I will say that because of my dislike for over-excessive
individualism in general, I like to ridicule attempts of people
claiming a person can totally choose his or her identity. No it
can't. Rachel Dolezal is not African, Pocahontas Warren is not
native American, and Bruce Jenner is not a woman. Can Zverev
claim he's German? Well, not entirely but legally he's German,
culturally as well, so I guess yes. I was just poking fun at max.
But he's not even of a mixed heritage, he's a Russian guy born
and raised in Germany and immersed in their culture. But would he
pass an asteroid test?
This whole thing with ethnicity, nationality, citizenship,
allegiance etc is very complex. In itself complex, as what should
we even look at.
And then even if we pick what to look at, we face our cultural and
other differences. World is also very complex, you have different
criteria E.g. someone with an Italian father would always be
considered more Italian due to father's line being well, more
important. Otoh Jews place more emphasis on mother's line.
So, a Jewish father, Italian mother, neither side would actually
claim the child, yet, Italian father and Jewish mother, both
sides claim it. Absurd or?
So, let's just say these stuff are complex and not that much
important anyway. Sharapova obeys the laws in USA, and if your
country allows her to be there without being a citizen, well,
it's not her fault. She's done nothing wrong, and in my mind she
wasn't insulting USA if she spoke positively about Russia or
about her feelings. I admit I can't really understand what's
bothering you in her case.
If you ask me personally, I understand her choice, and would
probably do the same. She's Russian and loves her nation, just
wanted to play tennis. Maybe at one point it started being about
the money, maybe Nike prefers her to remain officially Russian,
so covering effectively both markets? She's American enough for
you, and is Russian for her folks. Perhaps it's just money
decision.
Haas is a US citizen as well, so?
But if we discuss only emotional reasons, you once compared her
situation with father kicking her out, and neighbours welcoming
her. And you're surprised she talks positively about her family.
But that's the point of patriotism. Her "family" is more than her
(presumably) non caring father. Sisters, brothers, mothers,
cousins, ancestors, their achievements, sacrifices, shared
history, etc. Whole country, whole people.
One person doesn't mean whole country. Russia hasn't kicked her
out, like you feel it happened. Maybe she's only angry at the
couple of people who didn't give her chance, but if a country was
in bad shape and that forced her to seek her fortunes elsewhere,
an ethnic Russian would rarely be mad at his mother for her being
poor. Would you, honestly?
Maybe some people of different ethnicities who lived there but
don't identify with Russia to that extent would do that sooner.
Georgians, various Balts, Jews, etc. Move away, take new
citizenship etc.
Like it happens everywhere. You said your Mexican friend would
move away if things went bad there. Maybe at one point you'd do
the same if you were forced. But would you like America and all
it meant to you, less?
Sharapova could have started playing for USA and nobody would have
mind it. But as I said, you can expect that sooner from non
ethnic Russians coming from Russia.
I admire her, and that's why I dislike migrations. It takes very
long to assimilate people. :)
And in the meantime, lots of problems.