I'm creating a short video with actors in front of s green screen. It was
originally recorded in PAL 720 x 576.
I have set up the session in Vegas as a Standard PAL DV project with a
pixel ratio of 1.0926 so that there are no thin black bars at the top and
bottom of the screen.
When I try to compile the file as an wmv file I find that I can only set
the pixel ratio to 1.0 square and not 1.0926, this results in the actors
bodies not going completely down to the bottom of the screen and part of
the background appearing at the top and bottom of the screen in thin bars
(the background replaces the green screen).
I tried setting the project to a pixel ratio of 1.0 but with no luck as the
same problem appears.
I wish Vegas had allowed the user to set the pixel ratio to what ever ratio
the user wanted when using the wmv video format rather than just having two
choices from a drop down menu.
There is no problem when compiling the video in another format such as mpg2
so the only way is to convert the video to wmv using a file converter
program after I have compiled it in mpg2 format. I like using wmv when
uploading a video to YouTube.
There is also no way to compile the video to the popular Xvid and VidX
formats but as Vegas is designed for professionals maybe most professionals
don't need to use this video format.
> I'm creating a short video with actors in front of s green screen. It was
> originally recorded in PAL 720 x 576.
> I have set up the session in Vegas as a Standard PAL DV project with a
> pixel ratio of 1.0926 so that there are no thin black bars at the top and
> bottom of the screen.
> When I try to compile the file as an wmv file I find that I can only set
> the pixel ratio to 1.0 square and not 1.0926, this results in the actors
> bodies not going completely down to the bottom of the screen and part of
> the background appearing at the top and bottom of the screen in thin bars
> (the background replaces the green screen).
> I tried setting the project to a pixel ratio of 1.0 but with no luck as the
> same problem appears.
> I wish Vegas had allowed the user to set the pixel ratio to what ever ratio
> the user wanted when using the wmv video format rather than just having two
> choices from a drop down menu.
> There is no problem when compiling the video in another format such as mpg2
> so the only way is to convert the video to wmv using a file converter
> program after I have compiled it in mpg2 format. I like using wmv when
> uploading a video to YouTube.
> There is also no way to compile the video to the popular Xvid and VidX
> formats but as Vegas is designed for professionals maybe most professionals
> don't need to use this video format.
i've never changed pixel ratio in any format, simply matched project to media and haven't encountered any problems since vers 4.
xvid, et al are ok distribution formats, but useless for editing. i don't know of any nle that exports to that format?
Brian writes:
> I'm creating a short video with actors in front of s green screen. It was
> originally recorded in PAL 720 x 576.
> I have set up the session in Vegas as a Standard PAL DV project with a
> pixel ratio of 1.0926 so that there are no thin black bars at the top and
> bottom of the screen.
> When I try to compile the file as an wmv file I find that I can only set
> the pixel ratio to 1.0 square and not 1.0926, this results in the actors
> bodies not going completely down to the bottom of the screen and part of
> the background appearing at the top and bottom of the screen in thin bars
> (the background replaces the green screen).
Depending on pixel ratios other than unity may haunt you throughout
post-production, even if you get this to work. Just leave the black bars.
Mxsmanic <mxsma...@gmail.com> wrote:
> Brian writes:
>> I'm creating a short video with actors in front of s green screen. It was
>> originally recorded in PAL 720 x 576.
>> I have set up the session in Vegas as a Standard PAL DV project with a
>> pixel ratio of 1.0926 so that there are no thin black bars at the top and
>> bottom of the screen.
>> When I try to compile the file as an wmv file I find that I can only set
>> the pixel ratio to 1.0 square and not 1.0926, this results in the actors
>> bodies not going completely down to the bottom of the screen and part of
>> the background appearing at the top and bottom of the screen in thin bars
>> (the background replaces the green screen).
> Depending on pixel ratios other than unity may haunt you throughout
> post-production, even if you get this to work. Just leave the black bars.
I can't leave the black bars as they get replaced with part of the
background picture when i compile the video. If i was able to set the pixel
ratio to 1.0926 before compiling the video in the wmv format then there
would be no problem. its liked putting a slightly smaller picture over a
larger picture.
The wmv format must be sensitive about the pixel ratio setting as when I
compile the video using mpg2 then I don't need to set the pixel size and
the video has no problems after being compiled.
-- Regards Brian
ushere <removethis.leslie.andthis.w...@gmail.com> wrote:
> On 5/02/2012 5:41 PM, Brian wrote:
>> I'm creating a short video with actors in front of s green screen. It was
>> originally recorded in PAL 720 x 576.
>> I have set up the session in Vegas as a Standard PAL DV project with a
>> pixel ratio of 1.0926 so that there are no thin black bars at the top and
>> bottom of the screen.
>> When I try to compile the file as an wmv file I find that I can only set
>> the pixel ratio to 1.0 square and not 1.0926, this results in the actors
>> bodies not going completely down to the bottom of the screen and part of
>> the background appearing at the top and bottom of the screen in thin bars
>> (the background replaces the green screen).
>> I tried setting the project to a pixel ratio of 1.0 but with no luck as the
>> same problem appears.
>> I wish Vegas had allowed the user to set the pixel ratio to what ever ratio
>> the user wanted when using the wmv video format rather than just having two
>> choices from a drop down menu.
>> There is no problem when compiling the video in another format such as mpg2
>> so the only way is to convert the video to wmv using a file converter
>> program after I have compiled it in mpg2 format. I like using wmv when
>> uploading a video to YouTube.
>> There is also no way to compile the video to the popular Xvid and VidX
>> formats but as Vegas is designed for professionals maybe most professionals
>> don't need to use this video format.
> i've never changed pixel ratio in any format, simply matched project to
> media and haven't encountered any problems since vers 4.
> xvid, et al are ok distribution formats, but useless for editing. i don't
> know of any nle that exports to that format?
When I selected the PAL DV format 576 x 720 then Vegas automatically chose
this pixel ratio (1.0926). Normally there would be no problem but in this
case I'm replacing the green screen with a background picture.
Like I said in an earlier post sometime you need to have certain conditions
to reveal a problem in software. -- Regards Brian
> I'm creating a short video with actors in front of s green screen. It was
> originally recorded in PAL 720 x 576.
> I have set up the session in Vegas as a Standard PAL DV project with a
> pixel ratio of 1.0926 so that there are no thin black bars at the top and
> bottom of the screen.
> When I try to compile the file as an wmv file I find that I can only set
> the pixel ratio to 1.0 square and not 1.0926, this results in the actors
> bodies not going completely down to the bottom of the screen and part of
> the background appearing at the top and bottom of the screen in thin bars
> (the background replaces the green screen).
> I tried setting the project to a pixel ratio of 1.0 but with no luck as the
> same problem appears.
> I wish Vegas had allowed the user to set the pixel ratio to what ever ratio
> the user wanted when using the wmv video format rather than just having two
> choices from a drop down menu.
> There is no problem when compiling the video in another format such as mpg2
> so the only way is to convert the video to wmv using a file converter
> program after I have compiled it in mpg2 format. I like using wmv when
> uploading a video to YouTube.
> There is also no way to compile the video to the popular Xvid and VidX
> formats but as Vegas is designed for professionals maybe most professionals
> don't need to use this video format.
> --
> Regards Brian
Render it as a DV-AVI file first (the quality loss will be
imperceptible) and use that render to make your WMV file.
You can render to Divx or Xvid (they will be AVI variants) as long as
you have the codecs installed.
Make sure to get them from a reputable site.
> The wmv format must be sensitive about the pixel ratio setting as when I
> compile the video using mpg2 then I don't need to set the pixel size and
> the video has no problems after being compiled.
A good inference. Test your theory rendering to an MPG2, and then
convert the MPG2 into a WMV with a different program. This will tell
you if the problem is with WMV format in general, or just the program
you're currently using.
... experimentation, a good way to embody "what if" questions.
Brian writes:
> I can't leave the black bars as they get replaced with part of the
> background picture when i compile the video. If i was able to set the pixel
> ratio to 1.0926 before compiling the video in the wmv format then there
> would be no problem. its liked putting a slightly smaller picture over a
> larger picture.
Most still photos have square pixels. Maybe the discrepancy is confusing
Vegas.
You could try cropping the image to exclude the black bars, or rendering the
material with the unusual pixel ratio to a format with square pixels, and then
using that to matte in your background on a second pass.
Mxsmanic <mxsma...@gmail.com> wrote:
> Brian writes:
>> I can't leave the black bars as they get replaced with part of the
>> background picture when i compile the video. If i was able to set the pixel
>> ratio to 1.0926 before compiling the video in the wmv format then there
>> would be no problem. its liked putting a slightly smaller picture over a
>> larger picture.
> Most still photos have square pixels. Maybe the discrepancy is confusing
> Vegas.
> You could try cropping the image to exclude the black bars, or rendering the
> material with the unusual pixel ratio to a format with square pixels, and then
> using that to matte in your background on a second pass.
Thanks Mxsmanic for your suggestions.
Also I think there is a way of zooming into the output of the picture in
Vegas so the black bar are not present in the compiled video but need to do
some exploring to find out how.
