Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.
Dismiss

I'm Not There (1956)

0 views
Skip to first unread message

J. W. Mahoney

unread,
Aug 13, 2003, 5:23:26 PM8/13/03
to
I've just recently gotten a copy of I'm Not There, from the Basement
Tapes, the "saddest song in the world," according to Greil Marcus'
quoting from "The Dylanist" in "Invisible Republic." In looking up
what the words - almost certainly made up at the time - might be, I've
seen that most of the transcriptions available on the Internet are
quite imaginatively inaccurate. Listen to the song and see how this
fits it, however weirdly:

I'm Not There (1956)

A Phonetic Transcription
by J.W. Mahoney

1.
Well it's alright she'nay she's all the tide in my
neighborhood she cried both day and night,
I know it because it was there.

It's a milestone but she's down on her luck,
and she daily salutin but to make him hard to buck,
I bevaid…

I believe where she stopping whef she wants time to care,
I believe that she'd look upon deciding to care,
and I go by the Lord in a way she's on my way,
but I don't belong there.

2.
No I don't belong to her,
I don't belong to aevi'pize,
she's my prize forsaken angel
but she don't hear me cry.

She's a long-hearted mystic
and she dain carry on,
when I'm there she's alright ,
but when she's not, when I'm gone.

Heaven knows that the answer
she's don't call in no-one,
she's the way, a sailing beautiful,
she's mine, for the one,
and I loss a heavy tension, by temptation less it runs
but she don't allah me
but I'm not there, I'm gone.

3.
Now I've cried tonight
like I cried the night before,
and I'm neece on the haise,
but I dream about the door.

It's sa-long Jesus-saken,
blind fate, with a tell,
it don't hang contonation
she's my ald fare-thee-well.

Now when I cheeth the levee,
I was born to love her,
but she knows that the kingdom weighs
so high above her,
and I run but I race,
but it's not too fast a sleoun,
but I daren't perceive her,
I'm not there, I'm gone.

4.
Well it's all about deffusion and I cry for her veil,
I don't need anybody now beside me to tell.

And it's all efformation, I recieve but it's not,
She's a lone-hearted beauty but she's gone like the spot,
if she waoun…

Yes, she's gone like the rain-beow that shining yesterday
but now she's a'ome beside me and I'd like to here to stay,
she's a bone-forsaking beauty and it don't trust anyone,
and I wish I was beside her, but I'm not there, I'm gone.

5.
Well it's a too hard to stake-in,
and I don't bart-b'lieve
It's all bag for tebusing,
but she's hard, too hard to leave.

It's alone, it's a crime
the way she moults me around
but she told for to hate me
but this dong fortaken clown.

Yes I believe that it's rightful,
oh I believe it in my mind,
I b'told like I said when I before carry on the crying,
and she's all good to told her,
like I said, carry on,
I wish I was there to help her,
but I'm not there, I'm gone…

Ironywaves

unread,
Aug 14, 2003, 1:21:03 AM8/14/03
to
One of the all-time greatest! Hope to find a copy next week in Atlanta!
Will

http://www.angelfire.com/al2/dockery

"J. W. Mahoney" <maho...@hmsg.si.edu> wrote in message
news:651dc3f6.03081...@posting.google.com...


> I've just recently gotten a copy of I'm Not There, from the Basement
> Tapes, the "saddest song in the world," according to Greil Marcus'
> quoting from "The Dylanist" in "Invisible Republic." In looking up
> what the words - almost certainly made up at the time - might be, I've
> seen that most of the transcriptions available on the Internet are
> quite imaginatively inaccurate. Listen to the song and see how this
> fits it, however weirdly:
>
> I'm Not There (1956)
>
> A Phonetic Transcription
> by J.W. Mahoney
>
> 1.
> Well it's alright she'nay she's all the tide in my
> neighborhood she cried both day and night,
> I know it because it was there.
>
> It's a milestone but she's down on her luck,
> and she daily salutin but to make him hard to buck,

> I bevaid.

> if she waoun.


>
> Yes, she's gone like the rain-beow that shining yesterday
> but now she's a'ome beside me and I'd like to here to stay,
> she's a bone-forsaking beauty and it don't trust anyone,
> and I wish I was beside her, but I'm not there, I'm gone.
>
> 5.
> Well it's a too hard to stake-in,
> and I don't bart-b'lieve
> It's all bag for tebusing,
> but she's hard, too hard to leave.
>
> It's alone, it's a crime
> the way she moults me around
> but she told for to hate me
> but this dong fortaken clown.
>
> Yes I believe that it's rightful,
> oh I believe it in my mind,
> I b'told like I said when I before carry on the crying,
> and she's all good to told her,
> like I said, carry on,
> I wish I was there to help her,

> but I'm not there, I'm gone.


rankflv

unread,
Aug 17, 2003, 2:31:49 AM8/17/03
to
It sounds to me that dylan didn't finish the lyrics but mumbled
word-sounds to be changed at some later date . . .to keep a sense of
the flow, to quickly get it down before the song could be lost.

or

Maybe dylan wrote the lyrics first before the music and was having a
difficult time fitting them together and in the process slurred the
words and added nonsense sounds to fit to music

or

Dylan was very wasted.

Ironywaves

unread,
Aug 17, 2003, 12:11:07 PM8/17/03
to
"rankflv" <ran...@yahoo.com> wrote in message
news:14a0f657.03081...@posting.google.com...

Or singing while flipping throuh an obscure Japanese novel..? Sorry,
couldn't resist that one.
Will

http://www.hotornot.com/r/?eid=NER8GQR&key=TVL


0 new messages