Google Groupes n'accepte plus les nouveaux posts ni abonnements Usenet. Les contenus de l'historique resteront visibles.

Wind Dance question

1 vue
Accéder directement au premier message non lu

Jozxyqk

non lue,
23 févr. 2003, 01:01:3223/02/2003
à
This may sound like a silly question, but it may come up in a deck idea I
have (something I thought of as I was joining the triple-0 club at the
NE qualifier :) ).

If Magdelena Schaefer plays Wind Dance at superior, does she burn 1 blood
(for playing the card), or 2 blood (for each strike: dodge) ?


albert1642

non lue,
23 févr. 2003, 02:53:4323/02/2003
à

I think she would only burn 1... The only strike that requires tham is the
first strike... the second strike is gained from the first card... If
Antoinette DuChamp plays acrobatics at sup, she doesn't have to pay another
blood to do the additional strike...

I would like to hear the idea, the only way I could think of using wind dance
is just to survive to the second round...

The only thing I thought of cool was a weenie THA rush deck with Ghoul
Retainers to do all the combat... Meat hooks, ivory bow, and maybe 1 improved
flame throwers... I believe if the Ghoul Retainer strikes with the meat hook
you still get the press from it... Just wind dance your way around
everything...

The deck would be called...

Wait for it...
...
...
...

Meat the Dancing Hookers

albert1642

non lue,
23 févr. 2003, 04:03:0323/02/2003
à
>I think she would only burn 1... The only strike that requires tham is the
>first strike... the second strike is gained from the first card... If
>Antoinette DuChamp plays acrobatics at sup, she doesn't have to pay another
>blood to do the additional strike...
>
>I would like to hear the idea, the only way I could think of using wind dance
>is just to survive to the second round...
>
>The only thing I thought of cool was a weenie THA rush deck with Ghoul
>Retainers to do all the combat... Meat hooks, ivory bow, and maybe 1
>improved
>flame throwers... I believe if the Ghoul Retainer strikes with the meat hook
>you still get the press from it... Just wind dance your way around
>everything...
>
>The deck would be called...
>
>Wait for it...
>...
>...
>...
>
>Meat the Dancing Hookers
>
ACK... Totally got a new idea...

THA AUS deck... then you can CANCEL your additional strike with Primal
Instincts (Nothing on the card says you can't cancel your additional strikes)
and get an additional strike... Ack, that's good... THA AUS with improvised
flame thrower deck... (needs some prem aggro weapon, since a good portion of
the deck would be dodges)
Got so much dodge that range strikes won't be a problem... (only 'can't dodge'
range strike is from gargolyes i think)

Hmm, wonder if it'll work... Damn wonder where i can get like 15 wind
dances...

albert1642

non lue,
23 févr. 2003, 04:33:1123/02/2003
à
My question is...

if you play Wind dance at superior...
can I play a dodge strike cards as my additional strike? just to burn cards if
needed... you know, another wind dance at minor... Bond with the mountain for
the press...

reyda

non lue,
23 févr. 2003, 07:13:2523/02/2003
à
albert1642 wrote:

> THA AUS deck... then you can CANCEL your additional strike with
> Primal Instincts (Nothing on the card says you can't cancel your
> additional strikes) and get an additional strike...

except that the card text on Wind dances commits you to strike:dodge as your
second strike =/

it's like trying to cancel a gun strike with primal instinct after having
used it to maneuver.


> good... THA AUS with improvised flame thrower deck...

that would work easier with ghoul retainers and good ol' "do not replace"
dodges, for instance =)


LSJ

non lue,
23 févr. 2003, 08:10:0623/02/2003
à

Magdelena's problem comes on "using the strike", not on "playing the
strike card" (see recent thread on the difference).

Each time she uses a strike that requires Thaumaturgy, she burns an
additional blood.

So she burns a blood for the first dodge (assuming combat wasn't
ended by S:CE first, before the dodge could be "used"). And, if
combat lasts that long, she burns a blood for the second dodge as
well (when it is used).

--
LSJ (vte...@white-wolf.com) V:TES Net.Rep for White Wolf, Inc.
Links to V:TES news, rules, cards, utilities, and tournament calendar:
http://www.white-wolf.com/vtes/

Daz

non lue,
23 févr. 2003, 09:42:2623/02/2003
à
alber...@aol.com (albert1642) wrote in message news:<20030223040303...@mb-cf.aol.com>...

> >I think she would only burn 1... The only strike that requires tham is the
> >first strike... the second strike is gained from the first card... If
> >Antoinette DuChamp plays acrobatics at sup, she doesn't have to pay another
> >blood to do the additional strike...
> >
> >I would like to hear the idea, the only way I could think of using wind dance
> >is just to survive to the second round...
> >
> >The only thing I thought of cool was a weenie THA rush deck with Ghoul
> >Retainers to do all the combat... Meat hooks, ivory bow, and maybe 1
> >improved
> >flame throwers... I believe if the Ghoul Retainer strikes with the meat hook
> >you still get the press from it... Just wind dance your way around
> >everything...
> >
> >The deck would be called...
> >
> >Wait for it...
> >...
> >...
> >...
> >
> >Meat the Dancing Hookers
> >
> ACK... Totally got a new idea...
>
> THA AUS deck... then you can CANCEL your additional strike with Primal
> Instincts (Nothing on the card says you can't cancel your additional strikes)
> and get an additional strike... Ack, that's good... THA AUS with improvised
> flame thrower deck... (needs some prem aggro weapon, since a good portion of
> the deck would be dodges)
The oposing minion must also declare an additional strike if you want
to cancel your additional strike with Primal instinct.

> Got so much dodge that range strikes won't be a problem... (only 'can't dodge'
> range strike is from gargolyes i think)

Assamites get a recation card that gives them first strike and stops
dodges. (and that obf/cel first strike + no dodge card)

>
> Hmm, wonder if it'll work... Damn wonder where i can get like 15 wind
> dances...


And if you play superior wind dance you have already declared your
additional strike (like when you manuver with a gun or a thrown gate)
so you can´t play another strike card.

Frederick Scott

non lue,
23 févr. 2003, 13:29:1823/02/2003
à
LSJ wrote:

>
> Jozxyqk wrote:
> > If Magdelena Schaefer plays Wind Dance at superior, does she burn 1 blood
> > (for playing the card), or 2 blood (for each strike: dodge) ?
>
> Magdelena's problem comes on "using the strike", not on "playing the
> strike card" (see recent thread on the difference).
>
> Each time she uses a strike that requires Thaumaturgy, she burns an
> additional blood.
>
> So she burns a blood for the first dodge (assuming combat wasn't
> ended by S:CE first, before the dodge could be "used"). And, if
> combat lasts that long, she burns a blood for the second dodge as
> well (when it is used).

To clarify, if the first strike doesn't end the combat by itself (that
is, if the opponent doesn't play S:CE or Aggravated Damage/Rotschrek
or something), then the combat _will_ last that long and Magdelena
_will_ need to burn a second blood. This raises the question of whether
Magdelena's card text describes an effect or a cost. And if a cost,
how does the issue of her attempting to use Wind Dance at superior work
if she has only one Blood?

Fred

reyda

non lue,
23 févr. 2003, 13:39:1023/02/2003
à

she can also usewind dance if she has zero blood since it is not a cost but
a burn blood effect.

Jozxyqk

non lue,
23 févr. 2003, 13:44:3123/02/2003
à
> I would like to hear the idea, the only way I could think of using wind dance
> is just to survive to the second round...

Well, surely, the idea doesn't *center* around Wind Dance.
Thaumaturgy is a distant third in the discipline spread of the crypt
(and frankly, I'd rather have Heinrick Schlempt to share the low-cap-with-
Thaum duties with Roreca but I don't have one of him). And the deck doesn't
want to be in combat. But, of course, sometimes you get into combat and a
Theft isn't going to help against that 3 points of Agg damage...

I'm a big fan of using Absorb the Mind to dodge for Dominate, and a free dodge
for Thaumaturgy works well in the deck concept.

LSJ

non lue,
24 févr. 2003, 07:44:5224/02/2003
à
Frederick Scott wrote:
> LSJ wrote:
>>Each time she uses a strike that requires Thaumaturgy, she burns an
>>additional blood.
> This raises the question of whether
> Magdelena's card text describes an effect or a cost.

Effect.

0 nouveau message