Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.
Dismiss

IS NOTHING SACRED?!

1 view
Skip to first unread message

Matthew MacIntyre

unread,
Jan 13, 1994, 8:17:37 PM1/13/94
to

Well?

Paula Freeman

unread,
Jan 14, 1994, 3:00:59 AM1/14/94
to
In article <2h4rrh$9...@nuscc.nus.sg>,
Matthew MacIntyre <matm...@leonis.nus.sg> wrote:
>
>Well?

I've felt better, actually.

Paula

Mr Robin J Faichney

unread,
Jan 14, 1994, 5:03:53 AM1/14/94
to
Matthew MacIntyre (matm...@leonis.nus.sg) wrote:

>Well?

Yes

Mr Robin J Faichney

unread,
Jan 14, 1994, 5:04:42 AM1/14/94
to
Matthew MacIntyre (matm...@leonis.nus.sg) wrote:

>Well?

No--everything is.

Dave Palmer

unread,
Jan 14, 1994, 11:57:40 AM1/14/94
to
matthew macintyre wrote:
Well?

no.

--dave palmer
--
"Once I had a little game
I liked to crawl back into my brain
I think you know the game I mean
I mean the game called 'go insane'" Jim Morrison

David Nye

unread,
Jan 15, 1994, 3:47:50 AM1/15/94
to
Matthew MacIntyre (matm...@leonis.nus.sg) writes:

>Well?

Certainly.

David Nye, Pastor, Holy Nothingness Church.

David Nye, MD * Neurology Dept., Midelfort Clinic, Eau Claire, Wisconsin
For all but the elite, work holds less promise, less purpose, less
security and less dignity than a generation ago -- Peter T. Kilborn

Matthew MacIntyre

unread,
Jan 16, 1994, 8:11:30 PM1/16/94
to
Dave Palmer (ar...@quads.uchicago.edu) wrote:
: matthew macintyre wrote:
: Well?

: no.

: --dave palmer

Well, after mature consideration, I must controvert this assertion. God
is sacred. But God does not exist, ie, is nothing. Therefore, nothing is
indeed sacred. QED.

Grace Chow

unread,
Jan 17, 1994, 2:10:19 AM1/17/94
to

} : no.

} : --dave palmer

Nothing does not exist. Therefore something exists?

--
psycho*candy
art1...@leonis.nus.sg

John Cormac Davis

unread,
Jan 17, 1994, 10:40:11 AM1/17/94
to

Nonsense.

God is sacred.
God is Love.
Love is in the Air.
Something's in your hair.
"Some things I just have to do myself."
" I just am! "

" I'm awed by your nightly tumescence, O JCD, Sun of Whammo." JCD.



Thomas R Anderson

unread,
Jan 17, 1994, 12:15:13 PM1/17/94
to
Define 'sacred.'

Matthew MacIntyre

unread,
Jan 17, 1994, 8:10:10 PM1/17/94
to
Grace Chow (art1...@leonis.nus.sg) wrote:

: } : no.

: } : --dave palmer

From the mere fact that something, for example nothing, does not exist,
it does not follow that something else, for example something, does exist.
That is clear.

John Cormac Davis

unread,
Jan 18, 1994, 6:54:03 AM1/18/94
to


Nothing is clear. Or should that be, nothing is clear ?

I has been my experience that nothingness is rather tawny and swampish,
and dwells behind my sinuses on , for example, a late Sunday afternoon
after one too many scones during 'Songs of Praise' on BBC 2.

JCD

jeske garrett

unread,
Jan 18, 1994, 4:50:11 PM1/18/94
to

Poorly, after immature concatenation, ahem - i am apt to ask how something
which does not exist can *be* anything, and since it does not (exist) let us
more rightly call it 'nothing'; hence how can nothing, which does not exist,
*be* anything, i.e. 'sacred'? of course, i am of the opinion that it is
indeed sacred, after a fashion and so to speak, as it has been my experience,
and not of I, is that nothingness is rather bawdy and trampish - swells and
flows, for ex ample, dwells, in shorts, or long('johns') whereever it happens
to....happen. and fordeed - what better two do when bored??? besides eat. or
sleep??? well...

Matthew MacIntyre

unread,
Jan 20, 1994, 1:13:34 AM1/20/94
to
Thomas R Anderson (ande...@cps.msu.edu) wrote:
: Define 'sacred.'

"Sacred" is "nothing".

Matthew MacIntyre

unread,
Jan 20, 1994, 1:14:25 AM1/20/94
to
jeske garrett (sinc...@uxa.cso.uiuc.edu) wrote:
: Poorly, after immature concatenation, ahem - i am apt to ask how something

: which does not exist can *be* anything, and since it does not (exist) let us
: more rightly call it 'nothing'; hence how can nothing, which does not exist,
: *be* anything, i.e. 'sacred'? of course, i am of the opinion that it is
: indeed sacred, after a fashion and so to speak, as it has been my experience,
: and not of I, is that nothingness is rather bawdy and trampish - swells and
: flows, for ex ample, dwells, in shorts, or long('johns') whereever it happens
: to....happen. and fordeed - what better two do when bored??? besides eat. or
: sleep??? well...

Mikhail, it isn't nice to forge messages in other people's names.

Erik Hermansen

unread,
Jan 25, 1994, 12:48:14 AM1/25/94
to
<1994Jan17.1...@aber.ac.uk> <2heh31$f...@msuinfo.cl.msu.edu>
<2hl7ee$d...@nuscc.nus.sg>
Organization: Eskimo North (206) For-Ever


"These sociologists who talk so facilely about the sacred, are like a
man who keeps a toothless, old, circus lion around the house in order to
experience the thrills of the jungle." -Allan Bloom

One of my favorite quotes. It would seem to me that if one asks in all
seriousness if anything is sacred, as opposed to saying "x is sacred!",
they are itching to latch on to an old circus lion.

MAL...@idui1.csrv.uidaho.edu

unread,
Jan 26, 1994, 5:16:40 PM1/26/94
to
In article <CK684...@eskimo.com>
And I might argue that exactly the reverse might be true!

Elizabeth A. Green

unread,
Jan 28, 1994, 11:46:14 AM1/28/94
to
According to my religion professor, Winston Davis, the sacred is that to
which we are simultaneously drawn and repelled. But what does he know?
He wears a pastel plaid bow tie with a brown shirt and green pants.

Betsy

john patrick lodder

unread,
Feb 2, 1994, 10:44:40 AM2/2/94
to
In article <CK684...@eskimo.com> daed...@eskimo.com (Erik Hermansen) writes:

Ah, I see. Circus lions are sacred!

=====================================================
"April is the cruelest month" --TSE
"When April had pierced to the root..." --GC
My opinions probably belong somewhere......
=====================================================
yes, I took a class with Allan Bloom, so don't ask.

JAY PASCALE

unread,
Feb 7, 1994, 4:52:49 PM2/7/94
to

Pastel plaid bow tie with a brown shirt and green pants?!? And IF I were to
consider this sacred I would be simultaneously drawn and repelled by it? I
would rather be simultaneously drawn and quartered than wear that.

Jay

Bob Murken

unread,
Mar 2, 1994, 5:44:32 AM3/2/94
to
God is sacred, god is nothing, nothing is sacred...? Sounds a little twisted
to me--how do you mean it? God might be sacred, and he might not exist...and
not existing, he just isn't...so how can he or the nothingness that isn't his
be sacred? Or is it that nothing is sacred...as in, there is no thing that is
sacred?
0 new messages