(17) VERIFIABLE FACTS: ANAMBRA STATE VERSUS ENTIRE NORTHERN NIGERIA- COMPARE AND CONTRAST

520 views
Skip to first unread message

africa today

unread,
Jun 14, 2012, 2:29:52 AM6/14/12
to naijap...@yahoogroups.com, my brother, NIDO-USA NIDO-USA, nido...@niamericas.org, USAAfrica Dialogue, igbo events, AfricanTalk e-group, UMU-IGBO UMU-IGBO, Nigeria World, Yoruba World, newnaijapolitics, Punch me I deck U, Christian News, umeag...@yahoo.com, in...@intersociety-ng.org, ken.asagwara, asausad...@yahoogroups.com, asa...@yahoogroups.com, ANAMBRA FOURUM, Anambra-WorldForum

(17) VERIFIABLE FACTS: ANAMBRA STATE VERSUS ENTIRE NORTHERN NIGERIA- COMPARE AND CONTRAST

===========================================================================================

SOURCES:

VERIFIABLE DATA, FACTS, RECORDS AND INFORMATION FROM THE FOLLOWING SOURCES:

 FEDERAL GOVERNMENT OF NIGERIA RECORDS, STATE RECORDS, WORLD BANK, UNITED NATIONS, UNDP, MINISTERS, PRESIDENT YARADUA, PRESIDENT JONATHAN, NORTHERN LEADERS, SCHOLARS, NGOS, AREWA YOUTHS, AREWA SUMMITS, NORTHERN AND SOUTHERN LEADERS, NATIONAL SECURITY ADVISER, UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT, EUROPEAN UNION, UNIVERSITIES, JAMB,  Unified Tertiary Matriculation Examination, UTME AND Joint Admissions and Matriculation Board, JAMB, UN Human Development Index, WORLD BANK Global Hunger Index, 2002 Universities Matriculation Examination (U.M.E.)., NEWSPAPERS, MAGAZINES, WEBSITES, Paul Anber's essay "Modernization and Political Disintegration: Nigeria and the Ibos" published in the journal of Modern African Studies vol. 5, No 2 (Sep, 1967) 163-179. To be more specific see pp 171-172, and let me quote the relevant portion of Dr. Anber's essay:"A system of Universal primary education was introduced in Eastern Nigeria in 1953, WIKIPEDIA AND FINALLY FROM Professor Ibrahim Gambari, Under Secretary-General, Special Adviser to the Secretary General of the United Nations in his address lamented the poverty level of the North using grim statistics. 
 

 

DATAS, STATISTICS AND VERIFIABLE INFORMATION ON POVERTY, EDUCATION AND HEALTHCARE

IN SOUTH EASTERN STATES OF NIGERIA (ANAMBRA STATE IN PARTICULAR) VERSUS THE ENIRE 19 NORTHERN STATES OF NIGERIA.

(1)

=================================================================================

North has World's highest illiterate children —World Bank
Written by Emma Ujah & Luka Binniyat of Vanguard newspaper
Tuesday, October 7, 2008
* Poverty in the North, embarrassing – Yar’Adua

* North, by far, the poorest, says Gambari


ABUJA—The Northern Nigeria Economic and Investment Summit, kicked off in Abuja yesterday with the World Bank, saying that Northern Nigeria has the highest number of children not going to School in the world.

Professor Ibrahim Gambari, Under Secretary-General, Special Adviser to the Secretary General of the United Nations in his address lamented the poverty level of the North using grim statistics.


“On Health and Education”, he said, “the level of immunization of Children against dangerous childhood diseases, in the South-East is 44.6% immunization coverage, but the North-West has 3.7% and the North-East 3.6%.”, he said


“If you take the education of the girl-child as indicator, you see similar pattern of inequality with the South-East having an enrolment rate of 85%, South-Wes having an enrolment rate of 85%, South-South 75%, while the North-East 20% and North West 25%."


The Minister of Finance, Dr Usman Shamsudeen, while addressing the gathering of eminent Northerners at the Summit alluded the aforementioned to a recent World Bank statistics.


According to him, the level of education of a people has direct correlation with their living standards.


He then lamented that based on that correlation, Northern Nigeria was far behind all of humanity when it comes to Child Education.


His words: “About two months ago”, he said, “the Ministry of Finance organised a review session with our Development Partner like the World Bank. The World Bank representative gave a list of statistics that should shock all of us into action”, he said.


He said that "Northern Nigeria remains, and represents the only place in the world that has the highest number of Children that are not going to school. The Highest number of children that are not going to school in the world are in Northern Nigeria”, he emphasized.


He blamed the problem on lack of commitment and efforts on the part of Northern leaders. He then called on responsible, experienced and educated retired Northerners to take up political leadership of their various states, as politics has been hijacked by hoodlums who have turned it to total warfare


President Umaru Yar’Adua whose speech was read by the Minister of Commerce, Mr. Charles Ugwu, noted that there still remained a worrisome and embarrassing poverty situation in most part of Northern Nigeria.


This, the President said, is in spite of a sustained Gross Domestic Product Growth Rate of 6%; relatively stabilised Naira, controlled inflation and an enviable Foreign Reserve presently put at over $63 billion in a stable polity.


“In fact, in most of the Northern States the poverty level is very high”, Yar A’dua observed.


“In some of these States, there is equally high unemployment rate, near total collapse of infrastructure, virtual absence of new investments, while practically all the States depend essentially on revenues accruing from the Federation Account”, he said.


He then called on Northern States to take the advantage they have in Agriculture and Solid Mineral and harness them for the well being of their people.


Professor Ibrahim Gambari, Under Secretary-General, Special Adviser to the Secretary General of the United Nations in his address lamented the poverty level of the North using grim statistics.


“On Health and Education”, he said, “the level of immunization of Children against dangerous childhood diseases, in the South-East is 44.6% immunization coverage, but the North-West has 3.7% and the North-East 3.6%.”, he said


“If you take the education of the girl-child as indicator, you see similar pattern of inequality with the South-East having an enrolment rate of 85%, South-Wes having an enrolment rate of 85%, South-South 75%, while the North-East 20% and North West 25%."
==========================================================================================

(2) ON EDUCATION: SCHOOL ENROLLMENT AVERAGE 2008-2010

EXPOSES FALLS CENSUS AND POPULATION DATA FROM JAMB, INEC AND OFFICE OF STATISTICS

ZONE

POPULATION

COLLEGE ENROLLMENT

PER CENT

% OF TOTAL

% of Population

SS

21,014,655

140,000

0.7%

24.9%

15%

SE

16,381,729

190,000

1.2%

33.8%

12%

SW

27,581,992

116,000

0.4%

20.6%

20%

ZN TOT

64,978,376

446,000

0.7%

79.4%

46%

NW

29,460,613

30,000

0.1%

5.3%

21%

NE

22,999,885

21,000

0.1%

3.7%

16%

NC

22,564,668

65,000

0.3%

11.6%

16%

ZN TOT

75,025,166

116,000

0.2%

20.6%

54%

36 STATES

140,003,542

562,000

0.4%

100.0%

100%

================================================================================
(3)
POVERTY IN NIGERIA LOWEST IN IGBO SOUTH EAST
Monday, February 13, 2012 PUNCH NEWSPAPERS

Poverty, education and Boko Haram

by Olufemi Adebiyi
'From available information at our disposal, pieced together from publications by the World Bank and United Nations, there is a very strong correlation between some demographic factors and poverty in Nigeria. Firstly, there are more poor people in the rural areas relative to the urban centres; and poverty is disproportionately concentrated in families whose primary livelihood is agriculture. Secondly, and within these agricultural households, 75 per cent in the North are poor compared with 59.3 per cent in the South. This underlines the preponderance of poverty in the North relative to the South. Thirdly, and in terms of geographical distribution, the highest concentration of poverty, at close to 70 per cent of the population, is in the North-East, followed by the North-West and North-Central in approximately the same proportion of more than 60 per cent of the population. The zone with the least proportion of poverty incidence is the South-East at about 33 per cent, closely followed by the South-West at about 42 per cent, and South-South at about 50 per cent."

There is no single, universally accepted, definition of poverty. This is because poverty is multidimensional. However, it is not uncommon to describe poverty as a general state of deprivation or as Baker says, “A state of being deficient in money or means of subsistence.”



advertisement

AdChoices

In recent times, poverty has been frequently defined relative to the standards of living in a society. Thus, it is recognised when all available income is spent on food and the results still fall below a certain minimum level of calories. Recently available information places Nigeria at number 154 out of 179 countries on the Human Development Index, but Nigeria is a frontrunner on the Global Hunger Index, coasting in at number 20!

=======================================================

(4)

Northern Transformation Impact Summit Sponsored by the Arewa Transformation and Empowerment Initiative

Arewa House Kaduna

May 10th to 12th, 2012

QUOTE - General O.A. Azazi, CFR National Security Adviser The Presidency Federal Republic of Nigeria.
"The Arewa Transformation & Empowerment Initiative (ATEI) has sensitized us to the need for change through statistics I trust that they will share with you. For example, while there is massive unemployment all over Nigeria, our Northern states are particularly hard hit. The 2011 national unemployment rate is 23.9%, but the rates are 60.6% in Yobe, 42.6% in Zamfara and 39.4% in Niger. Likewise, the North, in general, features lower per capita income, vis-a-vis other parts of the country. The North-West has the highest poverty rate in the nation, with 71% of its people living below $1 per day. According to a CBN report, the literacy rate in the North is cause for concern, especially amongst women. For example, the female literacy rates in Sokoto, Kebbi, Zamfara, Jigawa, Katsina, Bauchi and Niger States average one-quarter of the average for Ekiti, Imo, Anambra, Ogun and Lagos States. If the numbers do not tell us that we must embrace change, what else will? Whatever we have tried in the past have obviously not worked well. We must, however, also take responsibility for our past actions, recognizing that we have had leaders that have not been able to deal with these same problems since independence. State Governments clearly have a lead role to play in addressing these issues." UNQUOTE General O.A. Azazi, CFR National Security Adviser The Presidency Federal Republic of Nigeria

=================================================================================

(5)

Polio in 5 states worries FG

It is inconceivable that polio is still raging in the northern part of Nigeria in Borno, Kebbi, Jigawa, Kano, Zamfara, Sokoto and Yobe states due to ignorance and not accepting polio vaccination.

This non acceptance of the vaccine stems from disinformation and brain washing from local religious leaders.

Can I appeal to Nigerian Doctors especially those from the affected states to initiate a campaign to dispel these negative rumours about polio vaccine and protect the lives and health of these innocent children. SEO
News

By Daniel Idonor & Victoria Ojeme

The Federal Government, yesterday, condemned the polio status in the country, noting that Nigeria, in August 2011, recorded 26 cases of polio in six states in contrast to six during the corresponding period in 2010.

The affected states are Borno, Kebbi, Jigawa, Kano, Zamfara, Sokoto and Yobe. The cases mainly are due to the high number of unimmunized children as a result of refusal of the vaccine by some parents and caregivers as well as children being absent.

President Goodluck Jonathan, who disclosed this in Abuja during the national flag-off ceremony of the September 2011 sub-National Immunisation Plus Days (SIPDs) and launch of the Polio- free Torch Campaign, said, “I understand that in August this year, 26 children in six states across the nation were confirmed to have been paralysed by the virus. This is unacceptable”.

=========================================================================================

(6)

ANAMBRA AND INFACT IGBO STATE HAVE BEEN LEADING IN EDUCATION ENROLLMENT AND GRADUATION IN THE LAST 20 YEARS

March 31, 2012 | 2:09 am VANGUARD - EDUCATION AND SCHOOL ENROLLMENT

http://www.vanguardngr.com/2012/03/only-3-score-over-300-as-jamb-releases-results/


By Favour Nnabugwu


About 1,048,314 out of the 1,503,931 candidates who participated in this year’s Unified Tertiary Matriculation Examination, UTME, by the Joint Admissions and Matriculation Board, JAMB, passed the examination. Out of this number, three candidates scored the highest with over 300 marks.

JAMB Registrar, Prof Dibu Ojerinde, who made this known at a news conference in Abuja yesterday said that 181 candidates from Kaduna and Ikoyi Prisons were among those who wrote the examination, adding that malpractices were recorded in 52 centres across eight states in the country over which the results of 27,266 candidates in those centres were being withheld.


The JAMB Registrar noted that six southern states registered the highest number of candidates for this year’s examination. Imo led with 123, 865, followed by Delta- 88,876; Anambra- 84,204; Osun- 73, 935; Oyo- 71, 272 and Ogun with 71, 173.
Also, six northern states, including Jigawa- 11, 529, Kebbi- 7, 364; Yobe- 6, 389; Zamfara- 5, 713; Sokoto, 5,664 and FCT with 3, 380 recorded the lowest number of candidates just as other states fell within the average.

============================================================================

(7)

==Sept 2002


In the 10th of July, the Joint Admissions and Matriculation Board (JAMB) released the results of the 2002 Universities Matriculation Examination (U.M.E.). According to JAMB Registrar, Prof. Bello Salim, 1,007,326 had completed and returned their admission forms to the Board out of which 975,060 candidates sat for the examination.

Giving a breakdown of the entries, Prof. Salim said Imo State presented the highest number of 95,984 or 9.84 per cent of the total entry. Delta State is the runner-up with 80,448 or 8.25 per cent while Anambra State came third with 64,296 or 6.59 per cent. Edo, Ogun and Ondo had 61,897 (6.37 per cent), 54,272(5.6 per cent) and 46,592 (4.7 per cent) applicants respectively, to occupy the third to sixth positions. States with the lowest number of applicants for UME included Borno with 4,358 , Taraba with 2,934 , Katsina 2,530 , Kebbi 2,438 (0.24 per cent), Zamfara 2,169 (0.22 per cent) and Yobe having 1,178 (0.12 per cent). The entries of Imo and Anambra States alone
amounted to a total of 160,280 or 16.43 per cent of the total entry, with the remaining 34 states and the F.C.T. making do with the remaining 83.27 per cent.

It should be noted, for the sake of emphasis, that Imo and Anambra States are in South-East Nigeria while Igbos make up about a quarter of the population of Delta State and Rivers State. Igbos in Delta State can be found in Agbor, Anioma, Asaba, Ibuzo, Ndokwa, Ogwashi Uku,Okpanam, Oshimili, etc.
=======================================================================================
(8)

To: nigerianw...@yahoogroups.com; oduaa...@yahoogroups.com
From: JAdemis...@aol.com
Date: Fri, 9 Dec 2011 18:24:43 -0500
Subject: [NIgerianWorldForum] Re: Are the Igbos the best educated group in Nigeria?

Folks:

In reading the Obituary of Chukwuemeka Ojukwu in The Telegraph, December 9, 2011, I found this interesting assertion that "The Ibo...were the best educated group..." Is this statement true or incorrect? I would like to have some reactions from the forum or contributions from people with the accurate information and knowledge on educational attainments among Nigeria's diverse ethnic groups. My understanding is that the Yorubas are the best educated ethnic group in Nigeria. If this is not the case, I stand to be corrected. Then, which ethnic group is best educated in Nigeria? Where is the empirical data to support the Ibo claim or any other claim for that matter? Thanks.

Joel Ademisoye

============================================================================================
(9)
From: Rex Marinus <rexma...@hotmail.com>
To: nigerianw...@yahoogroups.com; igbo_...@yahoogroups.com; igbowor...@yahoogroups.com
Sent: Friday, December 9, 2011 7:05 PM
Subject: [IgboWorldForum] RE: [NIgerianWorldForum] Re: Are the Igbos the best educated group in Nigeria?

Ademisoye: I'll refer you to Paul Anber's essay "Modernization and Political Disintegration: Nigeria and the Ibos" published in the journal of Modern African Studies vol. 5, No 2 (Sep, 1967) 163-179. To be more specific see pp 171-172, and let me quote the relevant portion of Dr. Anber's essay:

"A system of Universal primary education was introduced in Eastern Nigeria in 1953, though the mission schools had already prospered in the Region long before then. Despite the fact that there was a requirement for limited contributory fees, education continued to be very much in demand. Even at the time when universal primary education was first introduced, the percentage of the population over seven years of age who were literate was higher in the East than in any other Region: East, 10.6 per cent; West 9.5 percent; North, 0.9 percent. Since 1959, the East has had more teachers and pupils than any other area of the country, with the heaviest emphasis on primary education. Figures for elementary and secondary education indicate that the approximate ratio of teachers to population in 1963 was 1 to every 1,500 in the East, 1 to every 2,500 in th West, and 1 for every 10,000 in the north. Other statistical data reveal how rapidly the standard of living rose among Ibos. The East had the most extensive hospital facilities in the country by 1965, the largest regional production of electricity in the country by 1954, and the greatest number of vehicle registrations by 1963. The economic orientation of the Ibos was also reflected through membership of credit associations: in 1963 the East had 68,220 individual members, the west 5,776, and the north a mere 2,407." His source was the Annual Abstract of Statistics ( Federal Office of Statistics, Lagos, 1965), Table 2.4, p. 14.

The situation has not changed radically since Paul Anber - except possibly the two years 1970-72. All you need to do even now is to go to the JAMB website and see university matriculation state by state, and compute it. There you have it.
Obi nwakanma

============================================================================================
(10)
FACTS ON EDUCATION IN THESE LINKS:
IN EDUCATION ENROLLMENT AND GRADUATION IN UNIVERSITIES IN NIGERIA FOR 5-10 YEARS
http://nigeriaworld.com/articles/2009/feb/101.html
===================================================================
(11)

Source: UNDP, Human Development Report: Nigeria, 1996-2010, pp.83
' It is clear that, on the whole, the conditions of life in Nigeria are very low indeed. With an overall Human Development Index (HDI) of 0.400, Nigeria ranked 137 out of a total of 174 countries in the world in 1993.4 However, low as the overall national HDI is, the HDI for most of the Northern States is still much lower than those for the rest of the country. If we take life expectancy at birth, we can see that whereas it is 61.4 years in Lagos and 60 years in Imo, it is as low as 36.6 years in Kaduna, 36.7 years in Bauchi and 37 years in Borno. In terms of adult literacy, the picture is even worse. Whereas nearly 76% of adults in Imo were literate in 1993, only 2.7% of adults in Sokoto and 10% in Borno were so categorised. The figures for Kano (12.1%) Niger (16), Gongola (26%), Benue (27), were equally very low. When we consider the other components of the HDI index such as real GDP per Capita, mean years of school and educational attainment, we shall see that, as the UNDP observed in 1997, the regional disparities in Nigeria are among the worst in the world. Observed the UNDP

===============================================================
(12)
ONITSHA MARKET REPORTS FROM LONDON ECONOMIST MAGAZINE
Dec 3rd 2011 | from the print edition

Africa rising After decades of slow growth, Africa has a real chance to follow in the footsteps of Asia

Dec 3rd 2011 | from the print edition

ONITSHA MARKET:http://www.economist.com/node/21541015

"THE shops are stacked six feet high with goods, the streets outside are jammed with customers and salespeople are sweating profusely under the onslaught. But this is not a high street during the Christmas-shopping season in the rich world. It is the Onitsha market in southern Nigeria, every day of the year. Many call it the world’s biggest. Up to 3m people go there daily to buy rice and soap, computers and construction equipment. It is a hub for traders from the Gulf of Guinea, a region blighted by corruption, piracy, poverty and disease but also home to millions of highly motivated entrepreneurs and increasingly prosperous consumers.'

ONITSHA MARKET REPORTS FROM LONDON ECONOMIST MAGAZINE
======================================================================
(13)

African Traders in Guangzhou, China: Routes, Profits, and Reasons

Yang Yang

The traders today mainly come from Nigeria, Ghana, Mali, Cameroon, Senegal, Kenya, and Tanzania. The majority are identified as Nigerian Igbo, who are mainly Christians from Nigeria・s eastern regions. Compared to their other African counterparts, these Igbo usually stay for longer periods in China and sometimes manage to open multiple shops in China, earning a reputation of being ―very good at business.‖My Igbo friends said that they had to be good at business to survive, ―If you want to know about Igbo, you need to know the history of the Biafran War‖ a Nigerian ethnic war in the late 1960s which resulted in the mass expropriations of Igbo wealth and property. ―We became the poorest ethnic group and we could not enter good entry-level jobs because we were discriminated against. So Igbo had to stand on their own feet and make profits from whatever possible means,‖one trader in Guangzhou said. Here is the story of another trader:
=====================================================================
(14)
Nigeria Minister of Finance Dr. Ngozi Okonjo Iweala visits Nigeria (Igbo Business Community in China)02/24/2012
Surprise and unexpected, Nigeria Minister of Finance Dr. Ngozi Okonjo Iweala visits Nigeria(IGBO) Community in China, at the famous (click to see pictures) Guangzhou Tangqi Shopping Mall.A business center occupied mostly by (IGBO) Nigeria entrepreneurs in the chocolate district of guang yuan xi lu.She was accompanied by the Nigeria Ambassador in China H.E Aminu Wali,the President of Nigeria and Africa community in China,Mr Emma Osita Ojukwu and a team of entourage.

She was highly welcomed as Nigerians and Chinese converged and greets her with loud ovation.It was a very brief historic visit, on addressing Nigerians, she encouraged Nigerians in china to be hardworking and law abiding. She also emphasized on the N50bn Job creation fund †You Win†, created by President Goodluck Jonathan, for the benefit of Nigerians home and abroad.

After the short briefing, she was escorted out of the Tangqi Shopping mall by her encourage. Its a night to remember and indeed a historic visit. I was chatting with friends at the mall when she visited, and luckily, I have my camera with me.Below are the pictures of her brief historic visit.
Her Excellency, we’re looking forward to see you again! Thanks for the visit!
Regards to President Goodluck Jonathan, we’re looking forward to see him in near future.

Welcome to “Civilized and Harmonious Guangzhouâ€
========================================================================
(15)

The Making of Nigeria’s Film Industry

By ANDREW RICE

Editor: Vera Titunik

Published: February 23, 2012
Published: February 23, 2012

NEW YORK TIMES - USA LEADING NEWSPAPER OF WORLD STANDARD

About 30 years ago, According to legend, the first Nollywood movie was made by a small-time electronics trader named Kenneth Nnebue, who, stuck with a large shipment of blank videotapes, decided to unload them by making a movie about a man who sells his soul for wealth. That movie, “Living in Bondage,” sold hundreds of thousands of copies and established Nollywood’s archetypal plot elements: martial discord, greed, a conflict between Christianity and juju, as the occult is called in West Africa. From these accidental origins, a cultural phenomenon emerged.

Other merchants, overwhelmingly members of Nnebue’s ethnic group, the Igbo, followed him into business. They literally made things up as they went, shooting movies in just a few days, based on vague scenarios instead of scripts. Directors approximated tracking shots by pushing their cameramen around in wheelchairs. Quality was shaky, but the buying public didn’t care. Between 1994 and 2005, production in Nigeria went from a handful of feature movies a year to more than 2,500.

Kenneth Nnebue quit Nollywood a few years ago, retiring to his village to devote his life to preaching the Bible. But the industry he established remains tightly controlled by the same group of Igbo businessmen, an insular guild sometimes called the Alaba cartel.

"“We created the industry,” Gab Okoye, a marketer who goes by the name Gabosky"

=========================================================================================================
(16)

NORTHERN RICH CITIZENS on display.

The truth is that Anambra surpasses the entire North West zone by any
standards of social measurement. Therefore, it is “Anambra versus the
North”. While Anambra is highly urbanized, the North West and the entire
North excluding the FCT are bedeviled by higher rural-urban drift because
of the primitive concentration of the business of governance in the
capital cities of the North. While educational opportunities in the North
are reserved for Northern elites like Ahmad El-Rufai, alms and religious
radicalism are reserved for the vast majority of their populations. When
the Northern elites want political power, they recruit this impoverished
majority into misconceived religious zealotry and after ascending to
power; they reward them with weekly feeding and chaplet incantations at
their palatial homes. While the real political slogan of these inhumane
elites is “take money or material things and give me power, but when I get
power, I will use my power to take my money back from you”, they
indoctrinate this majority with “God giveth and taketh power”Public Statement By Intersociety Nigeria

Public Statement By Intersociety Nigeria 06/12/2012

Anambra Versus The North: How Nasir Ahmad El-Rufai & Other Northern
Elites Underdeveloped & Impoverished Majority Northern Populations

"Mallam El Rufai doing what he does best getting drunk in a Bar with friends"

(Onitsha Nigeria, Wednesday, 13th day of June 2012)-In the Social Bond or
Control Theory of Travis Hirschi, social deviance including criminal
offending becomes uncontrollable the moment people are made to disconnect
from the core agents of socialization, especially the four areas that bind
them with the core agents of socialization, that is to say: involvement,
belief, attachment and engagement. The absence of the foregoing,
criminologically speaking, leads to social disorganization as we see it
today in the North.

Similarly, in the Strain/Anomie Theory of Emile Durkheim and Robert K.
Merton, when there is disconnect between cultural goals and legitimate or
socially approved means (when the two conflicts), a state of
“anomie”(alienation of self from society due to conflicting norms and
interests) sets in. When this state occurs, it results into five
categories of social conditions of: conformity, innovation, ritualism,
retreatism and rebellion. Those in the class of conformity accept the
cultural goals and legitimate means; those in the innovation accept the
cultural goals but use illegitimate means to achieve them; those in the
ritualism lose faith in cultural goals but feel obligated to work under
routines for legitimate daily life; those in the retreatism, such as drug
addicts, reject both cultural goals and legitimate means and transform
themselves into the dregs of the society; and those in the rebellion not
only reject both cultural goals and institutionalized means, but also seek
to redefine new values for the society through uprising and violence, i.e.
Boko-Haram uprising in the Northern Nigeria.

It is on the premise of the foregoing that we at the International Society
for Civil Liberties & the Rule of Law (Intersociety), decide to critically
evaluate the Nasir Ahmad El-Rufai’s assessment of the public governance in
Anambra State of Nigeria, titled: Anambra’s Budgets of “Mispriorities”,
which was widely published on 8th day of June 2012. This evaluation of
ours, therefore, is in the context of Anambra versus the North in terms of
soio-economic comparison. While it is a widely held view that Mallam Nasir
Ahmad El-Rufai, like other Nigerians, is entitled to his opinion, but his
opinion should not be expressed at the gross expense of Anambra State and
its People, especially in the context of returning the State to its former
pariah status, as a pariah member of the States of the Nigerian
Federation, which his piece tried in vain to do. As noted by many
respected writers including Barrister Daniel Elomba, the Ahmad El-Rufai’s
piece is fraught with utterly discredited facts and stranger’s
information. It is purely an assessment from outside observation, fed by
laptop statistics.

"I mallam El Rufai loves to lie ,it gives me height and makes me feel cool"

For instance, contrary to Ahmad El-Rufai’s position in his piece, Anambra
State has minimum rural-urban drift. Non- Anambra State citizens of Enugu,
Imo, Ebonyi, Abia States, etc vastly populate the State’s old urban areas
of Onitsha and Nnewi as well as some of the new urban areas in the State.
These brother and sister-citizens have also made an inroad into Asaba,
Delta State, where they built many residential houses and business
facilities. Also, contrary to Ahmad El-Rufai’s submission, Anambra now
has over ten urban areas of Onitsha, Ogbaru, Idemmili(Awada, Ugwuagba,
Obosi, Nkpor & Omagba), Nkwere-Ezunaka/Nsugbe, Ekwulobia, Oko/Umunze,
Ihiala, Awka, Igbariam/Umuleri/Aguleri, Ogidi/Abagana and Oba. Anambra
population is over 5million and not “4,2million” as he erroneously stated.
The State is highly urbanized and densely populated with commerce as its
major economic base, engaged in by over 70% of its adult residents.
Anambra State is also second to none in self-help development index with
evenly spread incomes per head. In old Onitsha and Nnewi urban areas, for
instance, three out of every five commercial multi-storey buildings, have
their own sunk bore holes. Also, sophisticated private hospitals adorn
many of these old and new urban centers. In terms of primary and secondary
schools, the number of government-approved private schools surpasses those
of government and missionary schools and they are evenly distributed among
the old and new urban centers and semi urban areas in the State.

The number of high and low rising commercial and private buildings in
Anambra State surpasses the total number of same, if any, in the seven
States of the Northwest geopolitical zone put together, from where Mallam
Nasir Ahmad El-Rufai comes from. As at 1997, there were over 200 private
large-scale industries in Nnewi alone. Presently, the major problem
hindering the industrial growth in the State is the power epilepsy, caused
not by the government and people of Anambra State, but by the Federal
Government (power is in the exclusive legislative list). Presently, there
are over 200 markets in the State alone and more are springing up. There
is no major industry in Nigeria that does not have a link to Anambra
State. Any item of legitimate human use is not in short supply in the
State. Forty-percent of the Internally Generated Revenues of Delta State
comes from Anambra State. Therefore, the State is typically a blue-collar
society and one of the juiciest sources of the police illicit enrichment
due to high carriage of cash or hand-to-hand cash transactions.

In terms of public governance, Ahmad El-Rufai ought to know that another
name for high self-help development index is “government made easy”, in
that a society with high self-help development records reduces the burden
of government in the provision of social services to its people. Anambra,
like other Southeast States, to a large extent, had two major set backs
before now; its post civil war challenges, which deprived its post-civil
war generations and their parents of conventional education, resulting in
its present adult population’s limited education especially among the male
adult traders, as well as the tragedies of the early 2000s when criminal
gangs took over the management of the affairs of its men and women.
Perhaps, the likes of Mallam Ahmad Nasir El-Rufai are still dwelling in
this past ugly history of the State per his recent lopsided assessment of
the State and its public governance, by utterly ignoring the great wind of
change in the State epitomized by the present popularly instituted
governance, which originated in March 2006.

EL RUFAI arrested by EFCC for fraud"Former Minister of the Federal Capital Territory (FCT), Mallam Nasiru El-Rufai faces charges of misconduct and abuse of office."

To govern well in Nigeria’s context and under a democratic setting, a
governor must not have identity or personality and moral bankruptcy. Very
importantly, he or she must not be an electoral robber and he or she must
have the hallowed electoral mandate of his or her people. There are four
conventional ways of sourcing funds for public governance in Nigeria, that
is to say: federation accounts receipts, internally generated revenues,
borrowings and local/ international grants or development funds. Among
these four core areas, borrowings are not socio-economically helpful
because of their devastating effects on immediate and future well being of
the affected State or locality. To this effect, we give it to the present
government of Anambra State, which has successfully resisted the borrowing
temptations in the past six years, unlike Imo State, for instance, that
has over N100Billion internal debts to its deficit. In the inglorious
epoch of Dr. Chinwoke Mbadinuju, a $10Million loan was secured from an
Egyptian bank, for the “building of an international market”, which was
never built. Another N650Million loan was secured from a Nigerian bank for
“the building of a stadium complex” in Awka, the State capital, which was
also never built, to mention but a few. The debt regime under the
illegitimate and unlawful regime of Dr. Chris Ngige remains utterly
sketchy. Today, these loans with hash conditions are part of the
$24.4Million still owed international lending institutions by the
government of Anambra State. In the four core areas of fund sourcing, the
government of Anambra State, under Mr. Peter Obi, has done well in the
international fund sourcing or development partnerships as well as in the
area of maintaining almost zero-borrowing culture both internally and
externally.

However, true to Ahmad El-Rufai’s observation, the government of Mr. Peter
Obi has failed woefully in the area of improving the IGR fortunes of the
State, considering its vast revenue potentials. This is due to weak
revenue generation mechanisms, which tend to favour illicit revenue
agents, sometimes backed by some corrupt officials of the government both
at State and local levels. This failure appears to have been necessitated
by bountiful international patronage enjoyed by the government as well as
the availability of the Local Government funds, used, under special
conditions, for the development of selected infrastructures in the
affected LGAs. Again, some of the deficiencies of Mr. Peter Obi’s
administration are poor maintenance culture, snail-speed response to
matters of urgent public importance, non-conduct of the local council
polls, armchair syndrome of some, if not many of his bookish top aides and
weak/ timely enforcement of law and other conventional social controls.

As for Ahmad El-Rufai’s criticism of the Anambra’s budgets and their
sectoral allocations, he missed the point frontally and logically. This is
because there exists legitimate and illegitimate budgeting. Budget is
legitimate when it is realistic and executable, not fat and theoretical
allocation with little or zero execution capacity. It is illegitimate when
it is bloated, loan and white elephant driven. It is better to have a
small and realistic budget than to have lofty, loan driven and
white-elephant budget. Apart from attention being given to over 20 active
gully sites in the State, our field team has also found that there exists
a rapid response team that timely checks the newly developed gullies in
parts of the State. On-going works on two of such young gullies at Uke
Community in the State is a case in point.

Still on Anambra Budgets, the present government enjoys two
“government-made easy” packages, one from the high self-help development
index and the other from international funding and development
institutions like UNICEF, EU, World Bank, UNDP, DFID, etc. For instance,
we have found that many of the 177 communities, over 1000 public/mission
primary schools and 258 public/mission secondary schools in the State now
have bore holes courtesy of European Union, UNICEF, etc. In Ogbaru LGA, 30
boreholes are being sunk in thirty strategic places. In all, there are 434
water projects done in the State, excluding those done by the State
Ministry of Local Government & Chieftaincy Matters. Bore holes under
MDGs(millennium development goals) are 186, UNICEF through RUWASSA are
154, 17 EU Water schemes, 71 bore holes from MPUWRCD, to mention but few.
This is in addition to high private borehole ratio per residence in the
State and attention being given to the State’s major water schemes in
Awka, Onitsha, Nnewi, Obizi-Uga, etc. State’s community/general hospitals
and health centers are not in short supply in the State. Most, if not all
of them are provided with boreholes. Conversely, it is very important to
point out that there are some boreholes, especially those sunk in hilly
and dry areas that are not functioning, either due to shady jobs by
contractors or difficult terrains. In the area of education, about 800
mission primary schools and about 42 mission secondary schools were
returned to their missionary owners (Catholic church-over 400, Anglican
church-over 300, etc), excluding the payment of their teachers’ salaries
and other welfare, which is still borne by the State Government, thereby
living the State with 261 public primary and 216 secondary schools. The
intent for returning the schools is for moral rejuvenation.

In the areas of roads, crime rates and other social services, Ahmad
El-Rufai also goofed. While many States still find it difficult connecting
one LGA to another, road-wise, Anambra has gone far beyond that. The 177
communities in the State are now divided into first class, second class
and third class communities in terms of link roads. All the 21 LGAs, first
class and second-class communities are easily accessible road-wise. The
third class communities and some important street roads in old Onitsha
urban like Iyiowa Odekpe/Odo-Rubber, Okpoko/Nkutaku, Awada, Ugwuagba,
Nkpor, Ogidi and Woliwo Layout/ Omagba Phase 11, are still begging for
government attention. Some of these areas are new layouts. Also, major
parts of the Onitsha-Enugu Federal Road, which is at the heart of the
State, are still an eyesore, except few parts that have been
rehabilitated. On the other hand, urban areas like Fegge, Inland Town,
GRA, Nsugbe 33 and Odo-akpu all in old Onitsha urban and major parts of
Nnewi have very good road network. Also, the Omambala area of the State,
which used to be utterly neglected, is being transformed. Igbariam/
Umuleri and Nsugbe/Nkwere-Ezunaka are the newest urban areas in the State,
which are part of the hitherto neglected areas of the State. Over 15
medium and large-scale bridges and their connecting roads have been
constructed across the State’s difficult terrains. Conversely, Awka is yet
to wear the deserved look of a modern State capital city, though many of
its old-fashioned roads are tarred as well as erection of some key public
infrastructures like State Secretariat, CBN, etc

In terms of access to justice, there are court of superior records (high
courts) in Onitsha (many sub divisions), Otuocha(serving the river-line
areas of Anambra East/West, Oyi and Ayamelum LGAs), Awka (many sub
divisions), Aguata, Nnewi, Ogidi and Ihiala. In the area of “ high crime
rates”, Ahmad El-Rufai lacks professional know-how in criminology and
security studies or related fields to understand what “crime rates” are
all about. Though street crimes including property crimes are normal in
blue-collar society such as Anambra State, which also provides job for
social control agencies, other than Northeast zone which is the most
crime-prone in Nigeria presently, it is difficult to pin point any State
as “being among those with highest crime rates”. Since Ahmad El-Rufai is
not a crime statistician, we wonder how he arrived at the lopsided
submission that Anambra has one of the highest crime rates in Nigeria,
especially taking into account “dark” and “gray” figures of crime
statistics as well as prevalence of white-collar crimes and crimes against
persons (prevalent in the North). To credibly assess crime rates, crime
must be evaluated holistically. What two white-collar criminals steal in
Katsina State in a month, for instance, may most likely outweigh the total
proceeds of property crimes generated in one year in the entire Southeast
zone by property criminals. Contrary to Ahmad El-Rufai’s submission, crime
is not restricted to “property crime” of armed robbery and hostage for
ransom.

From the foregoing, therefore, it is clear that Ahmad El-Rufai’s piece is
ill conceived and utterly political. It may have derived its motives from
the forthcoming 2015 political power games. The piece utterly portrayed
Anambra State and its People as backward, manifestly poor,
under-developed, crisis and crime-prone, and above all, a pariah partner
in the Nigerian Federation Project. By canonizing an electoral usurper and
thief, Mallam Nasir Ahmad El-Rufai is encouraging electoral roguery and
telling the Anambra electorates to always allow their hallowed electoral
mandate to be stolen by an electoral criminal gang. His piece ought to be
titled:” How Ahmad El-Rufai & Other Northern Elites Underdeveloped &
Impoverished the Majority Northern Populations” and not, “Anambra Budgets
of Mispriorities”.

NORTHERN RICH CITIZENS on display.

The truth is that Anambra surpasses the entire North West zone by any
standards of social measurement. Therefore, it is “Anambra versus the
North”. While Anambra is highly urbanized, the North West and the entire
North excluding the FCT are bedeviled by higher rural-urban drift because
of the primitive concentration of the business of governance in the
capital cities of the North. While educational opportunities in the North
are reserved for Northern elites like Ahmad El-Rufai, alms and religious
radicalism are reserved for the vast majority of their populations. When
the Northern elites want political power, they recruit this impoverished
majority into misconceived religious zealotry and after ascending to
power; they reward them with weekly feeding and chaplet incantations at
their palatial homes. While the real political slogan of these inhumane
elites is “take money or material things and give me power, but when I get
power, I will use my power to take my money back from you”, they
indoctrinate this majority with “God giveth and taketh power”

Therefore, in the North, the two theories aforementioned are utterly
suitable. The Boko-Haram uprising in the North is not only an “intifada”
against the Federal Government, but importantly, it is also an uprising
against the Northern elites, who mindlessly blocked social opportunities
for the vast majority of their people for more than 25 years they held
sway at the presidency. Today, the uprising is against the Federal
Government and its security establishments as well as Igbo-Christians and
non-Igbo Christians as well, but tomorrow, Northern elites may most
likely be joined. Ahmad El-Rufai’ s handling of the landed properties of
the Southeast people during his days as the FCT Minister, which made him
to reveal that”75% of the properties in the FCT are owned by the Igbo
people”, as well as the fate of the displaced local indigenes
(Gbagi-Gwari) may be a topic for another day. The foregoing, therefore,
is part of how the Northern elites including Ahmad El-Rufai
under-developed and impoverished the vast Northern majority. We wish to
submit that Anambra State is not poor, backward or socially disorganized,
and if the North is Mogadishu, then Anambra is Tokyo.

Even in the area of external borrowings and debts, Anambra State is among
the five least indebted States, whereas the North including the Ahmad
El-Rufai’s North West, is heavily indebted. Some insiders have also
revealed that the heaven will let loose if the internal debts profiles of
many States of the Federation including States of the North are made open.
The Nigeria’s Debt Management Office’s recent report of March 2012 has it
that the Southwest zone is the most indebted in terms of foreign debts,
with $810Million or N122Billion, followed by North West zone $458Million
or N67.9Billion, with Ahmad El-Rufai’s Katsina State owing $74.13Million
or N11Billion (Kaduna State owes $182.2Million or N27.3Million); followed
by South-south with $289.2Million or N43.6Billion; followed by Southeast
with $193.7 or N29.1Billion; followed by North-central with $190.2Million
or N28.7Billon; and followed by Northeast zone with $185.1Million or
N27.7Billion. The Federal Capital Territory-Abuja owes $36.84Million or
N5.5Billion. Anambra is in the fifth position among the five least
indebted States of Borno-$12.9Million or N1.9Billion, Delta-$15.4Million
or N2.03Billion, Taraba-$20.4Million or N3.06Billion,
Plateau-$20.43Million or N3.07Billion and Anambra-$24.4Million or
N3.66Billion, using the exchange rate of N150.00 per USD. The present
government of Anambra State is also reputed to have borrowed nothing
internally since 2006 except statutory controversial service pay arrears
owed the workers of State parastatals like State water corporation, State
printing company and the State-broadcasting outfit as well as the Federal
Government bonded zero-interest World Bank facilities for health-care
delivery in selected States repayable under soft conditions.

Finally, we must avoid the grave mistakes of running down our few
comrade-governors, who have come to serve their people, simply because of
certain primitive political interests. We have always maintained that
Lagos people are lucky to have Tinubu/Fashola as their governors, even
though they ran and still run government of budget deficits with
staggering foreign debts of $491Million or over N73Billion and undisclosed
tens of billions of naira of internal debts. Also, Edo people are lucky
to have Comrade Adams Oshomoile as their governor and Anambra people are
very lucky to have Mr. Peter Obi as their governor. Ekiti and Osun people
may be lucky too to have their governors. Governor Rochas Okorocha of Imo
State has the mandate of his people, but he must refrain from further
mortgaging the future of the State by reportedly being a loan seeking and
borrowing governor. Public governance requires towering personality
profiles, creativity and frontal initiatives. Therefore, all the 36 States
governors are not the same, comparatively speaking. Some are charlatans
with mechanical legitimacy. Others are hedonistic compradors, while the
remainders are creative and innovative governors with hallowed mandates of
their people.

Signed:

Emeka Umeagbalasi
Chairman, Board of Trustees
International Society for Civil Liberties & the Rule of Law
+234(0)8033601078, 234(0)8180103912
umeag...@yahoo.com, in...@intersociety-ng.org
======================================================================================
.(17)

RICHEST AND POOREST STATES IN NIGERIA

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Nigerian_states_by_GDP

List of Nigerian states by GDP

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search

The following table presents a listing of Nigeria's 36 states ranked in order of their total GDP (PPP) in 2007.[1]


RankStateGDP (PPP$)
1Lagos State 33,679,258,023
2Rivers State21,073,410,422
3Delta State16,749,250,544
4 Oyo State16,121,670,484
5Imo State 14,212,637,486
6Kano State12,393,103,864
7Edo State11,888,446,884
8 Akwa Ibom State11,179,887,963
9Ogun State 10,470,415,017
10Kaduna State10,334,763,785
11Cross River State9,292,059,207
12Abia State8,687,442,705
13 Ondo State8,414,302,623
14Osun State 7,280,597,521
15Benue State6,864,209,262
16Anambra State6,764,219,562
17Katsina State6,022,655,197
18 Niger State6,002,007,080
19Borno State 5,175,165,142
20Plateau State5,154,059,937
21Sokoto State4,818,615,261
22Bauchi State4,713,858,180
23 Kogi State4,642,794,262
24Adamawa State 4,582,045,246
25Enugu State4,396,590,769
26Bayelsa State4,337,065,923
27Zamfara State4,123,829,498
28 Kwara State3,841,827,534
29Taraba State 3,397,790,217
30Kebbi State3,290,847,166
31Nassarawa State3,022,828,885
32Jigawa State2,988,014,405
33 Ekiti State2,848,372,512
34Ebonyi State 2,732,472,739
35Gombe State2,500,467,306
36Yobe State2,011,499,081
- Federal Capital Territory5,010,968,012

Nigerian States From Richest To Poorest (ppp) - Politics - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Politics / Nigerian States From Richest To Poorest (ppp) (24389 Views)

=============================================================================================================
GOVERNOR PETER OBI REPLIES TO EL RUFAI
On Sat, Jun 9, 2012 at 11:24 AM, Oderaigbo <odera...@yahoo.ca> wrote:
I am surprised that somebody I am not sure has been to Anambra State even as a Minister comments about the State from the point of view of what I consider as pure, unadulterated ignorance. It is an insult to the Igbo race to openly or even remotely suggests that any part of Igbo land in the Nigeria we all know today should be considered as the poorest in the country. This negates our resourcefulness and ingenuity as a people. Honestly, I do not know what propels him or what interest he is protecting.
Peter Obi
Mazi Odera

Truth is our standard,accept it in good faith or
we shove it down your throat.The Choice is yours.
I am off but on

--- On Sat, 6/9/12, Oderaigbo <odera...@yahoo.ca> wrote:

Received: Saturday, June 9, 2012, 5:15 PM
GOV OBI REPLIES TO EL RUFAI

El Rufai’s Consolatory Piece on Anambra State
Valentine Obienyem
In his back page column in, hardly does he write without mentioning the name of Jonathan. He has since extended it to those he perceives as close to him. The likes of Dr. Okonjo Iweala and prof. Barth Nnaji have come under attack from his rude fist. It has become the madness of Rufus about Naevia. Rufus thinks of nothing else, talks of nothing else; and if Naevia did not exist, Rufus would be dumb. In what has turned into his usual pilgrimage of vituperation, he has often described the president in words that question his maturity.
His last piece of June, 8, 2012 entitled Anambra’s Budget of Misplaced Priorities was another piece that sought to stand logic, deep thinking, mature approach to issues and objective appraisalon their heads. I will take the issues he raised seriatim.
I do not have any problem with his voyage into history. Indeed, the basic facts about Anambra, both old and new and other related facts are among the treasures of history which children learn in elementary social Studies and Geography.
First of all, he talked of Gov. Obi as enjoying the title of being the youngest Chairman of Fidelity bank.El Rufai ought to know that being the Chairman of a bank is not a title in the manner he talked about it, it was earned. It takes people having confidence in one to make him a Chairman or a director in reputable companies. Has he forgotten that from one small bank, he raised it to one of the most efficiently managed institution in the country. With El Rufia’s orientation and inherent cantankerous nature, no serious business concern would consider him for board appointment.
El Rufai lamented that Anambra is witnessing increasing crime rate, infratsucture deficits, a number of strikes over minimum wage, higher tax burdens, and exodus of elite, among other challages. This is the height of unfairness.Anambra today is among the safest States in the country. Manufacturers Association of Nigeria, Enugu, Anambra Ebonyi chapter said so after their last meeting with the Governor at which they commended him for tremendous improvement on security. When the Ag., Inspector General of Police visited Anambra State, he said so and even went ahead to commend the Governor for his extra efforts at securing the State. In any case, States that have commercial value are more prone to crimes.
From the past when security agencies did not receive any form of support from the Government, Obi has donated excess of 300 vehicles, communications gadgets and other forms of logistical support to them. Today, each of the 177 communities in the State receives 500 Thousand Naira quarterly for security.
El Rufai talked glibly about deficit in infrastructure in a state that under Governor Obi just got her first Secretariats, the first library, over 600kms of roads constructed in six years. There are local Government Areas in the State such as Anambra East, Anambra West Ogbaru and Anyamelum that are enjoying road facilities for the first time since the State was created. Until Obi, secondary schools in the State, even those designated as science schools did not have functional laboratories. Today schools are rehabilitated in massive scale and provided with boreholes, buses, INTERNETS, among others. Today the Governor has rebuilt all the structures El Rufai’s party then, the PDP, burnt down in Anambra State. What then informed the talk about deficit of infrastructure? He even said that Anambra witnessed a number of strikes (how can one strike be called a number of strikes?) over minimum wage, when a little research will show him that Anambra is among very few States that are actually paying minimum wage. Today, unlike what used to be, Judges, magistrates, Permanent Secretaries own brand new cars.
Anambra , in spite of what Obi is doing, is not owing any financial institution. The State has not raised any bonds thereby avoiding enslaving future generation with debts.
In one paragraph he talked about Anambra’s high tax burden, while inanother, hetalked about Anambra as having not enhanced her capacity to collect its taxes. This is reminiscent of his contradictory nature.
El Rufai said that unemployment in Anambra was among the highest in the region.This is far from the truth. By nature, Anambra man is the most entrepreneurial person on earth. Everything being equal, he needs just a little push to succeed and that has been the case in Nigeria. I am sure that in his own State, apart from those enjoying sundry handouts from Abuja,Anambra people are the next set of people meaningfully engaged, especially in commerce.Talk about Abuja where he lives, over 50% of structures there are owned by Anambra people.
“The incidence of poverty in the State is very high,” thus spoke El Rufai. He went on to quote faulty statistics that has been adjudged as incorrect for so many incredibilities such as showing Anambra people to be poorer than the people form Yobe, Taraba and Sokoto. The poverty Profile Report of National Bureau of Statistics as published in the Punch newspaper of February 14th, 2012showed that Anambra State, with a poverty rate of 22% is the least poverty-stricken State. Long before that, the former Senior Special Adviser (SSA) to a former President on Poverty Alleviation, Dr. Magnus Kpakol, on the 31st of August, 2010, at the flag-off of the Payment of Poverty Reduction Accelerator Investment and Second Phase of the Care of the People – COPE, Programme by Governor Peter Obi said the Governor was over fighting poverty and wished other Governor could push as hard as he does. Hear Mr. Kpakol: “Gov Obi was the first Governor to visit my office to discuss how to fight poverty in his State and remained determined and dogged byinitiating effective economic empowerment programmes.”
In Nigeria today, everybody knows that the number of millionaires in Anambra are many times magnified than those in other States. Because Anambra people share the same quality of industry, wealth is more commonly distributed among them. This can even be glimpsed in their communal quips. So in the State one can hear people say: Esi bie aga be onye, O na enyem nni (Does he feed me), this is in contrast to El RufaiState where hundreds of people may actually be dependent on one benevolent Alhaji for feeding .
El Rufai lamented that under Obi, there is no efforts to expand the productive base of the economy of the State. This is pure incestuous analysis. Since Anambra was created, Obi has done more to expand the productive base of the economy of the State. On the 22nd of May, 2012 Obi held the last in the series of routine meetings with Manufacturers Association of Nigeria,Anambra, Enugu, Ebonyi Chapter. The meeting is held routinely for exchange of ideas between MAN and Gov.Obi concerning their activities in Anambra State. At the last meeting, The Chairman of the Association, Dr. Chike Obidigbo said Governor Obi had performed beyond expectations in fulfilling the promise to empower and encourage indigenous manufacturers. He noted that many of their members had benefited from government infrastructural development of industrial areas and expressed gratitude to the Governor for his high patronage of Innoson Vehicle Company at Nnewi and other products packaged in the State, noting that it is great morale booster to other investors.
Anambra State has purchased vehicles of over 2 Billion Naira from INNOSON. The last batch of the vehicles were commissioned in the premises of INNOSON as a way of marketing the industry to the world. Bt August he will also supply about 500 vehicles to the State. This is coming from a man that is doing nothing to expand the productive base of the State.
The foregoing is not enough, by August/ September this year,SABAmiller, the second largest brewer in the world with the market capitalization of close to 50 Billion Pounds, will commence production in Anambra, following what is today the biggest foreign direct investment in Nigeria of over 120 Million Dollars in a year. According to Mr. Peter Stuttard, the Business Development Manager of the company, 22.5 per cent share of the new brewery is owned byindigenous entrepreneurs, which consist of 10 per cent for Anambra State Government(The State under obi invested over 2 Billion Naira in the facility), while other private local investors have 12.5 per cent. Stuttard commended Governor Peter Obi for his ability to convince the company to come to Anambra.
Chief Executive Officer SABMiller PLC worldwide, Mr. Graham Mackay commended Gov. Peter Obi for making their investment in the state a reality. He said that what initially attracted them to Anambra because of the presence of strong government.
Many other companies are coming up in Anambra State, both, local and foreign more than any state in the country and yet El Rufai said it was one of the lowestfor ease of doing business.He may be misguided in arriving at this conclusion because almost Anambra people are holding serious commercial activities in all the parts of the country, including his State. But this is in the nature of Anambra people, they climatic adaptability enables them to thrive in all the parts of the world. This does not mean that they do not have people left behind doing business in the State. Most wealthy traders from other neighbouring States in the South-East ply their trade in Anambra.
It is on record, and I challenge El Rufai to verify it, that Anambra State has more bank branches than the entire South- East put together. What this shows in practical terms is that businesses thrive more in Anambra than in those other places. In 2006, Anambra had about three good hotels, today they are about 30. In appealing to statistics that suit his fancy, he suffers from the “fallacy of biased statistics.”
In holding that Anambra has many unexploited natural resources, El Rufai is making the same old mistake peoples of the world are no longer laying emphasis on. Japan has no natural resources neither does Singapore. The best resources any people will have are the human resources. Many years, Anambra was on the precipice. The basis of Obi administration is re-building the human infrastructure. The fact that Obi administration is re-building the human infrastructure does not mean it is unmindful of natural resources in the State.
To show you that El Rufai is only a pseudo researcher, he said that Government was not doing anything about the large deposit of crude oil in the State.What should be noted here is that Orient Petroleum was formed in 2001. They achieved nothing until Gov. Obi developed interest in it. This much was revealed by the Chairman of the company, Chief Emeka Anyaoku. He did so many things for them, including Anambra State investing 4 Billion Naira.As we speak the State Government has commenced the construction of the road leading to the facility for over 1 Billion Naira. What else does El Rufai thought a concerned government should have done?
The way he analyzed the budget of Anambra State and drew conclusion that by projecting the same internal revenues of 12 Billion Naira in 2011 and 212 was evident that something is wrong. It betrays him as somebody who does not even understand the rudiments of budgeting. This is often the sin of many analysts. If 12 Billion Naira was the projected estimate for 2011, was it achieved? Is it this year that it will be achieved? These are necessary questions a smart inquirer should have asked. I admire his parroting of Anambra budget figures, but it remains mere parroting if notanalyzed rationally.
Then the education sector.JAMB is one education body that has maintained clear statistics since it was established in 1977. Their statistics show that Anambra is usually among the first three in terms of number of applicants. The 2012 statistics shows that Imo came first, followed by Delta and then Anambra State.
In terms of commitment to education, Obi is clearlyamong the best. Apart from providing computers, lab materials, water, busesto schools in the State. When he found out that major part of the problem in education sector were caused by the takeover of schools, he returned them back to their owners and set aside 6 Billion for them for their rehabilitation, out of which close to 1 Billion Niara has been disbursed. . For this, the Pope, local bishops, the Primate were all full of commendation for him.
Before him, the State University did not have any infrastructure, today it has changed. At the Anambra State University he has constructed the Faculty of Law building, the Administrative Building, the Faculty of management Sciences, the School Library, among others.
In 2009, when Universal Basic Education Commission reviewed the performances of States on Education, Anambra was the no 1 in the entire South-East. By picking one statistics that may not be favourable to the State and ignoring others, El Rufai is guilty of the fallacy of improper statistics.
At the last World Bank Spring meeting 2012, Gov. Obi presented what the State is doing on education, he was lavishly commended.
Writing on health, El Rufai’s headaches was not what was achieved on that sector or what the sector used to be and what it is now, but the fact that only 1.4 Billion was budgeted for it. Let somebody tell him that everything is not captured in the budget and our health sector is one good example.Anambra State teaching Hospital with over 18 giant buildings is above that amount even as the State enjoys assistances from development partners that are not captures in the budget. Facts on ground show that before this government, no heath institution in the State was accredited, today two hospitals are accredited and many institutions such as the College of Heath Technology, Obosi and the College of Nursing and Midwifery in Nkpor, School of nursing, Iyienu and many others are all accredited. Hospitals have been built and rehabilitated, hospital equipment has been procured, various health programmes are implemented.
This year, for example, the Governor is funding 10 hostels in various missionary owned hospitals such as Our Lady of Lordes, Ihiala; Water side, Onitsha; School of Midwifery, Adazi, but they are not captured in the Budget. He attracted the new maternity Complex at Waterside, the construction is on-going. This year, Borromeo hospital Iyienu and Adazi got over 500 Million attracted by Government from development partners which are not captured in the budget.
The above is also applicable in the water sector where he lamented that the State Government budgeted only 800Million Naira. Anambra is working on many water projects with support from development partners and in such a situation, will a wise man not put more money in sectors that do not enjoy the same support, for example, the EU, UNICEF and MDG are all assisting in the water sector. Last years, MDG did 6 major town water schemes; this year, they are doing 8. UNICEF is providing water to 30 communities in Ogbaru, etc.
In Agriculture, the same scenario is playing out. There are sectors that are best developed with the involvement of private sector. El Rufai presided over privatization and ought to know that many things are better privately- driven. What Government is doing in Agric sector is to encourage private enterprises. Just recently, the State secured 1 Billion Naira loan for farmers. We also have projects such as FADAMA where government is committing close to 1 Billion Naira. It is not for nothing that Anambra FADAMA 111 is regarded as the best in the country by the World Bank.
On roads and erosion, El Rufia is not even worth listening to. Today, Gov. Obi is working on over 27 erosion sites, either on-going or completed. Some of them areat Ebenebe; Umudim, Nnewi; Umuchiani, Ekwulobia; Umuchu; Umeze Uga, , among others.
Disguising as a genuinely concerned crusader, El Rufai advised the government of Peter Obi to cut down on the sizeand cost of Governance. The sad implication of this is that Obi spend more money on governance. It is this singular line that exposed him as being after something else. How can somebody say this about Governor Obi? Obi has successfully cut the cost of governance in the State by 40%. Each year, he under utilizes the money for his office. In terms of security vote, it has remained the same since 2006 shortly before he became governor, in spite of the fact that he does visible, verifiable things with it.
By El Rufai’s viewpoint, he was being true to character. An opportunist and an inconsistent character that he is, he once considered Atiku a saint only to treat him as a sinner when the chips were down.Today, he speaks about him unrestrainedly, the same for Gen. Buhari, late President,Alhaji Musa Yar’Adua. Shall we sample him using just Yar-Adua?
“Yar'Adua comes from a tradition of high reverence for public service. I knew him more than three decades ago. While I was entering Barewa College , he was in the final year. Then, he was our House Captain, a leader right from his school days. I put my name and credibility on the line to say that Yar'Adua is the most honest governor in Nigeria. This can be judged by his achievements. People have to review what Governor Yar'Adua has done in the last eight years. Then, they will discover he has done excellently well unlike most of the state governors we have in the country today.” This is El Rufai, when he was campaigning for him to become President. When Yar’ Adua failed to appoint him a Minister, he described him in terms fit for renegades, calling him a complete failure both in business and governance. He spoke about his irresponsible smoking habits, his insubordination to school authority and many more.
Whenever something is at stake El Rufia takes leave of his reason and act unbecomingly.What he is doing in Anambra State is trying in his own little way to deal with APGA government in the State since his party, CPC and ACN are discussing about going into alliance .
It is strange that Thisday newspaper, in its collective wisdom said in its paper of May 31, 2012 that Obi is the 4th best performing governor in the country. For El Rufai to still went ahead and write his piece means it is either Thiday as an institution is right and El Rufia wrong or vice versa.
If we turn away from this gale people like El Rufai enjoy raising, we find quieter but more inspiring scenes: Peter Obi clearing the areas of pension, building over 20 bridges as nobody has attempted doing in the Sate, recording breakthrough in erosion control , sustaining the culture of prudence. What else do you expect from him? This is perhaps the reason why he told me that he did not read the articles of people like El Rufai, who believing themselves to be geniuses lack the humility to understand essence of things.
Going by the havoc El Rufai does with his pen and how he disrespectfully writes about the President, he was not so hard in his voyage of fancy about Gov. Obi, Therefore I consider his piece as even consolatory.
Mazi Odera

Truth is our standard,accept it in good faith or
we shove it down your throat.The Choice is yours.
I am off but on
==================================================================================================
Sunday,10 June 2012 00:00 From Uzoma Nzeagwu, Awka News - National GUARDIAN NEWSPAPER
ANAMBRA State Governor, Mr. Peter Obi, yesterday debunked the former FCT Minister,Nasir El-Rufai’s claim
Says Former Minister Hasn’t Visited Anambra
ANAMBRAState Governor, Mr. Peter Obi, yesterday debunked the former FCT Minister,Nasir El-Rufai’s claim in a national daily (not The Guardian), that the State’s2012 Budget failed to address his concerns over alleged poverty level of thecitizens, who he (El-Rufai) said were the poorest in the Southeast.
El-Rufaihad, in the said publication, described the State’s 2012 Budget as that of“misplaced priorities,” stating, among other things, that Anambra was thepoorest state in the country, education nally backward, lacked priorities andsuffered from poor infrastructural development.
ButObi attributed the allegation to lack of understanding, by the former FCT Minister,of the state, its economy, politics and people.
Hetold probing journalists, in Awka, that only those who had not been to thestate and who had poor knowledge of its recent history could say anything closeto El-Rufai’s opinion. According to him, his administration had nothing to hideand had always been open to assessment, which was why the state became thefirst in the country to hold peer review mechanism where it threw its doorsopen to independent assessors.
“I amsurprised that somebody I am not sure has been to Anambra State, even as aMinister, comments about the State from the point of view of what I consider aspure, unadulterated ignorance.
“It isan insult to the Igbo race to openly or even remotely suggests that any part ofIgbo land in the Nigeria we all know today should be considered as the poorestin the country. This negates our resourcefulness and ingenuity as a people.Honestly, I do not know what propels him or what interest he is protecting,”Obi said.
Insistingthat only the indigenes of the State could properly assess his performance, theGovernor said:
“I amsurprised that somebody I am not sure has been to Anambra State, even asMinister, comments about the State from the point of view of what I consider aspure, unadulterated ignorance. It is an insult to the Igbo race to openly oreven remotely suggest that any part of Igbo land in the Nigeria we all knowtoday should be considered as the poorest in the country.
“Thisnegates our resourcefulness and ingenuity as a people. Honestly, I do not knowwhat propels him or what interest he is protecting,” the Governor said.
Restatinggovernment’s commitment to achieving the Millennium Development Goals (MDGs),Obi gave the assurance that his administration would sustain the pace of developmentalprojects in the State.
Obisaid he had laid proper foundation for the solid growth of the state from anear zero situation when he assumed office six years ago.
‘Weneed people to help to assess and validate what we’re doing. We’re on course andwe’re doing the right things,’ Obi stated, noting what was happening now wasnot a surprise as those who lived off the old order were averse to the changeshe was introducing and so were kicking against it.
TheGovernor recalled some of his revolutionary strides “manifesting in the statehaving the best road network in the country and the education and healthsectors receiving unparalleled development.”
Heparticularly recalled the handover of schools to their former missionary ownersas well as the take-off grant of N6 billion for their infrastructuraldevelopment, a feat that was replicated in the health sector with handover ofhospitals to mission schools.
Heregretted that some people preferred to “sit in the comfort of their homes tocomment on what they did not know and not making any effort to know.”
Meanwhile,a community Leader in the State, Chief Anthony Agidigbo Oguejiofor, hascommended what he referred to as Obi’ s efforts to re-position education in theState through a revolutionary approach.
Accordingto him, the return of schools to Churches is “ rare and courageous decisionthat past Governors didn’t have the courage to take until Gov. Obi did.”
In astatement issued yesterday, Oguejiofor said: “Because of all that he isdoing in the education sector, various organisations, including the World Bank,has taken interest in his activities.” He described the development aspositive, evidence that “the State is truly the light of the country.”
Hesaid the “strides” recorded by Obi’s administration in education had caught theinterest of the World Bank, which is currently set to carry out a special studyon Obi’s collaboration with churches on education and healthcare delivery.
Followingthe initial meeting in London, at the instance of the World Bank and the OxfordUniversity, London, with which the World Bank is collaborating, the team is setto carry out special study on how the State was able to collaborate withChurches on education and healthcare delivery.
TheGovernor had returned over 700 primary schools to their original owners, thechurches, with N6 billion set aside as grants for rehabilitation. Obi had alsoreleased over N1billion with the second tranche to be released after thechurches came up with their work plans on how the rehabilitation would beundertaken.
=====================================================================================================================
Category: Nasir El-Rufai
Published on Thursday, 07 June 2012 23:36
Written by Nasir Ahmad El-Rufai
our budgetary analysis with the South Eastern state of Anambra
    We continue our budgetary analysis with the South Eastern state of Anambra, with a view to analyze how the state’s budget plans to address development challenges within the state. The state is bounded by Delta to the west, Imo to the South, Enugu to the east, and Kogi to the North. It has a total land mass of 4,416 sq km, is

    situated on the eastern side of the River Niger and has 21 local government areas, its major towns are Awka its capital city, the commercial town of Onitsha, and the industrial city of Nnewi. Anambra has a population of 4.2m and is the 9th most populous nationwide. Most of Anambra’s population is rural. However, as is with every major state, rural-urban migration poses serious burdens for the state’s resources. This pressure is evident in the commercial city of Onitsha where amenities like decent housing, potable water and electricity are in short supply.

    Old Anambra state was created in 1976 from part of the East Central State, and its capital was Enugu. Following further state creation in 1991, it was divided into two new states, Anambra and Enugu. Anambra now has its capital in Awka. Mr. Peter Obi (APGA) is the current governor of the state, who resumed office in March 2006, after the removal of Dr Ngige by a Court of Appeal judgment in Enugu after it ruled that Ngige’s election in 2003 was defective. Obi was impeached in November 2006, but was reinstated in February 2007 after the impeachment was overturned. Although a fresh election was held in April 2007, he returned to office in June 2007 after a court ruling decided that he should be allowed to complete a four year term. He was re-elected for a second term on 6 February 2010.

    Peter Obi has a BA degree in Philosophy from the University of Nigeria Nsukka (1984) and enjoys the title of being the youngest Chairman of Fidelity Bank. Considering Mr. Obi’s career achievements, and the fact that he has been to the Supreme Court successfully three times to reclaim his electoral mandate, the people had high hopes that he would improve on the stellar performance of Dr. Chris Ngige, sadly, this has not been the case, as his administration has seen increasing crime rate, infrastructure deficits, a number of strike actions over minimum wage, higher tax burdens, and exodus of elites, among other challenges.

    Unemployment rate in Anambra is among the highest in the South East zone, at 21.3%, it is higher than the national average of 21.1%. Imo’s unemployment rate is 29.9% and Enugu is 15%. The state has tried to reduce unemployment through its Anambra Integrated Development Strategy (ANIDS) and the Anambra Youth Reorientation and Empowerment Program (ANSYREP), but the problem with these programs is that they contribute very little to the production base of the state.

    The incidence of poverty in the state is very high – actually disappointing. The South East has a food poor incidence of 41.0% of which 60.9% is absolutely poor, while 66.5% is relatively poor and 56.8% live under a dollar a day. Anambra has a poverty index of 22.8%, the third highest in the South East, and shares the 6th lowest position in Nigeria with Rivers State which also has 22.8%. About 47.6% of the state’s population is core poor, 45.0% is moderately poor and only 7.4% of the state’s population is classified as none poor. Income inequality as measured by changes in Gini co-efficient between 2003 and 2010 increased slightly by 7.6% as against 18.1% for Ebonyi and Enugu states 7.5% increase.

    The people of Anambra state are known to be brilliant, enterprising and resourceful. Most of Nigera's brightest professors, writers, public servants and politicians hailed from the state. One would expect that given this enterprising spirit, the state would create conditions conducive to innovation, business and development. This is not the case, out of the five South Eastern states, Anambra has the fourth lowest ranking for ease of doing business; it was at a distant 35th position out of the 36 states and FCT in 2010. Starting a business involves nine procedures that may span 39 days. Enugu with the best doing business ranking in the zone takes the 30th position of the 36 states, while Imo is ranked 36, as the most difficult state to do business both in the South East and nationally.

    Anambra State is not much endowed with mineral resources and the few known to exist are not exploited. For example, Tungsten at Oba, and large deposits of lignite in Onitsha, Idemili, and Nnewi LGAs are yet to be exploited. Kaolin is mined in the Ukpor lhembosi axis for the ceramic industry at Umuahia in Abia State; while the deposits at Afuleri are not exploited. Sandstones of Ameke Formation are quarried in several places, particularly at Abagana and Nsugbe for construction purposes. Natural gas has been discovered at Ebenebe Ridge, southeast of Ebenebe town, and preliminary prospecting indicates that crude oil exists in commercial quantities in the state. Cash Crops in the state include coco yam, cassava, rice, maize and oil palm.

    The 2012 budget for the state is N82.5bn as against N66.9bn in 2011, representing a 23.2% increase. N46.8bn (57%) is apportioned for capital expenditure, and N35.7bn (43%) is for recurrent expenditure. Analyzing the recurrent budget further, N9.2bn or (26%) is set aside for Consolidated Revenue Fund Charges, N16.3bn (45%) for personnel costs, N7.4bn (21%) for overhead costs and N2.8bn (8%) as subvention to parastatals/ tertiary institutions. Anambra’s total IGR for 2012 is projected at N12bn, the same figure as was projected in 2011. This means, while its expenditure has increased, the state has not enhanced its capacity to collect or expand its tax base.

    The two major contributors to IGR in 2012 will be N6.7bn from taxes and about N4bn from fines and fees. If this IGR is measured against the states projected personnel costs of N16.3bn, Anambra cannot pay its staff salaries without reliance on federal allocation; this means it is one of those ‘dependent’ states and is not economically viable for independent existence.

    The 2012 budget will be funded by projected capital receipts of N47bn, N12bn as IGR and N36bn as FAAC allocations, bringing total revenues to a sum of N95bn, out of which N12.3bn would be transferred to Capital Development Fund. In sectoral terms, N28.2bn (34.2%) is allocated to the economic sector, N24.2 bn (29.4%) to the social sector, N9.7bn (11.82%) for the environmental sector and N20.2bn (24.52%) for general administration.

    The education sub sector is allocated N10.99bn. Anambra state has a longstanding reputation of being an educationally advanced state: it has at least 9 institutions of higher learning, its literacy rate is comparatively high, in a 2010 NBS literacy survey, youth literacy in the state was said to be 92.9%, adult literacy at 74.0%. However, compared to its South East Neighbors, the state has the third lowest adult literacy amongst the 5 states, Abia has 78.2%, Imo 80.8%, Enugu with 64.6% and Ebonyi with 69.8%, this means that in education terms, Anambra is performing poorer than most other states in its region. From this regional perspective, it means investment in education urgently needs attention and ought to be ramped up.

    A meager N1.4 billion is budgeted for health, and considering that health should be the core focus of any state government, this amount is barely adequate. From this sum, it is evident that the government has misplaced priorities, apportioning only 1.7% of the entire budget to a sector that directly affects the livelihood of all of its populace.

    Another major problem of the state is roads and soil erosion. In a bid to tackle this, the government apportioned N10bn to continue the construction of several intra-state highways and bridges, targeting the completion of about 100km of roads this fiscal year. However, only N1.696bn is allocated for drainage, erosion control and sewerage. This we believe would not address the challenges in that area.

    Water supply which also is a major problem will get only N800m: of this sum, it is hoped that expansion works on major water schemes would be carried out, and new ones built. This sum is little, and may not amount to much improvement in water supply in the state.

    Agriculture is apportioned N1.4bn, an evidence of misplaced priorities: with figures like these, it is no surprise that unemployment in the state is high. How can a state government allocate only 1.7% of its entire budget to agriculture in a rural state?Unemployment can be tackled effectively with agriculture if the value chain challenges in food and cash crops production are tackled.

    The housing sub sector will get N1.8bn, the government plans to partner with the private sector in providing more residential accommodation, a core focus will be on completing all existing projects. This is commendable.

    What is clear from this analysis is that Anambra state like most states of the federation is not allocating funds to adequately address the key social challenges that confront its people. Anambra state should slim down the size and cost if its government, learn to prioritize its budget allocations, expand its revenue base from taxes by attracting federal government and private sector participation in mineral exploration, improve its business climate by easing the starting and running of a business

    Anambra state like other south-east states must address the security challenges arising from violent crimes and kidnapping that have scared the elites and investors from the state. The state should leverage its human resources by refocusing the priorities of government on SME and industrial development, investing in infrastructure, agriculture and human capital. Anambra needs to capitalize on the enterprising nature of its people by tackling unemployment, poverty and infrastructure deficits. Until that time, Anambra will remain a state with big prospects and very little growth.

    Sad Sunday.....

    I wish to join fellow country men and women in commiserating with all those that lost loved one, friends and family members in the Dana Air plane crash of Sunday 3rd June. I knew some of the deceased very well. Shehu Sa'ad was a year my junior in Barewa College, an accomplished banker and perfect gentleman. Falmata Mohammed, sister to my Barewa class monitor, Group Captain Aliyu Mohammed (Retired) was a kind and gentle soul. Mrs. Fatima Abubakar, a colleague of mine since the days I worked in the BPE lost her daughter, while another Barewa Old Boy and elder brother Shehu Kaikai lost his daughter. Dr. Usman Bugaje's brother Idris lost two daughters. May their souls rest in perfect peace, Amen. We hope that this disaster amounts to a wake-up call for strengthening regulatory oversight in our aviation sector. Out of every N25,000 we pay for our air tickets, at least N11,000 goes to government coffers - which funds ought to be used to ensure safe skies for Nigerians. Sadly, it is contracts-and-patronage galore with little attention to passenger convenience and safety. This must change.

    .....and Joyful Friday....

    As you read this, we will be joining many elders, leaders, friends and well-wishers in witnessing the turbaning of my friend, brother and one that can-do-no-wrong in my eyes - Sanusi Lamido Sanusi - as the new Dan-Maje of Kano. It is a title for princes, reserved only for sons and grandsons of deceased Emirs of Kano, and cannot be acquired in any other way. We are grateful to His Royal Highness, Sarkin Kano Alhaji Ado Bayero for honoring one of our own, one of the best and brightest of our generation, and without doubt the best-performing public servant in the otherwise incompetent Jonathan administration. May Allah continue to Protect the highly respected Emir of Kano, his Dan-Maje and the Emirate Council for Sanusi's recognition, and guide them all to achieve greater heights for Kano and Nigeria.

    Nigerian States From Richest To Poorest (ppp) by Ikengawo: 9:11am On Aug 18, 2010
    Rank State GDP (PPP$)

    1 Lagos State 33,679,258,023

    2 Rivers State 21,073,410,422

    3 Delta State 16,749,250,544

    4 Oyo State 16,121,670,484

    5 Imo State 14,212,637,486

    6 Kano State 12,393,103,864

    7 Edo State 11,888,446,884

    8 Akwa Ibom State 11,179,887,963

    9 Ogun State 10,470,415,017

    10 Kaduna State 10,334,763,785

    11 Cross River State 9,292,059,207

    12 Abia State 8,687,442,705

    13 Ondo State 8,414,302,623

    14 Osun State 7,280,597,521

    15 Benue State 6,864,209,262

    16 Anambra State 6,764,219,562

    17 Katsina State 6,022,655,197

    18 Niger State 6,002,007,080

    19 Borno State 5,175,165,142

    20 Plateau State 5,154,059,937

    21 Sokoto State 4,818,615,261

    22 Bauchi State 4,713,858,180

    23 Kogi State 4,642,794,262

    24 Adamawa State 4,582,045,246

    25 Enugu State 4,396,590,769

    26 Bayelsa State 4,337,065,923

    27 Zamfara State 4,123,829,498

    28 Kwara State 3,841,827,534

    29 Taraba State 3,397,790,217

    30 Kebbi State 3,290,847,166

    31 Nassarawa State 3,022,828,885

    32 Jigawa State 2,988,014,405

    33 Ekiti State 2,848,372,512

    34 Ebonyi State 2,732,472,739

    35 Gombe State 2,500,467,306

    36 Yobe State 2,011,499,081



    - Federal Capital Territory 5,010,968,012
    Re: Nigerian States From Richest To Poorest (ppp) by paddy_lo(m): 1:45pm On Aug 18, 2010
    I feel Enugu and Anambra should be higher. . .

    In Anambra,a lot of informal business goes on in the markets and manufacturing of car parts. .
    cool
    Re: Nigerian States From Richest To Poorest (ppp) by Nchara: 1:52pm On Aug 18, 2010
    This from Wiki? Perception is not reality, indeed.
    Re: Nigerian States From Richest To Poorest (ppp) by Adonike: 2:08pm On Aug 18, 2010
    This is just the fact!
    Re: Nigerian States From Richest To Poorest (ppp) by Mobinga: 2:11pm On Aug 18, 2010
    Ikengawo:

    Rank State GDP (PPP$)

    1 Lagos State 33,679,258,023

    2 Rivers State 21,073,410,422


    36 Yobe State 2,011,499,081



    - Federal Capital Territory 5,010,968,012

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Nigerian_states_by_GDP
    @Yobe: grin grin grin grin grin lwkmd

    @ Rivers: angry angry angry silly Country!! I'm currently running my generator angry angry
    Re: Nigerian States From Richest To Poorest (ppp) by Ikengawo: 5:44pm On Aug 18, 2010
    like you would in any other part of nigeria?
    Re: Nigerian States From Richest To Poorest (ppp) by philip0906: 5:47pm On Aug 18, 2010
    Ikengawo:

    Rank State GDP (PPP$)

    1 Lagos State 33,679,258,023

    2 Rivers State 21,073,410,422

    3 Delta State 16,749,250,544

    4 Oyo State 16,121,670,484

    5 Imo State 14,212,637,486

    6 Kano State 12,393,103,864

    7 Edo State 11,888,446,884

    8 Akwa Ibom State 11,179,887,963

    9 Ogun State 10,470,415,017

    10 Kaduna State 10,334,763,785

    11 Cross River State 9,292,059,207

    12 Abia State 8,687,442,705

    13 Ondo State 8,414,302,623

    14 Osun State 7,280,597,521

    15 Benue State 6,864,209,262

    16 Anambra State 6,764,219,562

    17 Katsina State 6,022,655,197

    18 Niger State 6,002,007,080

    19 Borno State 5,175,165,142

    20 Plateau State 5,154,059,937

    21 Sokoto State 4,818,615,261

    22 Bauchi State 4,713,858,180

    23 Kogi State 4,642,794,262

    24 Adamawa State 4,582,045,246

    25 Enugu State 4,396,590,769

    26 Bayelsa State 4,337,065,923

    27 Zamfara State 4,123,829,498

    28 Kwara State 3,841,827,534

    29 Taraba State 3,397,790,217

    30 Kebbi State 3,290,847,166

    31 Nassarawa State 3,022,828,885

    32 Jigawa State 2,988,014,405

    33 Ekiti State 2,848,372,512

    34 Ebonyi State 2,732,472,739

    35 Gombe State 2,500,467,306

    36 Yobe State 2,011,499,081



    - Federal Capital Territory 5,010,968,012

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Nigerian_states_by_GDP
    @ekiti
    grin grin grin
    But I think enugu should be ranked higher
    Re: Nigerian States From Richest To Poorest (ppp) by Aigbofa: 5:55pm On Aug 18, 2010
    philip0906:

    @ekiti
    grin grin grin
    But I think enugu should be ranked higher


    Why are you so excited about Ekiti and not Yobe. Ekiti is a very small state, you know!
    Re: Nigerian States From Richest To Poorest (ppp) by philip0906: 6:00pm On Aug 18, 2010
    Aigbofa:


    Why are you so excited about Ekiti and not Yobe. Ekiti is a very small state, you know!
    nah. . .d thing just funny 4 my eye grin grin
    Re: Nigerian States From Richest To Poorest (ppp) by Beaf: 6:07pm On Aug 18, 2010
    Nchara:

    This from Wiki? Perception is not reality, indeed.

    It might be from Wikipedia, but the data is from https://www.cgidd.com/
    We condemn Wikipedia a bit too much, the reference section of the articles is always very valuable.


    1 Lagos State 33,679,258,023

    2 Rivers State 21,073,410,422

    3 Delta State 16,749,250,544

    Up Delta! We no de carry last! Small but mighty! grin
    If this was done by GDP per capita, na we or Rivers for carry first. . . and by a very very long shot! cool

    28 Kwara State 3,841,827,534

    Lol @ "agricultural revolution!"
    Re: Nigerian States From Richest To Poorest (ppp) by Abagworo(m): 6:14pm On Aug 18, 2010
    My state is no 5
    Re: Nigerian States From Richest To Poorest (ppp) by Sharon_f(f): 6:17pm On Aug 18, 2010
    All 36 states constitute 1 third world country.
    Re: Nigerian States From Richest To Poorest (ppp) by Aigbofa: 6:19pm On Aug 18, 2010
    Sharon_f:

    All 36 states constitute 1 third world country.


    You are wicked grin grin grin grin

    Just when people are starting to enjoy themselves!!!!
    Re: Nigerian States From Richest To Poorest (ppp) by Ileke-IdI: 6:19pm On Aug 18, 2010
    philip0906:

    nah. . .d thing just funny 4 my eye grin grin
    undecided undecided undecided undecided
    Re: Nigerian States From Richest To Poorest (ppp) by THE AMAKA(f): 6:20pm On Aug 18, 2010
    MY STATE IS NUMBER 5! grin


    Sharon_f:

    All 36 states constitute 1 third world country.
    embarassed embarassed embarassed
    Re: Nigerian States From Richest To Poorest (ppp) by Fhemmmy: 6:21pm On Aug 18, 2010
    To raise this GDP in states like Oshun, Ogun, Ondo and Kwara is so easy.
    Let them embrace agriculture and they will soon pass lagos
    Re: Nigerian States From Richest To Poorest (ppp) by philip0906: 6:21pm On Aug 18, 2010
    Ileke-IdI:

    undecided undecided undecided undecided
    y u dey twist mouth? huh
    Re: Nigerian States From Richest To Poorest (ppp) by Ileke-IdI: 6:22pm On Aug 18, 2010
    philip0906:

    y u dey twist mouth? huh
    huh huh huh


    @post
    What happened to the cocoa export in ekiti? undecided
    See what that bastard oni turned my state into.
    Re: Nigerian States From Richest To Poorest (ppp) by Aigbofa: 6:25pm On Aug 18, 2010
    Fhemmmy:

    To raise this GDP in states like Oshun, Ogun, Ondo and Kwara is so easy.
    Let them embrace agriculture and they will soon pass lagos


    The whole country should go back to agriculture! There's is no industrialized country that is not also a major agricultural country!!
    Re: Nigerian States From Richest To Poorest (ppp) by asha 80(m): 6:26pm On Aug 18, 2010
    Fhemmmy:

    To raise this GDP in states like Oshun, Ogun, Ondo and Kwara is so easy.
    Let them embrace agriculture and they will soon pass lagos

    I doubt it will happen because they are are not 'forced' to do so.
    Re: Nigerian States From Richest To Poorest (ppp) by na_so(m): 6:27pm On Aug 18, 2010
    which kind wayo be dis na? Abeg my state Bayelsa is too low. Abi una zone dis one too? grin
    Re: Nigerian States From Richest To Poorest (ppp) by Aigbofa: 6:29pm On Aug 18, 2010
    Ileke-IdI:

    huh huh huh


    @post
    What happened to the cocoa export in ekiti? undecided
    See what that naughty person oni turned my state into.

    Oni is not responsible for the state of agriculture in Ekiti, he can improve on it, but the decline started way before he came to office!!
    Re: Nigerian States From Richest To Poorest (ppp) by Ileke-IdI: 6:32pm On Aug 18, 2010
    Aigbofa:

    Oni is not responsible for the state of agriculture in Ekiti, he can improve on it, but the decline started way before he came to office!!
    He had two terms to fix the situation, but. . . .

    But what DID happen to the cocoa exportation?
    Re: Nigerian States From Richest To Poorest (ppp) by EzeUche22(m): 6:33pm On Aug 18, 2010
    My state is #12! angry

    Put us back into Imo State! I dun tire 4 d Orjis!
    Re: Nigerian States From Richest To Poorest (ppp) by THE AMAKA(f): 6:36pm On Aug 18, 2010
    EzeUche22:

    My state is #12! angry

    Put us back into Imo State!
    I dun tire 4 d Orjis!
    GOD FORBID! grin grin grin
    Re: Nigerian States From Richest To Poorest (ppp) by Fhemmmy: 6:38pm On Aug 18, 2010
    asha 80:

    I doubt it will happen because they are are not 'forced' to do so.

    I pray and wish that we would have leader that will force this people to make it happen.
    We have great lands and the manpower to make it happen.
    Re: Nigerian States From Richest To Poorest (ppp) by philip0906: 6:39pm On Aug 18, 2010
    EzeUche22:

    My state is #12! angry

    Put us back into Imo State! I dun tire 4 d Orjis!
    u 4rm Abia state?. . .d orjis have really ruined abia state,else we have d potential 2 be amongst d top 5
    Re: Nigerian States From Richest To Poorest (ppp) by Fhemmmy: 6:40pm On Aug 18, 2010
    philip0906:

    u 4rm Abia state?. . .d orjis have really ruined abia state,else we have d potential 2 be amongst d top 5

    Almost every state has the potential to be number one, only if we have leaders that have what it takes to make it happen, and leaders that are not there for their own pocket
    Re: Nigerian States From Richest To Poorest (ppp) by Le Stylo: 6:42pm On Aug 18, 2010
    Ikengawo:

    Rank State GDP (PPP$)

    1 Lagos State 33,679,258,023

    2 Rivers State 21,073,410,422

    3 Delta State 16,749,250,544

    4 Oyo State 16,121,670,484

    5 Imo State 14,212,637,486

    6 Kano State 12,393,103,864

    7 Edo State 11,888,446,884

    8 Akwa Ibom State 11,179,887,963

    9 Ogun State 10,470,415,017

    10 Kaduna State 10,334,763,785

    11 Cross River State 9,292,059,207

    12 Abia State 8,687,442,705

    13 Ondo State 8,414,302,623

    14 Osun State 7,280,597,521

    15 Benue State 6,864,209,262

    16 Anambra State 6,764,219,562

    17 Katsina State 6,022,655,197

    18 Niger State 6,002,007,080

    19 Borno State 5,175,165,142

    20 Plateau State 5,154,059,937

    21 Sokoto State 4,818,615,261

    22 Bauchi State 4,713,858,180

    23 Kogi State 4,642,794,262

    24 Adamawa State 4,582,045,246

    25 Enugu State 4,396,590,769

    26 Bayelsa State 4,337,065,923

    27 Zamfara State 4,123,829,498

    28 Kwara State 3,841,827,534

    29 Taraba State 3,397,790,217

    30 Kebbi State 3,290,847,166

    31 Nassarawa State 3,022,828,885

    32 Jigawa State 2,988,014,405

    33 Ekiti State 2,848,372,512

    34 Ebonyi State 2,732,472,739

    35 Gombe State 2,500,467,306

    36 Yobe State 2,011,499,081

    - Federal Capital Territory 5,010,968,012

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Nigerian_states_by_GDP

    SARAKI! YOU SEE YOUR LIFE OUTSIDE? WITH YOUR THIEF-THIEF AGRIC REVOLUTION. angryangryangry
    Re: Nigerian States From Richest To Poorest (ppp) by Kilode?!: 6:46pm On Aug 18, 2010
    Ileke-IdI:

    huh huh huh


    @post
    What happened to the cocoa export in ekiti? undecided
    See what that naughty person oni turned my state into.

    Yea, Oni and co are messing up, but Cocoa was never an Ekiti thing really, that was Ondo, and they took their Cocoa with them when Ekiti decided to split grin
    Re: Nigerian States From Richest To Poorest (ppp) by Fhemmmy: 6:48pm On Aug 18, 2010
    Le Stylo:

    SARAKI! YOU SEE YOUR LIFE OUTSIDE? WITH YOUR THIEF-THIEF AGRIC REVOLUTION. angryangryangry

    Lol . . . not only him, i think it is mostly all of them
    Re: Nigerian States From Richest To Poorest (ppp) by asha 80(m): 6:48pm On Aug 18, 2010
    It has more to do with the system of governance in nigeria rather than the whoever is the governor.

    Let there be a rule that all states must generate their resources to run the state and no revenue allocation from abuja and see things gradually taking shape.

    (0)(1)(2)(3)(4)(5)(6)(7) (Reply)


    Ayo Obe

    unread,
    Jun 14, 2012, 3:52:38 AM6/14/12
    to usaafric...@googlegroups.com, USAAfrica Dialogue, umeag...@yahoo.com, in...@intersociety-ng.org
    Is all this because el-Rufai critiqued the budget of Anambra State?  And what is it meant to prove?  That Anambra State is being run perfectly, with a perfect budget and therefore cannot accommodate any improvement?

    Or that if el-Rufai comes from a poor state with low education figures, he is not entitled to point out deficiencies - as he sees it - in the budget priorities of Anambra State?  Or that being, or having been part of the ruling class, he is no longer entitled to comment on public affairs in Nigeria?

    I am afraid that that would be a rather immature reaction.  We all have 'beams in our own eyes' yet we can still benefit from the perspective of other miserable winners.  Of course, there are some who think, for example, that the United States government ought not to comment on events in our own country or Africa, since it has a high murder rate or divorce rate, or large numbers of people living in poverty, or formerly engaged in the African slave trade, or supported Mobutu Sese Seko etc. etc. etc.  But does that make the ills or deficiencies about which comment or criticism is made vanish?

    Ayo
    I invite you to follow me on Twitter @naijama

    Eke, Maureen Ngozi

    unread,
    Jun 16, 2012, 9:56:32 AM6/16/12
    to usaafric...@googlegroups.com

    Shame! Shame! Shame! And, Boko Haram still thinks it has an argument about the corrupting or assumed corrupting and negative impacts of (western) education? Without the rest of Nigeria, what would the North look like or be? Except for the data, there is nothing new in this piece, since anyone who is seriously familiar with Nigeria would already have a sense of this disparity.  Why are these so-called scholars and “elders” of the North still not critical of Boko Haram?  Must we wait for only “academic” occasions to engage in such analysis? The irony is that the very education and structures which Boko Haram seems to abhor will help to safeguard the people, the group, and region Boko Haram claims to be protecting. How sad, indeed.  

    Peace

     

    Maureen N. Eke, PHD

    Professor of English

    AN 240

    Central Michigan University

    Mt. Pleasant, MI 48859

    Direct: 989-774-1087

    Main: 989-774-3171

    Fax: 989-773-1271

    Email: eke...@cmich.edu or Maure...@cmich.edu

    --
    You received this message because you are subscribed to the "USA-Africa Dialogue Series" moderated by Toyin Falola, University of Texas at Austin.
    For current archives, visit http://groups.google.com/group/USAAfricaDialogue
    For previous archives, visit http://www.utexas.edu/conferences/africa/ads/index.html
    To post to this group, send an email to USAAfric...@googlegroups.com
    To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to USAAfricaDialogue-
    unsub...@googlegroups.com

    Reply all
    Reply to author
    Forward
    0 new messages