SIGIR Meta

Looking at Dr. Anderson's homepage, this article appeared in OS Review 2009. On Mon, Jun 13, 2011

I think it's probably important to discount authors' assessments when the paper is accepted.

OK, I just finished doing a KDD rebuttal. What a frustrating experience. "In a 2063-character

I think a broad rethink is necessary. My only quibble with what you're proposing is, I think it

Hi Ian, for me, the question is whether we leave this discussion just with a moral appeal to

Dear all, some of you might have wondered why theier messages were waiting for approval quite some

Thanks to Ian for setting up this discussion forum. I'm pleased to see a few new voices here as

gvc wrote: > Point 11. Lots of scientific inquiry requires no statistics. Many of >

Although I definitely assign reviewers by my feeling of their knowledge, I don't give reviews

Flagging short and/or inappropriate meta-reviews is a job for individual SPC members. It can't be

FYI ---------- Forwarded message ---------- From: Ian Soboroff <isob...@gmail.com> Date: Wed,

From http://sigir.org/Officers.html, it seems like it's: sigi...@acm.org -----Original Message--

Thanks, Ian, for setting this up.

This list was born out of a length discussion on the SIGIR 2010 senior PC mailing list about review