best.com Stephen Bartlett
bay...@fmi.uni-passau.de Thomas Bayer
beli...@fandago.read.tasc.com Bryan E. Lilius
bezn...@baptisthealth.net Konstantin Beznosov
bfor...@fame.com Brian Forester
bfr...@u.washington.edu B Robert Franza MD
b...@broadcom.ie James Cooley
Bharat...@liffe.com Bharat Bedia
bha...@iona.com Brian Hayes
bh...@pacbell.net Bjxrn Halvor Solberg
bial...@ix.netcom.com K. Scott Bialousz
BI...@novell.com Bill Griffeth
bke...@sema4usa.com Brian Keane
bke...@iona.com Brian Kelly
bmag...@dialogosweb.com Magella, Barbara] Barbara Magella
bmo...@camtech.net.au Brian Lionel Modra
b...@lanl.gov Bob Tomlinson
b...@lent.com Bob Lent
bobp...@lucent.com Bob Parry
bou...@daimi.aau.dk Niels Olof Bouvin
brad.s...@nsc.com Brad Schmidt
br...@dstc.edu.au bradley schatz
br...@pagesz.net Jeff Brandenburg
br...@concentus-tech.com Bruce Reed Jr.
Brian...@cl.cam.ac.uk Brian Cowe
br...@cadlips.ece.utexas.edu Brian McGiverin
bri...@adelphia.net Jay Brinton
br...@inf.fu-berlin.de Gerald Brose
Brun...@Stud-Mailer.Uni-Marburg.DE Daniel Brunner
Bryce....@nike.com Bryce P. Gemmill
bsc...@globalwave.com Blake Scholl
BS...@tribune.com Bob Serr
buf...@cs.uml.edu John Buford
but...@cs.byu.edu Kevin J. Butler
C.Dub...@hgu.mrc.ac.uk Christophe Dubreuil
c.mit...@unikix.com Calum Mitchell
cap...@cppm.in2p3.fr Mihai CAPRINI
car...@siggraph.org Steve Carson
cden...@ibm.net Craig Denison
c...@zurich.ibm.com Christian Facciorusso
cha...@imailbox.com Chad Hamann
ch...@algorithmics.com Jorge Chang
ch...@visigenic.com Chaz Ubell
che...@hotmail.com CHETHAN Y GORUR
c...@io.freinet.de Christian Helfrich
chig...@meta.dublin.iona.ie Colum Higgins
Chris...@fcit.monash.edu.au Christopher Exton
chris....@born.com Christopher J. Johnson
ch...@drake.bt.co.uk Chris Smith
ch...@rosette.com Christine Tomlinson</TT>
christoph...@ficsgrp.com Christophe WARLAND
chr...@www.eidea.com Christy L. Hermansen
cka...@de.lhsgroup.com Carsten Kaiser
cke...@paragon-software.com Craig Kelley
clark...@gartner.com Clark Evans
cli...@ix.netcom.com Clifford Thompson
cmcm...@teknowledge.com Chris McMahan
cmu...@netexplorer.com Christopher Murphy
co...@lumos.com Conor Dowling
core...@iona.com Caroline O'Reilly
co...@acm.org Court Demas
cra...@dstc.edu.au Stephen Crawley
c...@mitre.org W. Craig Trader
cu...@cadence.com Simon J. Curry
Curtis...@nike.com Curtis White
D.R.St...@nortel.co.uk Dave Stringer
DAn...@GW.NOVELL.COM Dan Andrus
da...@ica.net Dan Enache
dan...@sky.net Danny Porter
dan...@rsv.se Daniel Sundman
Dan_Gaines/Legacy_T...@legacytech.com Daniel Gaines
Darren_Hayduk/Legacy_T...@legacytech.com Darren Hayduk
da...@HealthMagic.com Dave K. Kythe
david....@dsto.defence.gov.au david bingham
david....@sherpa.com David Cameron
da...@cpg.it David Greco
dav...@dalim.com david Goujard
david_m...@sterling.com David R. Marshall
David_Oppenheim/CAM/Lo...@lotus.com david a oppenheim
dba...@bbn.com Dave Bakken
dbo...@caip.rutgers.edu Bogdan DOROHONCEANU
DBu...@us.lhsgroup.com Dave Busse
DCli...@dialogosweb.com Drew Clifton
dcl...@idt.net David Clunie
Dean.S...@dial.pipex.com Dean Sheehan
de...@gallant.com Dean Jones
Deepa...@siemenscom.com Goel, Deepak
depr...@mindspring.com Mike DePriest
d...@novell.com David Rorke
der...@ibm.net Derek A. Edwards
de...@iona.com Des Carbery
df...@agccss.lmco.com Daniel Jay Fox
di...@shellus.com Hieu Dinh
Dirk.F...@watershed.com Dirk P. Fromhein
di...@iona.com Dirk Marwinski
djo...@cs.auckland.ac.nz Daniel Johns
dk...@bbn.com David A. Karr
dk...@nmo.gtegsc.com David M. Karr
dlevitt...@ibm.net David Levitt
dlm...@literacypro.com David Mitchell
dlo...@gensym.com Doug Loyer
dlu...@checkfree.com David D. Lucas
d...@abasoft.co.uk David Byrne
donal...@cunav.com Donal Tobin
donk...@computer.org Don Kiely
don...@ix.netcom.com Donald Moe
dpr...@primenet.com Daniel Pritchard
dr...@milner.com David Reeg
dr...@worldmachine.com Dave Rees
dric...@shellus.com David C. Richoux
DSei...@dialogosweb.com David Seibert
dsn...@netgenics.com David Snyder
dstruct01!g8u...@uunet.uu.net Jay Tang
dta...@uswest.com David C. Tauzell
d...@dstc.edu.au Keith Duddy
duja...@chorus.fr Eric Dujardin
d...@lanl.gov David W. Forslund
eam...@QUALCOMM.Com Eamonn Coleman
edd...@bellsouth.net Eddie Hernandez
Edgardo...@aar.alcatel-alsthom.fr Edgar Montes de Oca
edward....@ab.com Ed Korsberg
eed...@eed.ericsson.se Walter Schusseng
efeu...@ida.org Edward A. Feustel
ehs...@ehs.ericsson.se Thomas Wolmer
ei...@worldonline.nl Erik van Elsas
elb...@regfs.sbi.com Igor Elbert
er...@baptisthealth.net Eric Butler
er...@baptisthealth.net Eric Navarro
er...@pandasys.com Eric A. Snell
erzb...@softwired.ch Martin Erzberger
etx...@aom.ericsson.se Stefan Eberg
eut...@siam.muc.de Ekkehard Uthke
ev...@arlut.utexas.edu Eric Evans
ew...@opensesame.com Eddy Wong
far...@bellcore.com Robert Farrell
fbo...@meta.dublin.iona.ie Fintan M. Bolton
f...@Mcs.Net Fred Yankowski
ferw...@beasys.com Paul Ferwerda
fic...@mpi.com David Ficenec
filip.o...@ficsgrp.com Filip Onkelinx
Floren...@cert.fr Florent Bouix
fm-li...@mediatrix.com Francois Menard
Francis...@barco.com Francis Labaere
fra...@caip.rutgers.edu Cristian FRANCU
Frank.Gru...@Inf-Technik.TU-Ilmenau.DE Frank Grueztmacher
frans_van_duinen@NO_SPAM_myna.com Frans van Duinen
fr...@kipling.se Daniel Fritz
f...@di.uminho.pt Francisco Coelho Soares de Moura
ga...@vuse.vanderbilt.edu Gabor Karsai
gan...@lgcit.com Vladimir Ulogov
ga...@visix.com Gary W. Keim
gbu...@corp.borland.com Geoff Bullen
gco...@OutBackInc.com Garrett Conaty
geo...@RealTimeIntegration.com George Sievers
gfi...@aeq.com Gary Fidler
ggio...@xl.com Geoff Giordano
ggla...@ssax.com Gene A. Glaudell
g...@io.freinet.de Gero Hoffmann
gha...@agfawest.com Girish T. Hagan
ghag...@hisd.harris.com George W. Hageman
g...@objs.com Gilbert Hansen
glen.c...@dsto.defence.gov.au Glen Coomber
gl...@avestatech.com Andy Glick
gls...@mitre.org Gary L Smith
gm...@bah.com Gregory A. Mack
gp...@de.ibm.com Gerhard Pfau
gra...@lhr-sys.DHL.COM Gerry Rankin
gran...@lifl.fr Christophe_Gransart
gutk...@lirmm.fr Olivier Gutknecht
gwda...@cca.rockwell.com Gary Wayne Daugherty
gze...@de.ibm.com Gudrun Zeller
g_cl...@roam.agfa.be Geert Claeys
han...@computer.org Hann Wei Toh
Hans.Bj...@uab.ericsson.se Hans Bjurstrom
harsha.c...@fmr.com Harsha Chaturvedi
har...@mitre.org Daniel Harter
ha...@smart.net Peter Haupt
hay...@neuron.datanetix.com Clive Hayward
haze...@doit.wisc.edu Keith Hazelton
hhec...@mgm-edv.de Hannes Heckner
h...@zurich.ibm.com Heiko Ludwig
hn...@cca.rockwell.com Hai Le
hoe...@fokus.gmd.de Petra Hoepner
ho...@fokus.gmd.de Michael Hopp
hop...@zetnet.co.uk David Hopwood
hro...@resumix.com Howard Rosen
HRSO...@wpmail.code3.com Harold Solbrig
hsa...@marnie.teuto.de Henning Sauer
HSHA...@us.oracle.com Hisham Shahtout
Ian.Ma...@mel.dit.csiro.au Ian Mathieson
ifu...@windwardsolutions.com Ian Fuller
i...@cie.fr VOGEL Regis
inga...@joda.cis.temple.edu Giorgio P. Ingargiola
IOt...@de.lhsgroup.com Otter Ingomar
iscl...@leonis.nus.sg Boon Peng, Lee
is...@visi.net Ivan S Kirkpatrick
ismo....@sampo.fi Ismo Puntti
j.le...@g3s.fr Jean LECANTE
j4...@midway.uchicago.edu Mary-Frances Jagod
Jacob.M...@cdc.com Jacob Morrison
jacon...@fau.campus.mci.net Jose Contreras
ja...@ENGR.ORST.EDU Lalit Kumar Jain
ja...@netins.net R. "Jake" Jakoubek
jal...@us.ibm.com John William Alcorn
ja...@enduring.com James Hale
ja...@rsd.dl.nec.com James Halbert
janne.ra...@innomat.com Janne Raitaniemi
jas...@gate.net nbsp; Jesse W. Asher
jason.h....@ac.com jason.h.erickson
JB0...@aol.com John Richards
jbir...@meta.dublin.iona.ie Jeremy Birrell
j...@levin.mv.com J. B. Levin
jcwil...@dialogosweb.com Joe Williams
jdas...@power2000.com John DaSilva
jdav...@teknowledge.com James Davidson
jdec...@juno.com John DeCarlo
jd...@jdege.visi.com Jeffrey C. Dege
je...@blackwhite.com Jeff Wasel
Jeff_...@vnet.ibm.com Jeff Miller
jenn...@igs.com Jeff Jennings
jens.s...@sap-ag.de Jens Steckhan
jer...@us.ibm.com John Jernigan
Jerold....@pilot.dcsi.axa.com Jerold Paulson
jerry_fe...@merck.com Jerry Ferentinos
je...@intercable.net Jesus Eugenio Sanchez
jg...@gmv.es Juan Carlos Gil Montoro
jha...@netscape.com John Harby
JHendr...@harland.net John R. Hendrickson
JHer...@dialogosweb.com Joe Herbers
j...@mitre.org John James
jim.a...@geac.com Jim Ancona
Jim.Fe...@MCI.Com James L Ferrigan
j...@fpk.hp.com Jishnu Mukerji
jit...@hotmail.com Jitendra Banthia.
jke...@iona.com John Keyes
jk...@ix.netcom.com Jim Killian
jkl...@capecod.net J.C. Klimm
jlu...@ford.com John M. Lukacs
jma...@concept5.com John Marsh
jmat...@gendev.com Jason R. Matthews
j...@xedoc.com James Matthew Pryor
jmul...@ozonline.com.au James Mullens
j...@tommy.demon.co.uk John Nissen
jne...@dialogosweb.com Jeffrey James Nelson
j...@millar.mv.com Joseph Millar
Joe_Tu...@chordiant.com Joe Tumminaro
John_Wie...@chordiant.com John A. Wiesendanger
jol...@meta.dublin.iona.ie Jim O'Leary
Jon.D...@mel.dit.csiro.au Jon Dell'Oro
j...@dikas.no Jon Marthins
j...@yieldbook.com j...@yieldbook.com
jo...@mealpha.engr.uaf.edu Jonah Lee
jo...@ugcs.caltech.edu Jonathan Aldrich
jonathan...@sybase.com Jonathan Stockley
Jonathan_...@mc.xerox.com Jonathan A. Goldstein
Jose.Lovo...@asu.edu Jose Lovo-Parrales
jr...@cris.com John R. Aldrin
jsho...@novell.com Jonathan Shopiro
jsqu...@iriscorp.com Jeffrey Dennis Squires
j...@dit.upm.es Joaquin Salvachua
jst...@america.net Jeff Stone
jth...@str.com Jeff Thomas
jtu...@ac.upc.es Pep Turro
jul...@fwb.gulf.net Jules Dubois
jul...@intelligentwave.com Julian Coombes
Julien.Ma...@aar.alcatel-alsthom.fr Julien Maisonneuve
ju...@xs4all.nl Just van den Broecke
jus...@lanl.gov Justin Doak
j...@mitre.org Jonathan Doughty
kan...@moncol.monmouth.edu Raman Kannan
ka...@avedal.se Karl Avedal
Karsten...@East.Sun.COM Karsten Riemer
k...@adcon.com Catalin Bratu
ka...@navd.alcatel.de Martin Kaul
k...@servodata.co.at Klemens Dickbauer
ke...@luey.redars.ca.boeing.com Steven R Keech
kent....@bst.bls.com Kent Holden
Kevin....@UK.Sun.COM Kevin Conner
ke...@netexplorer.com Kevin Sherwood
kev...@crt.com Kevin E. Dooley
kg...@asu.edu Kevin A. Gary
kie...@arsnova.com Klaus Kiehne
ki...@best.com Kim DeVaughn
ki...@riddler.com Kirk Woerner
kis...@ics.com Kishan Mallur
kjon...@notes.cc.bellcore.com Kanth Jonnalagadda
klaus...@mch.sni.de Klaus Schob
k...@glasser-whitley.co.uk John Whitley
k...@nlm.nih.gov Kevin L. Scott
kowa...@iglou.com Dennis Kowallek
kr...@tu-harburg.de Detlef Kreuz
KRhei...@t-online.de Klaus Rheinwald
krie...@informatik.uni-hamburg.de Ralf Kriebisch
kr...@ess.mc.xerox.com Kris Schneider
kr...@cgi.com Kevin M. Krom
KSwe...@netscape.com Keith Swenson
kurt.g...@usa.net Kurt Guenther
kurt.k...@lucent.com Kurt Kanaskie
kwin...@ford.com Ken Winters
kys...@nichols.com Jeff Kyser
la...@gamespot.com Larry Edelstein
lar...@ucsd.edu Larry Riedel
lawrence....@dfrc.nasa.gov Larry Freudinger
lde...@spnc-us.com Luc DELFAU
le...@us.ibm.com Leo Uzcategui
Lesli...@dsto.defence.gov.au Leslie Toh
lfsa...@microsoft.com Luiz Fernando Santos
lie...@ilog.com Lieber Matthieu
lin...@positive.Eng.Sun.COM Peter van der Linden
Lionel.S...@cnam.fr Lionel Seinturier
list-...@dream.hb.north.de Martin Schr"oder
lno...@ford.com Louis Novak
loe...@dialogosweb.com Lori Oehler
louis.b...@metaphasetech.com Louis E. Boydstun
ls...@worldnet.att.net Lloyd Eric Sher
M.A.B...@sms.ed.ac.uk Mark Brown
M.C.L...@newcastle.ac.uk Mark Little
m.c...@ns.sympatico.ca Michael Clase
m.pa...@sul.com.br MARCO ANTONIO PALUDO
m...@firefly.net John E. McNulty
mah...@paragon-software.com B.G. Mahesh
ma...@india.aspectdv.com K.R.Manjunath [Your Vote] =20
mans...@ssax.com Tung Mansfield
mar...@shellus.com Marcelo Gallardo
marco...@sap-ag.de Marco Ertel
mari...@best.com Mark A. Norris
mario....@ubs.com Mario Zannone
Mario...@hboc.com Marion Reed
ma...@roguewave.com Mark Chance
Ma...@pswtech.com Mark Kuharich
ma...@bacg.com Mark Payne
mar...@Exabyte.COM Mark J. Stang
mar...@t-mi.com Mark Wimpory
mark_s...@autosoft.com Mark Scoville
mar...@caip.rutgers.edu Ivan Marsic
mart...@cadlab.it Alex Martelli
Matt....@Radiology.MSU.edu Matthew G Potter
ma...@cac.washington.edu Matthew Freedman
matthew....@dsto.defence.gov.au Matthew Phillips
ma...@dns.praksis.it Mauro Zanzi
Max.J...@liffe.com Max Johnson
mba...@drake.bt.co.uk Mark Bagley
mba...@nortel.ca Mark Baker
mcfa...@dstc.edu.au Ted McFadden
mco...@dnrc.bell-labs.com Mauricio Cortes
mcph...@lanl.gov Allen McPherson
mcund...@mmm.com Maros Cunderlik
md...@plexsys.com Michael Scheer
MEH...@mail.dec.com Damian Mehers
m...@aurora.jhuapl.edu Mark Kinzie
me...@lifl.fr Philippe Merle
me...@informatik.uni-hamburg.de Michael Merz
m...@llnl.gov Mark Spruiell
MEt...@Sema4USA.Com Michael Etkind
mfr...@ibm.net Michael Friess
mgm...@iname.com Michael G. Mlynarczyk
MGR...@RoseVC.Rose-Hulman.Edu Jason Carlyle
mgu...@sema-taa.fr Michel Guyot
mha...@infinet-software.com Michael R Harris
mher...@lhpca.univ-lyon1.fr Marc Herbert
mhi...@i-kinetics.com Michael J. Higgs
mho...@iona.com Michael Hogan
mhol...@dialogosweb.com Holmback, Monica] Monica Holmback
m...@mft.co.uk Mark H. Wilkinson
mic...@santix.de Michael G. Binz
michael...@sherpa.com Michael Kakalec
mic...@kanji.com Michael Babcock
Michael...@BayNetworks.COM Michael Brutman
michel...@cnet.francetelecom.fr Michel MILHAU
mi...@DRI.cornell.edu Mike Cavanaugh
mi...@dstc.edu.au Michael Gray
mike...@firefly.net Michael A. Toth
mi...@motor.ru Dmitriy Degtiareff
mjhi...@trcinc.com Michael Hittesdorf
m...@sky.net Mike Coleman
m...@ooc.com Marc Laukien
mle...@str.com Michael W. Lewis
m...@zip.com.au Matthew Hannigan
mlie...@cisco.com Mindy Lieberman
mmar...@cscs.ch Marcello Marchesoli
moh...@lucent.com Piroz Mohseni
morris...@datacraft.com.au Morris Rashad
mpra...@progress.com Mayank Prakash
mram...@redwood.fr Rambert Marc
mso...@mistik.express.net Mustafa Soysal MS57
muma...@qualcomm.com Senthilkumar Sundaram
mver...@gunpowder.mit.edu Matthew D. Verminski
mwa...@iriscorp.com Matthew H. Wagner
mwwa...@uiuc.edu Michael W. Walker
my...@andrew.cmu.edu Min-Yu Yang
mz...@cast.msstate.edu Ming Zhou
mzim...@worldchat.com Milan Zimmermann
N.E.Noo...@research.kpn.com N.E. Noorlander
na...@firefly.net Nancy Benovich Gilby
Naveen...@Corp.Sun.COM Naveen Kumar
ned...@gate.net Charles E. Bush
ne...@shore.net Neil Berkman
n...@it.uq.edu.au Nic Williams
ni...@cimio.co.uk Nick Waterman - Long Ballot Hater
ni...@dstc.edu.au Nigel Ward
nira...@nms.fnc.fujitsu.com Niranjan Tripathy
nka...@mda.ca Nina Katic
Noell...@irisa.fr Noklle Adam
Norbert.W...@do.isst.fhg.de Norbert Weissenberg
npe...@mcc.com Nancy Perry
NR...@nexus-informatics.de Norbert Rapp
nsc...@tell.ascom.ch Benjamin Schlup
nsm...@iona.com Niall Smart
o...@cediti.be Olivier DECLERFAYT
Olivier....@aar.alcatel-alsthom.fr Olivier Potonniee
op...@dimensional.com Roger M. Opperman
orio...@iona.com David O'Riordan
Oscar....@trcinc.com Oscar A. Chappel
os...@fokus.gmd.de Thomas Karl Osten
osv...@visionnaire.com.br Osvaldo Pinali Doederlein
ot...@tortola.acunet.net Otis Gospodnetic
pascal...@ficsgrp.com Pascal Bouvry
pasi.s...@profithome.com Pasi Salminen
p...@expersoft.com J. Patrick Ravenel
pat...@visigenic.com patrick nouhra
Paul....@bglobal.com Paul Ananth
paul....@alcatel.com.au Paul Nader
pau...@w3com.com Paul Ho
Paul_K...@chordiant.com Paul Kendall
pa...@inorth.on.ca Trevor Tymchuk
permjee...@x400.icl.co.uk Permjeet Pandha
pe...@praxis.co.uk Peter Ferne
"Peter Forsberg"@raleigh.ibm.com Peter Forsberg
Peter....@Eng.Sun.COM Peter B. Kessler
pe...@santix.de Peter Chatchaturian
pet...@frac.iona.com.au Peter Krantz
pete...@ti.com Bob Peterson
petri.r...@tele.fi Petri Riipinen
pfer...@gte.net Pete Ferzoco
phe...@ssax.com Peter Herzum
ph...@pjbsware.demon.co.uk Philip Baker
philip...@ficsgrp.com Philippe Hubo
pkal...@esp.bellcore.com Kalpesh K Patel
plope...@epm.br Paulo Roberto de Lima Lopes
pol...@crpcu.lu Michel Poleur
po...@qds.com Alan L. Pope
po...@dstc.qut.edu.au Dean Povey
p...@quebec.rdd.lmsc.lockheed.com Charles Pow
p...@vossnet.co.uk Philip Preston
pranab....@boeing.com B>Pranab K. Baruah</B>
pre...@ifi.unibas.ch Gerald Pretot
pwa...@trcinc.com Peter Walker
qu...@baccus.franken.de Andreas Dietrich
qu...@us.ibm.com rick mandel
qz...@nbtel.nb.ca Qin Zhao
r.mee...@pecoma.nl Rob Meerwijk
radek...@ac.com radek.vacha
raj...@systemsmiths.com.au Rajeev Arora
Rajes...@nike.com Rajesh Zade
ra...@ark.franken.de
r...@appdesigngroup.com Rob Quinn
ratnak...@autodesk.com Ratnakar Dev
ra...@mail.c-bridge.com Ravi Seelamsetty
r...@arrakis.com.au Roland Turner
rd...@harlequin.co.uk Roger Day
rdh...@fedex.com Richard Hill
rei...@gsf.de Joerg Reiner
Rei...@neta.com Perry Reinert
remigio...@sargroup.com Remigio Di Muzio
res...@interlog.com Ron Resnick
rey...@tricom.com.ph Rey Antonio R. Rex
r...@shellus.com Richard G. Hash
Richard_...@usairways.com Richard E. Fletcher
r...@apg.philips.com Richard B Sagar
r...@technologist.com Randy Clarkson
rlc...@research.baan.nl Rine le Comte
rlo...@intaccess.com Richard Lowisz
Robert...@cern.ch Robert Jones
ro...@ics.com ROHAN
Rohit...@Eng.Sun.COM Rohit Garg
ronv...@xs4all.nl Ron van Wier
ro...@capecod.net Dolores Scaldini Klimm
rsc...@teknowledge.com Randall Schulz
rshe...@openeng.com Robert E. Shelton
RTr...@PlanetDirect.com Treacy, Robert
ruben_...@ibm.net Ruben Bakker
ruf...@e-math.ams.org J Rufinus
russ...@acm.org Russell Gold
rwor...@rwa-net.co.uk Rob Wortham
s027...@moncol.monmouth.edu Venkat Tadi
s030...@moncol.monmouth.edu Kavitha Challapalli
sam....@sciatl.ca Sam Cirka
Sandor...@let.ruu.nl Sandor Spruit
Sandr...@firefly.net Sandra Sheu
Sandy.G...@gsfc.nasa.gov Sandy Grosvenor
san...@nio.dec.com Stefano M. Santoro
sas...@powerup.com.au Scott Andrew Smith
sas...@nms.fnc.fujitsu.com Sastry Kolachana
sat...@adithya.ncb.ernet.in V Satish Kumar
sat...@amteva.com Satish Joshi
s...@metis.no Steinar Bang
sba...@fsg.com Steven Barber
sch...@bbn.com Richard Schantz
sel...@fit.qut.edu.au Selwyn Russell
semir...@mci.com Semir Patel
sha...@tecnomatix.com Ofer Shaked
sha...@wellsfargo.com SRIRAM SHANKARANARAYANA
sh...@sycomore.fr Mike Sharp
SHudd...@tribune.com Scott A. Huddleston
shu...@riverace.com Steve Huston
Sibtho...@JDCORP.deere.com Bryan Sibthorp
sie...@omg.org Jon M. Siegel
Siow...@earthling.com Tan Siow Boon
sirv...@sema4usa.com John Sirvydas
s...@dstc.edu.au Simon McBride
sk...@sybase.com Scott Kay
sku...@ford.com Shailesh Kumar
sku...@PaineWebber.COM SAURABH KUMAR
sk...@sclpinet.clp.com.hk Stephen Kwok
sli...@ebi.ac.uk Timothy Slidel
smc...@mail04.mitre.org Steven McGee
sm...@informatik.tu-darmstadt.de Oliver Kasten
Smith...@JDCORP.deere.com David Smith
so...@omg.org Richard Soley
som...@syl.nj.nec.com Somesh Rao
so...@home.com Steven J. Silverman
s...@rainbow.yonsei.ac.kr MyoungSoo Kang
S...@tntv7.ntrs.com Steve Bonine
spir...@ebi.ac.uk Anastassia Spiridou
ssan...@alpha.telecom-co.net Sandra Patricia Sanchez M.
ss...@iona.com Shrihas Shah
SSID...@us.oracle.com SSIDDIQU.US.ORACLE.COM
ssw...@netexplorer.com Stephen Swaney
sta...@stamper.com Chris Stamper
sta...@vnet.IBM.COM
Sten.Ro...@uab.ericsson.se Sten Rosendahl
ste...@cyberatl.net Steve Nichols
ste...@titude.Eng.Sun.COM Steven Butler
Steve...@chordiant.com Steven M. Sims
ste...@sequent.com Steve Peterson
Steve_Ro...@email.sps.mot.com Steve Roth
Steve...@pcmailgw.ml.com Steven C. Wolfe
stl...@consys.com David St. Louis
stoe...@faps.uni-erlangen.de Thomas Stoeckel
ston...@mc.duke.edu Alan Stone
stu.b...@mcc.com Stu Barrett
stuart.a...@usa.net Stuart Altenhaus
stu...@bmsi.com Stuart D. Gathman
suh...@ibm.net SUHAIL M. AHMED
suk...@paul.rutgers.edu Sukmoon Chang
T.Kr...@pop-koeln.bull.de Thomas Kriener
tan...@magnet.com Tanya Zimmerli
taoj...@acm.org Frank Svoboda
tay...@dstc.edu.au Richard J Taylor
tec...@ilcnet.com Matt Perry
Ted_Va...@Altris.Com Ted S. Valencia
terd...@dialogosweb.com Tom Erdevig
thomas.ch...@ibm.net Thomas Christensen
tich...@ap.org Charles Tichenor
ti...@appliednet.co.uk Tim Soakell
tli...@perspex.com Tripp Lilley
tlo...@adnc.com Timothy A. Lowery
tna...@afmedia.com Tarek S. Nassar
TOBr...@harris.com Terence W. O'Brien
tom.p...@ibm.net Thomas R. Perkins
tomas.a...@era.ericsson.se Tomas Andersson
To...@intelisys.net Thomas Crawley
to...@sparks.tomg.com Tom Gardner
TomGa...@mbconsulting.com Tom Garrity
to...@online.no Tor Iver Wilhelmsen
t...@Trema.COM Teemu Torma
to...@taskon.no Thor Henning Hetland
tspe...@cip.informatik.uni-erlangen.de Thomas Peuker
TWA...@dialogosweb.com Thomas R Wagner
tyon...@elementalsoftware.com Thomas W. Yonkman
u...@decrc.abb.de Axel Uhl
ul...@microguild.com Ulf Weltman
ul...@enea.se Ulf Santesson
um...@entelchile.net Yves Bossel
ung...@redwood.rt.cs.boeing.com Liz Ungar
Vansi_...@wb.xerox.com Van-Si Nguyen
vba...@telecom.ntua.gr Vangelis Baltatzis
ven...@fsc.fujitsu.com Venkat Kethanaboyina
ve...@objs.com Dr. Venu Vasudevan
vij...@visigenic.com Vijaykumar Natarajan
v...@oes.kareltek.fi Vesa-Matti Puro
vos...@egd.igd.fhg.de Joerg Voskamp
vpd...@hiwaay.net Vic Dura
vur...@rempt.xs4all.nl Boudewijn Rempt
W.Lu...@infosys.tuwien.ac.at Wolfgang Lugmayr
walter....@platinum.com Walter Guerrero
wate...@epims1.gsfc.nasa.gov Stephen Chaney Waterbury
Wayne....@nike.com Wayne Little
wedw...@visigenic.com William Edwards
wei...@caip.rutgers.edu Weicong Wang
weiq...@a.crl.com Weiqi Gao
we...@inflab.uni-linz.ac.at Werner Punz
witt...@iml.fhg.de Markus Witthaut
wohl...@mitre.org Steven Wohlever
Wolfgang.K...@abas.de Wolfgang Kretzschmar
wong...@rocketmail.com Frank Kwan Yin Wong
Woody....@PSS.Boeing.com Woody Pidcock
wo...@i-kinetics.com Devashish Worah
xant...@well.com Kent Paul Dolan
yil...@caip.rutgers.edu Yilu He
you...@info.bt.co.uk Pete Young
ze...@enteract.com Shuxiang Zeng
Zhiga...@loria.fr Zhigang Li
z...@odi.com Juergen Zimmermann
ziso...@fokus.gmd.de Andreas Zisowsky
zn...@teleport.com M. Edward Borasky
Zoely....@aar.alcatel-alsthom.fr Zoely Canela
Z...@us.oracle.com zhou ye
Voted No
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
bas...@cict.fr Remi Bastide
bed...@geocities.com Bobby Tendinitis
bo...@datasync.com Martin H. Booda
cala...@chass.utoronto.ca T.Calabrese
chr...@nortel.ca Chris Ebenezer
chuckh...@mindspring.com Chuck Hoffmann
cip...@mindspring.com David A. Howard
c...@get.be Chris Verret
Dave...@unisys.com David E. Keen
d...@cra.com Dmitry Grenader
er...@eisenhower.org Eric Eisenhower
gar...@netcomuk.co.uk Gareth Young
gpr9...@uconnvm.uconn.edu G.P. Ryan
hf...@lerami.lerctr.org Hank Fung
h...@demo.ru Alexander Horoshilov
hum...@eurecom.fr Jakob Hummes
J.J.C...@nortel.co.uk Jonathan Currey
j...@zukowski.net John Zukowski
jeffer...@bigfoot.com Jeffery D. Hunt
je...@ntrs.com Jose Everardo Herrera
jr...@xanadu.eng.utoledo.edu John Reed
mar...@pacbell.net Aaron Marquez
Mats.P...@mailbox.swipnet.se Mats Palmgren
ma...@symsoft.se Mats Palmgren
mcha...@iona.com Martin Chapman
mi...@dstc.edu.au Michi Henning
mmc...@irus.rri.uwo.ca Matthew McBain
ol...@viking.mv.com Olav Nieuwejaar
pa...@lcs.mit.edu Patrick J. LoPresti
pjen...@onramp.net Paul Jenkins
r...@rahul.net Red
ri...@bcm.tmc.edu Richard Miller
Robert....@nike.com Robert Huffman
stai...@bga.com Dwight Brown
stei...@primenet.com Jason Steiner
ste...@dimensional.com Steve Odendahl
td...@sargent.syr.edu Thorsten Daum
to...@null.net Tony Basoglu
Abstained
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
gjoh...@season.com Gary Johnson
guym...@deltanet.com Guy Macon
Votes in error
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
abb...@dakota.net Dan Abbott
! No ballot
abou...@teknowledge.com Kader Bouhdili
! No ballot
ad...@datorn.com Kenneth Persson
! Invalid address
d...@pobox.oleane.com Vincent Nonnenmacher
! No vote statement in message
ewal...@cme.nist.gov Evan Wallace
! No ballot
gp...@dbintellect.com Greg Pasquariello
! No vote statement in message
jgr...@knight-hub.com Jason C. Grant
! No vote statement in message
m...@epoch.ncsc.mil Michelle L. Patterson
! No ballot
ozsari...@ct.tudelft.nl S.S. OZSARIYILDIZ
! No ballot
s015...@moncol.monmouth.edu V.R.Reddy Sabbella
! Invalid ballot
tl...@fuse.net Todd Levy
! No vote statement in message
u...@best.com Charles Liu
! No ballot
--
Rebecca Graham McQuitty
Rebecca McQuitty
During the last few days of the vote I received both a copy of an
improper ballot distribution and a slew of votes mangled in the same way
(a classic sign of voting fraud). It turns out, however, that most of
those people were responding to a campaign notice that included pointers
to the CFV on multiple web news archives. Such a notice is proper, if
frowned on, and the votes from the archives are valid. The archives do
process Usenet posts a bit, and this must be what caused the mangled
ballots.
Any remaining votes from improper campaigning are insignificant in the
face of the obvious interest in this group.
I'm very sorry this vote took so long. My real-life work schedule went
out of control at about the time the vote ended, and the sheer volume of
questionable votes prevented me from investigating the apparent
problem. I'd like to thank all the people who responded so quickly when
I finally did write -- you were all very helpful.
--
Rebecca Graham McQuitty