BobbyK wrote:
> On Wed, 9 Aug 2017 20:28:30 -0500 (CDT), Moderate <
nos...@noemail.com> wrote:
> >-hh Wrote in message:
> >>
> >> Liberal? Or actually versed in Law Enforcement principles? it is already well known that
> >> crime rates of illegals are statistically lower than citizens, so that rape/murder is more likely
> >> to have been done by a citizen ... and when there's persecution of illegals just because, it
> >> means that no illegal will come forward as a witness, so your family member's crime will
> >> more likely go unsolved.
> >
> >Crime rates by illegals are probably higher.
> >
> >
http://thehill.com/blogs/pundits-blog/immigration/327229-crimes-by-illegal-aliens-not-legal-immigrants-are-the-real
>
> HH's post compares illegal aliens vs. American citizens. Your cite
> compares illegal aliens vs. legal immigrants. Big difference.
The first line of Moderate's cite:
"A story published by The Hill last month about two studies claiming that “immigrants
commit less crime than U.S. born citizens” misses the point..."
It goes on to try to point out how the study combined legal & illegal immigrants, but
does not dispute the conclusion that as a group their crime rate is lower than US Citizens.
Fortunately, a CATO Institute study did differentiate these two subgroups:
"Our headline finding is that both illegal immigrants and legal immigrants have
incarceration rates far below those of native-born Americans—at 0.85 percent,
0.47 percent, and 1.53 percent, respectively. Excluding illegal immigrants who
are incarcerated or in detention for immigration offenses lowers their incarceration
rate to 0.5 percent of their population—within a smidge of legal immigrants. As a
result, native-born Americans are overrepresented in the incarcerated population
while illegal and legal immigrants are underrepresented, relative to their respective
shares of the population."
<
https://www.cato.org/blog/immigration-myths-crime-number-illegal-immigrants>
TL;DR summary: crime* rate of US citizens is 3x higher than illegal immigrants.
Notes:
* - illegal immigration status is not a criminal offense; its a civil.
And note also what CATO points out:
"The relatively low number of incarcerated illegal immigrants places some immigration restrictionists in an uncomfortable position: choosing which myth to believe. The first
myth is that illegal immigrants are especially crime-prone. The second myth is that there
are actually two to three times as many illegal immigrants as is commonly reported.
The usual number used by the government and most demographers is that there are
11 to 12 million illegal immigrants in the United States but a steady drumbeat of skeptics
claim the real number is about 22 to 36 million."
Which means that if there really are more illegals than officially reported, this already low
number drops even further: the 0.5% drops to 0.25% (at 24M) to 0.15% (at 36M).
TL;DR: at the 36M, illegal immigrants are **10x more law abiding** than US Citizens.
Oh, and for snowflakes who don't like CATO, the Police Foundation says it too:
"The perception that the foreign-born, especially “illegal aliens,” are responsible for
higher crime rates is deeply rooted in American public opinion and is sustained by
media anecdote and popular myth."
<
https://www.policefoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/06/Appendix-D_0.pdf>
As does also Fox News:
"Fear of an illegal immigrant crime wave is sparked by the fear that they are
overwhelmingly murderers, rapists, and thieves. In reality, illegal immigrants
have lower incarceration rates and live in places with lower crimes rates than
native-born Americans."
Plus Fox even went here:
"Far from perpetrating a crime wave, immigrants actually decrease crime rates."
<
http://www.foxnews.com/opinion/2017/07/12/illegal-immigrant-crime-wave-evidence-is-hard-to-find.html>
Now if anyone wants to try to complain about how studies are supposedly dated, a
literature search published within the last 90 days says 'Nope!' (eg, no newer studies
were found which invalidate these prior conclusions):
<
http://www.nbcnews.com/politics/white-house/fact-check-no-evidence-undocumented-immigrants-commit-more-crimes-n777856>
Plus it noted that immigration crackdowns has a chilling effect on public safety, such
as through peoples reporting crimes, which backfires by invariably pushing up crime rates:
<
http://www.nbcnews.com/politics/donald-trump/experts-trump-s-immigration-orders-could-drive-crime-n723301>
-hh