Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.
Dismiss
Who rewinds power XFRs?
77 views
Skip to first unread message
ohg...@gmail.com
Dec 4, 2020, 12:32:44 PM12/4/20
to
I have a McIntosh MX110Z with a bad transformer. Any recommendations for rewinding? I've never done one and have no interest in trying. Thanks.
Peter W.
Dec 4, 2020, 1:09:55 PM12/4/20
to
On Friday, December 4, 2020 at 12:32:44 PM UTC-5, ohg...@gmail.com wrote:
> I have a McIntosh MX110Z with a bad transformer. Any recommendations for rewinding? I've never done one and have no interest in trying. Thanks.
https://www.mercurymagnetics.com/brands/mercury-vintage-transformer-restoration-service/
> I have a McIntosh MX110Z with a bad transformer. Any recommendations for rewinding? I've never done one and have no interest in trying. Thanks.
And there is the Mother Ship, McIntosh itself.
Peter Wieck
Melrose Park, PA
ohg...@gmail.com
Dec 4, 2020, 1:35:29 PM12/4/20
to
Paul Drahn
Dec 5, 2020, 1:09:39 PM12/5/20
to
On 12/4/2020 9:32 AM, ohg...@gmail.com wrote:
> I have a McIntosh MX110Z with a bad transformer. Any recommendations for rewinding? I've never done one and have no interest in trying. Thanks.
>
You can do better that that post.
> I have a McIntosh MX110Z with a bad transformer. Any recommendations for rewinding? I've never done one and have no interest in trying. Thanks.
>
How is it bad? Shorted turn, open turn, short to core? Which winding?
Primary or secondary?
What told you the transformer is bad?
Likely there is a transformer available with similar ratings that will
replace the transformer.
Paul
ohg...@gmail.com
Dec 5, 2020, 2:01:38 PM12/5/20
to
Phil Allison
Dec 5, 2020, 3:04:03 PM12/5/20
to
Paul Drahn wrote:
==============
.... Phil
l
==============
>
> > I have a McIntosh MX110Z with a bad transformer.
> >
> > I have a McIntosh MX110Z with a bad transformer.
> >
> You can do better that that post.
> How is it bad? Shorted turn, open turn, short to core? Which winding?
> Primary or secondary?
> What told you the transformer is bad?
> Likely there is a transformer available with similar ratings that will
> replace the transformer.
>
** For sure - sitting inside another MX110Z that is non working.
> How is it bad? Shorted turn, open turn, short to core? Which winding?
> Primary or secondary?
> What told you the transformer is bad?
> Likely there is a transformer available with similar ratings that will
> replace the transformer.
>
.... Phil
l
Peter W.
Dec 6, 2020, 7:49:16 AM12/6/20
to
A few things:
a) McIntosh winds their own transformers.
b) McIntosh has been in business for many years, and through many ups and downs.
c) Meaning that their management at least has some basic business intelligence.
d) Suggesting that the transformers they make/made are not unique to each individual component.
e) Suggesting that it is quite likely that they may have that transformer available.
a) McIntosh winds their own transformers.
b) McIntosh has been in business for many years, and through many ups and downs.
c) Meaning that their management at least has some basic business intelligence.
d) Suggesting that the transformers they make/made are not unique to each individual component.
e) Suggesting that it is quite likely that they may have that transformer available.
ohg...@gmail.com
Dec 6, 2020, 9:39:52 AM12/6/20
to
The MX110Z is very very tight. There's literally no room for a transformer that would allow the case to fit if the replacement was any bigger even by a small percentage. This particular piece is known to have a power transformer that runs *very* hot even when everything is otherwise normal. The transformer has a B+ winding and three filament windings and is also supposed to be more heavily shielded than the average bear.
I could probably find a way of cobbling a different power transformer and another smaller filament transformer somewhere else on the chassis (or just build a remote XFR box with an umbilical) but I don't want to reinvent the wheel at this point, plus I feel most of the *value* of this piece is in the originality of it, not to mention Mc's careful design of the filament circuit and wire routing for hum mitigation. Add to that the fact that two of the four selenium rectifiers under the deck relieved themselves of tiny solder balls (which happens when the 1A slow blow is replaced with a 20A fuse), and all cans are original and probably need to be restuffed, and it just seems like a project not worth the time at this point.
I returned the tuner/pre to the owner yesterday with the suggestion of either putting it on ebay, where this model in non working condition will bring $400 at least, or keep checking ebay and finding one in poor cosmetic condition with a good XFR in it.
Peter W.
Dec 6, 2020, 11:33:03 AM12/6/20
to
> I returned the tuner/pre to the owner yesterday with the suggestion of either putting it on ebay, where this model in non working condition will bring $400 at least, or keep checking ebay and finding one in poor cosmetic condition with a good XFR in it.
Or send it out to be rewound.
Mike Coon
Dec 6, 2020, 2:53:42 PM12/6/20
to
In article <7bd6a88f-43ff-4236...@googlegroups.com>,
ohg...@gmail.com says...
(which I still have; sentimentality!). I built it around the mains
transformer whichwas between two bulkheads and gave the whole thing
rigidity. So when it failed rewinding it was the only solution. And
building a coil-winder out of Meccano was my solution to that...
ohg...@gmail.com says...
>
> On Sunday, December 6, 2020 at 7:49:16 AM UTC-5, Peter W. wrote:
> > A few things:
> > a) McIntosh winds their own transformers.
> > b) McIntosh has been in business for many years, and through many ups and downs.
> > c) Meaning that their management at least has some basic business intelligence.
> > d) Suggesting that the transformers they make/made are not unique to each individual component.
> > e) Suggesting that it is quite likely that they may have that transformer available.
>
>
> It's not. I emailed McIntosh asking about a replacement, or a suggested "universal" replacement that might physically fit the tight chassis that could be installed with some circuit modification, or perhaps a suggestion of a rewinder they were familiar with or might even have used. I received a very quick and terse (if not polite) email from McIntosh Friday that answered all three of my questions with a simple "I?m sorry there are no options for this transformer."
> On Sunday, December 6, 2020 at 7:49:16 AM UTC-5, Peter W. wrote:
> > A few things:
> > a) McIntosh winds their own transformers.
> > b) McIntosh has been in business for many years, and through many ups and downs.
> > c) Meaning that their management at least has some basic business intelligence.
> > d) Suggesting that the transformers they make/made are not unique to each individual component.
> > e) Suggesting that it is quite likely that they may have that transformer available.
>
>
Boom.
>
> The MX110Z is very very tight. There's literally no room for a transformer that would allow the case to fit if the replacement was any bigger even by a small percentage. This particular piece is known to have a power transformer that runs *very* hot even when everything is otherwise normal. The transformer has a B+ winding and three filament windings and is also supposed to be more heavily shielded than the average bear.
>
> I could probably find a way of cobbling a different power transformer and another smaller filament transformer somewhere else on the chassis (or just build a remote XFR box with an umbilical) but I don't want to reinvent the wheel at this point, plus I feel most of the *value* of this piece is in the originality of it, not to mention Mc's careful design of the filament circuit and wire routing for hum mitigation. Add to that the fact that two of the four selenium
rectifiers under the deck relieved themselves of tiny solder balls (which happens when the 1A slow blow is replaced with a 20A fuse), and all cans are original and probably need to be restuffed, and it just seems like a project not worth the time at this point.
>
> I returned the tuner/pre to the owner yesterday with the suggestion of either putting it on ebay, where this model in non working condition will bring $400 at least, or keep checking ebay and finding one in poor cosmetic condition with a good XFR in it.
Sounds like a mistake I made ca. 1960 when I built a valve oscilloscope
>
> The MX110Z is very very tight. There's literally no room for a transformer that would allow the case to fit if the replacement was any bigger even by a small percentage. This particular piece is known to have a power transformer that runs *very* hot even when everything is otherwise normal. The transformer has a B+ winding and three filament windings and is also supposed to be more heavily shielded than the average bear.
>
> I could probably find a way of cobbling a different power transformer and another smaller filament transformer somewhere else on the chassis (or just build a remote XFR box with an umbilical) but I don't want to reinvent the wheel at this point, plus I feel most of the *value* of this piece is in the originality of it, not to mention Mc's careful design of the filament circuit and wire routing for hum mitigation. Add to that the fact that two of the four selenium
rectifiers under the deck relieved themselves of tiny solder balls (which happens when the 1A slow blow is replaced with a 20A fuse), and all cans are original and probably need to be restuffed, and it just seems like a project not worth the time at this point.
>
> I returned the tuner/pre to the owner yesterday with the suggestion of either putting it on ebay, where this model in non working condition will bring $400 at least, or keep checking ebay and finding one in poor cosmetic condition with a good XFR in it.
(which I still have; sentimentality!). I built it around the mains
transformer whichwas between two bulkheads and gave the whole thing
rigidity. So when it failed rewinding it was the only solution. And
building a coil-winder out of Meccano was my solution to that...
ohg...@gmail.com
Dec 9, 2020, 1:47:32 PM12/9/20
to
On Friday, December 4, 2020 at 12:32:44 PM UTC-5, ohg...@gmail.com wrote:
> I have a McIntosh MX110Z with a bad transformer. Any recommendations for rewinding? I've never done one and have no interest in trying. Thanks.
Follow up for general information. I received a second email from McIntosh a couple of days ago that said the only person they had to rewind transformers recently passed away. While looking for a rewinder on the web, I had seen references to a rewinder many used but who was in poor health, so maybe McIntosh used the same guy.
bruce bowser
Dec 14, 2020, 4:30:25 PM12/14/20
to
On Sunday, December 6, 2020 at 7:49:16 AM UTC-5, Peter W. wrote:
> A few things:
> a) McIntosh winds their own transformers.
> b) McIntosh has been in business for many years, and through many ups and downs.
> c) Meaning that their management at least has some basic business intelligence.
That means nothing. Management team assistants can be good or bad irrespective of time. The smaller; more prejudiced; more nepotistic and less meritocratic, the worse off. Like with the Trump family.
> a) McIntosh winds their own transformers.
> b) McIntosh has been in business for many years, and through many ups and downs.
> c) Meaning that their management at least has some basic business intelligence.
0 new messages