Google Groups Home
Help | Sign in
Message from discussion Bereaved, Vilified, Undaunted (Ajit Sahi in Tehelka)
The group you are posting to is a Usenet group. Messages posted to this group will make your email address visible to anyone on the Internet.
Your reply message has not been sent.
Your post was successful
Frederick Noronha [फ़रेदरिक नोरोनया]  
View profile
 More options Mar 21, 6:38 pm
Newsgroups: soc.culture.indian.goa
From: "Frederick Noronha [फ़रेदरिक नोरोनया]" <f...@bytesforall.org>
Date: Fri, 21 Mar 2008 16:38:23 CST
Local: Fri, Mar 21 2008 6:38 pm
Subject: Bereaved, Vilified, Undaunted (Ajit Sahi in Tehelka)
Bereaved, Vilified, Undaunted

 AJIT SAHI finds Fiona MacKeown determined to get justice in the face
 of personal attacks

 At 7.45 pm on February 17, 2008 Briton Fiona MacKeown phoned her
 15-year-old daughter Scarlett from a public booth off a Kerala
 highway. "We're going home to see your brother," Fiona said. "Yeah!"
 Scarlett, who was in Goa, was thrilled. "Love you, Mom… see you
 tomorrow." With six of her nine children and partner Rob, Fiona had
 earlier driven down the coast on an extended holiday but U-turned on
 hearing that her oldest son Hal had been badly hurt in a road accident
 in England. The party spent the night in their jeep in a stranger's
 garage. "I couldn't sleep," Fiona says. "I was up at 5 am to leave."
 At that very instant, Scarlett was raped and left to die on Goa's
 Anjuna beach. Ten hours later, Fiona received an SMS from Julio Lobo,
 the 25-yearold Goan guide with whom she had left Scarlett: "Cal me as
 soon as possible. Its very urgent." Fiona thought the message was from
 Scarlett who always used Julio's phone. But when she called back, a
 hysterical Lobo told her that Scarlett had been found dead on the
 beach that morning.

 Fiona, who turns 44 on Monday, now faces the biggest challenge of her
 life. Walking out of a broken home at 15, doing a year in jail for
 knifing a molester at 17, bearing nine children from four men but
 marrying none ("I don't really believe in marriages."), Fiona has
 shown her characteristic guts in challenging Goa's home minister Ravi
 Naik and his police force for stalling the probe into her daughter's
 murder to shield Goa's drug lords. Tattooed and dressed like a hippie,
 Fiona walks barefoot, fearless in a foreign land. She has been slammed
 in India, in England and across the world for leaving her minor
 daughter with Lobo, who she had just met a month ago. But Fiona says
 she won't stop trusting people and defends Lobo whom she believes
 tried to find her daughter through the fateful night. Fiona has been
 called a drug addict and a peddler. "I would be rich if I was a
 peddler, wouldn't I?" she asks.

 Rumours abound that she has often visited Goa and overstayed. Truth:
 Fiona got her first 10-year passport in 2007 and shortly afterwards
 came to Goa for two weeks with her partner Rob, a Goa veteran."Anjuna
 was so beautiful with such a lovely atmosphere," she says. "I had to
 bring my children here." The family came together last November. Fiona
 has been called dysfunctional."I am probably dysfunctional, compared
 with most people in British society. But I'm much happy," she smiles
 wryly."I don't have mortgages and I don't run up bills." Fiona denies
 she lives or travels on government dole. Indeed, she worked hard over
 the past decade to buy farmland in Devon, and raise horses there. She
 sold one horse to help pay for this holiday.

 As Fiona returned to Goa, Anjuna's police officer Nerlon Albuquerque —
 who had earlier that day hurried the autopsy to pass off Scarlett's
 death as a drowning, and who had made no effort to find Fiona — made
 her wait three hours. He showed her pictures of four other dead bodies
 before Scarlett's, and allowed her to see Scarlett's body only the
 next day. "I am most disappointed with the police for lying to me
 right through," Fiona told TEHELKA. "I trusted them as I would the
 police in England." At the morgue, Fiona was immediately suspicious of
 Scarlett's injuries, unlikely for a death by drowning. Plus, a toe
 ring was missing. But the police insisted Scarlett had drowned to
 death.
 Scarlett Keeling

 Fiona's suspicions were revived the next day when she visited the site
 where Scarlett's body was found, close to a shack named Lui on Anjuna
 beach. "That spot was right on the beach and it was impossible to
 believe Scarlett could drown there," she says. Then an eyewitness told
 Fiona that Scarlett's body had been missing the bikini bottom while
 her top had been pulled up past her breasts. Scarlett combed the area
 and found the missing garment in the rough ground behind Lui, where it
 later emerged Scarlett had been raped. Now Fiona knew better than to
 go to the police. She asked around and was led to a lawyer Vikram
 Verma, whose home has welcomed the small group that has sprung up to
 support the cause. A fellow campaigner is a tattooed American yoga
 teacher, the self-christened Dakini Runningbear, who sought out Fiona
 after hearing about her daughter's death. Counselled by Verma, Fiona
 lobbied the British press for an exposé, and demanded a second
 autopsy, which subsequently proved both rape and murder. The frantic
 international media coverage and public outrage has forced the police
 to arrest Samson D'Souza, a partner at Lui, on suspicion of plying
 Scarlett with drugs and then raping her, and Placido Carvalho, a local
 drug dealer. Meanwhile, police officer Albuquerque has been suspended.

 "I trusted him so much that I gave him Scarlett's diary, hoping it
 would help his investigation," Fiona says. Instead, the police gave
 copies of the diary to a London
 tabloid that published excerpts trashing the murdered teenager as a
 drug addict. Over the last two weeks, Fiona, Verma and Runningbear
 have emerged as determined sleuths, taking on the establishment. Last
 Saturday, Fiona accused home minister Naik and Goa's topmost police
 officer, Director- General of Police BS Brar, of leading the cover-up.
 She launched her accusations before the world press, moments before
 entering the juvenile wing of the police for questioning. Naik is yet
 to offer a word of condolence at Scarlett's death, or contrition for
 the police failure. Instead, he has spewed venom at Fiona. Brar has
 maintained a stunned silence.

 On Monday, Fiona scooped a key witness into their investigation: a
 British tourist Michael 'Masala' Mannion who saw a drunken Scarlett
 enter the Lui shack at 3 am on February 18. In his deposition, Mannion
 claims that a third man, Murali, who works at a nearby shack Curlies,
 walked out with Scarlett at 5 am, promising to drop her at Julio's
 house. Minutes later, Mannion went behind the shack and saw Samson
 trying to molest Scarlett, and Murali driving away. Scarlett's murder
 has once again shown that India's massively corrupt system won't move
 for the underdog unless an irrepressible maverick like Fiona arrives
 and refuses to give up. Sadly, the system is bent on running her down
 instead of helping. Already, Naik has threatened to lobby the Centre
 to not extend Fiona's visa which expires on May 4. Fiona is, of
 course, determined to bring justice to her daughter. "Scarlett was a
 wonderful big sister and a gatherer of people," she says of her eldest
 daughter, who would have turned 16 on June 17, exactly four months
 after her brutal murder. "Everyone misses her."
 From Tehelka Magazine, Vol 5, Issue 12, Dated Mar 29, 2008

 http://tehelka.com/story_main38.asp?filename=Ne290308bereaved_vilifie...


    Reply to author    Forward  
You must Sign in before you can post messages.
To post a message you must first join this group.
Please update your nickname on the subscription settings page before posting.
You do not have the permission required to post.

Create a group - Google Groups - Google Home - Terms of Service - Privacy Policy
©2008 Google