[transgendernews] [News][USA] Over half the nation will be covered by an equality law

4 views
Skip to first unread message

Meryl Sizemore

unread,
May 10, 2007, 8:40:05 PM5/10/07
to transgender_ne...@yahoogroups.com, transge...@yahoogroups.com, TNUKD...@yahoogroups.com, TGV_Ad...@yahoogroups.com
Gay People Chronicle - Cleveland,OH,USA
http://www.gaypeopleschronicle.com/stories07/may/0511071.htm
May 11, 2007

Over half the nation will be covered by an equality law

Map graphic <http://www.gaypeopleschronicle.com/stories07/may/map.jpg>

Almost a quarter of Ohio included;
TG measures will protect a third of U.S.

by Brian DeWitt

When the governors of three states sign new equal rights laws as expected
soon, over half the people in the nation will be covered by one that
includes sexual orientation.

Almost a quarter of Ohio’s population will be among them, although neither
state nor federal nondiscrimination laws protect lesbians and gays here.

In addition, a third of the U.S. population will be covered by a measure
that includes transgendered people, including some Ohioans.

In the last few weeks, legislatures in Oregon, Iowa and Colorado have passed
statewide LGBT equal rights laws, bringing to 20 the number of states that
have done so. All three state governors have said they will sign.

Most of these are broad measures covering housing, public accommodations,
loans, education and other areas. The Colorado law and one in Nevada are
limited to employment only.

Following the practice since the late 1990s, the three new state laws
include transgender people, either with the words “gender identity” or by
defining “sexual orientation” to include transgender status. With these, a
dozen states and the District of Columbia include transgender protections
along with sexual orientation.

The Vermont legislature voted last week to add gender identity to its
equality law, which would bring this number to 13. Gov. Jim Douglas is
reportedly willing to sign it, but he vetoed a similar measure last year.

The United States has about 300 million people; 299.4 million according to a
2006 Census Bureau estimate. The states with sexual orientation anti-bias
laws, along with D.C., hold 45% of this population. The ones that cover
transgender people have 28% of the population, again with D.C.

However, in the 30 states without a law, a growing number of people are
covered by local equal rights ordinances. There are close to 200 of these,
including almost all of the nation’s largest cities.

Eighty-six of the local codes also include transgender people.

Many of these local measures are in states with state laws. Outside those
states, a few more are in cities located in counties that also have one,
such as Key West in Monroe County, Florida.

Counting only the freestanding localities produces 78 that cover sexual
orientation, of which 48 include transgender people, either with “gender
identity” or some other language.

Adding these local populations to the state figures gives us over
half--53%--of the nation’s people covered by a “sexual orientation” law and
over a third--35%--by a transgender one.

2.6 million Ohioans are covered

While there is no state nondiscrimination law, 32 Ohio cities and villages
have ordinances that cover gay and lesbian residents and two of these,
Toledo and Cincinnati, include transgender people.

One city, Westlake, has a 1997 statement by its law director that the
existing fair housing ordinance applies to gays and lesbians. Canton’s law
director says that its job bias measure will be enforced to include
transgender people.

Summit and Cuyahoga counties, the city of Whitehall and the village of
Lordstown have equal job measures for public employees only. Dayton
reportedly has a policy that does the same thing, but nothing appears in the
city ordinances.

Codes in a dozen Ohio localities cover areas from housing discrimination to
employment and public accommodation, and one city will register domestic
partnerships. The protections for residents range from the Westlake opinion
to a unique 1996 Cleveland ordinance making job discrimination a
criminal--not civil--offense.

Another 20 towns are much narrower in scope, focusing on things like parade
permits or cable TV franchises.

The combined population of the Ohio cities whose “sexual orientation”
ordinances apply to their residents--not just city employees--is 2,649,119.
That’s almost a quarter--23%--of the state’s population of 11,478,006. The
two cities that include transgender people have 5.3% of the state
population.

Ignoring the narrow measures and counting only the ones on housing, public
accommodation or employment leaves just over a sixth of Ohioans covered,
17.76%.

Three Ohio cities once passed ordinances only to have them removed by
voters. An Athens measure passed in 1989 was repealed by voters the same
year, but a new measure was enacted nine years later. Wooster’s 1990
ordinance was repealed by voters that year and has never been restored.

Most famous of the three is Cincinnati, whose 1992 measure was voided a year
later when voters amended the charter to forbid it. City council repealed
the ordinance in 1995, but enacted a new one last year after voters repealed
the charter amendment in 2004.

Sources: News reports of measures passing, the Human Rights Campaign, Lambda
Legal Defense and the Transgender Law and Policy Institute. State and U.S.
populations are 2006 Census estimates; city ones are 2005 Census estimates
except New Orleans, which the agency recalculated post-Katrina in July,
2006.

==================

Local Ohio ordinances

The Ohio cities that have local housing, employment or public accommodations
ordinances covering their residents are shown in order of enactment. Below
them are the 20 “minor” codes, followed by the job bias measures for public
workers only.

1. Yellow Springs, enacted May 21, 1979: Public employment, private
employment, public accommodation, housing, credit, union practices.

2. Oberlin, early 1980s: Housing, public accommodation. City workers added
in fall 1993.

3. Columbus, August 1984: Housing, public accommodation. Private employment
added in June, 1992. Also public employment, education, credit, ethnic
intimidation.

4. Cleveland, March 23, 1994: Employment, public accommodation, housing,
union practices, ethnic intimidation. Public and private employment
discrimination made a misdemeanor crime on December 24, 1996, the only such
ordinance in the nation.

5. Cleveland Heights, January, 1995: Public employment, housing, city
contracts. Domestic partner benefits for city employees added in 2002.
Domestic partner registry approved by voters November 3, 2003, the nation’s
only voter-initiated one and the only such registry in Ohio.

6. North Olmsted, 1996: Housing.

7. Lakewood, 1997: Housing. Ethnic intimidation added in December 2000.

8. Athens, 1998: New measure to replace one passed and repealed in 1989
covers housing, public employment, public accommodation and ethnic
intimidation.

9. Toledo, December 18, 1998: Public and private employment, public
accommodation, housing, union practices, ethnic intimidation. The first Ohio
measure to include gender identity.

10. Shaker Heights, February 27, 2006: Housing.

11. Cincinnati, March 15, 2006: Replaces 1992 ordinance voided by
now-repealed Article 12; protects gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgender
residents in housing, employment and public accommodation.

12. Canton, March 20, 2006: Includes “sexual orientation” in employment and
union practices, including the use of employment agencies that discriminate.
Law director says “gender” will be enforced to include transgender.

Minor city codes

A search of 124 Ohio municipal codes published online by the Conway Greene
Co. of Cleveland turned up 16 more cities and villages that include “sexual
orientation” or “sexual preference” in an ordinance that applies to
residents. A Google search of the two phrases with “codified ordinances” and
“Ohio” revealed another four.

However, these measures are very limited in scope.

A half-dozen of them are parade and public assembly codes that appear to be
derived from model language provided by the International Municipal Law
Association. They bar discrimination in issuing parade permits by a list of
factors that include sexual orientation.

The localities with these are:

Blue Ash, adopted 1-11-01

Canal Winchester, 7-6-99

Cuyahoga Falls, 3-27-00

Hamilton, 5-26-04

Highland Hills, 12-6-99

Sheffield Village, 5-12-03

Ten cities bar discrimination in cable TV service. These ordinances are also
very similar to each other and all but two--Highland Hills and
Millersburg--use the phrase “sexual preference.” They are:

Bedford Heights, 5-16-00

Garfield Heights

Highland Heights, 11-11-97

Highland Hills, 7-16-01

Independence, 12-9-97

Lyndhurst, 5-5-97

Mayfield Village, 9-18-00

Millersburg, 11-13-01

Oakwood, 3-28-00

Strongsville, 12-21-98

Dayton bars discrimination in “sexual preference” by any utility using city
right-of-way, as do Upper Arlington and Westlake.

Gahanna has a charter article prohibiting city officials from discriminating
in their duties.

Springfield requires that mediation services be provided regardless of
sexual orientation.

Ohio has over a thousand municipalities, and only a minority of them have
ordinances that are searchable online. Others may have adopted minor
measures similar to the ones above.

Public worker job bias

In addition to the ordinances covering residents, five more Ohio localities
have job bias protections for public employees only:

Cuyahoga County, 12-21-81

Summit County, “sexual preference,” 5-7-01

Whitehall, “sexual preference,” 12-21-93

Lordstown, 8-6-01

Granville includes sexual orientation in a 2003 ordinance against workplace
harassment among city employees--but not the one on city job discrimination.

Dayton reportedly has a city worker job bias policy that includes sexual
orientation, but nothing in the ordinances online.

State laws cluster in groups

State laws group in four geographical areas: the Northeast including all of
New England with New York, New Jersey and Maryland; the three West Coast
states plus Nevada and Hawaii; a Midwest cluster with Minnesota, Wisconsin,
Illinois and Iowa; and pair of mountain neighbors, Colorado and New Mexico.

The 20 states with laws, plus the District of Columbia, are:

1. Wisconsin, 1982

2. Massachusetts, 1989

3. Hawaii, 1991, employment only; housing discrimination based on sexual
orientation and gender identity added 2005; measure adding gender identity
to job law was vetoed at the same time; sexual orientation and gender
identity added to public accommodation law in 2006.

4. Connecticut , 1991

5. New Jersey, 1992; transgender people added 2006.

6. Vermont, 1992; gender identity added by 2007 bill, still awaiting
governor’s signature

7. California, 1992; gender identity added 2003

8. Minnesota, 1993; includes gender identity

9. Rhode Island, 1995; gender identity added 2001

10. District of Columbia, 1997, gender identity added 2005

11. New Hampshire, 1997

12. Nevada, 1999, employment only

13 Maryland, 2001

14. New York, 2002

15. New Mexico, 2003; includes gender identity

16. Illinois, 2005; includes transgender people in definition of “sexual
orientation”

17. Maine, 2005; includes gender identity

18. Washington, 2006; includes gender identity in definition of “sexual
orientation”

19. Oregon, 2007; includes gender identity in definition of “sexual
orientation.” Signed by governor; takes effect January 1, 2008

20. Iowa, 2007; includes gender identity; still awaiting governor’s
signature

21. Colorado, 2007, employment only; includes gender identity in definition
of “sexual orientation”; still awaiting governor’s signature

Maine passed a law in 1997 but it was repealed by voters the next year; a
replacement measure was rejected by voters in November 2000. Another repeal
referendum was defeated by voters in 2005, allowing that law to stand.


Copyright Statement: Material appearing in this e-mail is distributed without profit or monetary gain to those who have expressed an interest in receiving the article material for research and educational purposes. This is in accordance with Title 17 U. S. C. section 107. Please note that distribution of articles doesn't constitute endorsement of the articles' content; "opposition" articles are distributed to educate interested readership about contrary and unfavorable standpoints.
Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/transgendernews/

<*> Your email settings:
Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/transgendernews/join
(Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
mailto:transgender...@yahoogroups.com
mailto:transgendernew...@yahoogroups.com

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
transgenderne...@yahoogroups.com

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/

Reply all
Reply to author
Forward
0 new messages