On 29/03/2017 11:01, *skriptis wrote:
> Brian W Lawrence <
brian_w_...@msn.com> Wrote in message:
>> On 28/03/2017 21:35, *skriptis wrote:
>>
>>>>> E.g. how would you defend UK democracy and Westminster system if
>>>>> 60 million any of te following, communists, nazis or sharia
>>>>> Muslims moved in and got a right to vote, and they for sure vote
>>>>> according to their preferences?
>>>>
>>>> That's an unrealistic what if, no country could possibly accept a
>>>
>>> Of course it's unrealistic, it was a hypothetical example to prove
>>> my point. Your dismissal of my argument proves you're a troll
>>> with bad intentions.
>>
>> I didn't dismiss your argument, I pointed out that your hypothetical
>> example had no merit nor precedent in the real world.
>>
>>> Point was about situation in which home population gets totally
>>> overwhelmed. But influence can be exerted even by 1%, even by one
>>> single vote.
>>
>> Which has always been the case, and should be in a democracy.
>
>
> You've heard about gerrymandering I believe and you realize what
> it means and you surely recognize how it's used.
>
> Letting in people who share different values without forcing them
> to accept yours, is a lot worse than gerrymandering.
In your opinion perhaps. Encouraging them to accept national values
perhaps, but forcing them would be repressive.
> E.g. a stupid example, why do the Germans always like turkish song
> at the eurosong contest the most? It's always 12pts for Turkey.
Well, accepting that Eurovision is a stupid or trivial contest, and that
the Turkish migrant workers in Germany would, naturally, vote for their
home country's entry; in total Germany gave Turkey 12 votes only 5
times - 1997-99, 2004, 2007. They did award 10 points on 6 occasions
as well. Telephone voting was first used in 1997, but I can't say if
Germany has used it since then, although I imagine it has.
Why would any modern, free-thinking, democratic country want to
restrict the rights of migrant workers or immigrants?
Obvious answer would be to discourage them migrating in the first place
I suppose, but there are usually easier & fairer ways to do that.