El martes, 25 de septiembre de 2012 20:05:07 UTC+1, Eugene Willow escribió:
> On 25 Sep, 18:45, Boikat <
boi...@bellsouth.net> wrote:
>
> > On Sep 25, 1:25 pm, Eugene Willow <
willowe1...@hotmail.com> wrote:
>
> >
>
> > > An article presents a matemathical proof for creationism:
http://mathfour.com/general/a-mathematical-proof-of-creationism
>
> >
>
> > You really didn't read the article, did you?
>
> >
>
> > Boikat
>
>
>
> Let me sum up the essence of the proof:
>
> 1. We know world exists.
>
> 2. Therefore, world exists, for if it had not existed, it would not
>
> had been created.
This articulation is not correct. Perhaps you mean the Universe,
for the world is our planet. Then, we identify the place we live
as the world.
Then, if we exist, there exists also the world, whatever it is.
But that mere fact that the world exist, does not prove it was
created. This is anthropomorphic concept, to create. The idea
comes from living beings doing things, like borrow a hole in
the ground, or to build a hut, or to cut a stone to build a wall,
or to take some vegetables to make a rope, or string, etc.
Then, whatever the world is, or whatever its size, it is the place
where we are living and this all we can know; nothing else.
Unless you start developing some astrophysics.
>
> Let me also prove the creator wasn't supernatural. We will use the
>
> method called "proof by contradiction".
>
> 1. Assume a supernatural god exists.
> 2. Therefore, it must have created the universe, since we have already
> proven it was created.
You have not proven anything.
There is not any reason to believe a god exists.
In the same way that theist cannot explain why god exist, or what
is the cause of god existence, unless you tell me, "god exists,
because humans invented god, for several reasons."
Then, this planet exist, and we have an astrophysical idea at how
a planet formed.
But the basic concept of the Universe, how matter exists, the
electrons, protons, neutrons, neutrinos, etc. including some
forms of matter not yet seen, or observed, is unknown. Science
is unable to explain how matter exists, even if they speak about
the big bang. Even if the big bang is real, science is unable
to say from where came out all the matter of the big bang
explosion.
Then, this is not so different to the theist that cannot explain
how a god exist, what is its cause, or it is eternal.
You have not proved anything.
Eridanus