Sarah Arthur Discussion Google Group

Re: Camp Class on Walking with Bilbo

sa...@saraharthur.com (Sarah Arthur) — Mon, 25 Jul 2005 13:35:17 UT

Sounds like a wonderful experience! Keep up the great work. The kids
will never forget that week.

Re: Camp Class on Walking with Bilbo

honig...@cmich.edu (Erika R Honigfort) — Thu, 21 Jul 2005 15:30:06 UT

Camp was great! I really enjoyed teaching the kids, and they
loved the lessons. I found that I had each group twice,
instead of once, so I had to come up with another lesson
which wasn't bad because I already had one planned for
Children's church. So, I just doubled the supplies and had
the kids at camp make christian survival kits for the first

Re: LOTR versus Narnia

mcbry...@chartermi.net (Candy Bryant) — Mon, 11 Jul 2005 02:47:40 UT

1. Which did you read first: the Chronicles or LOTR/The Hobbit?
Chronicles first, Hobbit, then LOTR
2. Which is your favorite and why?
Narnia, favorite for the worlds and characters. Memories of my
childhood are beyond the wardrobe.
LOTR, favorite for that life changing thrill that comes from reading

Re: Camp Class on Walking with Bilbo

sa...@saraharthur.com (Sarah Arthur) — Mon, 27 Jun 2005 14:17:43 UT

I'm happy to help! I organized a week of camp for our confirmation kids
every summer for six years, and I miss it sometimes. Your question was
a great excuse to get creative about those kinds of activities again.
Regarding the costume: What about something simple like a bandana and a
walking stick? A medieval dress doesn't fit the theme of treasure hunt

Re: Camp Class on Walking with Bilbo

honig...@cmich.edu (Erika R Honigfort) — Fri, 24 Jun 2005 02:09:12 UT

Thank you so much Sarah! I talked to the pastors wife at my
church so we could order some rings from oriental trading.
They arent wedding bands, but rings with crosses on them:) I
really appreciate your help! Again, thank you. The kids are
going to love it! I was thinking...should I wear a costume?

Re: Camp Class on Walking with Bilbo

sa...@saraharthur.com (Sarah Arthur) — Wed, 22 Jun 2005 12:46:11 UT

Walking with Bilbo was definitely a good choice for that age group:
even if they're not familiar with The Hobbit, they know that Bilbo was
the one to find the ring, so you can build a lesson off of that.
Perhaps your theme could be looking for treasure. Bilbo thought he was
on an adventure to find the dragon-wealth of the dwarves, when the REAL

RE: Camp Class on Walking with Bilbo

honig...@cmich.edu (Erika R Honigfort) — Wed, 22 Jun 2005 02:46:09 UT

The director of the week thought walking with Bilbo would be
better, so that is why they told me to go with it. I showed
them both books though, and that is the one they chose. If
you have any ideas on games or lessons, please write back.
Thanks
Erika

RE: Camp Class on Walking with Bilbo

cal...@comcast.net (kim) — Tue, 21 Jun 2005 19:25:51 UT

I have taught 3 classes on Walking with Frodo and am preparing to teach
three more classes on Walking with Bilbo. Personally, I think that
considering you are only teaching each class one day of the study,I
would think that Walking with Frodo would be a lot easier to adapt to
your situation. Most kids are familiar with the trilogy whereas,kids may

Camp Class on Walking with Bilbo

honig...@cmich.edu — Tue, 21 Jun 2005 03:32:26 UT

I will be teaching a class at a camp here in michigan on July 10-15.
The theme of the week is "Dude, Where's my bible?" and I was asked to
teach a class on what to do with the bible mainly. The other classes
will be history of the bible and other things. I was wondering if
anyone had any ideas on what to do with the class. I am currently

RE: LOTR versus Narnia

shire_hob...@hotmail.com (Nick Whitford) — Tue, 21 Jun 2005 03:05:14 UT

1. Which did you read first: the Chronicles or LOTR/The Hobbit?

The Hobbit, Fellowship then Lion Witch and the Wardrobe... and it was a
chaotic reading schedule from then on out...

2. Which is your favorite and why?

I loved both, but Narnia feels more like the childrens novels LWW was
written to be (or so suggests the dedication), whereas LOTR is much more

LOTR versus Narnia

sa...@saraharthur.com (Sarah Arthur) — Mon, 20 Jun 2005 22:18:40 UT

There's some debate going on (see "New Member Question LWW") as to
which movie series will have the greatest reach/impact in popular
culture: Lord of the Rings or the forthcoming Chronicles of Narnia. I'd
be really curious to hear all of your thoughts on any of the following:
1. Which did you read first: the Chronicles or LOTR/The Hobbit?

Re: New Member Question LWW

fortepra...@yahoo.com (Hannah Shoop) — Thu, 09 Jun 2005 19:22:47 UT

thanks :)

I'm also very excited about the LWW. The trailer certainly looks
promising! My dad started reading Narnia to me when I was 2. I

Re: New Member Question LWW

laura2...@arilion.com (Laura) — Thu, 09 Jun 2005 17:50:36 UT

Hahnnah,
I just figured that out, here's the scoop:
You can go the main discussion page and select "Unsubscribe or change
membership" Then you can set it up if you don't want to get the replies
via email ect.
I'm also very excited about the LWW. The trailer certainly looks
promising! My dad started reading Narnia to me when I was 2. I

Re: New Member Question LWW

fortepra...@yahoo.com (Hannah Shoop) — Thu, 09 Jun 2005 15:47:57 UT

Hi,
I didn't know that I had signed up for the group, because when I tried it wasn't working, so I just figured I wasn't on it. And if it's all right, how do I unsubscribe? I like the blog idea though!
Hannah

Hello all,
This is Sarah Arthur just wanting to clarify how the discussion group
works: If you're receiving these messages, it's because you signed up

Re: New Member Question LWW

pau...@wintellect.com (Theowyn) — Thu, 09 Jun 2005 14:40:15 UT

OK, I think that just answered my own question. You can post either
way.
So now back to the question at hand. I think I disagree with Chris
about the reach of the Narnia Chronicles. They are just as popular, if
not more so, than LOTR. And I have a friend at church who definitely
thinks their spiritual imagery, especially Christian imagery, is much