Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.
Dismiss

An Unknown Map Symbol

29 views
Skip to first unread message

The Welsh Windbag

unread,
Feb 23, 2013, 6:42:14 AM2/23/13
to
I'm off to Titterstone Clee Hill for a map reading exercise soon. Looking at
the Explorer map for the region there is a symbol that I don't understand.

Starting at the mast at the radar station (SO 5981 7785) is a linear
feature, running anticlockwise, contouring around mostly near the 490 metre
contour, eventually climbing towards Giant's Chair after crossing the
(parish?) boundary.

I can't make out what the cartographer is trying to tell us about this
feature. From Google Earth it looks like a wide stone track.

Can anyone enlighten me, please?
--
Lyndon

Bob Douglas

unread,
Feb 23, 2013, 7:14:38 AM2/23/13
to
>"The Welsh Windbag" wrote in message
>news:9eSdnZt_F7aONrXM...@bt.com...
I think you may find it's the line of boulders forming the secondary
defences of the old hill-fort, as in the second picture here:

http://www.secretshropshire.org.uk/Content/Learn/Landscape/Defence.asp


The Welsh Windbag

unread,
Feb 23, 2013, 7:44:29 AM2/23/13
to


>"The Welsh Windbag" wrote in message
>news:9eSdnZt_F7aONrXM...@bt.com...
>I'm off to Titterstone Clee Hill for a map reading exercise soon. Looking
>at the Explorer map for the region there is a symbol that I don't
>understand.

>Starting at the mast at the radar station (SO 5981 7785) is a linear
>feature, running anticlockwise, contouring around mostly near the 490 metre
>contour, eventually climbing towards Giant's Chair after crossing the
>(parish?) boundary.

>I can't make out what the cartographer is trying to tell us about this
>feature. From Google Earth it looks like a wide stone track.

>Can anyone enlighten me, please?

"Bob Douglas" wrote
>I think you may find it's the line of boulders forming the secondary
>defences of the old hill-fort, as in the second picture here:
>
>http://www.secretshropshire.org.uk/Content/Learn/Landscape/Defence.asp

Thank you Bob. That is certainly consistent with the Google Earth image of
the area.
--
Lyndon

Phil Cook

unread,
Feb 23, 2013, 9:28:56 AM2/23/13
to
On 23/02/2013 12:14, Bob Douglas wrote:
>> "The Welsh Windbag" wrote in message
>> news:9eSdnZt_F7aONrXM...@bt.com...
>> I'm off to Titterstone Clee Hill for a map reading exercise soon. Looking
>> at the Explorer map for the region there is a symbol that I don't
>> understand.
>
>> Starting at the mast at the radar station (SO 5981 7785) is a linear
>> feature, running anticlockwise, contouring around mostly near the 490 metre
>> contour, eventually climbing towards Giant's Chair after crossing the
>> (parish?) boundary.
>
>> I can't make out what the cartographer is trying to tell us about this
>> feature. From Google Earth it looks like a wide stone track.
>
> I think you may find it's the line of boulders forming the secondary
> defences of the old hill-fort, as in the second picture here:
>
> http://www.secretshropshire.org.uk/Content/Learn/Landscape/Defence.asp

On the 50k it is shown like a field boundary on a 25k.

On the 25k, going by the key, it is a line of scree.

http://www.streetmap.co.uk/key/25k_English_Legend.pdf
--
Phil Cook

The Welsh Windbag

unread,
Feb 23, 2013, 11:01:23 AM2/23/13
to


>> "The Welsh Windbag" wrote in message
>> news:9eSdnZt_F7aONrXM...@bt.com...
>> I'm off to Titterstone Clee Hill for a map reading exercise soon. Looking
>> at the Explorer map for the region there is a symbol that I don't
>> understand.
>
>> Starting at the mast at the radar station (SO 5981 7785) is a linear
>> feature, running anticlockwise, contouring around mostly near the 490
>> metre
>> contour, eventually climbing towards Giant's Chair after crossing the
>> (parish?) boundary.
>
>> I can't make out what the cartographer is trying to tell us about this
>> feature. From Google Earth it looks like a wide stone track.

Bob Douglas wrote:
> I think you may find it's the line of boulders forming the secondary
> defences of the old hill-fort, as in the second picture here:
>
> http://www.secretshropshire.org.uk/Content/Learn/Landscape/Defence.asp

"Phil Cook" wrote
>On the 50k it is shown like a field boundary on a 25k.
>On the 25k, going by the key, it is a line of scree.
>http://www.streetmap.co.uk/key/25k_English_Legend.pdf

My first thought when I saw the Google Earth image was that it looked like
scree, but I thought the symbol used on the 25K map looked quite different
from the symbol for scree. That was when I started to get confused. On the
map it is just solid dots of varying size and instensity, where scree is a
collection of boulder symbols (open circles rather than dots). To me it
looks closer to the symbol for the edge of a gravel pit. I guess the
cartographer had to use the best symbol available to him to convey what was
there.

0 new messages