TNG Spoiler: Lynch's Spoiler Review: "Interface"
Tim Lynch
Review by Tim Lynch <tly...@juliet.caltech.edu>
===============================================
WARNING: The following article contains spoiler information regarding the
TNG episode "Interface". Those not wishing contact with these spoilers
should calmly avoid the article.
Briefly: After "Descent, Part II" and "Liaisons", both fairly disappointing,
I'm feeling better about TNG's new season with "Interface". It wasn't
top-notch, but it was a good, solid character story.
So, without further ado, let's get into (and out of!) the synopsis:
The USS Raman is in jeopardy, trapped inside a gas giant, and the Enterprise
is naturally called in to rescue them. They plan to do so by using a new
piece of technology, a probe that Geordi uses via a direct neural interface,
letting him experience the probe's responses as if he were actually where the
probe is. Although the gas giant's atmosphere is very turbulent, the probe
should be able to transmit without problems. All is well -- until Starfleet
calls Picard with a message of bad news. The USS Hera disappeared four days
ago, along with all of her crew -- and her captain, Geordi's mother.
Geordi does not respond well to the news. Not having seen her for months or
even communicated with her in weeks, he feels somewhat guilty for not having
done so. However, he insists on carrying out the Raman rescue himself
anyway, insisting to Riker that "the Hera is *missing*; that's all." As the
interface is brought on-line, everything works like a charm, although the
input levels need to be very high (75% of neural tolerance levels) to get
through the atmosphere. Geordi finds the crew in a sealed cabin, but all
are dead. He prepares to move to a new location, but a fire suddenly appears
from nowhere -- and not only does Geordi "feel" it, but the *real* Geordi is
burned as well!
Fortunately, Beverly decides that a lower input level, while cruder, should
be safe for Geordi to use, and in a few hours, Geordi will use the probe to
bring the Raman out of the atmosphere. In the interim, however, he talks to
his father, who is planning funeral arrangements, and suggests that
everyone's jumping to conclusions about his mother actually being dead. He
also talks to Data about it (after some helpful prodding by Data), but Data's
recitation of the likelihood his mother is still alive doesn't help matters
any.
Later, he works on the Raman at lower levels, and prepares to pilot the ship,
but he suddenly stops dead -- seeing an image of his mother in that very
control room. She tells him that he needs to pilot the ship *down* -- "we're
dying." Geordi wants to know more, but his nervous system goes into shock
and Beverly and Data quickly break the connection and help him.
He has no permanent damage -- at least, not yet -- but Picard forbids the use
of the probe again, citing the danger and convinced that Geordi probably
imagined it. Geordi, however, insists he wasn't hallucinating, and that the
Hera is trapped on the planet's surface. Even after talking to Troi about
his mother and about Troi's theory that he's invented this hallucination to
stop himself from believing that she's really dead, he still believes -- and
won't back down.
In fact, in a few hours' time he invents a very plausible story for how the
Hera could have _gotten_ to the planet's surface in the first place, and
insists that the Hera is down there and needs rescue. Data admits the idea
is possible, but adds that it is extremely remote. Picard cites too great a
risk, despite his sympathy for Geordi, and opts instead for a safer strategy
to simply bring the Raman up. Geordi is most upset, and even a talk with
Riker about the death of Riker's mother doesn't lessen his bitterness.
Geordi prepares to engage the probe himself, when Data enters to stop him.
Data threatens to confine him to quarters, but when he realizes that Geordi
won't stop without such an action, he turns to help, saying "I cannot confine
you to quarters for something you have not yet done." Geordi "returns" to
the Raman, where the image of his mother confirms his suspicions about what
happened to the Hera.
Jubilant, he begins to descend -- but the probe's signal begins to flicker as
the atmospheric interference grows. Data slowly increases the input levels
until they verge on near-tolerance limits. As the bridge detects the Raman's
motion, and Picard, Riker and Beverly head to the lab, Geordi descends until
the input goes _past_ tolerance levels, refusing to stop -- and Data cannot
simply sever the interface without killing Geordi from the shock. Despite
the pain and despite orders from Picard, Geordi descends until he should be
able to detect the Hera -- but it's not there. He is puzzled, as his
"mother" suddenly attacks him. He repels it, only to find that "mom" is a
subspace creature, one of many that was accidentally picked up by the Raman
and mistakenly killed the crew by trying to read their thoughts. Geordi
continues down just far enough to free the creatures, then prepares to
ascend. The ship is destroyed, but Data and company manage to trick Geordi's
nervous system into "thinking" it's still receiving high input levels and
successfully break contact with the probe. Picard puts a stern reprimand on
Geordi's record, which he accepts -- and Geordi goes on to say that his
experience felt so real that he had a chance to say goodbye to his mother.
----------
There, that takes care of that. Now, the comments.
"Interface" was a very technical show on many levels, since the
virtual-reality probe was a crucial part of the plot. As such, you'd think
it would be extremely prone to the Technobabble Virus that seems to have
infected so many TNG episodes in the past year.
Amazingly, however, it didn't. In fact, "Interface" was delightfully
surprising in that it got back to what TNG does best: focusing on the
_characters_, not the gee-whiz techspeak. While "Interface" had a strong
technical component, what it was _about_ was Geordi dealing with loss,
something we haven't seen any regular do on this particular level before. I
quite liked it.
I was concerned early on that virtual reality would be held up as a giant
technical advance within the show itself, and have a strong "gee-whiz"
component. Fortunately, I was wrong. Although there was certainly some
shock value in seeing Geordi with eyes (and firing phasers out of his palms,
but that's a different point), this was head and shoulders above any virtual
reality program that's ever been done before on TNG, and so far as I know
it's well ahead of anything people are even envisioning as workable these
days. As such, I'm more than satisfied.
Interestingly, though, I thought that all of the best scenes did _not_ take
place on the Raman, but on the Enterprise, as we saw Geordi's denial dig
itself in deeper and deeper. In particular, almost all of the fourth act was
phenomenal. We saw Troi doing her job as well as she can, trying to get
Geordi to realize what he might be doing -- and Geordi rejecting it. We saw
Geordi seemingly doing his job on the surface, but then without warning we
see that he's still locked into his pet theories and his convoluted
explanations. Finally, we saw Riker get as personal as he ever has about his
past (and Frakes's best performance since "Second Chances" last year), and
really making an excellent point to Geordi -- and Geordi rejecting *it* out
of hand as well. Those three scenes, back to back, were extremely effective
in showing us just how much Geordi had invested in "keeping" his mother
alive, and it was a good bit of storytelling on all counts.
And, as I already said, there was surprisingly little in the way of tech to
slog through to get to the meat of the show. We had to take it as given that
the probe somehow gave Geordi "regular" sight when he couldn't get it any
other way; that's a bit of a stretch, but not bad. However, once we had that
and the fairly easy addition of the "input levels" issue, which hung together
nicely, that was it. We didn't hear every single detail of how the probe
worked -- and *nor should we have*, because it's not the point. I know I'm
harping on this, but since I've griped so much about technobabble lately I
want to make it clear how pleased I am to see an episode which so neatly
avoided it.
It was nice to see a role which finally let LeVar Burton show what he's
capable of. He was a bit sub-par last time he had the focal role, but then
nothing could have saved "Aquiel". The last time he had the crucial part in
a show worth watching was over two years ago, back in "The Mind's Eye".
That's too long for a character that still has a lot to learn, and for an
actor of Burton's caliber. "Interface" is great, but since we've now met
some of Geordi's family, I think we need another Geordi-centered show before
too much time has passed.
Another very strong plus that the show had was that Geordi's vision on the
Raman was *not* his mother. As a colleague of mine thought while he was
watching it: "Okay, so if this show's any good, it won't be his mother; and
if it's really really hokey, it will be." I completely agree. Had the Hera
actually been trapped down on the planet, it would have been another case of
Geordi LaForge, Technobabble Genius -- and it would have undercut everything
the previous 40 minutes had built up. I'm glad that the Powers That Be
decided not to go for the happy ending this time; there was no need to, and
it made for a much more affecting story this way. (It also, by the way,
brought the point home that space is a *big* place. Sometimes, things will
just vanish without a trace. I won't be distressed at all if we never find
out what happened to the Hera -- not everything in the universe is going to
be immediately understandable. Leave it alone.)
I've already said that Burton did a good job, but I have to say that everyone
really did. Frakes, as I've said, was at his best when Riker was talking
about his mother's death. Marina Sirtis did a nice job as Troi *doing her
job*. Brent Spiner did a very nice job as well -- in fact, the scene where
Geordi basically blackmails Data into going past safety limits was well
played enough to make me squirm as much as Data was. The rest of the
regulars were somewhat less crucial to the show, but were all quite up to
their respective tasks. I was quite pleased.
(Actually, one Picard-related scene worthy of note is the last one. It's
rare that we see him really chewing someone out, and I happened to like the
way he did it this time, a lot. "I am not happy," indeed.)
I was a little disappointed we didn't get to see more of Ben Vereen as
Geordi's father, but with luck we'll see him again. For what it's worth, I
thought he did a nice job with what little time he did have -- I had no
problems believing the relationship. Then again, I've been a Ben Vereen fan
for years, so my impressions are, as Data would have said, "biased". :-)
Madge Sinclair was fine as Captain LaForge in the letter to Geordi, and
though I never got much of a sense of the character on the Raman, that's
intentional -- it wasn't her. I feel vaguely as though something was
missing, but nothing major.
Finally, a quick word on the directing. While nothing was as striking as
DS9's "The Circle" was this same week, I thought everything was well done.
In particular, one scene that struck me as very difficult to make work was
towards the very end, when everyone's trying to figure out how to save
Geordi, and at the same time we're hearing just Geordi's side of his
conversation with the subspace being. That's a tough scene to manage, and I
thought it came off as very tense and powerful. Good job to Robert Wiemer on
that one.
That really takes care of it. "Interface" wasn't quite up with TNG's best
(bits of it seemed slow, but I can't put my finger on any specific spot), but
it was a very strong, very affecting character drama, which I've been waiting
for for a while. I was glad to see it.
So, to wrap up:
Plot: Definitely strong. A good technical premise, but used only to move
the strong character angle forward.
Plot Handling: Capable. Not stunning, but very capable.
Characterization: Exceptionally good, especially Geordi.
OVERALL: Call it a 9. Nice work.
NEXT WEEK:
Picard as a mercenary and a traitor? Most intriguing...
Tim Lynch (Harvard-Westlake School, Science Dept.)
BITNET: tlynch@citjulie
INTERNET: tly...@juliet.caltech.edu
UUCP: ...!ucbvax!tlynch%juliet.ca...@hamlet.caltech.edu
"I cannot have you confined to quarters for something you have not yet done."
-- Data
--
Copyright 1993, Timothy W. Lynch. All rights reserved, but feel free to ask...
john russell
>I was a little disappointed we didn't get to see more of Ben Vereen as
>Geordi's father, but with luck we'll see him again. For what it's worth, I
>thought he did a nice job with what little time he did have -- I had no
>problems believing the relationship. Then again, I've been a Ben Vereen fan
>for years, so my impressions are, as Data would have said, "biased". :-)
I found this to be very annoying, particularly in light of all the
"Ben Vereen to be on Star Trek!" hype I've seen in the past several
weeks (they made an awful big deal of it on that E! special). It would
have been nice to actually *see* him...
jr
Bill Henley
"Interface" certainly was an improvement over the two previous
TNG episodes-- almost anything would have been-- but though I
agree with everybody that it was a good thing that Geordi's
mother didn't really come back to life, I wasn't too happy with
the actual ending either. I guessed the ending about halfway
through the show and told the person sitting next to me --
"Hey, you know what's going to happen? I bet Geordi's mother
will turn out to be an alien of some sort who is taking her
form in order to communicate with Geordi." It would have
been nice to have a bit more of a surprise.
This isn't the first time that Geordi has had a denial problem
as regards death-- he refused to believe that *he* was dead
back in "The Next Phase." Considering that in that case he
was right, maybe he can't be blamed too much for thinking
he could bring his mother back from limbo by applied
technobabble.
--
Bill Henley, Assistant Sysop, Cleveland Free-Net Science Fiction
& Fantasy SIG (aa396)
Matthew Gertz
Tim Lynch <tly...@Juliet.Caltech.Edu> wrote:
>[TNG] Lynch's Spoiler Review: "Interface"
>Review by Tim Lynch <tly...@juliet.caltech.edu>
>===============================================
>
>WARNING: The following article contains spoiler information regarding the
>TNG episode "Interface". Those not wishing contact with these spoilers
>should calmly avoid the article.
>Briefly: After "Descent, Part II" and "Liaisons", both fairly disappointing,
>I'm feeling better about TNG's new season with "Interface". It wasn't
>top-notch, but it was a good, solid character story.
Oh boy, oh boy, I don't think we've ever disagreed so much on an episode.
My feeling was that this episode was a tedious piece of recycling.
>"Interface" was a very technical show on many levels, since the
>virtual-reality probe was a crucial part of the plot. As such, you'd think
>it would be extremely prone to the Technobabble Virus that seems to have
>infected so many TNG episodes in the past year.
>
>Amazingly, however, it didn't. In fact, "Interface" was delightfully
>surprising in that it got back to what TNG does best: focusing on the
>_characters_,
Well, focusing on *one* character, maybe. Problem is, when you focus on
one character, the other characters turn into props: Troi reverting
back to old Troi-isms, Data somehow ignoring orders (it's been made quite
clear that Data doesn't just arbitrarily ignore orders except when other
orders take precedence, e.g. "Clues" and "The Quality of Life"), Riker
waxing maudlin about his early days as a tot, Worf once again ignoring
his security board and letting things go to far, and Picard acting like
a blind authority figure). Every character in this episode, except for
Geordi, was portrayed as (for the most part) one-dimensional, and existed
only for Geordi to play off of.
>I was concerned early on that virtual reality would be held up as a giant
>technical advance within the show itself, and have a strong "gee-whiz"
>component. Fortunately, I was wrong. Although there was certainly some
>shock value in seeing Geordi with eyes (and firing phasers out of his palms,
>but that's a different point), this was head and shoulders above any virtual
>reality program that's ever been done before on TNG, and so far as I know
>it's well ahead of anything people are even envisioning as workable these
>days.
??? Granted, we can't tap directly into the brain yet, but, by using
goggles, earphones, and force-feedback, I could put together a pretty good
(if crude) demonstration of what the interface did, in my own lab (no tractor
beams or phasers, sorry, but you will be able to move the robot around
and manipulate things.) Far from being "well ahead of anything that people
are envisioning," this field, which is known as "telepresence," is one of
the biggest research fields in robotics today, and some amazing discoveries
are being made. Such telepresence should be centuries old by the time
of TNG, and definitely should have preceded the holodecks. This bit o'
technology in the episode did nothing for me. Just another example of
TNG writers grabbing another recent scientific topic and shoving it into
an episode. (On the other hand, I now have a good idea of how you feel
when recent astrophysical theories are shoved into TNG episodes... :-)
>Interestingly, though, I thought that all of the best scenes did _not_ take
>place on the Raman, but on the Enterprise, as we saw Geordi's denial dig
>itself in deeper and deeper.
Ehhh. This did nothing for me, either. On the other hand, Data's comment
that Geordi's hypothesis was nearly impossible was nice. Take that,
technobabble!
> In particular, almost all of the fourth act was
>phenomenal. We saw Troi doing her job as well as she can, trying to get
>Geordi to realize what he might be doing -- and Geordi rejecting it.
All I saw was a Troi who had mysteriously reverted to a pre-"Face of the
Enemy" character. At least she directly confronted Geordi about his
"wish-fulfillment" -- that's something, I suppose.
>Finally, we saw Riker get as personal as he ever has about his
>past (and Frakes's best performance since "Second Chances" last year), and
>really making an excellent point to Geordi -- and Geordi rejecting *it* out
>of hand as well.
This *should* have been good, but wasn't. I think perhaps that Frakes'
delivery was a bit off, including his nearly choking up. Granted, we all
miss our loved ones that have died, but it's been over thirty years for
Riker, and he really didn't know her.
>Those three scenes, back to back, were extremely effective
>in showing us just how much Geordi had invested in "keeping" his mother
>alive, and it was a good bit of storytelling on all counts.
I felt it was "collect the thoughts," as Wesley did in "The Dauphin," and
Data did in "In Theory," but reversed, with Geordi's friends seeking him
out, instead of vice-versa.
>And, as I already said, there was surprisingly little in the way of tech to
>slog through to get to the meat of the show. We had to take it as given that
>the probe somehow gave Geordi "regular" sight when he couldn't get it any
>other way; that's a bit of a stretch, but not bad. However, once we had that
>and the fairly easy addition of the "input levels" issue,
Heh... on our machines, you can adjust the force-feedback input levels, too,
but the machine will clip any truly dangerous responses no matter how high you
turn it up. It's just artificial danger added to the episode to try to excite
us.
>It was nice to see a role which finally let LeVar Burton show what he's
>capable of.
Finally, something we can agree on :-). LeVar Burton did a great job on
what was otherwise a business-as-usual script (lost entities who just want
to go home... who didn't see that one coming?).
>Another very strong plus that the show had was that Geordi's vision on the
>Raman was *not* his mother. As a colleague of mine thought while he was
>watching it: "Okay, so if this show's any good, it won't be his mother; and
>if it's really really hokey, it will be."
I think both conjectures are flawed, but that's just my opinion... :-)
> I completely agree. Had the Hera
>actually been trapped down on the planet, it would have been another case of
>Geordi LaForge, Technobabble Genius -- and it would have undercut everything
>the previous 40 minutes had built up.
It is true that the episode would have been much worse if that had been
the case. It would have sunk from a "just sorta there" episode to the
level of "Suspicions."
>I was a little disappointed we didn't get to see more of Ben Vereen as
>Geordi's father
Me, too!
>OVERALL: Call it a 9. Nice work.
I'd go for a 5 or so. The "character isn't believed" plotline is a bit old
for me, as is the "lost energy beings" plotline (odd, I was really expecting
you to have mentioned these critters in more depth in your review), and,
when the two are juxtaposed, the result is sheer predictability.
--
Matt Gertz, mwge...@cs.cmu.edu
Dept. of ECE, The Robotics Institute at Carnegie Mellon University.