Armed Forces win long standing pay battle in Supreme Court
21 views
Skip to first unread message
Veterans India
Sep 4, 2012, 11:25:31 AM9/4/12
to veteransindia
New Delhi: The armed forces won a landmark victory in their long
standing battle to get an anomaly in fixation of pay scales for
commissioned officers noticed in the 4th Pay Commission.
The Supreme Court today ordered payment of rank pay arrears to all
affected officers estimated to number over 20,000 with effect from
January 1, 1986.
The government had been told the pay the arrears within 12 weeks.
According to sources, the total outgo to government in making this
payment will be over Rs. 1500 crore.
Military lawyers told NDTV that historically the most important
litigation involving the military has culminated today.
The Supreme Court decided not to interfere in its earlier decision
granting the cumulative benefits and arrears of Rank Pay with effect
from 01-01-1986 to all affected officers.
It said the benefits shall be released to all officers irrespective of
whether they had approached a judicial forum or not.
According to Major Navdeep Singh who specialises in military cases,
this matter was carried over from the 4th Central Pay Commission (CPC)
when an integrated pay scale of Rs. 2300-5100 was implemented for
officers from the rank of 2/Lieutenant to Brigadier. In addition, rank
pay was authorised to officers from the rank of Captain to Brigadier
ranging from Rs. 200 to 1200 which was to be added into the basic pay
for all intents and purposes.
However, while fixing the pay in the new scales, an amount equal to
the rank pay was deducted from the emoluments resulting in financial
loss to all affected officers. Hence all officers holding the rank of
Captain to Brigadier as on 01-01-1986 suffered cumulative losses,
Major Navdeep Singh says. The Kerala High Court in a case filed by
Major AK Dhanapalan had termed illegal this deduction of rank pay.
Soon thereafter, many similar petitions were filed in various High
Courts all over the country which were clubbed together and
transferred to the Supreme Court.
The Supreme Court had on March 8, 2010, upheld the Kerala High Court
verdict and granted relief to all similarly placed officers.
Things were, however, not to end there since the government
constituted a committee to look into the amount involved and went back
to the Supreme Court by filing an application for recall of the order
dated March 8, 2010 on the grounds that the monetary outgo will be a
big burden on the exchequer and also stating therein that many more
issues on the subject were not taken into consideration by the Court
and hence the order needed to be recalled, Major Navdeep explained.
The biggest credit, he says should go to Retired Defence Officers'
Association (RDOA) who had been unflinchingly following up the matter
with great zeal in a very objective and balanced manner.
standing battle to get an anomaly in fixation of pay scales for
commissioned officers noticed in the 4th Pay Commission.
The Supreme Court today ordered payment of rank pay arrears to all
affected officers estimated to number over 20,000 with effect from
January 1, 1986.
The government had been told the pay the arrears within 12 weeks.
According to sources, the total outgo to government in making this
payment will be over Rs. 1500 crore.
Military lawyers told NDTV that historically the most important
litigation involving the military has culminated today.
The Supreme Court decided not to interfere in its earlier decision
granting the cumulative benefits and arrears of Rank Pay with effect
from 01-01-1986 to all affected officers.
It said the benefits shall be released to all officers irrespective of
whether they had approached a judicial forum or not.
According to Major Navdeep Singh who specialises in military cases,
this matter was carried over from the 4th Central Pay Commission (CPC)
when an integrated pay scale of Rs. 2300-5100 was implemented for
officers from the rank of 2/Lieutenant to Brigadier. In addition, rank
pay was authorised to officers from the rank of Captain to Brigadier
ranging from Rs. 200 to 1200 which was to be added into the basic pay
for all intents and purposes.
However, while fixing the pay in the new scales, an amount equal to
the rank pay was deducted from the emoluments resulting in financial
loss to all affected officers. Hence all officers holding the rank of
Captain to Brigadier as on 01-01-1986 suffered cumulative losses,
Major Navdeep Singh says. The Kerala High Court in a case filed by
Major AK Dhanapalan had termed illegal this deduction of rank pay.
Soon thereafter, many similar petitions were filed in various High
Courts all over the country which were clubbed together and
transferred to the Supreme Court.
The Supreme Court had on March 8, 2010, upheld the Kerala High Court
verdict and granted relief to all similarly placed officers.
Things were, however, not to end there since the government
constituted a committee to look into the amount involved and went back
to the Supreme Court by filing an application for recall of the order
dated March 8, 2010 on the grounds that the monetary outgo will be a
big burden on the exchequer and also stating therein that many more
issues on the subject were not taken into consideration by the Court
and hence the order needed to be recalled, Major Navdeep explained.
The biggest credit, he says should go to Retired Defence Officers'
Association (RDOA) who had been unflinchingly following up the matter
with great zeal in a very objective and balanced manner.
VIJAY KUMAR MAHESHWARI
Sep 4, 2012, 11:36:57 AM9/4/12
to vetera...@googlegroups.com
FANTASTIC> The hard work by RODA has borne fruit. Thanks to all members of RODA who fought the case on behalf of the veterans.GOD bless them all. From-- Gp Capt VK Maheshwari IAF (RETD)
On Tue, 04 Sep 2012 20:55:36 +0530 wrote
On Tue, 04 Sep 2012 20:55:36 +0530 wrote
 |
| Follow Rediff Deal ho jaye! to get exciting offers in your city everyday. |
Bidyadhar Nayak
Sep 5, 2012, 5:41:17 AM9/5/12
to
Armed Forces win long standing pay battle in Supreme Court
Reply all
Reply to author
Forward
0 new messages