Zuhair
unread,Jul 22, 2012, 5:59:05 AM7/22/12You do not have permission to delete messages in this group
Either email addresses are anonymous for this group or you need the view member email addresses permission to view the original message
to
Language: FOL
Primitives. membership, identical, ordered pair
Axioms: Identity theory + characteristic property of ordered pairs +
Sets with the same members are identical
An element of a set is singleton
A singleton is its element
If phi is stratified then a set of all singletons satisfying phi
exists.
An ordered pair is singleton
/
stratification follows Quine for = and e symbols, in addition an
ordered pair and its projection will be assigned the same type.
This theory is purely extensional as regards sets in it, but it can
interpret NFU+Infinity in the following manner:
x is an NFU set iff Exist p. x=(p,p)
x is an NFU element of y <> Exist p. y=(p,p) & x e p
It is trivial to prove that all axioms of NFU + Infinity follows.
So this is a purely extensional NFU + Infinity.
I have the vague sense of what qualifies a predicate to be type
leveling (like identity and projection) or type elevating (like
membership).
If a predicate P(x,x1,..,xn) is axiomatized such that
P(x,x1..,xn) & P(x,y1,..,yn) > x1=y1 &...& xn=yn & Exist y. x R y
where there can exist more than one object having the relation R to
the same y.
Then P is a type leveling predicate.
If P(x,x1,...,xn) doesn't satisfy the above property but satisfy Exist
y. x R y then it is type elevating predicate, i.e. x is higher in type
than every xi (i=1,..,n).
just a guess.
Zuhair